<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<debates proof="1">
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.3.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.3.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Meeting </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.3.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="speech" time="12:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>If there is no objection, the meetings are authorised.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.4.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.4.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Department of the Treasury; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="526" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.4.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="12:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Like all of us, I'm delighted to be here this week and particularly delighted to be here at this moment in the chamber to make precisely the same points that I've made before in relation to order No. 27, relating to Treasury advice concerning first home buyers. In previous Senate proceedings I've advised the Senate that the Minister for Housing made a valid claim of public interest immunity over documents within the scope of this order&#x2014;documents that clearly and unambiguously are directly related to the deliberations of cabinet. Yet here we are again, in another puerile exercise of abuse of the Senate processes, for a kind of base partisan reason, that says much more about where Senator Bragg and the Liberals are on housing than it does about anything else.</p><p>Of course, breaching cabinet confidentiality would do serious harm not to the government but to the ability of any future cabinet of any persuasion to conduct the business of government. It would constrain the briefings that are provided to ministers&#x2014;the material that is assembled for cabinet deliberations. It would completely constrict all of those things. That would not be in the public interest. But Senator Bragg knows that. He knows that pressing this order is an exercise in futility. It's not a new concept in proper understanding of the Westminster system of government. What is really going on here is a campaign against the five per cent deposit scheme and the government's decision to make that work for all Australians. That's what's really going on here. In Senator Bragg's world view, if you don't have the bank of mum and dad on your side, if you don't grow up with a silver spoon in your mouth&#x2014;or a silver foot, as the case may be&#x2014;then you don't get a home. You don't get a home. You don't get access to a five per cent deposit&#x2014;to the benefits that that offers people in terms of earlier access to their own home&#x2014;and to your own capacity to have lower mortgage insurance costs over the whole life of your mortgage.</p><p>If you want to have that argument, have the courage not to have it in here; have it with the 290,000 young Australians who have benefited from that scheme, who are proud homeowners now and who are meeting their mortgage payments and working to meet their mortgage payments. The truth is that Senator Bragg will never meet those people, because he operates in his own rarefied atmosphere of the fossils who inhabit Liberal Party branches these days and elements of the community who will never have to think about how hard it is to save for a deposit and never be troubled in the way that most Australians are by the struggle that they feel to meet their mortgage payments. People like Olivia&#x2014;</p><p>I know you're not interested in her circumstances. She's a first home buyer in Gymea in New South Wales, a single mum in her 40s. She has said that this has delivered a massive change to her outlook and her sense of security. Go and argue to Olivia. Go and argue to the 76,285 constituents of yours&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.4.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="12:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ayres, it is helpful if you direct your remarks through the chair.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.4.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="continuation" time="12:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, I don't know how many constituents in Western Australia have benefited from five per cent deposits, Deputy President&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.4.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="12:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That is not entirely my problem, Senator Ayres.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="47" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.4.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="continuation" time="12:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>but there would be many. There would be many tens of thousands, and Senator Bragg should go and argue to them, too, that this is a bad idea. This is an utterly reasonable position that the government's taken here, and we'll continue to take it&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="895" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.5.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="speech" time="12:07" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the explanation.</p><p>I take note of the minister's non-explanation here. I make the point here that the minister says these are cabinet documents. It is not a cabinet document if it is a piece of modelling produced by the Treasury and which was only produced by the Treasury after the election&#x2014;after the election in which the government announced the abolition of means testing and place caps on this scheme. This was a scheme that was designed for lower income earners, and they made it a free-for-all for people earning up to $650,000 or maybe even more; we don't know, because the government don't give us basic information that the Australian people expect the opposition and the parliament to be able to inspect for public consideration.</p><p>They've given it to people who don't need it. They've given it to noncitizens. We have no idea of the basis upon which the modelling by the Treasury was done before cabinet made these judgements. Our job is to come here and get to the bottom of things. The government's view of this parliament and the Australian people, as a consequence, is that they are of no importance to this government. They don't care about the effective role of this parliament, which is to hold this government to account for the judgements it makes.</p><p>This scheme is out of control. It is going to people who do not need it. It is going to people who aren't even citizens of this country. It is extraordinary that the government has now spent over 12 months of this parliament's time denying access to this modelling. What are they covering up? What are they hiding? Why can't they just show us the modelling done by the Treasury? It's not a cabinet document. It is not a cabinet document. It is an input to a cabinet debate that should be disclosed for the public to see.</p><p>Since 1 October last year, 102,000 people have used this scheme. Many of them today are in negative equity because Mr Albanese encouraged people to take up this scheme and then hit them like a ton of bricks with new taxes, which pushed the value of their properties down. There would be people in hundreds of suburbs, especially in Melbourne and Sydney, who are today in negative equity. That means the loan that you have is worth more than the house that you own. No-one would believe that a prime minister of this country would hate Australians so much as to&#x2014;as this man has done&#x2014;encourage people, peddle this scheme, say, 'There are no risks, nothing to worry about,' and then hit them with taxes which drive down the value of their properties. It is extraordinary, to me, that that has happened.</p><p>APRA, the prudential regulator, is now saying that there is a material increase in the amount of low-value loans, and that is a big problem here, because we know that people who are exposed to low levels of equity could be in big trouble, as we have seen with these taxes. The lending data we've seen in the last week from the ABS shows that there are fewer loans going to owner-occupiers and fewer loans going to first home buyers because of these taxes. These taxes, combined with this terrible, maladministered scheme, which was originally designed for low-income earners, have been a toxic mix of housing policies which add to the government's terrible record on supply, where we've seen the government spend billions of dollars to get fewer homes.</p><p>As I said, no-one would believe the cruel hoax which has been perpetrated here&#x2014;that the government would cover up the basic information about this scheme, would then encourage people to go into the scheme and hit them with higher taxes and that, meanwhile, those taxes would also damage the ability of first home buyers and owner-occupiers to enter the market. We are in a situation today where it has never been harder for people to get into the housing market, because of the high interest rates, the high levels of red tape and costs in the housing system and the high taxes that have been faced by all Australians. This five per cent scheme is a cruel hoax. It is a gimmick that has been developed by the Labor Party and which was once a policy designed and carefully calibrated for lower income earners. If you're wondering why the government's budget has its backside out of its pants and you're looking at 10 years of deficits, this is one of the reasons. They are giving this scheme to people who do not need it. It is another reason that we have a mass of waste and corruption in this country. The government doesn't care about taxpayer funds. They wouldn't treat their own money like this, but they're happy to use taxpayer funds in this very reckless way.</p><p>This attendance is all about getting to the bottom of why the government decided to do this policy in the way that they did. It is all about the modelling that was done by the Treasury that was commissioned as an afterthought after the policy was announced during the election campaign as a bribery scheme. All we want to see is the basic modelling, and we won't give up, because that's our job.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="771" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.6.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" speakername="Barbara Pocock" talktype="speech" time="12:12" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I also rise to take note of Minister Ayres's response on behalf of the Minister for Housing. I notice he calls his attendance here and the requirement of the chamber that he be here and respond to the request for information about his housing policy 'puerile' and a base waste of Senate resources, yet here we are, in a housing crisis, with inquiries going around our country and surfacing, every day, the nature of the impact of the government's failure on housing policy. The minister has multiple overdue orders for the production of documents and, yet again, is hiding behind public interest immunity. We need access to who is getting what levels of support, including the uncapped deposit subsidies, and their circumstances. This is a valid request for information about the most significant driver of the cost-of-living crisis affecting millions of Australians every day.</p><p>The minister asked, 'What is really going on here?' We want information. We have real concern about the failure of the government's housing policies. Its central policy, the Housing Australia Future Fund, is too complex, too slow and too small. The risks associated with achieving any of its goals have been pointed to by the ANAO very clearly, and we have to rely on the kind of work done by the ANAO to get some basic data about what's going on with programs like the HAFF. Why is this housing crisis, which affects every town, every regional city and every big city in our country, being met with episodic, complex programs without a long pipeline of supply of the kind we know we need?</p><p>At 7.30 yesterday morning, I met with the Australian Community Housing organisation and the many, many community housing providers across our country who are looking for a well-developed, well-planned, properly funded pipeline of ongoing programs to support the housing outcomes Australians need. Where is it? It's not there, and community housing providers, along with many Australians, are asking why there is not a more concerted response to the housing crisis.</p><p>Some of us in this chamber are participants at the moment in an inquiry into social housing through the Senate Economics References Committee. We are finding in panel after panel of individual women and men and young people affected by the housing crisis an absence to provide over the last 30 years the kind of investment in social housing that this country used to do last century. It has failed in the last three decades to do so. The Housing Australia Future Fund is expected to provide 40,000 homes by June 2029. Well, in your dreams! Last week, during the social housing inquiry hearing, Treasury told us that only 2,199 of those homes have been delivered through the HAFF so far, and the people before us from government could not tell us how many of those homes are available in perpetuity and how many of them are actually now in the public housing stock. These are very important basic questions that a government should be able to answer about a major crisis affecting Australians.</p><p>There are close to 640,000 Australians living in extreme housing stress at the moment. They are in real pain. They are in real danger of being kicked out of where they're living now, because of rents going up, onto the streets of Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney, Renmark and our country towns. It's predicted that this number of really at-risk Australians is going to grow to close to a million by 2041. These numbers are appalling. We are the third-richest country on the planet. We should be able to put a roof over everybody's head, and we should have a government that comes to this chamber and gives us the data and information we need to evaluate what this government is doing. We need to know who exactly is benefiting from what, with what impact on them and how their circumstances are affected by finding themselves with a very large housing loan and the prospect of going underwater.</p><p>We heard evidence last week from single mothers, older women and young people who have faced huge barriers to getting into any housing. Certainly one of them with three children with disabilities told us that she could be dead before she'd get up the list into social housing. This is unacceptable. We need an emergency response, and we need data that tells us how we're going to get there. We also heard from Elise, who'd been on a public housing waiting list for 22 years. We need solutions. We need information. It's time the government brought it to us in a timely way.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="626" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.7.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="12:17" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This is just a basic question today in relation to transparency. We saw the minister's performance, yet again coming into this place and treating the Senate with contempt, treating the Australian people with contempt and, more than that, seeking those who are trying to get into their first home with complete, total and utter contempt. He continues to use the excuse of cabinet confidentiality. But, as we know, these documents were not part of the cabinet process. These documents are input documents to a document that may have gone to cabinet. So the question that the Australian people should be asking themselves is: what has the Albanese government actually got to hide in relation to its five per cent deposit scheme if it's so sure about the success&#x2014;or, should I say, so-called success?&#x2014;of this scheme?</p><p>Sadly we know that, because of the government's housing policies, a number of young people did access in good faith the five per cent deposit scheme on the basis of the 50 promises that were made prior to the election. Mr Albanese said, 'For the 50th time, if I am elected, I am not going to touch negative gearing and I am not going to touch capital gains.' And then what did he do? He said to the Australian people&#x2014;and has now become famous for saying&#x2014;'I changed my mind.' Well, that is little comfort, Mr Albanese, to those young people who in good faith took you at your word not once, not twice, not three times, not even 10 times, 20 times, 30 times or 40 times but 50 times when you said, 'If I am re-elected, I will not change.' And then you did.</p><p>Do you know what the reality is now for so many of those young people? They are now in what is called negative equity. That is where the value of their home has now dropped because of the Albanese government's disastrous housing policies that have crashed the housing market. The value of their home, thanks to Mr Albanese, has dropped, and, sadly, what they owe the bank remains high. In other words, God help those young Australians. If the bank has to step in and take their home, they should squarely blame Mr Albanese (a) for the fact that he misled them over 50 times prior to the election and (b) because his housing policies are crashing the housing market.</p><p>The reason we got here as well is that the Senate, on 24 July, took the extraordinary step&#x2014;in other words, senators across all parts of this chamber voted together&#x2014;to say to the government, 'We actually order you now to produce the Treasury advice concerning first home buyers.' The Senate did not accept the claims made by the government of cabinet in confidence. As I said, here's the document. Do you see that? It's all blacked out. That is not a cabinet document, despite what the government would say. The Senate then took the further extraordinary step, on 27 August 2025&#x2014;not 2026 but 2025&#x2014;and ordered the production of modelling relating to the financial risks and budgetary costs of Labor's expanded home guarantee scheme. More than a year ago, the Australian Senate&#x2014;cross-parties and the coalition&#x2014;ordered the government to produce the modelling in relation to this scheme, because we do not accept their claim of cabinet confidentiality. Yet again an Albanese government minister has come in here today and has treated with disrespect not just the Australian Senate but the Australian people.</p><p>You are spending billions of dollars in relation to your housing. You are crashing the housing market because of your policies. The five per cent scheme is failing Australians, and you have the audacity to come into this place and refuse to produce the documents. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="650" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.8.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="12:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>What are you hiding? I forecast things would get worse for first home buyers. Now we can see the results, and I was right. On 10 May 2017, I first warned about first home buyers purchasing with five per cent deposits. I pointed out the heavy financial burden of mortgage insurance and argued that government concessions fail to fix underlying land release and tax constraints. On 14 October 2019, I again warned against the five per cent deposit guarantee model, during the second reading debate on the National Housing Finance and Investment Corporation Amendment Bill 2019. This is the bill which established the original First Home Loan Deposit Scheme, under the coalition government. At the time, I argued that guaranteeing the difference between a five per cent and a 20 per cent deposit would inflate property prices; encourage irresponsible bank lending&#x2014;because taxpayers wear the risk; and prop up the housing bubble ahead of a potential market downturn. On 4 February 2026, I again warned that pumping more low-deposit buyers into a supply constrained market would drive up prices for entry-level homes.</p><p>Speaking to the Housing Australia Amendment (Accountability) Bill 2025 last year, I argued that removing income caps and place limits would worsen affordability by forcing buyers to take on larger, 95 per cent, mortgages while triggering RBA interest rate hikes. I warned that borrowing with only a five per cent buffer will leave buyers exposed to negative equity if property values dip or interest rates rise. He described the policy as turning young Australians into 'debt slaves' to the banks. That's what I described as well. In September 2024 and February 2026, I advocated for a One Nation alternative that pairs a five per cent deposit and five per cent fixed rate people's bank loan with sharp cuts to immigration, allowing buyers to use their own superannuation for deposits and removing GST on new building materials&#x2014;comprehensive. This is still our policy, one which clearly saw the pitfalls of Liberal and Labor policies and advanced a comprehensive solution. If Australia had adopted One Nation policy, we would not be where we are today, in the mess that buyers are facing. With home prices falling nationally this year by six per cent, many of these first home buyers are in negative equity, meaning they owe more than the value of their house.</p><p>Sydney has fallen by 10 per cent. The ANZ bank reports that 2.3 per cent of their mortgage holders are in negative equity, with more than a third of homeowners stressed about repayments. APRA is reporting non-performing home loans at one per cent and growing. A low deposit scheme can work. One Nation's will work, when complemented by reductions in government spending and a thoughtful taxation policy. Treasurer Chalmers's tax changes have driven one of the fastest and worst fall in home prices in the 40 years accurate data has been kept. Excessive government spending is fuelling interest rate hikes, which also depress home prices while driving up interest rates and repayments. This is in the open.</p><p>The <i>Weekend Australian</i>, just last Saturday, shows graphs and a wonderful article packed with data. Repayments, on average, for first home buyer discounted variable rate loan, as a percentage of full-time earnings for 25- to 34-year-olds has gone from 35 per cent in Labor's first year to 53 per cent and now to 55 per cent. More than half the money that young people are spending goes on their repayments. This perfect storm of stupidity was started under the Liberal Party and made much worse by this Labor government. It's no longer hidden; it's in the public, as we can see. The failure and the pain are now out in the open, plus energy prices rising, plus the cost of living and plus government waste. Only a One Nation government can provide professional government to the people of Australia.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.9.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
MOTIONS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.9.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Taxation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="755" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.9.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="12:27" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I seek leave to move a motion relating to the Albanese Labor government's proposed changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts as circulated.</p><p>Leave not granted.</p><p>Under contingent notice standing in my name, I move:</p><p class="italic">That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving a motion to provide for the consideration of a matter, namely a motion to give precedence to a motion relating to the Albanese Labor government's proposed changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts.</p><p>The Senate must suspend standing orders today because the Albanese government is yet again pursuing another multibillion dollar tax impost on Australian businesses in the last 48 hours. What has now been established demands, immediately, the suspension of our normal business. This is a matter of urgency on behalf of the Australian people, on behalf of the farmers who are going to be affected and on behalf of the small businesses across Australia who have been told, in compliance costs alone, you could now be spending billions and billions of dollars. That is why the ordinary business in relation to the Senate must give way.</p><p>We seek to suspend because, in the last 48 hours devastating new information has emerged in relation to the impact that this proposed trust change will have, as I said, on farmers and on small businesses. In particular, the urgency arises because we now know what the price Australian Greens are saying the government needs to pay to actually get the Greens to vote for this legislation. If you are a charity, if you are a private school, if you are a sporting body, be very, very worried if the government proceeds with this legislation.</p><p>These developments make this suspension necessary today. Worse than that, we now know that the urgency of this suspension goes to the fact that the Business Council of Australia now estimates that Australian businesses could face an additional $1.73 billion in taxation each and every year. Sadly, when compliance and implementation costs are included, five-year costs could reach&#x2014;wait for it; this is why the matter is urgent&#x2014;$4.14 billion. That is more than $4 billion. If you are a business in Australia, yes, we hear you. We will axe Labor's toxic taxes. We hear you, and that is why suspending the ordinary course of business today is so important. If the Labor Party does proceed with the Australian Greens in putting this toxic tax through, businesses have been pretty clear that they will have to close, and Australian people understand what happens when a business closes. A business that has to close employs no-one. In other words, the business is closed. I can no longer go there to get a service.</p><p>But what is worse and why this is so urgent is that those employees of that business, because of the actions of the Albanese government not being able to rein in its own spending and going after other people's money, will not have jobs. That is precisely why this Senate must consider the matter immediately before any further concessions are agreed to. We have five major business organisations now formally writing to this chamber and saying, 'For God's sakes, do you understand? Do you understand the consequences of Labor and the Greens doing this deal for family businesses.' Family businesses are businesses that are mum-and-dad Australians and the farmers who produce our food. We want the farmers to get on with their life, not actually have to restructure their businesses at a cost and potentially close down the farm. The impact on jobs, the impact on housing&#x2014;the warnings have been heard loud and clear.</p><p>Negotiations are currently on foot with the Australian Greens, the Albanese government wants this legislation passed before the parliament rises, and that is why the Senate simply cannot proceed with business as usual. Without suspending standing orders, quite frankly, this is likely to go through under a guillotine. What that means for the Australian people is we will not have time to properly look at the legislation, to understand the legislation and to explain to you why it should not go through. That is why we are seeking now the immediate opportunity to consider these new developments rather than allowing the government and the Greens to do a dirty deal that is going to impact businesses across Australia, businesses that are already struggling under the weight of bad decisions of the Albanese government. Worse than that, it will impact the employees who will lose their jobs because of Labor.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="660" approximate_wordcount="212" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.10.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="12:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We are not supporting the suspension motion today. I acknowledge the political points Senator Cash was making, but I don't think her argument about urgency was made to the satisfaction of the getting the support of this chamber. To use a political argument and a political opposition to a piece of legislation as a way of arguing urgency, I think, is insufficient. The chamber needs to be convinced why the program that's been circulated and agreed should be upended, because the opposition wants to make a political point. We understand that the opposition oppose the tax reform that we have been pursuing and&#x2014;</p><p>I listened in silence to your presentation. I understand that you are making a political argument, but what you're using here is a standing order to make an argument about urgency. When I read the suspension notice&#x2014;there is nothing in the motion that can be dealt with today in a way that justifies up-ending all of the important legislation that we have on: the counterterrorism legislation, the defence legislation and the administrative and judicial review legislation that we're partway through. We also know we only get about an hour of government business on a Tuesday, so essentially what you're arguing is to deal with none of those important pieces.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.10.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="interjection" time="12:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>You guillotine everything through!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.10.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="interjection" time="12:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Cash, you were listened to in silence. Please respect the standing orders.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="241" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.10.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="continuation" time="12:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In relation to the program, we want the program dealt with. I think there was a lot of hyperbole in Senator Cash's presentation on the substantive argument around trusts which I know doesn't relate to the matter that the chamber's currently dealing with, which is the suspension. To correct some of what was being argued, farm income will be exempt from the changes that have been proposed under tax reform. There were a number of other things, but I won't go through them. But just to come in here and argue that farmers will be put out of business when their farm income is actually exempt from the legislation does need to be corrected. And I also think it's important for people to understand that the vast majority, 95 per cent, of tax filers don't receive discretionary trust distributions. It is a very small percentage of tax filers that do. And we are making some modest reforms to those arrangements to ensure that the wages for workers who earn their income through labour, through wages, are not treated unfairly when compared to some of the arrangements that exist against other structures. And that is why we are seeking to make those reforms.</p><p>We don't support the suspension. The Senate's got a lot of work to do this week. We made small progress yesterday. We would like to make some more progress today, and I move:</p><p class="italic">That the question be now put.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.10.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="12:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the question be put.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.11.1" nospeaker="true" time="12:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="33" noes="24" pairs="6" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="aye">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="aye">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="aye">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="aye">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="aye">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="aye">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="aye">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="aye">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855" vote="aye">Don Farrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" vote="aye">Katy Gallagher</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="aye">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="aye">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="aye">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="aye">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="aye">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="aye">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="aye">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="aye">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="aye">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="aye">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="aye">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="aye">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="aye">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="aye">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="no">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="no">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="no">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="no">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="no">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="no">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="no">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="no">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="no">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="no">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="no">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="no">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" vote="no">Jane Hume</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="no">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="no">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="no">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="no">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="no">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="no">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="no">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="no">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="no">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="no">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="no">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920">Jess Walsh</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916">Paul Scarr</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="480" approximate_wordcount="14" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.12.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="speech" time="12:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the urgency motion moved by Senator Cash be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.13.1" nospeaker="true" time="12:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="25" noes="33" pairs="6" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" vote="aye">Michaelia Cash</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" vote="aye">Jane Hume</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855" vote="no">Don Farrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" vote="no">Katy Gallagher</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="no">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="no">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920">Jess Walsh</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916">Paul Scarr</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.14.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.14.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7516" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7516">Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.14.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="speech" time="12:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The committee is considering the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 and the deferred division on amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116. The question is that the amendments be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.15.1" nospeaker="true" time="12:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7516" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7516">Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="24" noes="11" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="aye">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="aye">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" vote="aye">Michaelia Cash</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="aye">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="aye">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="aye">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="aye">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="aye">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="aye">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855" vote="aye">Don Farrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="aye">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="aye">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="aye">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="aye">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="aye">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="aye">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="aye">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="aye">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="aye">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="aye">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="aye">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="aye">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="aye">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="no">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="no">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="no">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="829" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.16.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="12:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I move the amendments on sheet 4132 together:</p><p class="italic">(1) Schedule 1, page 4 (before line 5), before item 1, insert:</p><p class="italic">1A After section 101</p><p class="italic">Insert</p><p class="italic">101A Dismissal by registrars where no reasonable prospects of success</p><p class="italic">(1) Before a registrar exercises a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) in relation to an application for a proceeding, the registrar must:</p><p class="italic">(a) if the registrar is not certain it is appropriate to exercise the power&#x2014;consult a senior member in the relevant jurisdictional area; and</p><p class="italic">(b) give written notice to each party to the proceeding that the registrar is considering exercising the power and invite the parties to make submissions in response to the notice by a day specified in the notice (which must be no less than 14 days after the notice is given); and</p><p class="italic">(c) consider any submissions made in response to the notice before the day specified in the notice.</p><p class="italic">Note: A registrar may be authorised by the President to perform or exercise certain functions or powers of the Tribunal (see section 285).</p><p class="italic">(2) The exercise of a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) by a registrar is not valid if the registrar fails to comply with subsection (1).</p><p class="italic">(2) Schedule 1, item 2, page 4 (line 12), omit "this Act.", substitute "this Act; and".</p><p class="italic">(3) Schedule 1, item 2, page 4 (line 12), at the end of the item, add:</p><p class="italic">(d) a power of the Tribunal under paragraph 101(1)(b) must not be exercised by a registrar unless:</p><p class="italic">(i) the registrar has obtained a degree from a university, or an educational qualification of a similar standing, in the field of law; and</p><p class="italic">(ii) in the opinion of the President, the registrar has sufficient experience in the field of law to exercise the power.</p><p>Labor and the coalition have done a stitch-up job here, as they usually do. They have come up with a process where whereby registrars will now be empowered to dismiss matters where a registrar forms the view that there are no reasonable prospects of success.</p><p>Now, let's say a couple of things. I'm sure registrars are all very nice. I'm sure that they're all people largely trying to do the right thing. But they do not have tenure of appointment. They're just members of the executive. They're not members of the tribunal; they're members of the executive and can be hired and fired by the principal registrar without any statutory protection. They don't even have to have the legal qualifications of a member, and they're being given the power to dismiss matters, when they have a subjective view about whether or not the matter has reasonable prospects of success.</p><p>As the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre said in their submission to the inquiry on this bill&#x2014;a neat summary of their position is: this is a dumb idea, it undermines the independence of the tribunal, and registrars are not the right people to make that decision. I will just read into the record some of what Joshua Strutt from IARC said:</p><p class="italic">You have rigorous merits based appointments at the tribunal for people to engage in merits based assessments of applications through members and senior members.</p><p>Members and senior members are not registrars. Members and senior members are statutory appointments, they have statutory protections, and they're there to make the decisions. Registrars are just employees. Mr Strutt went further:</p><p class="italic">We understand that registrars may not be put through the same processes or have the same qualifications and experience as members. So we are quite concerned that this may mean that registrars are being asked to participate in a merits review process without the appropriate training or qualifications. We also know that applicants also put forward review applications without legal advice. As you are saying, there is a lot of unrepresented applicants. They may not know what the facts in issue are or what to put in the review application in order to assist the decision-maker to make that assessment as well.</p><p>When we asked the Attorney-General's Department about this, they asserted that registrars would be using this power only in 'objective circumstances'. When we asked them how tests such as reasonableness could be objective&#x2014;reasonableness is the quintessential subjective test. From a legal perspective, the test that is so obviously subjective, that doesn't actually have objective parameters that you look to, is reasonableness. So, when we asked the Attorney-General's Department, 'How could you say that giving registrars the ability to knock off matters where there are no reasonable prospects of success would be an exercise of objective decision-making against objective criteria?' they just floundered and failed to even address the issue.</p><p>Now, maybe that's the advice that the government's been getting. I'd be interested to know from the minister: does the Attorney-General accept the position from the Attorney-General's Department that a test of whether or not a matter has reasonable prospects for success is an objective test? Does the Attorney-General adopt that evidence from the Attorney-General's Department?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="485" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.17.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="12:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm happy to speak to the amendments put forward by the Greens before going to the substantive question. Firstly, the government will not be supporting these amendments. The proposal under the bill is appropriately designed to balance enhanced efficiencies in the tribunal processes with strong safeguards that exist. The function of the tribunal to dismiss an application if satisfied the application has no reasonable prospects of success is intended to be exercised by registrars for dismissals that are unambiguous and routine in nature and can be adequately performed by an authorised registrar. As a safeguard, the president would be able to issue directions in relation to registrars' use of the dismissal power for no reasonable prospects of success, and registrars would be obliged to comply with any directions when they exercised that power. The ART Act already requires the tribunal to provide each party with a reasonable opportunity to present their case, and, as a matter of procedural fairness, the tribunal will write to an applicant to seek their submissions before dismissing an application for no reasonable prospects of success. Under the act, there's a requirement that a person cannot be appointed a registrar unless they have certain qualifications, so they're not just nice people; they are qualified people.</p><p>The question that Senator Shoebridge put was discussed yesterday during debate. Rather than refer to the entire answer I gave in full, I'll just provide the example that I gave. The power to dismiss applications for no reasonable prospects of success, as I said, is intended for registrars for dismissals that are unambiguous and routine in nature where clear and objective criteria demonstrate that an application is bound to fail. What that means is that it would be appropriate for a registrar to dismiss an application where the applicant fails to meet an objective visa criteria, for example, where the applicant is required to be onshore in Australia at the time the application is made, but they are in fact outside Australia. Another example might be where they must be below a certain age when the application is made by the original decision-maker and they are older than that age. Perhaps they've been required to have a nomination in place at the time of their visa application, but the decision-maker and the nomination have not been approved. Finally, one that we often see come through the ART system is that the applicants are required to provide evidence when making their visa application that they have undertaken an English language test and achieved a specified score, but they have not been able to do so. As I said previously, as a safeguard, the president would be able to issue these directions to ensure the powers of dismissal for no reasonable prospects of success are complied with, and they would set out circumstances in which it would be appropriate for the registrar to exercise this dismissal of power.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="568" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.18.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="13:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm not sure that answered the question, but we could probably try again and get the same non-answer to the core question. Of course the legislation contains none of those safeguards. The legislation just gives a power for registrars to dismiss where there are no reasonable prospects of success. A small subset of those matters may have an objective element to them&#x2014;like failing to attach the English language certificate. But the legislation is in no way limited to that. The government was unable to provide a draft direction from the principal registrar. When questioned, the principal registrar could provide no clarity on what the principal registrar's thoughts were for a direction. You're just providing this incredibly broad power that, if it's not abused by this principal registrar or this attorney-general, could well be abused by a future one because there are no statutory protections.</p><p>The amendments that the Greens are moving here on sheet 4132 are based upon the evidence we got from the Law Council. The Law Council said that they oppose these changes to give registrars these kinds of powers. They were unambiguous about it. They said it's bad&#x2014;bad for the independence of the tribunal, bad for individual justice&#x2014;and that registrars are not the right people in the tribunal to have the power. But they then said, 'Well, look, if you are going to insist upon these changes, put some legislative safeguards in.' This is what is picked up in our amendments on sheet 4132.</p><p>The Law Council said in their submission that, while they preferred for these changes not to happen, if they do happen, there should be the following: 'a requirement that only registrars who have legal qualifications and sufficient post-admission experience may exercise the dismissal powers'. We'll just stop there. We got some kind of woolly statement from the minister then that there are some kind of criteria required for registrars in the selection process, but they are not the minimums that the Law Council is calling for. To be clear, that was 'a requirement that only registrars who have legal qualifications and sufficient post-administration experience may exercise the dismissal powers'. That should be a limitation.</p><p>They also said 'a qualification requiring that a registrar be required to consult with a senior member or the relevant jurisdictional area leader where uncertain about a finding before committing to that finding'. So get some advice from someone who knows and who has the qualifications and the independence.</p><p>The third point they said was 'ensuring that, if an application is dismissed under this power, this will not prevent an applicant being able to make a request to the media to the minister under section 351 of the Migration Act or for the ART to continue to be able to refer a matter for consideration to the minister under that section'. Lastly, they said 'an express requirement that, before an application is dismissed, the applicant must be given notice that the registrar has formed a view that it may be appropriate to dismiss an application and the applicant be provided an opportunity to be heard specifically on that question'. They continued:</p><p class="italic">A failure to give notice or to hear the applicant should be expressed as rendering any dismissal to be of no effect.</p><p>These are the amendments that are contained in the Greens amendments on sheet 4132. For those reasons, we commend the amendments to the Senate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="508" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.19.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="13:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The coalition will not be supporting the amendments moved by the Australian Greens. It is our belief that these amendments would impose additional procedural requirements and restrictions that risk undermining the very efficiencies that the legislation was indeed drafted to address.</p><p>As we know, and it was again confirmed with us at the most recent Senate estimates hearing, the Administrative Review Tribunal is already facing extraordinary pressures. In fact, in 2024-25, the tribunal received more than 83,000 applications with almost 80 per cent relating to migration and protection matters. We also know that the Federal Circuit and Family Court is also experiencing significant pressure from increasing migration litigation. The actual stated purpose of the bill&#x2014;certainly, this was the evidence that was elicited by many witnesses, including the tribunal's head at the hearing into the bill&#x2014;is to address those pressures by reducing unnecessary administrative burdens, streamlining decision-making and allowing tribunal members to concentrate on what are substantive matters. Yet the Greens are proposing amendments&#x2014;and Senator Shoebridge just outlined what they would be&#x2014;that we believe risk making these processes and procedures more complicated.</p><p>Their amendments to expand the registrar powers would introduce additional statutory procedures, including mandatory written notices, a minimum 14-day period for submissions and further restrictions on which registrars may exercise dismissal powers. Of course, the coalition supports appropriate safeguards, but these proposals risk adding unnecessary delays to decisions about applications that have no reasonable prospect of success. We believe the tribunal must retain the flexibility to determine where appropriately qualified and experienced registrars should exercise these powers, rather than having unnecessarily prescriptive requirements imposed by legislation. That's what would happen if the Australian Greens amendments did indeed pass the Senate.</p><p>The Greens also propose restricting the use of oral decisions and oral reasons to circumstances where a decision is wholly in favour of the applicant. Again, the coalition believes that this would substantially undermine what is actually one of the bill's central efficiency measures. We recognise that written reasons are important, particularly where an applicant is considering whether or not to take a further step in the process and apply for judicial review; however, the bill as drafted will actually preserve the ability of the applicants to request written reasons.</p><p>The Senate committee has also recommended that applicants receive clear written notice of the relevant timeframes for requesting reasons and seeking judicial review, and we believe that the recommendation coming out of the Senate committee in that regard is a more proportionate approach than effectively reinstating the existing requirement for written reasons in every unsuccessful application. On that basis, as I said, we believe that the priority must be to ensure that Australia's administrative and judicial review systems operate efficiently, that unmeritorious applications do not unnecessarily consume resources and that genuine applicants receive timely decisions. We won't support amendments that risk increasing delays, adding administrative burdens and frustrating the practical improvements that this bill seeks to deliver. As I said, for those reasons, the coalition will not be supporting the amendments put forward by the Australian Greens.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="354" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.20.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="13:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Law Council, law societies, people appearing before the ART and people who have applications before the ART do not consider things like natural justice, the right to be heard and having your matter decided by a tribunal member who actually has tenure and who is not an employee who can be hired and fired by the government of the day to be additional procedural requirements. They consider those rights a fundamental part of a fair tribunal and the rule of law.</p><p>But we hear the coalition's views. They believe procedural fairness and the rule of law are just additional procedural requirements that can be just cast aside at any moment. Of course, they're in good company there, because the Labor Party believes the same thing. Natural justice and the rule of law&#x2014;they're simply additional procedural requirements on which the coalition and Labor, as always, can team up to take away basic rights from Australians, basic rights from applicants and basic rights from people appearing before a tribunal whose whole purpose is to hold the government to account and challenge the decisions made by the executive. That's the whole purpose of the ART&#x2014;to challenge decisions made by the executive. Now, Labor and the coalition want critical decisions in that tribunal to be made by members of the executive not members of the tribunal with protected statutory tenure&#x2014;have the executive passed judgement on the executive. That's how little you care about independence or basic legal structures and basic concepts.</p><p>We can see the stitch up is in, because this is how both Labor and the coalition&#x2014;there's so little between you. There is so little between the Labor Party and the coalition. Every time they see a chance to pump up executive power and to push down against rights, Labor and the coalition join together, like you're doing today. You may as well just get a merger happening here. When it comes to national security and when it comes to basic rights in our legal system, why don't the Labor Party and the coalition just do a joint ticket on this stuff, like you're doing today?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="14" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.21.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="speech" time="13:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that amendments (1) to (3) on sheet 4132 be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.22.1" nospeaker="true" time="13:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7516" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7516">Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="10" noes="24" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" vote="no">Michaelia Cash</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="no">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="no">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="420" approximate_wordcount="1047" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.23.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="13:17" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I move Greens amendments (1), (2) and (3) on sheet 4133 together:</p><p class="italic">(1) Schedule 1, item 35, page 17 (lines 12 to 19), omit paragraphs 111(2)(a) and (b), substitute:</p><p class="italic">(a) the Tribunal's decision:</p><p class="italic">(i) in writing; or</p><p class="italic">(ii) if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant&#x2014;orally, and later in writing;</p><p class="italic">(b) reasons for the Tribunal's decision:</p><p class="italic">(i) in the form of a statement of reasons; or</p><p class="italic">(ii) if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant&#x2014;orally, and later in the form of a statement of reasons if the party requests a statement of reasons under subsection (4);</p><p class="italic">(2) Schedule 1, item 38, page 19 (line 11), omit "paragraph 111(2)(b)", substitute "subparagraph 111(2)(b)(ii)".</p><p class="italic">(3) Schedule 1, item 58, page 24 (line 4), after "orally to the applicant", insert "if the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant".</p><p>One of the key proposals in this bill is to remove the obligation to provide written decisions to applicants, and, of course, pretty much every submission we received included deep concern about what that would mean in practice. As the Refugee Council of Australia said in its submission:</p><p class="italic">Timely written statements of legal decisions are central to administrative justice and transparency. Written notices provide an authoritative record of the tribunal's findings, decision-making process and help inform applicants about the basis of the decision. This is significant for refugee claims when matters of life and death are under consideration.</p><p>Witnesses also raised concerns that the absence of the need to put pen to paper and commit reasons to writing would seriously degrade the quality of decision-making and that removing the obligation to provide written reasons when decisions are made also seriously impacts people's ability to file appeals of decisions of the ART. If you haven't got the reasons in front of you, how do you formulate the basis on which you seek to appeal or review them?</p><p>This bill just creates more complexity. It provides that, where a decision is made orally, applicants may then request written reasons. Well, first of all, the most marginalised applicants&#x2014;the ones for whom English is a second language or who may not have English language skills at all; people who are economically disempowered; women fleeing violence&#x2014;are the types of applicants that the evidence said will be most disadvantaged by this. They haven't got the legal resources. They haven't got the cultural resources. They don't understand the complexities of administrative review. Yet the government says, 'Don't you worry about that'&#x2014;people without those resources and without those cultural assets will somehow magically know that they can request written decisions. And providing the written decisions could take up to 28 days, eating into the 35-day appeal period, making it even harder for the most marginalised people to exercise their rights.</p><p>Perhaps that's what Labor's intent was here. Labor knows who this is going to have the biggest impact on, and that's why they're doing it&#x2014;people without economic power, people without cultural power. Labor says they'll take rights away from those people, because then they won't kick up a stink; they won't be able to build the movement to challenge Labor's decision to take away their rights. That's why Labor is focusing these changes on taking rights away from the most marginalised people. And of course the coalition cheers this in every time, because they want to take rights away from the same people; that's in their political DNA.</p><p>Watching Labor and the coalition do this&#x2014;craft amendments that are designed expressly to have the greatest impact on the people with the least ability to resist&#x2014;is exactly why people are looking at the way Labor and the coalition exercise government, are looking at the way they exercise their political powers and are increasingly revolted by it. They can see that you'll take every opportunity you get to punch down on ordinary Australians, the most marginalised. You want to punch down on pensioners, punch down on people on the NDIS, punch down on migrants and punch down on people seeking asylum. And you do that because you know they've got less capacity to politically resist. Instead of making the hard decisions and maybe taxing the one per cent to get the funding to properly resource the ART so that they've got the members they need in order to make decisions, or having Home Affairs make good decisions in the first place and resource that, no, no, no&#x2014;Labor and the coalition want to punch down on marginalised people, because they think there'll be no resistance. Well, the Greens are resisting it, on behalf of all those Australians who need someone in their corner&#x2014;because they sure as hell don't have Labor or the coalition in their corner.</p><p>And of course there was incredible confusion in the rationale from the Attorney-General's Department on the proposed extent to which they intend to use this power. The chief executive officer and principal registrar of the ART, Mr Hawkins, made clear that they don't expect to use the power in complex cases, so of course there's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided was for its use in successful cases, as, again, Mr Hawkins explained, because no-one from the Attorney-General's Department could explain when they wanted to use this power to get rid of the need for written reasons. Mr Hawkins said:</p><p class="italic">I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons. They are probably very straightforward decisions. In cases where it is set aside, it is up to the department whether it seeks the written reasons.</p><p>Well, we're going to take Mr Hawkins up on that suggestion, and that's exactly what the Greens amendments do. They do this because we're going in to bat for people who have less power. These amendments say that the only circumstances in which the tribunal cannot provide written decisions are when the decision is wholly in favour of the applicant. For the reasons put forward by Mr Hawkins, the principal registrar, and for the reasons put forward in so many submissions to the tribunal&#x2014;and just for basic decency&#x2014;we commend these amendments to the Senate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="635" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.24.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="speech" time="13:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 is a bill that my team and I have been looking at, grappling with. I had planned to vote in support of this bill until yesterday, with the amendment that was circulated by the government and passed. Clearly there is a real problem with the backlog in the migration case load, and it needs to be addressed. As Senator Cash pointed out in her second reading speech, the tribunal's September quarter figures reportedly show median finalisation times of 64 weeks for migration matters, 89 weeks for protection reviews and 136 weeks for family and partner visa reviews. This should not be allowed to continue. This has a huge impact on people's lives. Visa applicants should not be forced to wait years for an outcome. The cost of those delays is huge.</p><p>I accept what the government has said about some applications being made without reasonable prospects of success. The Law Council and others, as has been canvassed in this debate, have talked about the need for greater efficiency&#x2014;but weighed against real concerns about access to justice and the rule of law. I take seriously the concerns about expanded registrar powers, oral reasons and identity verification. On balance, though, my view had been that the need to fix the backlog outweighed those concerns.</p><p>Then, the government circulated the amendment on sheet IE116, which the Senate just agreed to. It lets the minister promote a general member to senior member without the publicly advertised, merit based assessment that the ART Act otherwise requires. The president is asked for advice. There is no advertising, no open competition and no assessment panel. The decision then sits with the minister. I thought this was the whole point of Labor getting rid of the AAT. We heard so much about it when Labor was in opposition&#x2014;about jobs for mates and all the things that were wrong with the AAT&#x2014;to the point where it got abolished. The former attorney-general in particular fought very hard to fix the issues, and I commend him for it. Merit based, publicly advertised appointments were the centrepiece of the new tribunal, and this amendment, which the government put forward and the coalition supported, seems to disrespect the work of the Hon. Mark Dreyfus in fighting for a merit based process so that we can have trust in the ART. I'll read a quote from the Prime Minister at a doorstop interview in May 2024, shortly after the AAT was replaced by the ART:</p><p class="italic">Now, we have replaced the AAT this week. We've gotten rid of it. Gotten rid of it &#x2026; We've abolished it, gotten rid of it and replaced it with the Administrative Review Tribunal, which will be more rigorous, which will not be full of former party political appointments.</p><p>It's amazing what can happen in a couple of years. The amendment that just passed is a step backwards, towards the bad old days, and I suspect many in Labor know that. Before the AAT was abolished, appointments were tarnished by cronyism. There were so many criticisms and allegations about the way that the appointments process worked. Given that, I think this is a poisoned pill in this bill. Canberrans want to see appointments generally, but particularly to our Administrative Review Tribunal, based on merit and merit alone. It is just not good enough for this Labor government to introduce that amendment.</p><p>So, Minister, I'd love to hear from you and the government. I certainly didn't see, in any of the submissions or anything put forward by witnesses, suggestions that the government should water down the merit based appointment process. Where has this idea come from, and why is the government watering down the merit based process that was put into place by former attorney-general Mark Dreyfus?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="138" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.25.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="13:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Senator Pocock. We did answer questions extensively on this yesterday, but I can rephrase or summarise those for you. Firstly, we agree that the AAT did require reform, and we thank the Senate for its support, in the previous term of this parliament, in abolishing the former Administrative Appeals Tribunal. It had been stacked with around 80 former political MPs, candidates, staffers and supporters and didn't have an established merits review as part of the appointment process. It's really important that appointments undergo rigorous arms-length assessments before serving on the tribunal. That's exactly what the government has been progressing. I think you will be fully aware that the government has appointed 114 new general members, 18 new senior members, five judicial deputy presidents and four non-judicial deputy presidents. That's an equivalent of 94.3 FTE&#x2014;</p><p>Progress reported.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.26.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
STATEMENTS BY SENATORS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.26.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Corporate Governance </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="326" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.26.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" speakername="Alex Antic" talktype="speech" time="13:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In possibly the least surprising news of the last six months or so, we learnt out of the US recently that diversity, equity and inclusion policies have been a total failure. A recent investigation by the United States Committee on Oversight and Government Reform entitled <i>Combating </i><i>DEI </i><i>in American </i><i>institutions</i>, has been reviewing diversity inclusion in America, and, over the last 10 years, it found that prominent US consulting group McKinsey &amp; Company have been producing a series of reports entitled <i>Diversity </i><i>m</i><i>atters</i>, <i>Delivering through </i><i>d</i><i>iversity</i>, <i>Diversity wins</i> and <i>Diversity </i><i>matters even more</i>, which assert that companies that hire more diverse candidates into management positions are more likely to see improved financial performance and productivity. Of course they would say that.</p><p>Public companies, asset managers, proxy advisers and major institutional investors have cited these reports as justification for embedding racial and sex based targets into hiring, promotion, executive pay and voting policies. And yet the White House's own April 2026 report entitled <i>Economic </i><i>r</i><i>eport of the President</i> detailed that, 'promotion into management on the basis of race&#x2014;a key consequence of DEI initiatives&#x2014;cost the U.S. economy roughly $94 billion in 2023 alone.' But this is, of course, how soft power operates in the modern age. You don't have to win every argument on the floor of parliament. You've just got to get the right report repeated enough by the right people and adopted by big business, and the culture shifts beneath you.</p><p>Now in Australia, the corporate world and bureaucracy has allowed the language of diversity and inclusion to become a moral absolute while the underlying data remains contested and the practical results are damaging. I've spent many years talking at estimates and quizzing public servants about DEI policies, and I can't seem to get a good response. If we're serious about restoring a culture of competence, colour-blind opportunity and gender equality before the law, we've got to demand the end of the corrosive DEI era policies.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.27.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Mental Health First Aid International </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="309" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.27.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="speech" time="13:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise today to recognise Mental Health First Aid International and the important role that mental health first aid training plays in communities right across Australia. We're in a situation where we've seen more than 1.5 million people across Australia trained in mental health first aid and another 10 million people across 53 different countries. I think you'll agree that's quite an impressive feat for Mental Health First Aid International.</p><p>For someone who's experiencing a mental health challenge, it's often very, very difficult for them to ask for help. But it's also really difficult for the co-worker or the family member or the teammate to actually know how to have that conversation. They can see that their friend, co-worker or family member is starting to struggle or that there's a change in their behaviour, and they want to help, but to know how to start that conversation can be so terribly difficult. The kind of work that goes on to actually recognise that and teach people how to start that conversation without offending anyone and to get the right pitch, get the right approach and also to look after your own mental health while you're doing it is so, so important.</p><p>We're looking at a situation this year where we have world Mental Health First Aid Day on Wednesday. That's tomorrow, and there's a great breakfast going on tomorrow morning. Don't miss it. The theme this year is 'Ready when it matters' and I think that speaks volumes. Ready when it matters. Ready to respond when someone you know starts to exhibit behaviours or changes that may mean they need some support. The hardest conversation is always the first one, and the more we equip people in our workplaces and across our community to deal with this and to support people, the better off we're all going to be.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.28.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Data Centres </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="277" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.28.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" speakername="Barbara Pocock" talktype="speech" time="13:34" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Communities across Australia are saying no to AI data centres. Last Sunday, hundreds of South Australians protested the planned 1.2-gigawatt AI data centre at Tungkillo in our beautiful Adelaide Hills. They're concerned about its potential impacts on our farmland and our power supply and cost, as well as on our water, and the potential for increased bushfire risk. Thank you to everyone in South Australia who turned up. When you stand up, you win. Those plans have been paused due to your action and your voice, but they haven't been fully stopped, so we cannot let this go. They've been paused.</p><p>Data centres have no social licence. They're trying to railroad so many communities across the country, taking their water, pushing up power prices and making inflation worse. That is not the way to win social licence. Australia needs rock-solid regulations in place before data-mining factories are allowed into our communities, consuming our water, our power and our beautiful farmland.</p><p>So the Greens have been very clear: we need a moratorium on new AI data centre applications, approvals and builds. We're in a housing crisis, and our construction workforce needs to be building homes, not AI data centres. We're seeing workers across sectors lose their jobs to AI or AI washing, and Labor is doing nothing to protect them. This government must stop rolling out the red carpet for trillion-dollar AI giants that have repeatedly shown little regard for Australian workers, for Australian jobs, for our natural resources and for our artists and culture. They are vultures, and we need this parliament to legislate for real, enforceable protections for workers and for our communities, not voluntary guidelines.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.29.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Aged Care </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="296" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.29.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" speakername="Chris Gatenby" talktype="speech" time="13:36" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Australia is facing an aged-care calamity, and nowhere is the failure of the Albanese Labor government more concerning than in my home state of Tasmania. Under this government, since 2022, Tasmania has gone backwards in residential aged-care capacity. Last year alone, Tasmania lost 50 beds. Just let that sink in. At a time when our population is ageing and demands are increasing, we're losing places for people to be cared for, and the consequences are devastating. This is a national crisis, and it's worse for Tasmania because we have the oldest population in the country.</p><p>Older Tasmanians who are medically fit to leave hospital are left waiting for residential aged-care beds that simply aren't available, and the result is that the number of stranded patients in our hospitals has doubled in two years&#x2014;doubled. Not that the Albanese government knows&#x2014;at Senate estimates, they couldn't even tell us the number of people that were stranded across the country. They just hid behind the idea that a definition needed to be developed. It's simply not good enough. Hospital beds remain occupied. and families are left wondering where their loved ones will receive the care that they need.</p><p>This isn't just a coalition concern. In South Australia, Labor Premier Malinauskas has publicly demanded urgent action as well, because around 500 older Australians are stuck in hospitals and some are now being charged even more for their extended stays. When a Labor premier is publicly calling out the federal Labor government over aged care, surely alarm bells should be ringing. Our regional communities already face significant challenges accessing home-care services, and this is on top of the mess with Support at Home. The Albanese Labor government must get its head out of the sand and fix aged care as it promised.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.30.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Civics Education </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="309" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.30.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" speakername="Charlotte Walker" talktype="speech" time="13:38" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise today to discuss a topic that has historically been overlooked and underresourced in our education system, and that is civics education. A lot of people in this room can remember their first trip to Canberra, usually at around 12 years old, to see our democratic institutions up close. We toured old and new Parliament House, checked out the National Gallery, paid our respects at the War Memorial and had a great time at Questacon. It's a fun school excursion, but unfortunately it seems to be the pinnacle of civics education for most Australians. Data released by the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority shows that the average Australian's understanding of how our country and our democracy work is at a 20-year low. This needs to change. That's why I was so happy to hear Minister for Education Jason Clare's announcement a few weeks ago that the Albanese Labor government has asked the curriculum authority to look into making civics education compulsory for students in years 9 and 10.</p><p>Timing is critical when it comes to civics education. Young people should leave school with a clear understanding of how Australia is governed, how laws are made, the role of the Constitution and how they can make their voices heard. Reinforcing these lessons from their Canberra trip as they approach voting age gives students the best opportunity to put that knowledge into practice and participate meaningfully in Australia's democracy.</p><p>I want all young people to feel empowered to use their voice to make the country better and to use our incredible democratic system to their best advantage. I'm proud to be a part of a government that's pushing for these much-needed reforms, and I hope to see the next generation of Australians confident and secure in their knowledge of our system and how to make it serve them better.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.31.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Aged Care </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="282" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.31.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="speech" time="13:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>When did having a cooked breakfast, listening to music, watching TV or speaking with your family become a luxury in aged care? Thanks to yet more great reporting from the ABC, last week we discovered that companies like Bupa are stinging people nearly 300 bucks a week for some eggs at breakfast two days a week, an extra lunch choice and some dessert after dinner. That's $15,000 a year. The ABC also reported that Oryx Communities' Queenslea facility has rooms that require a $2 million deposit, but TVs aren't included. To access the TV you have to pay for the entertainment package, costing $14,508 a year. If you don't pay, they don't remove the TV; they just unplug it.</p><p>I had a person reach out saying that their family is paying $2.28 per day at an Opal facility for their father to access YouTube. He has dementia, and music helps keep him calm. That's about $69 a month, or $832 a year. A premium YouTube subscription starts at $9 a month. How are we allowing older Australians to be price-gouged like this? How about this: a provider in Queensland is charging $14 per video catch-up call. These providers are taking advantage of our older Australians. Another person told me they're paying $8.25 per day for a non-alcoholic drinks package. That's 3,000 bucks a year for what they tell me is a choice between orange or lemon cordial.</p><p>This has to stop. And we know it's not just in residential aged care. We're seeing price gouging in Support at Home, and the commission has ordered providers to refund more than $300,000 so far. It's not good enough, and we need to fix this.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.32.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Western Australia: Infrastructure </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="283" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.32.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="speech" time="13:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Western Australia is on the cusp of transformational projects through Westport, AUKUS and the continued growth of Perth's southern industrial corridor. But there is a simple reality: you cannot govern major infrastructure projects by media statements alone. Labor has become very good at announcements at both the state and federal level, but what Western Australia needs is delivery. Ports do not operate without freight corridors. Defence precincts do not function without upgraded roads. Major industrial expansion cannot occur without housing, workforce planning and transport infrastructure. The greatest risk to Westport and AUKUS is not a lack of vision; the vision already exists. The risk is that the governments continue to fail to deliver the enabling infrastructure needed to make these projects succeed.</p><p>Recent Senate estimates raised serious questions about Westport. Commonwealth officials confirmed to me, in answer to questions that I asked, that they had not been advised of project delays to the port and had not received the Western Australian government's KPMG workforce capability report. This comes as the state government now acknowledges that Western Australia will need around 200,000 additional workers over the next decade. If the Western Australian government is confident that major projects remain on track, then it should release the KPMG report. Instead, the report remains hidden, while the Commonwealth department responsible for funding enabling infrastructure has not seen it and has not been advised of workforce related delays to the port. At the same time, communities around Henderson, Rockingham and Kwinana continue to ask questions about road capacity, freight movements and the infrastructure needed to support growth. Success will not be measured by press releases or announcements. It will be measured by whether roads actually are built.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.33.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Raise Our Voice in Parliament </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="239" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.33.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" speakername="Michelle Ananda-Rajah" talktype="speech" time="13:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'll be reading a speech from Dhruv, a young Victorian, as part of the Raise Our Voice campaign. He writes:</p><p class="italic">I am writing because my generation is facing a ghost economy.</p><p class="italic">As artificial intelligence and automation aggressively rewrite our workforce, the entry level jobs we were promised are rapidly vanishing.</p><p class="italic">We are constantly told to study hard and adapt. But how can we honestly adapt when the path ahead is being blocked before we even have a chance to reach it?</p><p class="italic">We are graduating into an unwilling world with fewer traditional roles and never-see-before competition.</p><p class="italic">This isn't just an economic shift; it is a major catalyst for a rising crisis in youth mental health and anxiety.</p><p class="italic">To fix this structural decay, I demand that Parliament take immediate, fair action. We must fund a national 'Future Proof Skills' package.</p><p class="italic">This policy should mandate advanced digital literacy, moral AI usage, and one-of-a-kind human skills across every school curriculum.</p><p class="italic">Crucially, back this up with government funded, paid internships in emerging green and tech industries.</p><p class="italic">Politicians always talk about protecting Australia's future. Well, we are that future. Stop preparing us for yesterday's workforce and equip us to lead tomorrows.</p><p>Thank you, Dhruv, for your thoughtful contribution to this body of work. You rightly showcase the challenges ahead and call on us to take meaningful action to ensure that your generation and in fact all Australians aren't left behind by the impact of AI.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.34.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Parliamentary Standards </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="257" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.34.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="speech" time="13:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>From the Prime Minister on down, we're being told to turn down the political temperature&#x2014;to be more civil and less angry. Well, I will absolutely not be doing that. Of course there's no place for violence in politics, but it has to be said that the same people demanding we turn down the political heat are the very same people who are cooking the planet, those who profit from the destruction of humanity's future and their political enablers in this parliament. They want us to be polite while they torch our future. They want us to be reasonable while billionaires hoard wealth and working people can't get enough to eat. They want us to speak softly while fascist tech bros steal the entire intellectual and creative output of humanity and corporatise it for profit. They want us to be courteous during the Gaza genocide. They want to smother legitimate anger under the stifling blanket of civility.</p><p>Calls to turn down the political temperature are demands to silence dissent. People have every right to be angry at the rolling polycrisis we are living through. Anger at injustice is a fundamental human right. And, when the planet is burning, when inequality is exploding and when children are being murdered in Gaza, the last thing we need is centrist, incrementalist politicians telling us to turn down the temperature and cool down. I will absolutely not be going quietly into the night. I will stay angry. I will stay loud. And I will resist the tyranny that is governing Australia now.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.35.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Women's Health </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="320" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.35.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="13:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Last week in Perth, the Select Committee on Women's Health heard from clinicians, community organisations and mothers. Their stories differed, but their ask was the same: fund Medicare support for psychology and pelvic health physiotherapy that matches real need.</p><p>In a survey of more than a thousand WA women, 57 per cent identified that they went without postpartum health care, like pelvic health and physiotherapy, purely because of cost. We heard that, around six weeks, the system largely steps back. In that same Luma survey, nearly one in five Western Australian women needed mental health support in the past two years and did not get it. A perinatal psychologist told the inquiry that 10 sessions can run out long before a mother's anxiety does, and women live with pelvic pain and injury with nowhere affordable to go. I'm almost six months postpartum myself. I know what it feels like when the visits stop and the questions stop while your body and mind are still healing. I know what it feels like to look in the mirror and not recognise the person staring back&#x2014;the eye bags, the pain everywhere, the hair loss, the loneliness, the days that just drag on. I cannot imagine how much more isolating this would feel if I could not access essential supports.</p><p>Women need psychologists and pelvic health physios, and right now access depends on their bank balance. Our ask of the government is simple: put your money where your mouth is. We cannot keep holding inquiries that ask women to relive their birth traumas only for the recommendations to sit gathering dust. So I call on the government to fund Medicare psychology and pelvic health physiotherapy through the first year after birth. Early support costs less than crisis, and it's what women have asked for. I thank everyone who made a submission and everyone who appeared before the committee. Thank you for sharing your stories.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.36.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Western Australia: Defence Industry </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="313" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.36.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" speakername="Glenn Sterle" talktype="speech" time="13:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I recently had the pleasure of attending a forum in Broome focusing on the defence industry, and I want to congratulate the Broome Chamber of Commerce and Industry for bringing everyone together for such an important discussion. Having spent considerable time working across the Kimberley, I know firsthand the capability, resilience and potential of people and businesses in this region. As Australia's focus on northern Australia grows, the Kimberley has an important role to play in supporting our defence industry, particularly in aviation, fuel security, logistics and critical infrastructure.</p><p>The highlight of the forum for me was hearing from Nathan McIvor, CEO of Djarindjin Aboriginal Corporation and general manager of Djarindjin Airport. Nathan delivered an outstanding speech and made a very important point&#x2014;I'm going to use some of his words&#x2014;when he said, 'We need to recognise and build on the capacity that already exists in our region, rather than looking elsewhere for solutions.' Djarindjin Airport is a terrific example. A small Aboriginal community has built and operates a specialised aviation business supplying millions of litres of aviation fuel, supporting offshore operations and creating real economic opportunity for its people. I particularly agree with Nathan's message that Indigenous participation must be about more than employment targets. It's about genuine ownership, building successful businesses and ensuring economic benefits stay within local communities. The 2023 Kimberley floods also reminded us how important local knowledge, infrastructure and strong regional relationships are when supply chains are disrupted and communities need support.</p><p>As we continue to discuss opportunities for Defence to strengthen its presence in the north, we must ensure Kimberley businesses, Aboriginal organisations and local communities are part of that future. We have the people, the experience and the capability. We need to make sure they get the opportunities to demonstrate it. Congratulations again to Mala and the Broome chamber, and thank you, Nathan, for an outstanding contribution.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.37.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Zero Suicide </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="322" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.37.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" speakername="Tyron Whitten" talktype="speech" time="13:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On Thursday, you will see shoes being laid out on the lawn in front of the people's parliament in remembrance of the souls lost to suicide by the Zero Suicide community awareness program. Today, I ask this of my parliamentary colleagues: let's put politics aside on Thursday and work together. The number of Australians lost to suicide is a national tragedy. Please take the time on Thursday to go out on the grass, tie a ribbon on a pair of shoes or boots and let Australia know that you care about how many people we are losing to suicide each and every year. Let the volunteers know that you appreciate their efforts in moving over 20,000 shoes and boots during the year. Let them know we hear them.</p><p>Last year, 2,425 Australian men lost their lives to suicide. That's nearly seven men every single day. Men make up 76.5 per cent of suicides. Every morning in Australia, families are waking up without a father, a husband, a son or a brother who should still be here. And, every morning, there are men waking up who are silently wondering whether they can face another day. Almost three out of every four Australians who took their own lives were men. We may disagree on many things in this chamber, but surely we can agree that every Australian deserves to feel valued, supported and hopeful about their future. This parliament should be giving so much more support to men. This does not mean we should take anything away from women. This shouldn't be a contest. But we need to dedicate resources to understanding the challenges facing Australian men and boys. Strong men and strong women make stronger families, stronger communities and a stronger Australia. Let's put aside our differences for the good of our country on Thursday, because our suicide rate is a national tragedy and it's something all Australians ask us to face together.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.38.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Working Holiday Maker Program </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="275" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.38.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:54" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Earlier this year, this federal Labor government announced massive cuts to the number of backpackers that would be allowed into this country. Following pressure put on this government by and on behalf of the agriculture and tourism industries, this federal Labor government has done not one backflip but a double backflip on its cuts. The government is now adding some more days of required regional work to backpackers in their first year. They're now returning some of the numbers of backpackers who can stay on for a third year. But the fact is that cuts remain. This simply will not overcome the disaster that this country is going to be facing whilst food cannot be picked or pulled out of the ground and ends up rotting there instead and causing supermarket prices to skyrocket just like we experienced during the COVID days.</p><p>In another change today, it now looks like the promised new ballot system is called an application for a guarantee. No matter what name it's given, it will discourage backpackers from coming here in the first place, or it will stop backpackers from staying on for more than one year. We're also now hearing that the government is trying to set themselves up for another backflip&#x2014;a triple backflip. Are they politicians, or are they acrobats? They're trying to do a deal with the UK on UK working holiday visas to return to UK backpackers a requirement to perform regional work. Who can keep up? I'll tell you what this is. This is policy on the run, scapegoating backpackers in a political game in a race to the bottom on migration with One Nation.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.39.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Albanese Government </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="296" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.39.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" speakername="James McGrath" talktype="speech" time="13:56" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Labor's policymaking is all about backflipping. They announce a policy, they defend it, they refuse to engage with stakeholders, they go overseas, they ignore the warnings, they face the backlash, they go overseas again, and then they do the backflip. This is the Albanese Labor government's absurd approach to governing. They lurch from one policy disaster to another while Australians are left to pick up the pieces. Just last week, Labor was forced into an embarrassing backflip on its plans to sell off historic Defence sites after widespread community outrage from veterans and the broader community. Before that, Labor tried to impose a disgusting $5,000 cap on allied health services for veterans. Despite repeated warnings from the coalition, Labor pressed ahead before ungracefully backflipping again. Queensland Labor politicians, like Labor's Ali France in Dickson, even published videos telling veterans that Labor was doing the right thing. Seriously? How about not introducing bad policies in the first place? Then there was Labor's attempt to slash Commonwealth disaster recovery funding, leaving Queensland communities to foot the bill&#x2014;another spectacular backflip that, again, was defended by Labor's Matt Smith up in Cairns. But who could forget the disastrous plan of Jim Chalmers, the Treasurer, to tax unrealised super gains? That was another thought bubble that was eventually dumped.</p><p>But perhaps the biggest backflip of all is Anthony Albanese's broken promise on negative gearing and capital gains tax. Before the election, the Prime Minister explicitly ruled out such changes. Now Labor has done precisely what it promised Australians it would not do. This is not a government that listens to Australians. It is a government that is weak. It is a government that lies. It is led by a weak prime minister who's rarely in the same room as the truth.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.40.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Cubes Loses his Bum </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="146" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.40.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" speakername="Carol Louise Brown" talktype="speech" time="13:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I realise, being the last drop before question time, you normally have some controversial issue that you want to fire up the opposition with to set the tone for question time. But I have decided that we really need to lower the tone. We need to present an atmosphere of calm for the minister. I can't promise I won't leave the last 10 seconds for Minister Watt. So just be warned!</p><p>I had the great pleasure of officially launching the book <i>Cubes Loses </i><i>his </i><i>Bum</i> at Eastside Lutheran College in Warrane. Written by author and children's television producer David Gurney and Tasmanian illustrator Kim Linnett, <i>Cubes </i><i>Loses </i><i>his </i><i>Bum</i> tells the rather unfortunate but very entertaining story of a wombat who finds himself in a bit of trouble when his bum is blown off in the wind. Behind the humour is something genuinely worth celebrating. Murray!</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.41.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Wombats </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.41.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="13:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As the minister for the environment, I love all wombats, whether they have bums or no bums.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.41.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="13:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The time for statements has expired.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.42.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.42.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Taxation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="71" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.42.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Minister, 350,000 small businesses will be hit by your toxic trust tax restructure. They will not only have to get legal and accounting advice, which will cost thousands and thousands of dollars, but also have to rewrite every lease, every licence, every franchise agreement, every employment contract and every supplier contract. How much will that cost Australian small businesses?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="261" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.43.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank the senator for the question. I'll start by making the point in relation to trusts that only around five per cent of individual tax filers receive a discretionary trust contribution; 95 per cent do not. So let us be very clear that Senator Hume is standing up for the five per cent of taxpayers who get a trust distribution. We are standing up for the 95 per cent of Australians who do not get a trust distribution.</p><p>In relation to small business, I have said before here that I believe only 10 per cent of small businesses actually operate through trusts, and we are obviously working through the impact of trust reforms on small business. But again, Senator, I think the question is: why are you standing up for the 10 per cent and not the 90 per cent? Why aren't you standing up for the millions of taxpayers who do not get a trust distribution? It is very clear that those opposite are only interested in the five per cent. They are only interested in safeguarding the tax benefits which accrue to those Australians who do have trusts and distribute wealth through those trusts.</p><p>We are engaging in tax reform, which is about making sure we make the system fairer and that we align more fairly the taxation of income from assets and the taxation of income from labour. Given the numbers of Australians who do benefit from a fairer tax system, I would suggest to the opposition that they are on the wrong side of this debate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.43.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hume, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="76" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.44.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="14:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, you may think that 350,000 small businesses are tax avoiders. Over here on this side of the chamber, we certainly do not. You've told them that, in order to avoid your toxic trust tax, they can enter into excluded election trust regimes. But what happens if their circumstances change, with a son or daughter coming home to work in the family business? Will they be slugged with a 47 per cent tax in that year?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="44" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.44.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Before I call the minister, I'm going to remind senators, particularly those on my left, that Senator Hume was able to give her question in complete and respectful silence, and that is how I expect the answer to be received: in the same way.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="119" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.45.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I said in my primary answer, the vast majority of small businesses do not operate through a trust. Fewer than 10 per cent are affected in any given year, and the Treasurer has ensured there are a range of options for existing trusts, which include paying a wage to beneficiaries employed in the trust, restructuring into a fixed trust or company with expanded rollover relief, and choosing to be exempt from the minimum tax as long as they do not change the allocation of distributions from year to year.</p><p>I would also make this point, Senator Hume: this is a measure which provides a shift in how we tax in this country, a shift that more fairly aligns&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.45.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="interjection" time="14:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's called socialism.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="43" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.45.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'll take that interjection. She says it's socialism to tax people more fairly. She says it's socialism to make sure 95 per cent of taxpayers get a fair deal. You are for the five per cent, and we all know that. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.45.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hume, second supplementary.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="64" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.46.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="14:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, the 350,000 small businesses around Australia that are being hit by your toxic trust tax may not be able to restructure to an excluded election trust. But is it true, as we heard in the inquiry, that the owners of those businesses would need to earn $230,000 per annum in order to not pay higher taxes under your 30 per cent minimum tax?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.46.2" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="36" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.46.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Once again, before I call the minister, I'm going to remind those on my left that the time for you to make a comment is during taking note of answers, not when the minister is speaking.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="155" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.47.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On small business, as I said yesterday, we understand the extent to which small businesses are a substantially important part of the economy. That is why it is a good thing that we see the number of new small business registrations up. That is why it is a good thing that we are seeing 30 times more businesses opening than closing. It's why it is a good thing that big businesses are required to pay small suppliers faster. And it is a good thing that the Commonwealth, through its procurement practices, is ensuring that we are paying twice as fast as the average. It is a good thing that the budget includes new practical measures worth billions of dollars, including to benefit small business, including making the instant asset write-off permanent&#x2014;a $20,000 instant asset write-off. This is a tax benefit. This is a benefit to small business. And that is the right thing to do.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.48.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Economy </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="69" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.48.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" speakername="Tammy Tyrrell" talktype="speech" time="14:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister for Finance, Senator Gallagher. The Treasurer confirmed today that the Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook will contain savings to build on the work the Albanese Labor government has done since coming to government. What measures will the Albanese Labor government take to further strengthen the budget in next month's MYEFO? And why is it important that the responsible approach to budget management continues?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="312" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.49.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="14:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Tyrrell for that question. It is an important one. It's about the decisions we are taking now and it's also about the decisions we've taken in previous budget updates and budgets since coming to government&#x2014;that, since day one of forming government, we have consistently been cleaning up a mess that we inherited. And we've been investing in the essential services the Australian people rely on, whether it's making sure Services Australia is funded properly so it can deliver the services people need through the income support system or whether it's investing in our energy system, the grid, to make sure it operates properly and keeps prices as low as they can be for households&#x2014;again, something ignored by those opposite.</p><p>It's about whether we get the NDIS back on track so we can manage the costs associated with a scheme that's really important for people in this country who have a disability. Under those opposite, the scheme had been allowed to grow uncontrollably and without systems in place. And it's about aged care and whether we can fund and provide all the packages we need for a growing population of elderly Australians&#x2014;again, an area that was a mess when we came to government and one that we've methodically worked through and are reforming over time, and there's more work to do there. It's about whether we've got the money to invest in defence&#x2014;in actual capability, not just a media release, as those opposite used to issue, without actually delivering the capability the country needs to keep us safe.</p><p>Those are the big decisions we've been working on. We will continue on that path in MYEFO. It will have additional savings, just as every budget and every MYEFO have had since we came to government, to make sure we have the funds available to invest in the services Australians rely upon.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.49.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Tyrrell, first supplementary.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="47" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.50.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" speakername="Tammy Tyrrell" talktype="speech" time="14:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Albanese Labor government has been repairing the budget position left behind by the coalition, including finding $180 billion in savings and reprioritisations. Why was that task necessary from day one? And why will the government continue to find sensible savings to repair and strengthen the budget?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="173" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.51.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="14:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Tyrrell for the supplementary question, because it is an important one about something we will be finalising some decisions around over the next few weeks. It is important to continue to repair the budget over time. We inherited a budget with massive deficits, debt growing and escalating at a very fast rate and essential services that weren't being delivered and weren't in the state that they needed to be in to provide services to the Australian community. We have been doing that work. It is difficult work and it has taken a number of budgets. We will continue to do it.</p><p>At the same time, we have faced considerable criticism from those opposite, who criticise every saving and every reform. They criticise every decision, every reform, every piece of legislation and every saving that come into this place. They say no to everything and, at the same time, are promising to spend much more than what's outlined in our budget papers without any way to pay for it. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.51.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Tyrrell, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="38" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.52.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" speakername="Tammy Tyrrell" talktype="speech" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Albanese Labor government have funded our commitments while making difficult decisions on sensible savings measures and repairing the budget. Why have the minister and the Treasurer taken this approach, and why is this savings task so important?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="104" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Tyrrell for that question. We'll continue to make those difficult decisions to ensure that we can continue to deliver the services Australians deserve. We're upfront about the hard decisions that need to be made and also the important investments that need to be made to keep services being provided at a standard that Australians expect.</p><p>But those opposite&#x2014;and yesterday I referred to them as a bunch of hypocrites&#x2014;are hypocrites, and we should hold them to account. At the same time they are criticising the government and saying we have to reduce services and reduce investment, they are spending out of control.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" speakername="James McGrath" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We're not in government; we're not spending anything.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="61" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="continuation" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I don't know if any of you have woken up to how that is what is happening. You've made promises that you're going to repeal all the reforms we've made, you're going to increase funding to defence, you're going to build the Inland Rail, you're going to do all these things, and you have absolutely no way to pay for them.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>You're the government.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="27" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>President, I raise a point of order on disorderly conduct, including by the Leader of the Opposition in the Senate, who should show a little more leadership.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Remember when you used to sit here? Seriously.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="39" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Minister Wong. You would be aware that I did call 'order' about five times. There was so much noise I don't think anyone heard me. But the minister is right. Respectful silence is what is called for.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.10" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="continuation" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The only thing I'll say is that we know what they'll do to pay for it. They'll cut Medicare, they'll come after workers and they will&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" speakername="Sarah Henderson" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Your own backbenchers are disgusted with you.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="23" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.53.12" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order, across the chamber! Senator Henderson, you may not have noticed, but Senator Kovacic is on her feet trying to ask her question.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.54.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects in Victoria </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="119" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.54.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="14:12" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Minister Wong. Yesterday, Victorian Premier Ben Carroll defended his decision to establish a royal commission, saying he did it 'because it was the right thing to do'. He went on to say:</p><p class="italic">I could have delayed it, I could have run away from it. Do you know what I did? I actually ran towards the royal commission.</p><p>Premier Carroll then said:</p><p class="italic">I love the Labor movement, I've been a member of it since I was 14.</p><p class="italic">But I love the state of Victoria even more.</p><p>Minister, when will the Albanese Labor government love Australia more than they love the CFMEU and support a Senate inquiry into corruption in construction?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="51" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.55.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We can tell that there's a state election on, and the Victorians here are seeking to demonstrate to their colleagues that they are campaigning whilst in Canberra. Some are actually campaigning, I believe. But, anyway, I'll leave that there. Senator Kovacic, we've taken stronger action than you ever did in government.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.55.2" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="24" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.55.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Your yelling does not make your argument any more logical. Your yelling does not make you make any more sense. You just get louder.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.55.4" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="30" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.55.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order! There needs to be silence. I've had to call order on nearly every answer that's been given this afternoon. That's not acceptable. I want respectful silence. Minister, please continue.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="102" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.55.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I was saying through you, President, to Senator Kovacic, we have taken stronger action than a coalition government has ever taken against the CFMEU. The Prime Minister also took action, which is well known, in relation to the leadership of the CFMEU. And we have achieved more progress than those opposite ever did because we do believe that corruption, criminality and violence are not to be tolerated anywhere and not in the construction industry. As proud trade unionists, we also believe that the trade union movement and the labour movement should never be tainted by that kind of corruption and criminality.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.55.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Kovacic, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="69" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.56.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="14:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, Premier Carroll also appears to love Robert F Kennedy, pointing to him as one of his heroes and noting Kennedy's work investigating organised crime and corruption in the labour movement through the US Senate. Premier Carroll clearly recognises the value of Senate inquiries in exposing corruption and criminal infiltration. Why won't the Albanese Labor government recognise that same principle and support a Senate inquiry into corruption in construction?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="39" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.57.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>There is certainly one aspect of what the senator said which I agree with and that is her regard for Premier Carroll. I would invite her to participate in supporting his campaign, given she thinks so well of him.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.57.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Kovacic, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="63" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.58.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, more than 64,000 Australians have signed our petition calling for a Senate inquiry into corruption in construction. When will your government agree to support that inquiry? You have another opportunity to do that today. Will Labor finally listen to the Australians demanding answers and save them billions of dollars, or will you once again vote against an inquiry into corruption in construction?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="73" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.59.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We are taking action against corruption in construction. Let's be clear; we're not talking about it. We have acted and we continue to act, which is why you see progress in what the administrator is doing, why you see multiple referrals from police and regulators, and why there are over 100 active investigations, cases, audits and reviews into the construction sector. So we are already acting and we will continue to do so.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.60.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Artificial Intelligence: Intellectual Property </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="94" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.60.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="speech" time="14:17" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Australia has a copyright regime that's worked for over 100 years, a regime that has protected the rights and supported the employment of creative workers and authors&#x2014;journalists included&#x2014;for decades. Why is the Australian government even considering proposals from US AI companies to undermine the very principle of copyright, and isn't it true that an opt-out model undermines the very notion that an artist owns and controls their own work&#x2014;how it is allowed to be used&#x2014;and that they're paid fairly for its use?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="254" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.61.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Hanson-Young for the question. I'd start by saying Australian creatives are world class and we are committed, as a government, to supporting them. But I think in part of your question, Senator, there was a discussion about the history of copyright but not about the current reality, which is that, right now, creators in Australia are for the most part not being paid and have no control. But their works are still being used because, in part, that AI training is not occurring here in Australia. So I think it is wrong to suggest that artificial intelligence, and its deployment, is not already having an effect on Australian rights holders. So the question is not no change. The question has to be: what is the change that best protects and most effectively protects the Australian creatives?</p><p>We want to ensure the strongest copyright protection for Australian artists. To do that, that means we need to be active and involved in frontier AI training and development.</p><p>I know that the ministers engaged in this&#x2014;including the Attorney-General and Minister Ayres, and Minister Burke&#x2014;are engaging very closely with the sector on this, and we understand, absolutely, their concerns. We also are concerned, because this goes not only to their own proprietary interest; it also goes to our identity as a nation, because our creative sector does speak to who we are and expresses our views, our experience and our identity as Australians. So the government will keep engaging constructively. I know the ministers are.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.61.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hanson-Young, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="24" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.62.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="speech" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In response to the minister's answer to my first question: if work is already being stolen, why are you wanting to legalise that theft?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="29" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I don't accept the premise of the second part of that question. That is not the approach the government has taken. You know that is not, and I know&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="interjection" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That's what it's going to do.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It isn't.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="interjection" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That's what's happening.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="70" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, Senator, that is not the approach the government is taking. I've outlined to you, and the Attorney-General has outlined to you, what we are seeking to do, and I think it is important that we try to deal with this responsibly, recognising the imperative of the national interest, of ensuring that the copyright protections for our artists and creative sector are effective, in a world where artificial intelligence is&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" speakername="Sarah Henderson" talktype="interjection" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>AGD doesn't even understand copyright law.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>already accessing and utilising&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="50" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm sorry, Minister Wong. Please resume your seat. Senator Henderson, I should not have to call you by name. I called order at least three times. You completely ignored me. When I call 'Order', it applies to you. I expect you to listen in respectful silence. Minister Wong, please continue.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="22" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.10" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As the Prime Minister has made clear, artificial intelligence presents significant opportunities, but we must pursue these on Australian terms. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.63.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hanson-Young, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="57" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.64.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="speech" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The only reason, Minister, we are having this debate is because big AI wants Australia to create a loophole to legalise this theft. As big AI tries to steal from Australian artists, replace Australian workers and take our water and energy, does the Prime Minister stand with Jimmy Barnes and the working class man, or big tech?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="11" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.65.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Prime Minister and this government stand for Australia, always, and&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.65.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order! Minister Wong.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="136" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.65.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>First, artificial intelligence presents enormous opportunities and great risks&#x2014;and there will be differences of views about how they are to be navigated. But it is, I think, not open to any government&#x2014;and, frankly, not to any serious political party&#x2014;to pretend you can just avert your eyes and that things will never change. They are changing. So the question is: how do we ensure that we do this on Australian terms?</p><p>When it comes to data centres, the Prime Minister, some months ago, already articulated the need for mandatory standards and the need for social licence to be retained when it comes to copyright. We are consulting. We are engaging. But let us not pretend that we do not already have a challenge, where Australian creative content is being used without protection in different jurisdictions. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.66.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Gas Industry </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.66.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="speech" time="14:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, President.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.66.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Grogan, please resume your seat. Senator Hanson-Young and Senator Shoebridge, we have moved on.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="50" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.66.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="continuation" time="14:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Resources, Senator Ayres. For too long, Australians have faced volatile gas prices, despite being one of the world's largest gas exporters. Looking at the domestic gas reservation, how will this landmark economic reform fix 25 years of patchy gas-market policy?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="245" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.67.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="14:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Grogan for that for that question. 'Landmark economic reform', she says. Well, Senator, you took the words right out of my mouth. For 25 years, Commonwealth gas policy has been patchwork at best. Australia became one of the world's largest gas exporters, but we did not do what every other gas exporting economy has done. We did not reserve Australian gas, which is the birthright of Australians, for Australian industry and Australian households. We did not take that step to build our sovereignty. Successive governments failed to grapple with that reality, and that has meant that Australian households have been exposed to prices that have been too high. Australian businesses have been exposed to gas prices that have made it hard for them to compete. Most acutely, in our heavy industrial sector where gas is required to provide not just energy as a heat source but, in many examples, energy as a feedstock and a chemical process, high gas prices have forced them offshore.</p><p>Under the former coalition government, the position became more volatile and more expensive. The only thing that the former government offered was a three-word slogan: gas fired recovery. That delivered zero. That delivered zero for heavy industry and saw closures continue to happen and jobs continue to flood offshore. This Albanese government has brought to this parliament a sensible landmark reform that will deliver for Australia and deliver for Australian business and heavy industry in particular. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.67.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Grogan, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="45" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.68.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="speech" time="14:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The domestic gas reservation is an important reform for providing certainty to industry and ensuring the future of Australian manufacturing. What is at risk for investment in Australian manufacturing and Australian jobs if we fail to deliver a more reliable and affordable supply of gas?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="141" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.69.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="14:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p> (&#x2014;) (): The parliament has a choice this week: low-cost gas or high-cost gas. It's a binary choice, really. It presents a risk for business investment, and it presents a risk for Australian jobs. It presents a risk for those businesses right now, in Australia's outer suburbs and our heavy industrial regions, who rely upon gas and low gas prices. Every closure that occurs in that sector&#x2014;every closure&#x2014;will be on the heads of members of parliament and senators here who do not vote for that reform. Just as importantly, it's what you won't hear about, what Australians won't hear about, which is the investment decisions that are not made if this reform is not delivered through this place this week&#x2014;investment in new manufacturing that doesn't happen if the parliament fails to come to grips with its responsibility to Australia. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.69.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Grogan, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="46" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.70.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="speech" time="14:27" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It seems abundantly clear that the Albanese Labor government is making it a priority to put Australia's national interests first and deliver more affordable gas for Australians. What is at stake if this important economic reform is delayed, and what would this mean for gas prices?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="168" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.71.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="14:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p> (&#x2014;) (): Well, this goes to the heart of Australia's future competitiveness. If the parliament fails to grapple with this, if the parliament fails to rise to this challenge, we cannot make low-cost gas a source of future competitiveness for Australian industry. That's the test. It's a basic economic test. You're for high prices or low prices. You're for consistent supply or unreliable supply. You're for the status quo, where jobs flood offshore, or you're for Australian jobs first and for Australian industry. That is the choice. That is the choice. This is targeted at the heart of this fundamental competitiveness question and at a future for blue-collar jobs. Don't put on the high vis and don't try and look manufacturing workers in the eye if you don't deliver this reform through the parliament, because they know hypocrites when they see them. They know hypocrites when they see them. Let's do it together. Let's actually do the job this parliament was meant to do for Australia. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.72.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Tasmania: Infrastructure </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="93" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.72.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="speech" time="14:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government. When the Prime Minister flew down to Hobart in 2023 to officially announce that he was giving the Tasmanian government $240 million of taxpayers' money for the Macquarie state stadium project, Mr Albanese promised that the stadium precinct would include social and affordable housing and recreational spaces. Is the federal government's funding contingent on social and affordable housing being built, and can the minister tell me exactly how many social and affordable houses will be built?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="137" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.73.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="speech" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Senator Lambie, for the awareness of your question about the stadium. We certainly have given a lot of support for the Macquarie Point precinct. We've said that our contribution of $240 million for urban redevelopment is capped. It does require the Tasmanian government to meet a range of conditions that are set out in a federation funding agreement. We have certainly committed to the delivery of housing at Macquarie Point, including a portion of that for affordable essential worker or social housing at Regatta Point. The precinct will include housing for allied health professionals and other health related workers in a location nearby the Royal Hobart Hospital and the University of Tasmania's medical school. We've also committed $188 million to upgrade the Macquarie Wharf 6, safeguarding the operations and ensuring Hobart remains Australia's Antarctic gateway.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.73.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Lambie, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="64" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.74.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="speech" time="14:31" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Prime Minister told Tasmanians that the $240 million would be capped, but the ABC has reported today that the Tasmanian premier and the Tasmanian treasurer have been in talks with the federal government asking for more funding for the Macquarie Port stadium project. Is the federal government considering giving more of Australia's taxpayer money for a stadium in Tasmania that it doesn't need?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="55" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.75.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="speech" time="14:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We certainly do care about Tasmania, Senator Lambie, and conversations between the Commonwealth and Tasmania will always be ongoing because we are doing many other things for Tasmania as well as bulk-billing practices&#x2014;76. We've got eight new UCCs, we've got $13 million of cheaper scripts in Tasmania. We will always be negotiating with the state&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.75.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Lambie.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="56" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.75.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="interjection" time="14:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Point of order: I just asked about the federal funding for Macquarie Point stadium. That was the discussion. I don't need to hear anything else. I just need to know what's come out of those discussions. They've been back up here with their hand out, so are you or are you not giving them more money?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="10" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.75.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Lambie, the minister is being relevant to your question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="56" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.75.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="continuation" time="14:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I can certainly follow up if there's been an update to discussions. We know that, when the premier came to parliament in the last sittings&#x2014;and also, I think, the Tasmanian Devils came up. A lot of Tasmanian senators did meet with them, and I can certainly find out if there's been any progress from those conversations.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.75.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Lambie, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="44" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.76.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="speech" time="14:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Today and every other day, the failure of Tasmania's health system is in the front-page news. What's new? What assurances did the federal government seek from the Tasmanian government that Macquarie Point stadium would not negatively impact essential services for the people of Tasmania?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="80" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.77.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="speech" time="14:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I can certainly say that we are very much looking at all the issues, particularly around health. I can go directly to your question in more detail later, but, as I did say there before, we have been providing so much support in health, with 76 new bulk-billing practices. We've got the bulk-billing rate up from 65 per cent to 79 per cent, we've got the eight UCCs in Tassie. I'm certainly happy to come back to you, Senator Lambie.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.78.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Health Care </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="124" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.78.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="speech" time="14:34" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Health, Disability and Ageing, Minister McAllister. Minister, yesterday Ahpra released new figures showing that, for the fourth year in a row, more overseas Australian doctors were registered than Australian medical graduates. Nearly three in five new doctors are now overseas trained. The National Medical Workforce Strategy recommended some time ago that the government improve our domestic self-sufficiency and give young Aussies a chance to become the doctors that we will need now and into the decades ahead. My question is: why are fewer and fewer of our doctors trained in Australia year after year, and why are we becoming so reliant on pinching medical skills from other countries, who also desperately need those skills?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="284" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.79.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Pocock, our government shares, I think, the intent expressed in your question, which is to see more and more of our medical workforce trained here. Thanks to our government, more doctors have joined our healthcare system in the last two years than at any time in the past decade. It reflects our acknowledgement that there is a growing demand for health care and a growing demand for care more generally. More doctors are registering to practice in Australia, more junior doctors are training to become GPs, and more medical graduates are aspiring to become GPs since our government's record investment to strengthen Medicare.</p><p>We are making a $617 million investment to deliver more doctors and more nurses. That includes $265 million to expand GP training, with an extra 200 training places per year from 2026, increasing to an extra 400 places per year from 2028. There is also a $204 million investment for salary incentives for junior doctors who specialise in general practice. There is $43.9 million to provide paid parental leave and study leave for trainee GPs; $44 million for an extra 200 rotations for junior doctors into primary health care per year from 2026, increasing to an extra 400 per year from 2028; and $48.4 million for an extra 100 Commonwealth supported places for medical students per year from 2026, increasing to 150 per year by 2028. There is, in addition to this, a $10&#xBD; million investment for 400 scholarships for nurses and midwives to extend their skills. This is producing the strongest workforce recovery in memory. We accept that there is more to do, but we are making the necessary investments in our workforce because we believe in public health.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.79.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Pocock, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="85" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.80.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="speech" time="14:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, our reliance on overseas trained doctors is well above the OECD average. I acknowledge that the Labor government has expanded the number of Commonwealth supported places by 100 extra places from this year, but I hold that up against the Department of Health saying that we'll be short 12,000 specialists by 2048. Those 100 extra a year are clearly not going to fix that gap. How will the government fill the shortage of specialists that will be needed in communities over the coming decades?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="130" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.81.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It is simply not the case that we can run the healthcare system without skilled workers from overseas. We depend on migration to fill critical gaps in hospitals, in aged care and in primary care that we cannot meet through local training alone, and we don't see it as a dichotomy, Senator Pocock. Migration strengthens not replaces our local workforce. It is the case that almost 19,800 doctors from overseas have registered to practice in Australia since July 2022, and they are migrating from a range of countries, including from the UK and Ireland, to build a life in Australia. One in two doctors that newly registered to practice in 2024-25 were educated overseas, and 54,000 nurses and midwives from overseas have registered to practice in Australia since July 2022.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.81.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Pocock, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="80" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.82.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="speech" time="14:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>But, Minister, when the majority of doctors registered every year over the last four years is more than the number of Australian doctors who are registering, that's not strengthening. We are relying on countries who also need these skills, because we're a wealthy country and we're not willing to invest in the future. Is it time to actually expand the Commonwealth paid prac to those studying medicine, given what we're seeing&#x2014;the dire need for more Australians to be studying medicine?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="158" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.83.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Pocock, in my answer to your primary question, I provided detailed information to you about the very significant investment that we are making in the health workforce, and that is in training doctors, ensuring that we have doctors that are willing to invest their time in becoming GPS so they can serve communities, including rural communities, and investing in nursing as well. It is the truth that by the time of the 2022 election, the health workforce was exhausted. It was depleted after a decade of Liberal cuts and neglect. But we don't assert that this workforce can be sustained exclusively by training Australians. We welcome those trained professionals who want to come and make a life here, and I think the communities that they work in welcome them too. I think Australians very much appreciate the men and women who come here and serve in the health workforce in a range of communities across our country.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.84.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Iran </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="145" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.84.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Senator Wong. On Wednesday 11 November the United Nations General Assembly elected the Islamic Republic of Iran to the UN Committee for Programme and Coordination, 144 votes to 39. This was a secret ballot, which doesn't sound very open, democratic or transparent. In 2021, Iran was elected to the UN Commission on the Status of Women and expelled in 2022 due to its violent crackdown on nationwide protests and systematic suppression of the human rights of women and girls. Australia co-sponsored the removal option. Sadly, since then, Australia's opposition to Iran appears to have weakened. Minister, did Australia vote in favour of the Islamic Republic of Iran taking a position on the UN Committee for Programme and Coordination? And, if we did oppose, why did we not join the United States in registering a formal objection?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="265" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.85.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The first point I'd make is that the senator spoke about our actions against Iran, and I would make the point that I have made previously, which is that Australia under this government has taken stronger action against Iran than any previous government. In fact, those opposite never held Iran to account&#x2014;nine long years, not one new sanction, not one word of complaint when Iran was elected to the UN Commission on the Status of Women, even though we were a committee at the time that. We have sanctioned more than 230 Iran linked persons and entities, including 100 IRGC linked individuals and entities. We have altered and put in place a sanctions framework that enables us to target those involved in oppression inside Iran, including against women and girls. We have expelled the Iranian ambassador to Australia and three Iranian diplomats. We have listed Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, the IRGC, as a state sponsor of terrorism.</p><p>And, as you noted, we were at the forefront of efforts to remove Iran from the Commission for the Status of Women, and we have co-sponsored the successful human rights council resolution establishing the independent investigation into human rights violations. I will ensure that I provide you with full information, but I think I made a public statement on 12 November in the following terms: 'Australia strongly opposes and voted against Iran's appointment to the UN Committee for Programme and Coordination. Iran's human rights violations and destabilising conduct undermine multilateralism. Australia stands with the people of Iran.' That was a public statement from me on that date.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.85.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Roberts, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="59" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.86.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="14:43" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The United States declared last Wednesday's vote morally bankrupt, which is accurate. It seems the Australian government's opposition to Iran's regime has become tepid at best. Minister, has the UN with this vote taken a pro-Islamic position, effectively rehabilitating the Islamic Republic of Iran and then siding with that totalitarian, barbaric, terrorist regime against our ally, the United States?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="67" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.87.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I take objection to the words you used in relation to Australia's position. I think I have just outlined the action we have taken. It is stronger action than any previous Australian government. In relation to the vote, I made clear publicly last week that we opposed and voted against their appointment. I disagree with the wording and the point that you've made in your first supplementary.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.87.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Roberts, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="60" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.88.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="14:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Islamic Republic of Iran is violently murdering and, in some cases, raping their own citizens protesting the regime. Human rights groups put the number of executions in the last 12 months between 3,000 and 7,000. Why didn't Australia formally object to the vote which rehabilitated this murderous regime? Don't the lives of women and men matter to your government?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="128" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.89.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Roberts, I've now said this three times. We opposed and voted against their appointment in the UN to the Committee for Programme and Coordination. I don't know how much how many more times I can explain that. I've also said we have&#x2014;you are right to point out the way in which this regime brutalises and oppresses its people, which is why we have sanctioned to an extent no Australian government has. You are right to speak about the actions of the IRGC, which is why we have listed them as a terrorist organisation or state sponsor of terrorism. We agree on those issues. I don't believe this is a point of domestic partisanship. I think Australia should be united in our support for the people of Iran.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.90.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Medicare </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="86" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.90.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" speakername="Charlotte Walker" talktype="speech" time="14:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Health and Ageing, Senator McAllister. Delivering affordable health care when and where Australians need it is a key priority for the Albanese Labor government. Last year, the government made the single largest investment in the history of Medicare, delivering on our commitment to increase bulk-billing. New quarterly data released today shows more Australians are accessing care at bulk-billing GP practices. How is the government helping more Australians see a GP for free and easing cost-of-living pressures?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="280" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.91.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It is always great to share new figures that show just how important bulk-billing is to Australians, and the latest quarterly data is another reminder of the strong difference that a strong Medicare can make. When we came to government, bulk-billing was in free fall. That is why we made the investments in Medicare that we did, and those investments are delivering results. Just a year ago, there were around 2,300 fully bulk-billing GP practices across Australia. Today, there are 4,000. That's more places that families can turn to. That's fewer Australians having to ring around looking for a doctor that they can afford. In regional centres, bulk-billing has risen to 84.7 per cent. That is up 8.1 percentage points. In your home state of South Australia, Senator Walker, bulk-billing has increased by 7&#xBD; percentage points, reaching 82 per cent. Importantly, for pensioners, veterans and other concession-card holders, 93.2 per cent of GP services were bulk-billed.</p><p>These figures translate into real savings for Australians. That is more pensioners being able to see their doctor without having to worry about a gap fee. That is more parents who are able to take a sick child to the GP without another unexpected bill landing later on the kitchen table. That is more Australians managing their health without having to manage another out-of-pocket expense, because, on this side of the chamber, we have a firm conviction that health should be available to Australians when they need it not just when they can afford it. That is why we are making the largest single investment in Medicare's history, and it's why we're seeing the difference that that investment is making right across the country.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.91.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Walker, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="67" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.92.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" speakername="Charlotte Walker" talktype="speech" time="14:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We on this side of the chamber know that a strong Medicare means having places people can go to get the care they need when they need it. It's why the Albanese Labor government has delivered Medicare urgent care clinics right across Australia. How are Medicare urgent care clinics making a difference for Australians and providing access to free urgent care when their regular GP is closed?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="145" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.93.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>When we came to government, we wanted to make sure that Australians had somewhere to go when they needed urgent medical care, because, as any parent knows, kids don't tend to get sick or hurt themselves against a schedule. In fact, they get sick usually just before dinner or on Saturday afternoon. We didn't want families waiting for hours if they didn't need to in an emergency department for something like a sprain or a cut. That is why Medicare urgent care clinics are so important.</p><p>We've now opened 137 clinics across the country. More than 3&#xBD; million Australians have received treatment. These clinics provide free bulk-billed care for urgent but non-life-threatening conditions, seven days a week. Importantly, these clinics are now a permanent part of our primary care system, giving families somewhere to turn and helping take the pressure off busy hospital emergency departments.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.93.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Walker, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="64" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.94.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" speakername="Charlotte Walker" talktype="speech" time="14:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's clear that the Albanese Labor government's investments in Medicare are delivering real change and helping Australians get the care they need. A strong primary care system is essential to keeping Australians healthy and taking pressure off our hospitals. Why is it important that the government continues to strengthen primary care? Can the minister outline whether anything stands in the way of this approach?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="159" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.95.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Being a responsible government means making choices that deliver for Australians. It means investing in the services that Australians rely on, strengthening Medicare and ensuring that our hospitals can focus on those who need the highest level of care. When Australians see a GP to get an infection treated or have an injury seen to early, we can prevent more serious health problems and ease pressure on our hospitals. That is why we're investing in primary care and in Medicare urgent care clinics.</p><p>Now, there are different approaches and there are obstacles, because those opposite described Medicare urgent care clinics as 'wasteful spending'. Those are their words, not ours. Let's not forget that the current opposition leader wanted the coalition's freeze on Medicare rebates to go even further. The current opposition leader described a GP co-payment as reasonable. The opposition continued this approach. They continue the approach they had in government, diminishing public health and limiting access to bulk-billing.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.96.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Taxation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="68" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.96.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" speakername="Matthew Canavan" talktype="speech" time="14:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong, Minister, you claim that farmers are exempt from your new trust tax, but family farms earning income from leasing land, farm stays and other diversified activities are still caught. Why are your government and Anthony Albanese punishing hardworking farming families for trying to keep their farms viable, just to squeeze another dollar out of regional Australia?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="90" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Senator Canavan. I think I've answered this question quite a few times. I've indicated to you that the advice that the Treasurer has provided is that farming income will be exempt, so we seem to be having the same conversation. I also would say to you, Senator, as I said to Senator Cash before, that 95 per cent of Australian taxpayers do not get a distribution from a trust, and I think that is relevant. It is relevant to think about how it is you distribute most fairly&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.2" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I was saying, the tax reform that we've engaged in does ensure we treat more fairly&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.5" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.7" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="12" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I've just been waiting for silence, and you've just kept on interjecting.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="24" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Again, what I'd say is that 95 per cent of Australian taxpayers do not receive a distribution from a trust. Five per cent do.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.10" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="24" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ruston, I shouldn't have to call you by name to come to order. I've called for order, and you just kept on interjecting.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="104" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.12" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I said, farm income earned by a trust is an exception to our changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts, and that is reasonable. It is an important exception. It is an exception which recognises the importance of primary production. But I think what the senator is proposing is that there should be a general exemption available which is not available to any other trust beneficiary in similar circumstances. The design of the policy recognises the importance of primary production income. It is excluded from the minimum tax on trusts that the government is proposing because we recognise the importance of supporting farmers.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.97.13" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Canavan, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="42" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.98.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" speakername="Matthew Canavan" talktype="speech" time="14:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Family farms are passed down through generations. Farmers use trusts to protect their assets, manage risks and provide for their children. Why is Labor forcing farming families to choose between paying more tax and restructuring businesses their families have spent generations building?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="83" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.99.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Again, I'd say that we are exempting farm income earned by a trust because we recognise the importance of primary production. That is a recognition of the importance of farmers in the design of the policy. For those that do want to restructure, we are providing plenty of notice ahead of 2028, and the government has announced rollover relief for three years, which would enable people to ensure that they can manage their affairs in a way that is most tax-beneficial to them.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.99.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Canavan, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="49" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.100.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" speakername="Matthew Canavan" talktype="speech" time="14:56" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Farmers are battling rising fuel, energy, insurance and production costs, and there always remains the ever-present threat of drought. Farm Management Deposits help farmers manage drought by helping to average income across years. Will farmers that incorporate to avoid Labor's trust tax still have access to Farm Management Deposits?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="48" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.101.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:56" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The advice I have is that the Farm Management Deposits scheme will continue to operate as intended. It is obviously an important and well established tool to help farmers manage the ups and downs of agricultural income. In relation to restructuring, I refer you to my earlier answer.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.102.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Housing </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="88" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.102.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="14:57" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister for the Environment and Water, Senator Watt. The Albanese Labor government's plan to drive growth and boost the capacity of our economy is focused on putting downward pressure on inflation while lifting living standards. Increasing housing supply is key to both, and that means making it easier to build the homes that future generations of Australians will need. How are the government's landmark reforms to our national environmental laws making it easier to build the projects that we need across our country?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="342" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.103.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="14:57" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thanks, Senator Dolega&#x2014;someone who I know wants to see a lot more homes built in this country and has voted for that, more importantly. You should try it sometime. All you've got to do is say the word 'aye' when we want to build more homes, just like Senator Dolega. That's how you get more homes in this country.</p><p>Our government understands that many Australians are under pressure right now, and our government is taking action to help them. We're making our economy more resilient while at the same time delivering help with the cost of living, including cutting taxes five times, providing more bulk-billing, expanding Paid Parental Leave and backing higher wages. Every single one of those measures was opposed by the Liberals, the Nationals and One Nation.</p><p>Another challenge is, of course, increasing productivity, including in the construction sector. To deal with the 20-year productivity challenge in our economy we're delivering the broadest productivity agenda in decades. As environment minister, my role includes ensuring approvals for key projects of national importance are better and faster while maintaining strong environmental standards. To do that, we've reformed Australia's outdated environmental laws, better known as the EPBC Act.</p><p>Labor's environmental law reforms were desperately needed to prevent the loss of the species that make our country so special. Equally, we'd seen project approval times blow out from a median timeframe of 48 weeks at the turn of the century to 118 weeks now. Those delays certainly aren't good for business, and they don't do anything to protect the environment either.</p><p>Our new EPBC Act is streamlining approvals, fast-tracking priority projects and giving developers more certainty, which means more homes for Australians more quickly. Our government has approved the construction of 85,000 homes in 114 residential development projects. Twenty of those projects have been approved since 1 July, resulting in 6,600 more homes being approved, and, overall, 93 per cent of statutory decisions under the act are now made on time, compared to as low as six per cent under the coalition. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.103.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:57" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Dolega, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="33" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.104.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="14:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That is indeed great news. Making it easier to build is central to the Albanese Labor government's productivity agenda. How much will these reforms save Australian businesses through the reduction of regulatory costs?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="192" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.105.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="15:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thanks, Senator Dolega. Our environmental law reforms, which, of course, were voted against by Senator Bragg over there, along with all of his colleagues, have been one of the key measures taken by the Albanese government to power up productivity. Analysis of the economic value of these reforms shows that they will deliver annual savings of at least half a billion dollars and up to $7 billion in total to the national economy. That's what you voted against, and I don't need to remind everyone that the coalition and One Nation voted against these vital reforms. They voted against more homes for Australians and more energy projects, and they voted against higher productivity. While they call, on the one hand, for spending cuts, they are right now blocking legislation that we've introduced into this parliament that would deliver $10 billion in further savings to the budget. This is just a small taste of what would lie ahead under the coalition if they ever got to form government with One Nation. They won't back $10 billion in savings under us, but we know that they would require a billion dollars of savings cuts&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.105.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="15:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Minister. Senator Dolega, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="50" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.106.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="15:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Albanese Labor government is delivering faster approvals, simpler regulations and better infrastructure, all designed to make it easier to build projects across Australia. What more is the government doing to speed up approvals and drive economic reform, and what obstacles do stand in the way of the government's approach?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="192" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.107.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="15:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thanks, Senator Dolega. Turning around decades of stagnant productivity growth won't happen overnight, but we are making good progress while acknowledging we still have got more to do. In the coming weeks, the final tranche of our EPBC reforms will come into effect, and we're working on bilateral agreements to streamline project approvals with state governments.</p><p>Now, despite the obvious productivity gains from these changes, I don't expect to see any support from the coalition for them. They voted against our EPBC reforms, they're blocking $10 billion worth of savings that we're trying to pass, and they can't even agree with their own savings plans&#x2014;because we heard this morning, on Radio National, Senator McLachlan being asked his view of the coalition's proposed savings measures, and what was his response? That he is totally opposed to them and that his own party's savings measures are illogical. That's what Liberal senators have to say about their own economic policy. Right now, Australians need a government that manages our economy responsibly while relieving cost-of-living pressures. They don't need a Liberal-National chaotic government with One Nation that delivers illogical savings and harms the economy. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.107.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="interjection" time="15:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I ask that further questions be placed on notice.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.108.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: ADDITIONAL ANSWERS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.108.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
United Nations Climate Change Conference </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="56" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.108.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="15:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In question time on Monday, I undertook to provide further information in response to questions asked of me by Senator McDonald, in my capacity as the Minister representing the Prime Minister, relating to Ask Izzy. I've written to the senator to provide that additional information, and I table the letter for the information of all senators.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.109.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Tasmania: Infrastructure </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="57" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.109.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="speech" time="15:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I wish to add to an answer I gave to Senator Lambie in question time today in my capacity as the Minister representing the Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government. I'm informed that we have received no formal request from Tasmania to further vary the funding agreement. Our contribution remains capped at $240 million.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.110.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
MOTIONS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.110.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Statute Update Bill 2026 </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7500" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7500">Statute Update Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="723" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.110.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" speakername="Susan McDonald" talktype="speech" time="15:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I seek leave to move a motion relating to the consideration of Senate amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026, as circulated.</p><p>Leave not granted.</p><p>Pursuant to contingent notice of motion and at the request of Senator McKenzie, I move:</p><p class="italic">That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving a motion to provide for the consideration of a matter, namely a motion to give precedence to a motion relating to the consideration of Senate amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026.</p><p>I rise today because this matter is urgent, and our veterans should not have to wait any longer for certainty about their health care. This Senate has already considered the issue. The Australian people expect that, when a chamber of this parliament votes on legislation, that decision is given proper consideration and acted upon. They do not expect legislation to simply be left sitting on someone's desk, unresolved and gathering dust. That is not how this parliament is supposed to operate. Australians elect us to do a job, and that job is to scrutinise legislation, make decisions and see the parliamentary process through.</p><p>It has heard the concerns of veterans, considered the evidence and voted on amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary restrictions on their allied health treatments. These amendments were agreed to by this Senate on 10 September. Yet, more than two months later, they remain unresolved in the House of Representatives. The question before us is simple: why should the Senate allow any further delay? Our veterans have served our country with courage, with commitment and with distinction. They have put their lives on the line to protect the freedoms and ways of life that Australians enjoy. The very least they should expect in return is a government that respects their service and delivers the support that they need.</p><p>But what we have seen is a troubling pattern from the Albanese government. Decisions affecting veterans are announced, defended and then reversed after significant public pressure. We saw it with the proposed 20-year time limit on retrospective military honours. We saw it when funding was cut to Invictus Australia, an organisation supporting injured and disabled veterans through sport. We saw it when travel support was withdrawn from Kaye and Doug Baird, the parents of Corporal Cameron Baird VC. And my reason for standing here today: we saw it with the proposed $5,000 annual threshold for veterans' allied health treatment. Each time veterans and their families were forced to speak up and to fight to have their concerns heard.</p><p>The $5,000 threshold is particularly concerning because it goes directly to veterans' access to health care. Veterans have made their concerns very clear. The Senate Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee also examined the issue and recommended that the Australian government consider legislative amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary and numerical restrictions on treatment. Even Labor senators acknowledged the government's decision not to proceed with the proposed annual monetary limit.</p><p>This Senate subsequently acted and agreed to amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026 on 10 September. These amendments are about a very straightforward principle: a veteran's health care should be determined by their clinical needs, not arbitrary financial thresholds or expenditure triggered, bureaucratic restrictions. And this is precisely why this matter cannot continue to sit unresolved.</p><p>Here we are on 17 November, and those amendments remain outstanding. What exactly are we waiting for? If the government supports protecting veterans from arbitrary restrictions, it should have no difficulty progressing this matter. And, if it disagrees with the amendments, then it should explain why. But what it cannot do is leave veterans in a state of uncertainty while the matter sits unresolved. That is the urgency before us today. This is not a request for another inquiry, another consultation or another government announcement; it is a request for the Senate to act on a matter that has already been considered and to ensure the House of Representatives is held to its commitment to honour these amendments. There is no reason to allow this to drift into another sitting period. We ask for certainty that this be dealt with this year. There is no reason to make veterans wait any longer for clarity about the protections this parliament intends to provide. It is about trust. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="150" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.111.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="15:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Greens very much support this suspension, and we support the substantive motion. We don't think it's a laughing matter; we think it's important that veterans get the protection that the Senate endeavoured to give to them.</p><p>We know why the government are opposing this motion, and we know why they refuse to move on the amendments that the Senate put into the legislation. Whatever they say, at any one moment, about veterans, they seem to be unwilling to back it up with clear legislation to make sure veterans are protected and that they won't do another sly job to try and put unfair caps and unfair limitations on the medical and treatment needs that veterans have&#x2014;because that's what the Senate said. We saw what this government did. We saw what Labor had proposed to do with veterans, without consulting with the veterans community&#x2014;putting arbitrary, unfair, damaging caps on veterans.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.111.2" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Government Senators" talktype="interjection" time="15:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Government senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="47" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.111.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="continuation" time="15:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The hypocrisy of this lot, who complain about interjections! They complain about interjections unless they're doing it themselves. Have you ever noticed that? These Labor ministers complain about interjections unless they're throwing it themselves. Their total hypocrisy is here for everybody to see. Everybody can see it.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.111.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="15:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order! Senator Shoebridge has a right to be heard.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="527" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.111.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="continuation" time="15:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I know Labor doesn't want this discussion. I know they're trying to do everything they can. They refused leave. They could have agreed to give leave to have this debate in an orderly way, but they are so desperate to avoid talking about their ugly attack on veterans rights, their decision to go and put arbitrary, unfair, damaging caps on the medical and other support that veterans could have, without ever talking to the veterans community&#x2014;without ever having the courage to go and talk to the veterans communities and say to them, to their faces: 'Oh, guys, thanks so much for the service. Thanks so much for putting on the uniform. We're actually, now, going to dud you and put arbitrary caps on.' Is it any wonder they didn't have that conversation with veterans? We know what veterans would have said: 'How dare you?'</p><p>Then, when you did it&#x2014;you did it in a dirty backroom deal inside the Labor Party&#x2014;veterans came out and said, 'How dare you?' And it turns out that the veterans have a far better sense of where community sentiment lies than the Labor Party has, because the community hated what you did, and they were willing to back in the veterans every single time. They have no time for your nasty way of making budget savings on the backs of the people who most need help. That's all it was&#x2014;it was a $1.5 billion budget saving you wanted to get from not giving essential medical care to veterans. And, when the Senate puts in place legal protections to say, 'You can never do it again,' you leave it parked in the other place and you refuse even to move on it. You put it into some kind of purgatory in the other house, refusing to move on it, because you don't want to commit to legal protections for veterans and their benefits.</p><p>What this motion is saying is: 'Pull it out of purgatory. Have a vote on it.' If it really is the Labor Party's position that you won't put in place clear legal protections to stop you from doing it again to veterans, well, have the guts to bring it on for a vote down in the other place, and then let's see how you get judged. Not by the Greens, not by the National Party&#x2014;let's see how you get judged by the Australian public if you have another go like this at veterans. Put the legislation to a vote down there. Have the courage next time to talk to veterans before you pickpocket them and take away their benefits, and move on that piece of legislation.</p><p>The Senate made it clear&#x2014;I think every single senator in this place, except for the Labor senators, wrapped themselves around that and said they supported it. We've made it clear. And I'll tell you why we made it clear. It was because we heard from the Australian public that Labor's plans for veterans were toxic&#x2014;they were wrong, they were nasty, and they were going to harm veterans. So move on the legislation, and have the courage to either vote it up or vote it down.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="662" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.112.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="15:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, that was quite a speech from Senator Shoebridge&#x2014;most of it misleading, as we've come to expect in this chamber. Honestly, to take a lecture from Senator Shoebridge, who uses every opportunity to criticise our defence forces&#x2014;in every estimates hearing, in every committee hearing I have ever sat in, he has been a deep critic. If he doesn't think that translates into veterans&#x2014;you do know that veterans actually work for the Defence Force that you criticise before they retire, Senator Shoebridge? Don't have a foot in each camp. One minute you're the leader of the Greens, the next minute you're a member of the coalition. That's what we're seeing play out in this chamber.</p><p>I won't be lectured by Senator Shoebridge about the extra investment, $16 billion, that we as a government have put into supporting veterans. Go back and have a look at the budget papers, Senator Shoebridge. It is $16 billion extra that has gone into supporting veterans in their post-ADF career. Don't come in here and call us the names you've called us. When we came to government, there were over 40,000 veterans claims sitting&#x2014;oh, yes, that's what you do, Senator Shoebridge. You come here and you have a spray, most of it misleading, and then you walk away. You walk away because you can't handle the facts, which are that we, as the government, have invested more in veterans care and support than any government, in the time that we have been in power, because of the mess that we inherited&#x2014;40,000 veterans not even having their claims processed. What have we done? We've invested in the department, they've dealt with the claims and $16 billion has flowed, quite rightly, to veterans for the claims that those opposite kept on the shelf.</p><p>In relation to the allied health reforms that we sought to put in place, we did two things: we increased the fees being paid to allied health practitioners in response to allied health practitioners seeking an increase in those arrangements; and we sought to reform an area that is growing considerably and continues to&#x2014;and, as finance minister, I have a responsibility to keep an eye on that. We have responded to the views of the Senate, and we have been clear and Minister Keogh has been clear&#x2014;and it was talked through with veterans. All that Senator Shoebridge says&#x2014;and for those listening: when he gives a speech like that, go and do a fact check on it, because most of it isn't factually correct.</p><p>We put out a public statement saying we will not proceed with those changes. That is on the public record. The finalisation of that will be clear through the budget update, as we make those reforms clear, but it has been made public. This motion is not needed because we are not pursuing the changes we sought, because the Senate said no. We've listened to the Senate. We have made a public statement. We are adjusting the costs. We are increasing funding to veterans on top of the $16 billion we have already provided into that very important area to support veterans in their post-serving careers, for the supports they need. That is the position of this government. To pretend otherwise&#x2014;and I can't listen to that spray from Senator Shoebridge without responding to it, because most of it is factually incorrect. You should be sitting over there, Senator Shoebridge, with some of the positions that you bring into this chamber; one minute you're this, and the next minute you're that.</p><p>Sometimes, responding to some challenges requires difficult decisions. We've heard the Senate on the veterans reforms that we sought. We are not proceeding with them. That is on the public record. The minister has responded. Adjustments will be made through the budget process, as we have to do, to respond to that decision. There is no need to suspend standing orders and there is no need for this motion to go to the House.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="841" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.113.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" speakername="Anne Ruston" talktype="speech" time="15:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The reason why this is so urgent is that, despite the minister's protestations that when the government say something we should take them at their word, their history proves that when they say something they have to be forced into actually putting their word into action. You went to the last election promising no new taxes and no increases in taxes. Subsequent to that, you've actually gone and increased taxes. We saw them all at the budget. You say, 'You heard the Senate.' Well, did you hear the Senate when the Senate said you needed to put a human back in charge, put human override back in charge, of the aged-care algorithm? You didn't, because the bill's parked down there, alongside the veterans allied health bill, in the other place. So I think it is a little disingenuous for the minister to stand there and say that we shouldn't be doing this because they 'can be taken at their word', because the government keeps ignoring the will of the Senate. The government keeps ignoring the bills that are sent down to the other place, where it has the numbers. What they say and what they do are often two very, very different things. The reality is that this government, time and time and time again, has proved that it cannot be taken at its word. So to come in here and stand up and make the comments that the minister just made&#x2014;I think that maybe it should be her that's going and checking the record for the accuracy of the actions that have been taken, because you'll find it is the Labor government that is the one that cannot be trusted to keep its word.</p><p>And this is really urgent because, when you consider it, the people that are impacted by the refusal of the government to accept the will of the Senate on so many different occasions are some of the most vulnerable in our society. We are talking about people who are veterans, who often are requiring this allied health support because of injuries that they've sustained in combat. To take that away&#x2014;and then the minister comes in and starts waffling on about some other thing that they've done in veteran affairs. The reality is that their cruel action was to take away the opportunity for our veterans, our serving veterans, to get the health care that they need quite often as a result of the injuries that they received serving our nation in combat. What sort of government thinks that veterans should be paying the price for its budget mismanagement?</p><p>Another instance is the private health insurance rebate for over-65s. This is a government who thinks pensioners, age pensioners, should be paying the price for its budget mismanagement and the need for it to try and rectify its budget. Once again, the will of this Senate said it did not want that particular bill to proceed. It was discharged from the <i>Notice Paper</i>. What is the government doing? Apparently, they don't hear what the Senate has to say, because the bill has been reintroduced in the other place and, no doubt, will turn up here again. So don't, Minister, come into this place and tell us that you have heard what the Senate said, because all you do when you hear what the Senate says is ignore it.</p><p>Another piece of legislation, as I said&#x2014;the aged-care algorithm, for older Australians, people who need care, who are towards the end of their lives and are needing care in order to remain in a dignified environment as they age. You have put a computer in charge of making the final decision about the care that they need and the urgency with which they receive that care. Even the Ombudsman was completely damning of that proposal and the fact that you're doing that. So we moved a bill in here. It passed this Senate with the support of everybody in the chamber, apart from the government. Where is it? It's languishing down in the other place, alongside the veterans allied health bill and where the private health insurance rebate bill for over-65s is sitting.</p><p>So I think it is pretty disingenuous for the government to stand up here and spray everybody in the chamber for wanting to make sure that a very serious issue is dealt with. In another classic example, we had to force you to get rid of your widows tax. You said you were going to get rid of the widows tax. But, once again, that is what you say, and then you just leave it and do not fix it. We had to force you through legislative means to actually get rid of the widows tax. What this seeks to do today&#x2014;what Senator McDonald is seeking to do today&#x2014;is actually force you into doing what you have promised to do, because, quite frankly, your refusal to ever do anything that you promise to do is the reason that this Senate has to force you into doing it.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="907" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.114.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" speakername="Ross Cadell" talktype="speech" time="15:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This government shows that a promise of something means nothing to it, because what we have here is a government that got wedged. They were going to wear the criticism. They were going to wear the veterans laying the medals down out the front. They were going to witness the veterans coming in here. We had people like John Armfield, Dr Tim Nelson, Julie-Ann Finney and Marc Diplock&#x2014;all those people&#x2014;coming here and telling their stories. We had Sean Smith. When I go back to the Hunter, I see Ruth Rogers. At the funeral of Brett Wild, a person who championed the Branxton to Greta memorial walk, I met people who told me that they wouldn't be on this planet if it weren't for the allied health services. This government was going to wear that until the Senate came together&#x2014;until the Liberal Party, the National Party, the Greens and the crossbench, including Jacqui Lambie, with all the work that she did, got together and voted this down. There was a mechanism that found a way to put pressure on the government so they had to cave in.</p><p>Now they say, 'Trust us; we've got this.' Well, we can't trust them. These veterans, these people who signed up to put their lives at risk, can't trust them. We saw the great work done in the committee by Senator Jess Collins here, pointing this out and getting down to it. This was a budget saving of $748 million over the first three years and then $340 million a year after that. It was a budget line item. These people didn't matter. The reason the Senate must insist on sending this message, suspend standing orders and send this downstairs is to make sure we deliver certainty to these people, who deserve it. This is not a budget line item to those sitting around here and on the crossbench. This is an item about people. This is an issue about people&#x2014;the people that we rely on, the people that trusted us to deliver for them and the people this government was ready to betray.</p><p>So that is why we are here. We've heard the evidence in the committee. We have seen the lobbying. We've seen the people coming here. We've seen the personal stories. We've heard the emotional things from families. We heard a personal story from veterans in this building, in this chamber. All they are asking for is the next step of certainty. Get it done. You can tell from the way those people are speaking today that, if it came back here, it would be insisted upon. We aren't backing down from this, because this Senate should never walk away from Australians who put their lives on the line for us. It's not a big ask. It is to reaffirm the decision we made not long ago, a few months ago, in September&#x2014;I think it was 14 September. It is to say that, when the other place said, 'Oh, we'll make it a matter for the next sitting; we'll kick it down the path,' we remember what happened. They waited till the Thursday or Friday of that week, when parliament wasn't sitting, and said, 'We're going to fix it.' Well, we don't trust that. Australians don't trust it. The veterans who originally knew you promised to look after them and their health after their service can't trust it, because you were ready to renege on that promise.</p><p>So here we stand. I heard the conversations earlier pointing out how sad it is that we're up here and we're misrepresenting this and that. Everything is clear. It was in the budget papers: budget savings of $748 million in the first three years and $340 million a year after that. It was a savings measure that hurt people. So forgive us if we don't believe you when you get up here and say it's misrepresenting what the facts are, because they're clear. It was in the budget. People came here and protested. They lobbied. The public cried out. The veterans community rose up and said, 'Not good enough.' Even then, you were still wearing it. Even then, this government said: 'We can take pressure. It doesn't matter.' It was this Senate that found a way to finally make you see you have no way out. Now you're saying: 'Trust us again. We've still got it.' Well, we don't. Send this message. Have the lower house not review the bill as it originally was. Have them either accept it or put it up.</p><p>I don't believe there's been any consultation with the minister talking to the coalition, One Nation, the Greens or the crossbench about another way of doing this. You say it's dead, but what is another way of doing this? How do we know? How do we go forward? What we find time and time again is that what you say is not what happens. Even what you intend doesn't happen, even when you go there and we flip all the time. We mentioned the trust taxes. We mentioned increased taxes everywhere that you just pluck out of nowhere. A thought bubble comes all the time here.</p><p>So let's do the right thing by our veterans. Let's push this. The Senate stands united to look after Australians, because that is what we should do. To vote against this means nothing more than that you are still trying to be tricky.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="720" approximate_wordcount="570" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.115.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" speakername="Jessica Collins" talktype="speech" time="15:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We are here. This is an urgent motion to be passed, yet for 12 sitting days it had been sitting there, over in the House, collecting dust. It's on such an important issue. We've seen, time and time again, this year, this government not standing by its veterans.</p><p>We have just chaired the inquiry into the allied health for veterans. Let me tell you what we found in there. The No. 1 recommendation that the committee made was:</p><p class="italic">The committee recommends that the Australian Government consider potential legislative amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary and numerical restrictions on health treatment to ensure that care is provided according to clinical need.</p><p>It would mean that they could never do this again to our veterans.</p><p>We heard from the minister that this was just about money&#x2014;that this was just about trying to find some budget savings. But these are the people that ticked that box to give their lives to our nation, for our freedom, and they're trying to find the savings from them!</p><p>We heard, through the committee, that the allied health system is actually a very, very complex system to go through. The time it takes for them to actually get the health care that they need&#x2014;let alone the caps that this government put on them&#x2014;can be up to 10 years. I had somebody tell me it took 10 years to get the health care that they needed. These are the people who, as I said, ticked that box for unlimited liability: 'I will lay down my life for this nation.' That's what they said. Their families ticked that box too. And this government wanted to take away the care that they needed. We still have a significant challenge with the allied care system for our veterans. The administrative burden on them, while they're coping with their physical and mental health challenges, makes their physical and health challenges only worse.</p><p>So we are standing here today to say to this government: 'Why are you still sitting on the Senate's request&#x2014;the amendment that we made to the statutory bill that would protect our veterans from this cap?' We all know that this government didn't do any consultations on the cap. They did it. They thought they'd get away with it. It took veterans coming down to this parliament, to lay down the medals that they'd received, to send a message to the government, on behalf of the rest of the veterans around Australia, that this was not okay. What an extraordinary message to be sending to their government that they were prepared to lay down their lives for&#x2014;to hand back their medals!</p><p>I have heard stories from these veterans&#x2014;from a long line of generations of service to this country&#x2014;that they're now telling their own children: 'Do not do it. Do not tick that box. Do not be prepared to lay down your life for this country, because this country, this government, will not have your back.' They have taken hit after hit after hit from this government, all year long: the cuts to funding for Corporal Baird's parents to go around and tell a story of courage and valour; the cuts to Invictus, an important program for our veterans.</p><p>Of course, let's not forget the selling of our defence estate and the spiritual home of the Army&#x2014;an army that will be evicted from Victoria Barracks in a matter of weeks.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.115.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="15:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Collins, the time for the debate has expired.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="10" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.115.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="15:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the suspension motion be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="5" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.116.1" nospeaker="true" time="15:38" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7500" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7500">Statute Update Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="37" noes="23" pairs="7" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" vote="aye">Michaelia Cash</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" vote="aye">Pauline Lee Hanson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973">Chris Gatenby</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="35" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.117.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" speakername="Susan McDonald" talktype="speech" time="15:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That a motion relating to the consideration of Senate amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026 may be moved immediately, have precedence over all other business and be determined without amendment or debate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.117.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="15:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion moved by Senator McDonald be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.118.1" nospeaker="true" time="15:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7500" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7500">Statute Update Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="37" noes="23" pairs="7" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" vote="aye">Michaelia Cash</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" vote="aye">Pauline Lee Hanson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973">Chris Gatenby</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="147" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.119.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" speakername="Susan McDonald" talktype="speech" time="15:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">(1) That the Senate&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">(a) notes that:</p><p class="italic">(i) on 10 September 2026, the Senate agreed to amendments to the Statute Update Bill 2026 to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary restrictions and expenditure-triggered barriers to allied-health treatment,</p><p class="italic">(ii) the bill and the Senate's amendments were returned to the House of Representatives seeking its concurrence,</p><p class="italic">(iii) on 14 September 2026, the House resolved that the Senate's amendments be considered 'at the next sitting', and</p><p class="italic">(iv) as part of its inquiry into the Department of Veterans' Affairs-funded health treatment, the Senate Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee recommended that the Australian Government consider legislative amendments to protect veterans from arbitrary monetary and numerical restrictions on health treatment; and</p><p class="italic">(b) requests that the House of Representatives consider and determine the Senate's amendments without further delay.</p><p class="italic">(2) That this resolution be communicated by message to the House of Representatives.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.119.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="15:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion moved by Senator McDonald be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.120.1" nospeaker="true" time="15:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7500" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7500">Statute Update Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="37" noes="23" pairs="7" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" vote="aye">Michaelia Cash</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" vote="aye">Pauline Lee Hanson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973">Chris Gatenby</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.121.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.121.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Answers to Questions </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.121.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="speech" time="15:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in accordance with informal arrangements agreed by the whips.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="524" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.122.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="speech" time="15:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by opposition senators today.</p><p>Yet again today in this chamber we heard from a government that doesn't understand small business, that doesn't know small business, that has no experience of small business and that has no empathy whatsoever for small business. Small businesses at the moment are failing at the rate 46 per day&#x2014;that is, going into administration or insolvency&#x2014;every single day, not just Monday to Friday but Saturdays and Sundays, the highest rate of failure we've seen in several years, and yet what we hear from this government as they go about imposing a new and novel tax on small business is a complete disregard for them. We were told by Minister Wong that it's only 10 per cent of small businesses that operate through trusts. Well, it's 350,000 small businesses that use these, and the bulk of them are classified by the ATO as micro businesses&#x2014;that is, with turnover under $2 million, the vast majority. These are mum-and-dad, brother-and-sister, mother-and-daughter operations. They're some of the most vulnerable businesses in our country, and Labor is hitting them with new taxes.</p><p>It's not like the Labor government took these taxes to the last election. It's not like they told small business before the last election that they were going to put this impost on you. No; they unveiled this in their budget of broken promises. Their assault on aspiration was included in that.</p><p>We have small businesses at the moment dealing with a cashflow crisis. They've got weak consumer demand, high electricity prices, high inflation and interest rates that are some of the highest amongst advanced economies in the world. They've got new industrial relations laws to deal with. They had credit card surcharging to absorb. They've got payday super that they've had to absorb. On top of all this, the government think they will now impose a minimum tax on the main vehicle that small businesses use to structure their affairs&#x2014;a discretionary trust.</p><p>This leaves small businesses with only bad options. They can be faced with a 30 per cent minimum tax, but you need to be earning over $230,000 as a small-business owner to be paying anywhere near that level of tax now. You can be forced into restructuring your business at a cost of around $50,000 to $100,000 in legal and advisory fees, plus the stamp duty on that, or you can opt into a fixed trust, which will mean that your business structure and those who can participate in your business will not be able to change or grow or evolve with the business.</p><p>This is nothing more than an attack on small business from a government that has no regard for them, as their own ministers say&#x2014;a government that has no experience of small business and no knowledge of small business. It could only come from a government that is completely cavalier about the state of the economy, the state of small business in Australia and the number of households and businesses doing it tough right now in adverse economic conditions.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="323" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.123.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" speakername="Ellie Whiteaker" talktype="speech" time="15:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I also rise to take note of answers provided to coalition senators. I'm left wondering why the Liberal Party is standing in the way of our plans to make the tax system fairer. Yet again, day after day, week after week, they come in here and stand in the way of our work to give tax cuts to working Australians, to make it easier for first home buyers to buy their first home and to align the treatment of income that employees make from working with other forms of income. That's what they're doing today and every day when they come into this place. Why is the Liberal Party opposed to working Australians receiving a tax cut? Why did they take a policy to the last election of increasing tax cuts for Australian workers and then come in here and argue that, while workers should pay more tax, the very small percentage of Australians who receive income from a discretionary trust shouldn't be taxed more?</p><p>It's really clear today and every day who the Liberal Party and their friends in the National Party and One Nation are here for, and it is not working Australians. It is not ordinary Australians who are trying to put food on the table. It is not ordinary Australians who are going to work day in and day out and paying their taxes. It is not those Australians who the Liberal Party and the National Party and One Nation are here for, but they are the Australians who we are here for, who we will fight for and who we will stand up for. It's clear to me, and I think it's clear to Australians right across the country that the Liberal Party does not have a plan to make life easier for working families. They tell that story every day, whether it's opposing our plans to make the tax system fairer, opposing tax cuts for working Australians&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.123.2" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="15:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="23" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.123.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="interjection" time="15:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Deputy President, I believe Senator Sharma was heard in silence. Yet we've heard nothing but interjections from those opposite since Senator Whiteaker started.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.123.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="15:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I will remind those on my left that Senator Whiteaker should be heard in silence.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="186" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.123.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" speakername="Ellie Whiteaker" talktype="continuation" time="15:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>What we're seeing here is a desperate attempt to claw back votes&#x2014;votes that they've continued to haemorrhage, election after election, because they have no plan to make life easier for working Australians. They're not here for the 95 per cent of working Australians who do not earn income from discretionary trusts. They're not interested in arguing for them to get a tax cut. In fact, they voted against it in this place. Senator Hume called those tax cuts 'egregious'. Yet they're willing to come in here and make the argument that our tax system should not be fair, that we should not align the tax that is paid on income&#x2014;by workers, by employees&#x2014;with the tax paid by the five per cent who make money from a discretionary trust. What they conveniently leave out is that there's quite a bit in our tax reform that makes life easier for small businesses. They're not interested in talking about that, because they are desperate and they have no plan to make life easier for working Australians. But Labor does, and we will not let them stand in the way.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="589" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.124.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" speakername="Leah Blyth" talktype="speech" time="15:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It is offensive, quite frankly, to sit on this side of the chamber and listen to what Labor are spewing at the Australian people, and I think the Australian people are seeing through it. What we've just heard from the senator on the other side is astounding, and I wonder if she actually knows what she is talking about. Australian businesses are everyday Australians. They are mums, they are dads, they are hardworking families who are just trying to make ends meet. But it seems Labor have decided that if you have a successful business they're going to come after you, because they've got to fix the huge hole in their budget. We've heard from them that they're going to come after veterans as well to try to fix this huge hole in their budget.</p><p>So this is about socialism and it is about how they want to redistribute wealth in this country, even from the finance minister, Katy Gallagher. She got up and told Australians, 'Come on: we're working really hard to fix the economy in Australia.' Well, like all other Australians, I wish that Labor would stop working so hard. You've collapsed the housing market, you are coming after aspiration in this country and you are making it impossible for small businesses to flourish. When we are seeing dozens of small businesses in this country closing every single day, you have to ask yourself: what is this government's plan for our economy? Those opposite come in here and tell us they've got a plan. Please, scrap the plan. Australia cannot afford the plan. They cannot afford this path that you are leading us all down.</p><p>It is very clear that the Labor government has no experience when it comes to running a small business. They've got no idea. They see this as, 'Well, it's only five per cent of businesses that take income from a discretionary trust.' 'Only five per cent?' Is this how they justify it? That is 350,000 small businesses. That is 350,000 families that these businesses are supporting. But it's okay, because it's only five per cent! If we talk about it in those terms, we don't have to see these business owners as real people who are struggling with the high energy prices in Australia, who are struggling with the additional tax&#x2014;after this Labor government promised they would not introduce any new taxes. Well, we know what this Labor government does. Anything they say you can pretty well take with a grain of salt, because then they come along and introduce taxes.</p><p>I think it's fair to say that the Australian people are wide awake to what this Labor government is doing to small business in Australia. And I am proud to say that on this side of the chamber&#x2014;in the coalition, the Liberals and the Nationals&#x2014;we are standing with small businesses here in Australia, because we want to see those 350,000 small businesses. And we don't want to see this government making it impossible for our farmers. Where do you think food comes from in this country? Who do you think is filling the shelves at Woolworths and Coles? It is our hardworking farmers, and a lot of them use trusts&#x2014;and they use trusts because that is a structure that allows them to pass their farming business from one generation to the next. If you want to see the killing of aspiration, the killing of farming&#x2014;making sure we cannot eat in the cities&#x2014;then absolutely, Labor's plan is what we should be following!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="573" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.125.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" speakername="Lisa Darmanin" talktype="speech" time="15:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The key question that Senator Wong asked in response to the original question from Senator Hume in question time is: 'Why are you standing up for the 10 per cent and not the 90 per cent?' We need to look at the broader context here. What this government is doing is trying to bring back fairness into our tax system, making judgements and treating people in a way that is reasonable. Everyone should have a fair crack at the opportunity to succeed, particularly when we know that Australians are under pressure. Importantly, this taxation legislation is part of a suite of reforms that are about taking pressure off families, making the economy more productive and resilient and making the budget more sustainable. That is the driver of all of these things for Australians: tax cuts for workers, expanding Medicare, funding aged care and early childhood care, and enabling the budget to pay for these things for 100 per cent of Australian society. Those are the values of our government, and that is what we are seeking to enshrine with these laws.</p><p>We are taking the hard decisions to reform the system in the name of fairness&#x2014;to reduce the tax burden for over 13 million workers and support 75,000 Australians to enter the housing market. That is the context of these reforms in our bills. We are seeking to undertake the hard reform in our tax system by showing leadership to make sure our economy works in the interests of Australians, businesses and future generations&#x2014;for not only the 10 per cent but 100 per cent.</p><p>The Senate Economics Legislation Committee inquired into this legislation very recently, and I wanted to pull out a few things from that inquiry to share with Australians who might be watching. Dr Mark Zirnsak from the Tax Justice Network observed that those with an interest in retaining existing arrangements may be more strongly motivated to engage in the debate than the broader group of taxpayers who may benefit from this reform, which I think is worth bearing in mind.</p><p>I wanted to also briefly talk about the comments from Senator Canavan with regard to farms. Senator Canavan asked why we were punishing hardworking farming families. The National Farmers' Federation CEO said in the inquiry:</p><p class="italic">&#x2026; our principal request to the committee is straightforward: please protect the primary production income exemption contained in the bills.</p><p>He went on to say:</p><p class="italic">I'd like to thank particularly the Treasury and the Treasurer for the enormous amount of consultation. The detailed work that was done in both these areas was incredibly constructive and helpful from our perspective&#x2014;</p><p>support for the bill from the National Farmers' Federation, quite the contrary to what we heard from Senator Canavan in his question purporting to be on behalf of farmers in this country. The CEO of the NFF went on to say:</p><p class="italic">The baseline request from us is that primary production income, as described by the ATO, be the carve-out, or the exemption, not the total income by that business, to the extent they have income that is not primary production income.</p><p>I think that is actually the opposite point to what Senator Canavan was raising in question time. The NFF went on to say:</p><p class="italic">What we are asking for, and what we believe is very important for family farms and for Australian agriculture, is the primary production income exemption, as defined by the ATO.</p><p class="italic">
  <i>(Time expired)</i>
</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="464" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.126.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" speakername="James McGrath" talktype="speech" time="16:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It is a fact that the CFMEU are corrupt. It is a fact that the CFMEU are a corrupt cartel that have cost not just taxpayers but all Australians billions of dollars because of their corruption and the connection with Labor Party politicians. We only have to look at the evidence that has been provided to the Queensland commission of inquiry into the CFMEU on the links between CFMEU officials and Labor Party ministers&#x2014;these are ministers who sat around the cabinet table&#x2014;in terms of the power that the CFMEU held over the Labor Party when it came to the awarding of contracts and when it came to the bastardisation of the award system in Queensland. That's why it is not surprising that, in response to the questions that were put by my colleague Senator Kovacic in relation to the CFMEU, Senator Wong&#x2014;who happens to be a member of the CFMEU; the forestry division, to be sure&#x2014;failed to answer the questions that were put by Senator Kovacic, and in particular failed to explain why the Labor Party would not support a Senate inquiry into allegations of corruption in the construction sector.</p><p>It's pretty obvious why Senator Wong, Prime Minister Albanese and the other Labor Party ministers who sit around the cabinet table do not want to support a Senate inquiry into corruption within the construction sector&#x2014;because they know that the Labor Party itself, whether at a state level or a federal level, is intrinsically linked to the CFMEU. The Labor Party, since Mr Albanese became leader, has taken over $7 million worth of donations from the CFMEU. When the coalition was in government, the Labor Party opposed the Australian Building and Construction Commission. They opposed the Registered Organisations Commission. They not only opposed stronger union accountability; they dismantled the watchdogs holding unions accountable. This is the hypocrisy that Labor often forgets. In 2019, the coalition introduced legislation to strengthen the Federal Court's powers to put a dysfunctional union into administration, and the Labor Party voted against it. When the coalition were fighting for stronger powers to remove rogue union officials and place lawbreaking unions into administration, Labor stood in our way, and we know why&#x2014;because of the $7 million money trail that goes from the CFMEU to the Labor Party.</p><p>We also know, because of the evidence that has been provided to the commission of inquiry in Queensland, of the corruption between Labor Party ministers who are still serving in the Queensland parliament and CFMEU officials. We can be certain that the commission of inquiry in Victoria will unveil similar evidence. This is why the Labor Party do not want a federal Senate inquiry into corruption&#x2014;because they are up to their necks in corruption, and they should be called out for it.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.127.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Artificial Intelligence: Intellectual Property </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="627" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.127.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="speech" time="16:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answer given by the Minister for Foreign Affairs (Senator Wong) to a question without notice I asked today relating to Australia's copyright laws.</p><p>I asked Senator Wong why the Australian government is currently entertaining options that would fundamentally change and undermine the very principle of copyright laws here in Australia. The reason I asked this question is, right now, the Australian government are debating how far they will go in rolling out the red carpet and changing Australia's laws to suit big tech and their AI boom right here on Australian soil. If we don't get this right, and if we don't stand up to the bullying, the pushing and the lobbying of big AI, we are going to make a fundamental mistake that unravels and undermines the very principle of copyright that has protected Australian artists, authors, writers, academics and journalists for decades.</p><p>Let me be clear: Australia is set to become the Cayman Islands of AI, a haven where big tech companies come so that they don't have to follow the normal rules, regulations and laws that other countries have, because they want to undermine the rights of creators in order to feed their hungry AI machines. This is a culture grab, and right now the Albanese government is debating whether to give AI that power or not. Big AI companies like Anthropic and OpenAI are shopping around, trying to find governments and parliaments that are willing to roll over and change their national laws to suit the corporations. Why do they want this? In order to feed their big AI machines that are powered through these data centres&#x2014;these huge air-conditioned sheds full of computer services that scrape, steal and hoover up a whole lot of data in order to feed their AI machines so that they can become more and more powerful. Big AI companies don't think they should have to pay for this. They think we should be thanking them for creating this technology in the first place. These are the narcissists in charge of these corporations. They think Australian citizens and the governments and people of countries around the world should be thankful that there are these big tech bros who are so narcissistic and that we should just change our laws, undermine our own workers and our own culture and let them have whatever they want and take whatever they want.</p><p>They've come to Australia because they think that we're stupid enough to roll over and do this for them. They think Australia is easy pickings for them, because other governments around the world have stood up for their creative industries, academics, journalists, writers and authors and said: 'No, if you want access to people's work, you ask them, you get permission and you pay for it. You don't get it for free, and you certainly don't get it at an easy, cheap price.'</p><p>So the question to the government right now is: why on earth would you be setting Australia up as the global pariah of AI? We've seen what happened in the United States only in the last couple of weeks. Even American citizens are sick and tired of being pushed around, bullied, bulldozed and left for dead by the AI industry. They're sick and tired of having data centres imposed on their communities, only to push up their power prices and make the cost of living worse. Here in Australia, those very same companies want to set up shop and get away with the same. I say to the Albanese government: have a bit more pride in your country. Have a bit more pride in the people who make things and should be paid for it.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.128.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Tasmania: Infrastructure </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="375" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.128.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="speech" time="16:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answer given by the Minister for Indigenous Australians (Senator McCarthy) to a question without notice I asked today relating to Tasmania's infrastructure.</p><p>If the federal government aren't worried about Tasmanians' access to timely health care, they should read the comments on my socials, like this one: 'Hi Jacqui. I recently completed a short-term nursing agency contract in Tassie. I'm from Victoria. I was appalled at how underresourced and underfunded the healthcare system was. It's a beautiful place to visit but not to get sick. Tasmanians deserve so much more.' Tasmanians do deserve more.</p><p>Today a story broke on the ABC that the state government has once again put its hands out for more funding for a stadium because&#x2014;surprise, surprise!&#x2014;the cost has blown out. That is beyond embarrassing and is completely incompetent. The Tasmanian Liberals did a dirty handshake on this stadium. There was no business case, and they didn't run it by Treasury. They knew our health system was broken, our education system was buckling and people were barely getting by. They promised the stadium bill wouldn't impact the Tasmanian budget but have since cut 1,700 public sector jobs. Four thousand Tasmanians are waiting for an endoscopy. They're waiting a thousand days to see a neurologist, and they're dying waiting for an ambulance.</p><p>This mess is absolutely at the feet of the Tasmanian Liberal government, but Tasmanian Labor is just as responsible and just as shocking. Before the 2024 state election, the Labor Party opposed the stadium, and, after the election, they did a complete 180. Did they think it would bring them out of the political wilderness? You've got to be kidding yourself, backing in a stadium that nearly 70 per cent of Tasmanians never wanted. Guess what Labor did in the Tasmanian parliament in question time this morning. They sat there in silence and in shame. That's what the Tasmanian Labor Party did. They sat in silence and shame when it came to speaking about their grand plan with the Liberal Party in Tasmania. Tasmanians deserve a government that is going to prioritise the services they need, and they deserve a decent opposition. An opposition, to start with, would be great.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.129.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Iran </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="162" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.129.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="16:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answer given by the Minister for Foreign Affairs (Senator Wong) to a question without notice I asked today relating to Iran.</p><p>I dispute Senator Wong's answer. The Australian government have not, on any government platform, made an official statement regarding the UN vote, nor have they sent communication to the UN, which was my point. Minister Wong made a single post on her personal X account. That's not an official government communication.</p><p>The UN is not just siding with the Islamic Republic of Iran, though. Nigeria is allowing Islamic terrorists to conduct a campaign of murder, rape and dislocation against Nigeria's own Christian citizens. Nigeria is chair of the UN committee on peacekeeping and chair of the UN committee on disarmament. It should start with Boko Haram. What is the UN doing about Christian genocide in Nigeria? It sent them a letter. The UN is siding with Islam over Christianity.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.130.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Medicare </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="315" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.130.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="speech" time="16:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answer given by the Minister for the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Senator McAllister) to a question without notice asked by Senator Walker today relating to bulk-billing.</p><p>The question was about bulk-billing rates. We certainly won't be getting dorothy dixers about the ACT bulk-billing rates any time soon, because the current bulk-billing rate in the ACT is 59.3 per cent and the average gap fee is $65. The national bulk-billing rate is 84 per cent. The seat of Canberra has the lowest bulk-billing rate in the country. It's the only electorate in the country where the bulk-billing rate is below 50 per cent. Children in the ACT are bulk-billed the least, at 70 per cent, compared to 90 per cent across the country. Even concession card holders, those on seniors health cards, are generally bulk-billed less in the ACT than people without a concession card in other states and territories.</p><p>The Prime Minister spoke a lot about Australians only needing their Medicare card. It's not the case in the ACT. While I acknowledge that there have been investments from the Labor government, clearly they're not working here in Canberra. I'm keen to see the impact of the direct investment in bulk-billing clinics and what it will do here in the ACT, but, from what I'm hearing, it's still very hard to get in. Not all Canberrans are wealthy. We have to ensure that we actually have solutions that are going to ensure people in Canberra can get bulk-billed, children can get bulk-billed and pensioners can get bulk-billed. Most doctors here don't even take gold cards. We have to change that. We need more investment from the government, and we need to be real about the fact that you do need a credit card here in the ACT if you want to see a doctor.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.131.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
NOTICES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.131.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Postponement </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="37" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.131.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I seek leave to postpone business of the Senate notice of motion No. 4 until the next sitting day.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p>I seek leave to postpone general business notice of motion No. 828 as well.</p><p>Leave granted.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.133.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BUSINESS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.133.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Consideration of Legislation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="48" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.133.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="speech" time="16:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Gallagher, I move:</p><p class="italic">That private senators' bills be considered this week as follows:</p><p class="italic">(a) Wearable Recording Devices (Import Control) Bill 2026, on Wednesday, 18 November 2026; and</p><p class="italic">(b) Fair Work Amendment (Disqualified Officers Bill 2026), on Thursday, 19 November 2026.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.134.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.134.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Reporting Date </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.134.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="speech" time="16:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>If there is no objection, the business is postponed.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.135.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BUSINESS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.135.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Leave of Absence </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="40" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.135.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="speech" time="16:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I move:</p><p class="italic">That leave of absence be granted to the following senators:</p><p class="italic">(a) Senator Waters from 16 November to 26 November for personal reasons.</p><p class="italic">(b) Senator Steele-John from 16 November to 26 November for personal reasons.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.136.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.136.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
METRONET; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="95" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.136.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="16:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Dean Smith, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government, by no later than midday on Wednesday, 25 November 2026, all documents held by the minister, her office, the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts or Infrastructure Australia, created since 1 June 2022, relating to the METRONET on Swan Ferry Service Expansion project, including all correspondence between the Commonwealth and Western Australian governments relating to the project.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.137.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BUSINESS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.137.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Consideration of Legislation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="420" approximate_wordcount="39" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.137.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="speech" time="16:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Gallagher, I move:</p><p class="italic">That the provisions of paragraphs (5) to (8) of standing order 111 not apply to the Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026, allowing it to be considered during this period of sittings.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="18" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.137.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that government business No. 1, standing in the name of Minister Gallagher, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.138.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:27" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="33" noes="8" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="aye">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="aye">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="aye">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="aye">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="aye">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="aye">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="aye">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="aye">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="aye">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="aye">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="aye">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="aye">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="aye">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="aye">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="aye">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="aye">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="aye">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="aye">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="aye">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="aye">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="aye">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="aye">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="aye">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="no">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="no">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="no">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="no">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="no">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="no">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="no">Lidia Thorpe</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="no">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="14" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.139.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="speech" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senators, there may be further divisions. The bells will be rung for one minute.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.140.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
NOTICES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.140.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Withdrawal </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.140.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" speakername="Lidia Thorpe" talktype="speech" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I withdraw business of the Senate notice of motion No. 1 for today.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.141.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
REGULATIONS AND DETERMINATIONS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.141.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Support) Determination 2026; Disallowance </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="29" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.141.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="speech" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Steele-John, I move:</p><p class="italic">That the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Support) Determination 2026, made under the <i>National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013</i>, be disallowed [F2026L01332].</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="25" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.141.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that business of the Senate No. 2, standing in the name of Senator Steele-John and moved by Senator McKim, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.142.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:31" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="12" noes="28" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="no">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="no">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="no">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="no">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="no">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="no">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="no">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.143.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.143.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026; Reference to Committee </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7566" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7566">Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.143.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="16:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Hume, I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026 be referred to the Economics Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 26 February 2027.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="22" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.143.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is business of the Senate notice of motion No. 5 standing in the name of Senator Hume be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="10" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.144.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7566" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7566">Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="24" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.145.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.145.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="259" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.145.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="16:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">(a) notes that:</p><p class="italic">(i) a response to order for the production of documents no. 672, agreed to on 9 September 2026 and relating to the Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program, was tabled on 12 October 2026,</p><p class="italic">(ii) in a letter tabled as part of the response, the Assistant Minister to the Prime Minister notes that 'the Prime Minister was not the decision maker for grants awarded under the Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program, nor is the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet the department for the administration of this program' and that 'requests for documentation in relation to these grants would appropriately be directed to the Department of Infrastructure',</p><p class="italic">(iii) on 14 October 2026, the Senate rejected this explanation and ordered the Minister representing the Prime Minister to either table the documents or make a claim of public interest immunity, and</p><p class="italic">(iv) the Minister representing the Prime Minister has failed to comply with the order; and</p><p class="italic">(b) requires the Minister representing the Prime Minister to attend the Senate on Wednesday, 18 November 2026 at the conclusion of question time to provide an explanation, of no more than 5 minutes, as to why the minister has not complied with the Senate's order, and that:</p><p class="italic">(i) any senator may move to take note of the explanation, and</p><p class="italic">(ii) any such motion may be debated for no longer than 30 minutes and shall have precedence over all business until determined, and senators may speak to the motion for not more than 5 minutes each.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.145.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 826, standing in the name of Senator Payman, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="11" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.146.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="33" noes="20" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.147.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
MOTIONS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.147.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Construction Industry </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="582" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.147.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="16:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This is a good one, President. We'll see how we go. I move:</p><p class="italic">(1) That a select committee, to be known as the Select Committee on Corruption in the Construction Industry, be established to inquire into and report on:</p><p class="italic">(a) allegations of corruption, criminal infiltration, intimidation, coercion and misconduct in the construction industry;</p><p class="italic">(b) the impact of such conduct on project costs, productivity, workplace safety, competition and public confidence in the construction industry;</p><p class="italic">(c) the adequacy of Commonwealth laws, policies, procurement rules, regulatory frameworks and enforcement responses;</p><p class="italic">(d) risks arising in relation to tendering, subcontracting, labour hire, industrial arrangements and Commonwealth-funded projects;</p><p class="italic">(e) the adequacy of existing oversight and administration mechanisms, and whether administrative or legislative reform is required; and</p><p class="italic">(f) any other related matters.</p><p class="italic">(2) That the committee present its final report by 23 June 2027.</p><p class="italic">(3) That the committee consist of 7 senators, as follows:</p><p class="italic">(a) three nominated by the Leader of the Opposition in the Senate;</p><p class="italic">(b) two nominated by the Leader of the Government in the Senate;</p><p class="italic">(c) one nominated by the Leader of the Australian Greens; and</p><p class="italic">(d) one nominated by minority party or independent senators.</p><p class="italic">(4) That:</p><p class="italic">(a) participating members may be appointed to the committee on the nomination of the Leader of the Government in the Senate, the Leader of the Opposition in the Senate or any minority party or independent senator;</p><p class="italic">(b) participating members may participate in hearings of evidence and deliberations of the committee, and have all the rights of members of the committee, but may not vote on any questions before the committee; and</p><p class="italic">(c) a participating member shall be taken to be a member of a committee for the purpose of forming a quorum of the committee if a majority of members of the committee is not present.</p><p class="italic">(5) That the committee may proceed to the dispatch of business notwithstanding that all members have not been duly nominated and appointed and notwithstanding any vacancy.</p><p class="italic">(6) That the committee elect as chair a member nominated by the Leader of the Opposition in the Senate and as deputy chair the member nominated by the Leader of the Australian Greens.</p><p class="italic">(7) That the deputy chair shall act as chair when the chair is absent from a meeting of the committee or the position of chair is temporarily vacant.</p><p class="italic">(8) That, in the event of an equally divided vote, the chair, or the deputy chair when acting as chair, have a casting vote.</p><p class="italic">(9) That the committee have power to appoint subcommittees consisting of 3 or more of its members, and to refer to any such subcommittee any of the matters which the committee is empowered to consider.</p><p class="italic">(10) That the committee and any subcommittee have power to send for and examine persons and documents, to move from place to place, to sit in public or in private, notwithstanding any prorogation of the Parliament or dissolution of the House of Representatives, and have leave to report from time to time its proceedings and the evidence taken and such interim recommendations as it may deem fit.</p><p class="italic">(11) That the committee be provided with all necessary staff, facilities and resources and be empowered to appoint persons with specialist knowledge for the purposes of the committee with the approval of the President.</p><p class="italic">(12) That the committee be empowered to print from day to day such papers and evidence as may be ordered by it, and a daily Hansard be published of such proceedings as take place in public.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.147.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 830, standing in the name of Senator Kovacic, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="12" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.148.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:43" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="23" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.149.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.149.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Skills in Demand Visa; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="138" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.149.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="16:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Cash, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Home Affairs, by no later than midday on Thursday, 19 November 2026, the following documents held by the minister's office or the Department of Home Affairs:</p><p class="italic">(a) briefing materials, meeting agendas, minutes, notes, records of discussion and action items relating to a union consultation roundtable on or around 20 August 2024 for the development of the new Skills in Demand Visa;</p><p class="italic">(b) briefing materials or any documents shared between the department and the minister concerning union advice on the Skills in Demand Visa between 1 January and 7 December 2024; and</p><p class="italic">(c) all correspondence, including emails, between the minister and any union relating to the Skills in Demand Visa between 1 January and 7 December 2024.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.150.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="speech" time="16:47" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business 833 standing in the name of Senator Cash be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.151.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:47" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="25" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.152.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
International Maritime Organization; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="129" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.152.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="16:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator McKenzie, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government, by no later than 10 am on Tuesday, 24 November 2026, the following documents, dated from 1 January 2026, relating to the International Maritime Organization's proposed Net Zero Framework under Annex VI of the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships:</p><p class="italic">(a) any briefing materials, briefing notes, file notes and emails between the minister or their office and the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts;</p><p class="italic">(b) any correspondence between the minister and the Minister for Climate Change and Energy; and</p><p class="italic">(c) any correspondence between the minister and the Minister for Trade and Tourism.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="26" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.152.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 836, standing in the name of Senator McKenzie and moved by Senator Kovacic, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="14" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.153.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="24" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.154.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Robbins Island: Orange-Bellied Parrots; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="65" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.154.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="speech" time="16:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister for the Environment and Water, by no later than Wednesday, 25 November 2026, all documents produced by the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water in relation to the Site Specific Survey Methodology for the presence of orange-bellied parrots at Robbins Island, Tasmania, between 1 January and 30 September 2026 inclusive.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.154.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 834, standing in the name of Senator McKim, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.155.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="17" noes="23" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="no">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="no">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="no">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.156.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BUDGET </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.156.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Consideration by Estimates Committees </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="38" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.156.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="16:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate directs the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee to remind the Australian Energy Market Operator that written responses to questions on notice from the 2026-27 supplementary Budget estimates are due by 17 December 2026.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.157.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="speech" time="16:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I seek leave to make a short statement.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.157.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Leave is granted for one minute.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="121" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.157.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="continuation" time="16:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This will apply to general business notice of motion No. 838 as well. The government will be opposing these motions. AEMO is a not-for-profit company limited by guarantee. It is established with statutory functions in state law and is cost recovered from industry. While it can receive Commonwealth funding for projects, this is akin to any other non-Commonwealth third party&#x2014;that is, it receives rather than spends Commonwealth funds. AEMO does not attend estimates or answer questions on notice, and there are other avenues for the Senate to ask questions of AEMO, including through other inquiries. I understand that AEMO has already offered briefings to all members of the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee should senators wish to engage with AEMO further.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.157.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 837 standing in the name of Senator Roberts be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="16" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.158.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:57" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="24" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="47" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.159.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="16:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate requires the Australian Energy Market Operator to attend the 2026-27 additional estimates hearings of the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee for a minimum of 45 minutes and commencing no later than 3 pm on a day to be determined by the committee.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.159.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="16:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 838 standing in the name of Senator Roberts be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.160.1" nospeaker="true" time="17:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="24" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.161.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.161.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Cybersafety; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="185" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.161.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="17:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Antic, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Prime Minister, by no later than midday on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, documents in the possession of, or to or from, the Behavioural Economics Team of the Australian Government (BETA) from 1 January 2023 to date, relating to the claimed or alleged dangers of social media and the need to restrict or regulate social media companies, including without limitation:</p><p class="italic">(a) research, literature reviews, surveys, focus groups, behavioural analyses or evaluations regarding the harms, risks or negative effects of social media (including on mental health, children and young people, addiction, disinformation and misinformation, polarisation, radicalisation or related issues);</p><p class="italic">(b) advice, briefings, emails, meeting notes or minutes or correspondence relating to restricting, regulating or imposing obligations on social media companies or platforms (including age limits, design-feature controls, algorithmic restrictions, duty-of-care or safety-by-design measures, or similar);</p><p class="italic">(c) any input or collaboration by BETA with other departments or agencies relating to the above topics; and</p><p class="italic">(d) related internal discussions, ethics reviews or capability work relating to the above topics.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.161.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="17:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 840, standing in the name of Senator Antic, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="18" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.162.1" nospeaker="true" time="17:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="24" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.163.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Housing; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="81" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.163.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="17:07" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Bragg, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Housing, by no later than midday on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, a list setting out the number of recipients of First Home Guarantees issued by Housing Australia under the Government's 5% deposit scheme, broken down by the geographic location of each recipient, including the recipient's:</p><p class="italic">(a) state or territory;</p><p class="italic">(b) federal electorate;</p><p class="italic">(c) local government area; and</p><p class="italic">(d) suburb.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.163.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="17:07" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 842, standing in the name of Senator Bragg, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.164.1" nospeaker="true" time="17:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="32" noes="20" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.165.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Defence Properties; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="193" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.165.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="speech" time="17:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">(a) notes that:</p><p class="italic">(i) the order for the production of documents no. 368, relating to the independent audit of the Defence estate as provided to the Government in December 2023, was agreed to by the Senate on 4 March 2026,</p><p class="italic">(ii) the associated public interest immunity claims advanced by the Government were rejected by the Senate, with the order reaffirmed by order no. 695 on 10 September 2026,</p><p class="italic">(iii) on 7 October 2026 the Government advised additional time was required to comply with the order, and</p><p class="italic">(iv) the order has still not been complied with; and</p><p class="italic">(b) requires the Minister representing the Minister for Defence to attend the Senate on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, at the conclusion of private senators' time, to provide an explanation, of no more than 5 minutes, of the failure to comply with the orders, and that:</p><p class="italic">(i) any senator may move to take note of the explanation, and</p><p class="italic">(ii) any such motion may be debated for no longer than 30 minutes, shall have precedence over all business until determined, and senators may speak to the motion for not more than 5 minutes each.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.166.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="speech" time="17:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I seek leave to make a short statement.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.166.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="17:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Leave is granted for one minute.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="103" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.166.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="continuation" time="17:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As the government has previously stated in the chamber, the PII claim for the classified version of the Defence Estate Audit clearly outlines that it includes sensitive information that relates to our defence bases. There is already a public version available online that will not jeopardise the operational effectiveness of Australia's defence capabilities. Defence is being targeted by adversaries looking to gain a strategic advantage, with foreign interference at extreme levels. If the opposition indeed votes with the Greens and others on this matter, it will be made crystal clear that Labor is the only party of government that takes national security seriously.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.166.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="17:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notice of motion No. 844, standing in the name of Senator Lambie, be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="20" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.167.1" nospeaker="true" time="17:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="31" noes="20" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833">James McGrath</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.168.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Office of the eSafety Commissioner; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.168.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="17:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>If it suits the chamber, I'm happy to move general business notices of motion Nos 845 and 846 together.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.168.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="17:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Senator Kovacic. I'll just test the chamber. The suggestion is that we move general business notices of motion Nos 845 and 846, both standing in Senator Henderson's name, together. I'm seeing yeses.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="194" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.168.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="continuation" time="17:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Henderson, I move general business notices of motion Nos 845 and 846 together:</p><p class="italic">GENERAL BUSINESS NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 845</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Communications, by no later than midday on 25 November 2026:</p><p class="italic">(a) all documents held by the Office of the eSafety Commissioner concerning the decision to cease monitoring, researching or publishing figures on compliance with the social media minimum age law; and</p><p class="italic">(b) all communications between the Office of the eSafety Commissioner, the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts and the minister or her office concerning the decision to cease monitoring, researching or publishing figures on compliance with the social media minimum age law.</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">GENERAL BUSINESS NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 846</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Communications, by no later than midday on 19 November 2026, all briefing documents prepared for the eSafety Commissioner and representatives of the Office of the eSafety Commissioner appearing at the supplementary Budget estimates hearing of the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee on 27 October 2026.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.168.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="17:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that general business notices of motion Nos 845 and 846 standing in the name of Senator Henderson and moved by Senator Kovacic be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.169.1" nospeaker="true" time="17:17" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="23" noes="28" pairs="10" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827">Matthew Canavan</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859">Jane Hume</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833">James McGrath</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908">Nita Green</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306">Anne Ruston</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845">Jenny McAllister</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303">Dean Smith</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.170.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.170.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026; First Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="s1529" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/s1529">Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="55" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.170.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="speech" time="17:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the following bill be introduced: A Bill for an Act to amend the <i>Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918</i>, and for related purposes.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>I present the bill and move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill may proceed without formalities and be now read a first time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bill read a first time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.171.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="s1529" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/s1529">Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="817" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.171.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" speakername="Anthony Chisholm" talktype="speech" time="17:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I table the explanatory memorandum relating to the bill and move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill be now read a second time.</p><p>I seek leave to have the second reading speech incorporated in <i>Hansard</i>.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p class="italic"> <i>The speech read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">Today I introduce the <i>Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026.</i></p><p class="italic">In February 2025, this Parliament passed historic reforms to Australia's electoral laws, the most significant in more than 40 years. Those reforms strengthened transparency and accountability and tackled the influence of big money in our politics.</p><p class="italic">The Reform Act has commenced, with the new funding and disclosure framework to take effect from 1 January 2027.</p><p class="italic">Since passage, I have continued to work with stakeholders as implementation work has progressed. That engagement has identified areas where the framework can be refined.</p><p class="italic">This Bill makes targeted changes to address practical issues, provides greater certainty for those who will operate under the new framework and ensure the reforms operate as intended.</p><p class="italic">Australia's electoral system is the envy of the world. These changes will reinforce the integrity of the new funding and disclosure framework and in turn further strengthen our representative democracy.</p><p class="italic">Federal accounts</p><p class="italic">This Bill refines the federal account settings under the funding and disclosure framework to provide greater flexibility while maintaining transparency and integrity, and to provide greater certainty for regulated persons and entities.</p><p class="italic">The settings will continue to ensure gifts made for a federal purpose are credited to a federal account and electoral expenditure is incurred from a federal account. These arrangements preserve the immunity of those gifts from state and territory electoral laws and ensure that electoral expenditure is funded only from permitted sources.</p><p class="italic">However, these controls must support regulated persons and entities to manage their funds in a financially responsible way and with a view to the future use of those funds.</p><p class="italic">First, the Bill will allow funds to be transferred from a federal account to a federal administrative account, enabling funds to be repurposed for administrative expenditure. This ensures that regulated persons and entities can manage their funds in a financially responsible way. Transfers cannot be made in the other direction, preserving controls over the sources of funds used for electoral expenditure.</p><p class="italic">Second, the Bill will address a gap in the funding and disclosure framework: that regulated persons and entities commonly, and sensibly, invest funds, to grow their reserves for use in future election campaigns.</p><p class="italic">The Bill will allow funds to be invested from a federal account, enabling regulated persons and entities to earn a financial return on those amounts. Those funds and returns may remain invested or be reinvested. However, any amounts no longer intended for investment or reinvestment must be credited back to a federal account to be used for one of the permitted purposes.</p><p class="italic">The Bill will also provide transitional arrangements for investments that regulated persons and entities have in place before the new funding and disclosure framework comes into effect on 1 January 2027. Regulated persons and entities may bring all or part of a pre-existing investment within the federal account framework, subject to the same safeguards as other permitted investments.</p><p class="italic">Strict reporting, record-keeping and anti-avoidance requirements will maintain transparency, support compliance and reduce the risk of non-permitted funds entering the federal account system.</p><p class="italic">Finally, to provide greater certainty for regulated persons and entities, the Bill will clarify existing obligations in relation to the use of funds held in federal accounts by explicitly setting these out on the face of the legislation.</p><p class="italic">Clarifying and technical amendments</p><p class="italic">The Bill will also make clarifying and technical amendments to improve consistency and streamline requirements across the funding and disclosure framework, and ensure the framework operates as intended. These changes will address issues identified through consultation and implementation work and support the effective administration and enforcement of the framework.</p><p class="italic">The changes include:</p><ul/><ul/><ul/><ul/><p class="italic">&#x2022; ensuring consistency in how the annual returns framework applies to new and existing regulated persons and entities and foreign donors, and operates as intended</p><ul/><ul/><ul/><p class="italic">Electoral Commission must pay administrative assistance funding, from the 7th day of a quarter to the 14th day of a quarter, to reduce administrative burden and support the efficient processing of various types of payments.</p><p class="italic">Conclusion</p><p class="italic">Australia has one of the world's strongest electoral systems. These targeted changes will support the effective implementation of the new funding and disclosure framework and reinforce its integrity.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Electoral Commission has and will continue to work closely with regulated persons and entities to implement the framework and support them to understand their obligations, address inadvertent errors and build their capability to comply, particularly in the early stages of implementation.</p><p class="italic">It will provide detailed, scenario-based guidance to support stakeholders to understand the changes in this Bill ahead of the reforms taking effect on 1 January 2027.</p><p class="italic">The Bill will strengthen transparency, support public confidence in our electoral processes and further protect Australia's representative democracy.</p><p class="italic">I commend the Bill to the Senate.</p><p>Debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.172.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.172.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Senate Estimates; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="129" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.172.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="17:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">(a) notes that the Minister representing the Minister for Communications has failed to comply with order for the production of documents no. 727, agreed to on 16 September 2026, relating to an answer to a question on notice;</p><p class="italic">(b) further notes evidence provided by officials from the Office of the eSafety Commissioner to the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee at a hearing held on 27 October 2026 that material relevant to the response to the order was sent by the Office of the eSafety Commissioner to the Minister for Communications' office 'last week or the week before'; and</p><p class="italic">(c) requires the Minister representing the Minister for Communications to comply with the order by no later than midday on 18 November 2026.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.173.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Early Childhood Education and Care; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="184" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.173.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="17:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">(a) notes that:</p><p class="italic">(i) a response to order for the production of documents no. 780, agreed to on 14 October 2026, relating to the proposed child care centre at Mukinbudin, was tabled on 30 October 2026,</p><p class="italic">(ii) in a letter tabled as part of the response, the Minister for Education noted that, if tabled, 'some documents would, or would reasonably be expected to, reveal deliberations of the Executive and Cabinet', and</p><p class="italic">(iii) while the Senate has previously accepted disclosure of Cabinet deliberations as a ground for a claim of public interest immunity, it has repeatedly rejected public interest immunity claims over deliberative material of the Executive;</p><p class="italic">(b) rejects the claim of public interest immunity over material which the minister believes would, or would reasonably be expected to, reveal deliberations of the Executive; and</p><p class="italic">(c) requires the Minister representing the Minister for Education to table a new response to the order, by no later than 7 December 2026, with redactions applied to material which would, or would reasonably be expected to, reveal deliberations of the Executive removed.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.174.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Child Abuse; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="228" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.174.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="speech" time="17:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move general business notices of motion Nos 831 and 832 together:</p><p class="italic">GENERAL BUSINESS NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 831</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Attorney-General, by no later than midday on Monday, 23 November 2026, all documents held by the Attorney-General's Department or the Attorney-General's office relating to the review, amendment or removal of content on the <i>Stop it now! Australia</i> website and its linked <i>Get help! Australia</i> self-help modules since 1 April 2026, including:</p><p class="italic">(a) versions of the relevant content before and after each amendment or removal and records showing when each change was made;</p><p class="italic">(b) briefs, advice, assessments or other records concerning any amendments or revisions to the content; and</p><p class="italic">(c) communications between the department, the Attorney-General's office and Jesuit Social Services about the review or changes.</p><p class="italic">GENERAL BUSINESS NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 832</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Attorney-</p><p class="italic">General, by no later than midday on Monday, 23 November 2026, all briefs, advice, assessments or other records held by the Attorney-General's Department or the Attorney-General's office concerning the appropriateness, clinical or evidentiary basis or child-safety implications of content developed for or published on the <i>Stop it now! Australia</i> website and its linked <i>Get help! Australia</i> self-help modules, including content about managing sexual fantasies involving children and whether sexual interest in children can be changed.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.175.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Urban Precincts and Partnerships Program; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="171" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.175.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="17:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator McGrath, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government, by no later than 5 pm on 17 December 2026, a document containing a complete list of all projects submitted for consideration or assessed under the Urban Precincts and Partnerships Program, across all funding rounds, tranches and streams of the program, including:</p><p class="italic">(a) all successful, unsuccessful, withdrawn, ineligible, pending or otherwise determined applications; and</p><p class="italic">(b) for each project:</p><p class="italic">(i) the project name and description,</p><p class="italic">(ii) the name of the applicant or proponent,</p><p class="italic">(iii) the total estimated project cost,</p><p class="italic">(iv) the amount of Commonwealth funding sought and, where applicable, approved,</p><p class="italic">(v) the state or territory in which the project is located,</p><p class="italic">(vi) the federal electorate in which the project is located,</p><p class="italic">(vii) the funding round, tranche or stream under which the application was considered, and</p><p class="italic">(viii) the status or outcome of the application, including the date of any final decision.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.176.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Department of Veterans' Affairs; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="348" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.176.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" speakername="Ross Cadell" talktype="speech" time="17:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I seek leave to amend general business notice of motion No. 839.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p>I move the motion as amended in the terms circulated in the chamber:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Veterans' Affairs, by no later than 5 pm on Monday, 30 November 2026, the following documents:</p><p class="italic">(a) the executed contract between the Department of Veterans' Affairs (DVA) and MedHealth Pty Ltd for the provision of independent medical examinations through MLCOA (AusTender CN ID: CN3867989), including all schedules and annexures, each version of the fee schedule specifying the fees payable for each type of assessment and report, and any renewal or extension provisions and documents giving effect to them;</p><p class="italic">(b) all executed variations to the contract and any briefs, approvals or other documents recording the reasons for each variation;</p><p class="italic">(c) the tender documents used to Approach the Market which resulted in the contract advised by AusTender notice CN3867989;</p><p class="italic">(d) the request for tender for the replacement contract (AusTender ATM ID: MIGS26), including any mandatory requirements and evaluation criteria;</p><p class="italic">(e) a statement setting out the number of tenders received and the number that met the mandatory requirements;</p><p class="italic">(f) the final tender evaluation report, including any attachments and recommendation on the award of the contract;</p><p class="italic">(g) any contract executed as a result of the procurement, including its schedules and annexures;</p><p class="italic">(h) all briefs, advice, costings, modelling and analyses prepared by or for DVA comparing the fees payable to MLCOA with the fees paid or payable to veterans' treating practitioners for comparable medical reports;</p><p class="italic">(i) all briefs, advice, costings, modelling and analyses prepared by or for DVA that informed the development or approval of the fee limits for medical reports prepared by treating practitioners that took effect on 9 February 2026; and</p><p class="italic">(j) a statement setting out, for each financial year from 2021-22 to 2026-27 inclusive, the total amount paid by DVA under contract CN3867989 and the number of medical reports for which DVA made payments under that contract, with figures for 2026-27 to the latest available date.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.177.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Household and Personal Debt, Housing Australia Future Fund; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="173" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.177.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="17:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Bragg, I move general business notices of motion Nos 841 and 843 together:</p><p class="italic">GENERAL BUSINESS NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 841</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Treasurer, by no later than 11 am on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, any briefing, advice or analysis provided to the Treasurer by the Department of the Treasury in relation to the lending indicators for the September quarter 2026 published by the Australian Bureau of Statistics.</p><p class="italic">GENERAL BUSINESS NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 843</p><p class="italic">That the Senate&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">(a) notes that:</p><p class="italic">(i) on Tuesday, 13 October 2026, the Senate agreed to order for the production of documents no. 778, relating to the Housing Australia Future Fund, requiring the Minister representing the Minister for Housing to comply by no later than midday on 22 October 2026, and</p><p class="italic">(ii) the order has not been complied with; and</p><p class="italic">(b) requires the Minister representing the Minister for Housing to comply with the order by midday on Wednesday, 18 November 2026.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.178.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
MATTERS OF URGENCY </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.178.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Fossil Fuel Industry </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="139" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.178.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="speech" time="17:25" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator McKim has submitted a proposal under standing order 75 today. It is shown as item 13 on today's order of business:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The need for the Australian Government to ensure Australians receive a fair return from the nation's natural resources, noting that Australians have missed out on an estimated $135 billion in revenue over the past 14 years following Labor's decision to abandon its proposed Resource Super Profits Tax in the face of a mining industry scare campaign.</p><p>Is consideration of the proposal supported?</p><p class="italic">
  <i>More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places&#x2014;</i>
</p><p>It is supported. With the concurrence of the Senate, the Clerk will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="805" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.179.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="speech" time="17:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The need for the Australian Government to ensure Australians receive a fair return from the nation's natural resources, noting that Australians have missed out on an estimated $135 billion in revenue over the past 14 years following Labor's decision to abandon its proposed Resource Super Profits Tax in the face of a mining industry scare campaign.</p><p>Today we have been able to put a figure on Labor's decades-long capitulation to the fossil fuel industry, and that figure is $135 billion. Labor has learned absolutely nothing from the mining industry's campaign to kill the Resource Super Profits Tax. More than a decade later, we are watching the exact same playbook unfold, and Albanese is letting these fossil fuel producers get away with it again and again and again. Every time we talk about getting a fair share of Australia's resources for Australians, the fossil fuel lobby runs the same tired scare campaign&#x2014;the same talking points that we hear reiterated by the corporate parties in this place, the corporate parties being Labor, the Liberals and One Nation. We hear the fossil fuel lobby stamp their feet and threaten investment. We hear them threaten jobs. They warn that the sky will fall in if we tax them and make them pay what they owe. Well, then we see Labor capitulate, as they have done on the gas tax.</p><p>The mining industry spent $22 million on an advertising campaign to kill Prime Minister Rudd's Resource Super Profits Tax back in 2010. You know, $22 million sounds like a lot of money to people out there listening in. But what an extraordinary return on investment for the fossil fuel industry when it saved $135 billion. Twenty-two million bucks is loose change for these guys. It's a couple of lunches for their mates. And what does Australia get out of this deal? What do Australians get out of this deal? Nothing. It's nothing like the fair return that we would have if we received a fair share for our finite natural resources.</p><p>The PBO, the Parliamentary Budget Office, has now estimated that the original Resource Super Profits Tax would have delivered $135 billion to government revenue between 2012 and 2026, had it gone ahead. That's $135 billion that could have gone into investing in things to actually make people's lives better. Just imagine what that amount of money could deliver for Australians: universal early education&#x2014;let's make it free education from early childhood through to university, like it used to be; a properly funded NDIS; cheaper, cleaner, more secure energy; electrification of our homes and businesses; public housing; proper investment in our hospitals and schools; and money back into the pockets of everyday Australians doing it tough. But, instead, this $135 billion stays in the pockets of some of the world's biggest and richest mining corporations.</p><p>Meanwhile, we hear this Labor government saying that there are going to be cuts in this upcoming budget&#x2014;that we need to tighten our purse strings, that we need to count our pennies. They want an austerity budget at the same time as they are leaving billions on the table for these resource corporations, often multinational corporations, to feed their bottom line and to fatten their purse. We are today watching this exact same playbook happen on gas and a gas export tax. The gas industry spent $11 million campaigning against a 25 per cent gas export tax&#x2014;same scare campaign, same empty threats, same vested interests. And it turns out that, once again, this Labor government is too timid and unwilling to stand up to them, stare them down and say, 'You pay what you owe for Australia's resources.'</p><p>The government tells us there's not enough money to have nice things, essential things. Apparently there's no extra money for early childhood education, there's no money for public housing, there's no money to properly fund the NDIS and there is no money to help people get off expensive gas. Well, we say bulldust. There is always enough money for this government to continue to subsidise the fossil fuel industry, but never enough to give Australians their fair share. The Australian people are sick of being told to tighten their belts, to tighten their purse strings, when this money is being left on the table.</p><p>If you want to know what corporate capture looks like, it is this; this is corporate capture. This is a fossil fuel industry funding our major parties, our 'corporate parties', through donations, offering them jobs after they finish in this place and fighting any reform that will help Australians live better lives. Australian Labor keeps falling for it&#x2014;or, more perhaps more accurately, keeps choosing to fall for it. Tax our resources and make Australians' lives better. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="676" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.180.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" speakername="Susan McDonald" talktype="speech" time="17:31" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Once again, we're going to have another debate with people who don't understand how the world works or how economies work. For the five millionth time, I'm going to go through it. The Greens political party is not interested in running a successful economy that allows Australians to live a first-world lifestyle, as we have for generations. Instead, they are interested in the complete destruction of our resources sector and our economy, and are happy to spend money ahead of receiving it. We talk about scare campaigns; we hear a lot about them from the Greens. Well, Australia should be incredibly worried; what would happen if the Greens ever got near the Treasury benches? One of the only truths in this chamber is that if a Greens member is talking about the economy, you can be pretty sure it will be the end of that economy. They are trying to make Australians poorer, and this is one more example of how this works. This is a wholehearted campaign by the Greens against our mining sector that pays billions of dollars into the economy every year.</p><p>The Greens talk about missed revenue. Well, let's talk about what the actual revenue is. The mining industry has paid $255.1 billion in capital expenditure over the last 10 years in Australia. The Australian mining industry has paid $432.2 billion in company taxes and royalties over the past 10 years. That is real revenue&#x2014;the billions of dollars of Australian wages and salaries, more than double what the average wage and salary in Australia is, paid by resources companies to Australians. That then floods into other businesses around Australia&#x2014;small businesses, boating and camping, fishing, motorbikes, jet skis and all other sorts of interesting and fun things&#x2014;and it is thanks to wages and salaries from the mining sector.</p><p>What would have been missed if the mining tax was kept? The proposed resources super profits tax was fundamentally flawed. It would have undermined investor confidence, threatened Australia's competitiveness and created significant uncertainty for an industry that is one of the largest contributors to our national prosperity. We can point to other jurisdictions that went down exactly the same socialist road. Argentina, a country that is now clawing its way back into the world economy, is fighting desperately to be competitive for attracting investment into its resources sector, its gas sector and, indeed, its beef sector. The claim that Australians have missed out on $135 billion is based on some hypothetical calculation of revenue that may have been collected, but it conveniently ignores the potential economic consequence of the tax and of the investment that would have fled the economy.</p><p>What about an analysis of the terms of trade impact, of what that tax would have done to Australia? Do you enjoy buying a well-priced motor vehicle that was manufactured overseas, a well-priced TV that was manufactured overseas or a well-priced fridge that was manufactured overseas? All of those things would not have been possible without the fantastic terms of trade that Australia enjoys because of, primarily, mining and gas and, to a lesser extent, agricultural exports. It is the giants of mining and gas that ensure that we can enjoy that First World lifestyle.</p><p>Our resources sector supports hundreds of thousands of Australian jobs, particularly in regional and remote communities. It underpins local businesses. It creates opportunities for workers and apprentices. It supports regional infrastructure and contributes significant revenue through company tax royalties and other taxes. It is the Australian resources sector that is the largest funder of environmental measurement and management in this country. Australians benefit when our resources sector is successful, and our focus should be on maintaining our high-quality resources sector, our high standards of workplace health and safety, our high environmental standards and all the contributions they make to Australians and to the First World lifestyle that we have. We should be encouraging resource companies and supporting them here in Australia, not revisiting a failed tax that would have put all of that at risk&#x2014;or, worse, introducing a new one.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="689" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.181.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" speakername="Lisa Darmanin" talktype="speech" time="17:36" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In considering this urgency motion from Senator McKim, I think it's important to put some facts on the record. Australia has a profits based tax applying to offshore petroleum projects, the petroleum resource rent tax or the PRRT. The PRRT taxes excess profits from offshore petroleum projects at a rate of 40 per cent after allowing projects to recover their costs and achieve an appropriate return on their investment. Since coming to government, Labor has strengthened that system to ensure LNG projects pay more tax and pay it sooner. We also introduced a cap on the deductions LNG projects can use to offset their PRRT liability in any one year. Once a project becomes liable for PRRT, accumulated deductions can no longer be used to completely eliminate that liability. We have also reformed the way gas transfer pricing is calculated and strengthened the PRRT's anti-avoidance rules, bringing those arrangements into line with the broader tax integrity framework.</p><p>Those reforms have already resulted in an additional $1.2 billion being collected from LNG projects, and the contributions of the resource sector extend well beyond the PRRT. Senator McDonald outlined some of those, including some of the numbers, but I'll add a couple more. In 2022-2023, the resources sector contributed nearly a third of all company tax paid in Australia, amounting to $47.3 billion. Of that, mining contributed $37.8 billion and the oil and gas sector contributed $10.4 billion. Treasury forecasts from MYEFO 2025-26 in December last year showed that the PRRT alone will raise $5.4 billion in receipts over the next four years from 2025-26. At the state and territory level, around $22 billion in royalties was received from the resources sector in 2024-25.</p><p>I think it's worth having the full picture when we debate the return Australians receive from their natural resources, and I do agree with Senator McKim's sentiment on the motion that Australians should receive a fair return on our natural resources. That is why this government is also acting directly on the domestic supply of gas. Australian gas should work for the Australian people. We have abundant gas resources, and Australians rightly expect reliable access to those resources at a reasonable price. That is why the government's domestic gas reservation legislation package is designed to address this. The proposition is straightforward: where exporters benefit from Australian gas resources, they also have a responsibility to contribute to meeting Australia's domestic needs.</p><p>Under the legislation, gas exporters will be required to make sufficient gas resources available to the Australian market before exporting gas overseas. This has not been developed in isolation. The government's 2024 Future Gas Strategy recognised that gas will continue to play a role through the transition to net zero, including as a peaking and firming capacity to support renewables and in industrial uses where alternatives are not yet readily available. It also made clear that gas must remain affordable for Australian users through that transition. The gas market review then considered the longer term settings for Australia's gas market. Its final report, released in December 2025, found that those settings needed to evolve, and recommended establishing a domestic gas reservation scheme. The government has subsequently worked through the design of that scheme so it can respond to changing economic and supply circumstances, rather than operate as a blunt instrument.</p><p>Australians absolutely should expect a fair return from the resources that they own. That means making sure resource companies pay their fair share of tax. It means protecting the integrity of the tax system. It also means making sure Australians have access to the resources produced here. The government has strengthened the PRRT so LNG producers pay more tax and pay it sooner. We have strengthened integrity rules and we are now putting in place a domestic gas reservation scheme to ensure Australia's gas resources also contribute to Australia's domestic needs. Rather than rehearse a debate from 14 years ago, this government is focused on what will make a practical difference now&#x2014;ensuring LNG producers pay more tax, pay it sooner, strengthen the integrity of our tax system and ensure Australian gas is available to meet Australian needs.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="263" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.182.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="17:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>A teacher earning $100,000 a year pays more than $20,000 in income tax. They don't get to negotiate that obligation with the Treasurer. When governments ask multinational resource companies to contribute fairly from their profits, suddenly the rules are up for negotiation. We have families struggling to pay their bills, underpaid teachers, overstretched hospitals, and communities waiting for essential childhood education and care facilities and infrastructure that this government promised them. Australians are drowning. But, in the meantime, we see enormous profits continue to flow offshore, with Rio and BHP alone reporting approximately $35 billion in profits this year.</p><p>Sixteen years ago, the Labor government proposed a resource superprofits tax but backed down under pressure from the resources lobby. Today Parliamentary Budget Office analysis estimates that, had the original tax been introduced and maintained, Australia's budget could be $135 billion better off. Imagine what that money could have meant to Australian families, and imagine where we'll be in another 16 years if we continue to reject measures like a 25 per cent tax on excess gas export profits&#x2014;still telling parents struggling with childcare fees that we can't afford to help, still cutting disability and support services, still failing to deliver meaningful relief for renters, still putting our climate targets at risk to protect the profits of fossil fuel companies and still asking the most vulnerable Australians to make sacrifices while multinational corporations extract billions from our natural resources. Every dollar we fail to collect from our natural resources is a dollar we cannot invest in the Australian people, and the people deserve better.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="709" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.183.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" speakername="Richard Dowling" talktype="speech" time="17:43" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, there's one part of this motion that I do agree with. Australians do deserve a fair return from the natural resources they own. But everything else beyond that causes some issues. We hear that Australia somehow missed out on $135 billion from a tax that never existed. This is not money collected and it's not money guaranteed. If we look at the PBO work, it's actually an estimate of what might have happened, assuming no change to investment, production or prices. So it's effectively hypothetical revenue from a hypothetical scenario, and nobody should be fooled otherwise. Have a look at the PBO's own work. It's a purely hypothetical scenario; nevertheless, the Greens have already gone ahead and spent the money.</p><p>Since the Greens want to go back many years and revisit history, I think we should go back to 2009, when Labor in fact proposed an emissions trading scheme&#x2014;a price on carbon pollution that would reduce emissions and raise billions through the sale of permits. Treasury estimated back then that around $13 billion in permanent revenue in 2012-13 alone would have been raised, with much of those billions supporting households and businesses. At that time, what did the Greens do? They voted with the coalition against an emissions trading scheme. Apparently it wasn't ambitious enough, and, instead of getting a carbon price, Australia got no scheme at all. They demanded perfection and achieved nothing. Now, 17 years later, they're lecturing the Senate about the revenue Australia might have collected from a tax. The Greens suddenly have a very selective interest in missed economic opportunities.</p><p>Let's return to this latest proposal. It is a 25 per cent tax on gas exports, which they claim will raise $17 billion a year, and, my word, they've been busy spending it&#x2014;dental care, mental health, housing, schools, free university, student debt, solar panels, batteries. That $17 billion hasn't even been collected yet, but it's already visited the dentist, paid off its HECS debt, bought a house and installed solar panels. It's the hardest working money in Australia, especially considering it doesn't even exist. There's a rather significant problem: the Greens want to phase out the very industry they're proposing to tax; their policy calls for fossil fuel exports to cease. So the plan is simple&#x2014;tax the gas, spend the revenue, stop exporting the gas and somehow keep spending the revenue. I've got news: 25 per cent of zero is zero. They've tried the same trick in Tasmania as well. The Tasmanian Greens have proposed $108 million a year from taxing salmon farming. Meanwhile, Senator McKim and his Tasmanian colleagues want salmon farms moved out of state waters. Apparently, fish can leave the water but the revenue is expected to keep swimming.</p><p>Underneath the comedy is a serious economic problem. The Greens want to fund permanent public services with revenue from industries they're determined to close. Schools, hospitals and dental care need funding long after the Greens finish their press conference. You cannot build a sustainable budget around a revenue stream you've promised to abolish. Labor understands that economic reality. That is why we have strengthened the petroleum resource rent tax. In 2024-25, oil and gas companies paid $10.6 billion in company tax, with another $1.9 billion in petroleum resource rent tax payable. That is real revenue from real economic activity.</p><p>We're also proposing the domestic gas reservation to improve supply and put downward pressure on prices for Australian households and manufacturers. In fact, I've just returned from Japan, where our partners made very clear how much they value Australia as a reliable energy supplier. We've been supplying gas to Japan since the 1960s, and a shipment has not been missed. We are one of the most reliable suppliers in the world, and that is why we can command premium prices for our exports. We should not forget those factors as we consider how we capture the most from our resources. These decisions have consequences for investment, jobs, international relationships and household budgets. The Greens can promise the revenue, promise the spending and promise to abolish the industry all at the same time, all before lunchtime. That's not a budget; it's a magic trick, and eventually Australians will be left holding the empty hat.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="719" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.184.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="17:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We've now got a small insight into how different the world would be if the Labor Party actually had a backbone and was willing to do what the Australian public have been demanding, which is govern for them, not govern for their vested interests and the one per cent. The Greens asked the Parliamentary Budget Office to work out how much revenue the Australian public would have received if the tax reforms on the resource sector that Kevin Rudd proposed and put in place for a very brief period of time 14 years ago had actually been held on to and hadn't been undermined and ratted by the Gillard government and then entirely gutted by the coalition.</p><p>How much revenue has been lost because Labor got rolled internally by the resources industry and then the coalition came over and did the coup de grace on good policy? It's $135 billion in lost revenue because Labor did not and does not have a backbone. At least 14 years ago the Labor Party was willing to have a look at getting some of the public wealth back from these largely multinational corporations that are getting access to public resources. Remember, every tonne of iron ore, every megajoule of gas, every gram of gold, every tonne of aluminium, are all public resources&#x2014;public resources that corporations get a licence for access to then dig up and flog off. And of course, the Labor Party, their mates in the coalition and their mates in One Nation, are quite happy for the public to have these resources stolen and get nothing back.</p><p>But now we know, and I really want to credit Senator Hodgins-May for pushing this issue, for finding out the answers and for getting this result. Lost revenue of $135 billion is an extraordinary amount. Now, you may only buy two of Labor's AUKUS submarines or one of the coalition's extraordinary gifts that they want to give to corporate Australia. But I'll tell you what it would build. It would build a world-class hospital system. It would build extraordinary public schools. It would build the core infrastructure we need to have publicly owned, incredibly low-cost renewable energy being pumped into everyone's home. That's what $135 billion would build.</p><p>But what have we got Labor doing now? Roll on 14 years, and they've lost $135 billion because they had the backbone-removal exercise. What have we got now? Well, now we've got Prime Minister Albanese and his Treasurer, Jim Chalmers, getting ready to make a substantial package of cuts and an austerity budget. And who's in Labor's sights right now? Is it the export gas industry? No, they're getting away&#x2014;no export gas tax, $17 billion lost a year. Is it the resource sector, who are making record profits? No. Who's in the line of sight for Labor in this budget? Pensioners, people with disability, migrants&#x2014;that's who Labor's going after.</p><p>We've just seen some of the impacts of Labor gutting the NDIS. The analysis has come out, and we see that there have been 120,000 children being kicked off the NDIS because of Labor's changes. That's what it's going to mean. They're overwhelmingly boys from disadvantaged backgrounds that are getting the biggest cuts. Labor's getting its budget savings from boys from disadvantaged backgrounds with disability&#x2014;that's who. That's who Labor are getting their budget savings from, because they won't take on the export gas industry, because they won't take on the resource sector.</p><p>Rather than another round of austerity, the Greens have identified billions of dollars of revenue that the government could have. Why don't you knock off the $16.3 billion a year you're giving fossil fuel subsidies to the resource sector? Why don't you join with the Greens and get rid of the tax perks and the tax breaks you give to billionaires, who are getting $640 million a year in tax subsidies when they fill up their private jets? They pay one-fifteenth of what an ordinary motorist pays in tax per litre. Join with us. But no, you're too happy to be giving Senator Hanson $174 every time she fills up her private jet or $3,000 every time your mate Clive Palmer fills up their jet. This is not the time for austerity; this is the time to be backing in Australians and Australian families.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="600" approximate_wordcount="299" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.185.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="17:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Fossil fuel corporations are taking taxpayers for a ride. By not paying a fair tax on the resources that they extract, fossil fuel corporations have deprived taxpayers of receiving cost-of-living relief and the services that they need and deserve. By using and abusing insolvency laws, they also make taxpayers pay billions of dollars cleaning up the mess that these massive fossil fuel corporations leave in our oceans. There are currently 6,000 kilotons of oil and gas infrastructure sitting in our oceans. They're all going to have to be cleaned up. The cost: $60 billion. Now, onshore mining companies have to pay a bond to clean up after themselves when they finish digging holes in the ground. Renters have to pay a bond in case they don't clean up after themselves when they move out of the house that they have been renting. But we just want to give big, polluting corporations operating offshore oil and gas rigs a free ride on the taxpayer.</p><p>This federal Labor government has been promising that it will make laws requiring these big, offshore, polluting corporations to pay a bond to clean up after themselves so that we do not have toxic junk left in our ocean, polluting it and killing our marine wildlife. Where is it? A company that used insolvency laws to walk away before it had to clean up its offshore junk is now being given the money to clean up the junk by this federal Labor government from the taxpayer's pocket. We keep on being told that there isn't the money to fund the services we deserve and government departments keep being asked to find savings. We wouldn't be in this situation if the government grew a backbone and told fossil fuel corporations to stop taking taxpayers for a ride.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.185.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" speakername="Richard Mansell Colbeck" talktype="interjection" time="17:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion moved by Senator McKim be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-17" divnumber="22" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.186.1" nospeaker="true" time="18:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="11" noes="29" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" vote="aye">Lidia Thorpe</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="no">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="no">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="no">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="no">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="no">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="no">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="no">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="no">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.187.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Housing </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="100" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.187.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" speakername="Richard Mansell Colbeck" talktype="speech" time="18:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Senate will now consider the proposal from Senator Bragg, which is also shown at item 13 on today's Order of Business:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The Government's failure on housing, including the Budget tax hikes that have smashed lending for homeowners and first home buyers.</p><p>Is consideration of the proposal supported?</p><p class="italic"> <i>More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places&#x2014;</i></p><p>With the concurrence of the Senate, the Clerks will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="637" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.188.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="speech" time="18:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The Government's failure on housing, including the Budget tax hikes that have smashed lending for homeowners and first home buyers.</p><p>The matter of urgency is that the government have imposed taxes onto the Australian economy and onto the Australian housing system, which have been an absolute disaster. They've been an absolute disaster. I think most people would look at it and say, 'Why are you imposing taxes on everything in order to solve a housing problem which has made the economy sicker and has made the housing system much worse?' I say to the good doctor, over in the other place&#x2014;Dr Chalmers is what he calls himself now&#x2014;that there are really three tests for this budget. Test 1 is: do you have more loans or fewer loans? Test 2 is: are rents going up or are rents going down? Test 3 is: are you getting more houses or are you getting fewer houses?</p><p>On the first test, in terms of loans, we saw last week the ABS coming out with their historic publication in which they said that this was the biggest drop in home lending since records began. I think that gives you a pretty clear score on the lending side. We saw a drop in loans to investors; yes, we did. We saw a drop in loans to owner-occupiers. We also saw a drop in loans to first home owners&#x2014;apparently, the people who were supposed to be the great beneficiaries of this fantastical, magnificent, beautiful largesse from Canberra! So you've got lower loans to owner-occupiers, to first home owners and to investors. The Labor Party hates investors more than they want to solve the housing crisis; that is well established. But who knew that they hated first home owners so much? Who knew that they hated owner-occupiers this much? Who knew? Not I, and not anyone else. So you've got a massive collapse&#x2014;in fact, the biggest and most historic collapse in home lending since records began. That's how good this budget is on that front.</p><p>Then we go to rents. The good doctor, when he was cooking up this crooked stew, said 'two bucks a week'&#x2014;'two bucks'. In Sydney, already, we're seeing rents increasing by up to 200 bucks. So there you go: he's failed on rents; he's failed on loans.</p><p>But maybe the biggest of them all is that he's failed on supply. Now, I imagine that most people in this place are of sound mind. I imagine that's the case&#x2014;even as to the members of the government. I believe they're of sound mind, at some level. But I have to say I was scratching my head on budget night, when I saw in the budget papers that these tax measures would reduce housing supply by 35,000 dwellings. I thought to myself: 'Why would we want to reduce dwellings by one, let alone by 35,000? Something is awry over on the government benches. They've been down to Treasury, down at Langton Crescent, and they've had too much punch, and something's happened!' But that's what the budget papers say. They want to reduce housing supply by 35,000, because they hate investors more than they want to build houses for Australians. And that is in their budget papers.</p><p>But, when you look at the industry analysis, it all stacks up. The industry agrees: there will be 35,000 fewer houses, but it will be more than 35,000; it will be more like 50,000 over the 10-year period.</p><p>What's more, when the government did the deal to pass their stinking budget through this Senate, they did a deal with the Greens to stop SMSFs from investing in new houses. So, the doc&#x2014;the good doc; I'm trying to be generous here, Deputy President&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="11" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.188.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="18:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Bragg, you know you have to refer to people properly.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="252" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.188.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="continuation" time="18:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, Dr Chalmers is his name&#x2014;the Treasurer. That's his name, isn't it? Yes. Anyway, he comes up and he says: 'We're only going to take away 4,000 SMSF-funded houses. It's only 4,000 houses. You won't even notice. It's so small, you won't even see it. It's not even there. It's like it's hiding. Four thousand are going to go&#x2014;4,000 new houses. That's 4,000 houses we don't need.'</p><p>But the problem with that is that then, when estimates roll around, and I say, 'Well, how's it going with your 4,000 fewer houses?' the Treasury officials say, 'It's actually 8,000.' So he was wrong on that. But then the bigger problem is that the industry says it's 16,000&#x2014;16,000 houses in the last financial year were supported by SMSFs. The problem with the doc's data is: he got the wrong data from the Treasury and the wrong data from his office. He doesn't know what he's doing. But the main point is: why is he cutting supply at all? Why is he cutting them by 35,000? Why is he cutting them by 16,000? There'll be a cumulative total, over the decade, of 75,000 fewer houses. So, if you want to look at this stinking wreckage of a budget, this stinking turd of a budget, you are looking at higher rents, you are looking at fewer houses and you're looking at fewer loans to the people who are supposed to be helped.</p><p class="italic"> <i>An incident having occurred in the chamber&#x2014;</i></p><p>And your phone's ringing, by the way.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.188.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="18:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The bell was tolling for someone, Senator Bragg!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="754" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.189.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="18:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Bragg for the opportunity to talk about the great work that's been done by the Albanese Labor government, as we address the housing crisis after a decade of neglect. Unfortunately, buying a home has become a life-defining challenge for so many people. Far too many Australians are burning the midnight oil and doing everything right but haven't been able to find a place to call their own home, and many younger Australians have just given up hope. It's an utter disgrace that we've come to this, and it should never have been allowed to happen. Put simply, we've had a housing market geared towards investors for a generation, which left us nothing more than plummeting homeownership rates, spiralling house prices and a generation of losing hope.</p><p>This year's budget helps to build more homes and levels the playing field for her first home buyers. House prices have risen around 54 per cent since COVID and more than 400 per cent since 1999&#x2014;400 per cent! As a result, the average time taken to save a 20 per cent deposit has increased to more than 11 years, while the median dwelling price has risen from roughly four times the average income in 1999 to more than eight times the average income. This is unacceptable. That's why, since coming to office, we've pursued the most ambitious housing agenda in generations. We recognise more needs to be done. We're limiting negative gearing for residential property from the 2027-28 financial year so that it can only be used for new builds, and we're replacing the 50 per cent capital gains tax with inflation adjusted indexation from 1 July 2027 to restore the taxation of real gains. These changes will help around 75,000 first home buyers into the market over the next decade.</p><p>Our efforts are already helping to level the playing field and ensuring investment flows to where it's more productive, instead of housing, where more and more Australians are being priced out of the market. Recent ABS data backs our reforms. Investors are now moving away from bidding up the price of existing homes and moving towards new builds, encouraging new supply. This is in addition to our five per cent deposit scheme, which is helping more than 270,000 first home buyers into the housing market and saving them $2.3 billion in lenders mortgage insurance costs. Despite the chorus of contempt from those opposite, the RBA governor has said that negative equity remains very limited, affecting less than one per cent of borrowers. Sure, home lending may have declined a little, but this has been caused by many factors, including unprecedented global economic uncertainty and higher interest rates, as seen during other periods of decline, such as from 2017 to 2019 and 2022 to 2023.</p><p>Here are some impressive numbers painting a crystal-clear picture of what we're doing compared to what those opposite did. We're investing $47 billion in our Homes for Australia plan, nearly 10 times what the coalition invested in housing. They invested just $5 billion. We're investing $6.3 billion in housing-enabling infrastructure, over 50 times what the coalition invested, which was just $123 million. We're building 55,000 social and affordable homes, which is nearly 150 times what the coalition built. They built just 373&#x2014;yes, just 373. We are also building homes for first home buyers and working to deliver 1.2 million homes. In fact, since we were elected, more than 700,000 homes have been built across the nation. I'm quite surprised, Senator Bragg, that you wanted to keep talking about housing, given there are more homes under construction right now in Australia than at any other time in our history. Construction cost inflation has fallen from 17 per cent under the coalition&#x2014;a half-century high&#x2014;to 3.8 per cent. Approvals have risen for three consecutive years. They are up nine per cent over the past year, and approvals were 26.3 per cent higher in the June quarter compared to the June quarter 2024, just before the accord started.</p><p>Senator Bragg and those opposite want to see their rich property mogul mates buying more investment properties while telling those on lower incomes to just accept substandard housing. Add to that the shadow treasurer's advice to put on a jumper in winter rather than spending huge amounts of money, which starts to resemble a modern form of medieval feudalism. It's just crazy. It's about accessibility, energy efficiency and basic livability, not luxuries. These are the bare minimum housing standards that all Australians are entitled to expect.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="149" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.190.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="18:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm not sure about everything Senator Bragg proposes in this motion, but he is right to suggest that this government has failed on housing. The situation in Perth and across Western Australia, particularly for renters, is desperate. The latest Cotality data from September puts the median rent in Perth at $798, not far behind Sydney. That amount has increased by eight per cent over the last year, in spite of an increase in vacancy from 1.2 per cent to 2.2 per cent. For Australians looking to buy their first home, things aren't much better. At the same time that the government makes changes to negative gearing and capital gains tax discount, it is running programs like the five per cent deposit scheme, which has no maximum income limit. It is pushing down on prices with one lever while inflaming demand with another. We need a fair go on housing.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="724" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.191.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="speech" time="18:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Bragg for bringing this important subject before us to debate today, and I commend Senator Bragg on the outstanding work that he's been doing in holding this government to account and unpicking the folly of their failed housing program. It is not meeting the objectives of Australians that are desperate to be able to get into a home&#x2014;an affordable home&#x2014;and this government is failing at every level, not just in housing but right across their entire platform. At the heart of this is a very simple question: are young Australians any closer now to owning a home than they've been before? The 2026 <i>Intergenerational </i><i>r</i><i>eport</i> puts a stark number on this challenge. It now takes 11.2 years to save for a 20 per cent deposit, and in December 2002 it took just 7.1 years. For a young person or a couple, that means working, paying rent and trying to save while the goal just keeps moving further away. Even the most naturally optimistic young Australian must be asking how long they are expected to wait.</p><p>This government claims that it's done more than any previous government to help young people and families buy their home. But&#x2014;and these stats were missed by the previous speaker, Senator Dolega, who obviously just used an outdated version of ChatGPT or something to come up with his speech, because it did not reveal facts and truth&#x2014;the ABS figures show that new home loan commitments fell 15 per cent in the September quarter alone. First home buyer loans fell 8.6 per cent in the quarter and 12.3 per cent over this year. Owner-occupier commitments fell 5.3 per cent. Young Australians need more than announcements. They need a chance to be able to buy and save for their home.</p><p>As Peter Costello, one of the greatest treasurers that this country has ever seen, put it, 'Debt-free government is the best youth policy you'll ever come across.' No truer words have been spoken about the economy. That captures a broader truth. Sound economic management is the foundation of sound housing policy, yet young people face high inflation and the highest interest rates since 2008. Labor's new taxes on housing investment risk discouraging investment in homes and making ownership harder to reach. For some first home buyers, the pressure continues after they get the keys. Reporting this week on Equifax data found that some buyers using the government's five per cent deposit scheme are now behind on their repayments. Among those in administration and other services, almost six in every thousand were at least 30 days behind, compared to about two in every thousand in finance and education. This shows how quickly repayments can squeeze households with very little room in their budgets.</p><p>In question time today, Minister Watt said that the government is making the economy more resilient. Resilience means withstanding a shock and then recovering from it. Minister Watt and his government sure have delivered shocks and difficulties to Australians, but I cannot see a recovery in sight delivered by this government. I can see families facing higher costs of living, higher mortgage payments and a housing market pushing them further from homeownership. Where is the bounce back for a couple in their late 20s who moved in with their parents to be able to save for a deposit? Some have told me it feels like they are stepping backwards and not stepping forwards. That pressure is not just limited to first home buyers; it is in the community at large.</p><p>I want to spend the last 40 seconds of this speech talking about the AUKUS program and the pressure that that is putting on the housing market in Western Australia and in the southern suburbs of Perth. We've got sailors and submariners coming here, thankfully, as part of the AUKUS program, from the United States and the UK. Where are they going to be housed? All that's happening is Defence is taking up homes within the local economy, on the local market, and there are not enough new homes being built. How many new homes do we need? How many times does the government need to be reminded that this is an urgent problem that needs to be resolved? They are doing nothing about it&#x2014;and not just this federal government but, indeed, the state government. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="169" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.192.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="18:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>A young couple today have a very different life to that of their parents, who were able to raise a family and buy a home on one wage. Here's why. The McMahon government fell in 1972 when unemployment went over two per cent. Today it's 4.7 per cent. Full employment is considered anything under four per cent&#x2014;a figure more beneficial to corporate profits than workers' wages. Full-time employment has fallen from 87 per cent of wage earners in 1975 to just 68 per cent today. A family earning the median wage in 1975 spent 35 per cent of their gross salary on a mortgage; today, it's 50 per cent or more. An average home in 1975 was 12 times the worth of median earnings; today, it's 28 times. Taxes take two per cent more today than they did in 1975. Housing affordability is not about one thing; it's about everything. That's why One Nation's policies are detailed and work together to restore opportunity for young Australians and all Australians.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="106" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.193.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" speakername="Carol Louise Brown" talktype="speech" time="18:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This motion brought on by the opposition today is quite laughable when, just three weeks ago, the coalition put $4.7 billion in proposed housing cuts on the table. They would abolish the Housing Australia Future Fund, scrap Help to Buy and the New Home Bonus Program and remove incentives for building more rental homes. That is their published policy. Senator Bragg should explain how taking away that support will help Australians find a home. Indeed, for most of the nine years the coalition were last in power, they didn't even have a housing minister. They built just 373 social and affordable homes over that entire period.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.193.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="interjection" time="18:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That's not true!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="466" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.193.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" speakername="Carol Louise Brown" talktype="continuation" time="18:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Now they come in here and try to convince us that they care, but actions speak louder than words, and no amount of shouting from Senator Bragg will change their record.</p><p>This is the thing about Senator Bragg; it's not a serious response. And Australians deserve a serious response.</p><p>Our $47 billion housing plan is about building more homes, giving renters a better deal and helping more Australians buy their first home. For too long, people bidding for the first time have competed against investors receiving tax concessions to buy another existing property. Our budget reforms to negative gearing and the capital gains tax are designed to give first home buyers a fairer chance and encourage investment in new housing. We know that when the coalition was in government they did nothing about this situation. They did nothing to help first home buyers try to get into the housing market.</p><p>From 1 July next year, eligible new builds will still qualify for negative gearing, and investments made before budget night will still be protected. If we're going to use the tax system to support housing investment, it makes sense to encourage investment that adds to the number of homes available. We're also tackling the deposit barrier directly. In the first year after we expanded the five per cent deposit scheme, more than 100,000 Australians used it to buy their home. I met one a few months ago who told me that he never really thought that he'd ever be able to get into his own home, a home that he has managed to purchase. He was so excited and so grateful for this scheme. All we have with Senator Bragg is that he comes in here and he is negative about the government's program, but he's not serious about having a real response to assist people who are looking for affordable housing, renters and people who are looking for their first home. The person I spoke to is one of 1,600 Tasmanians. Since Labor came to office, the scheme has helped more than 280,000 Australians, including those Tasmanians. For an eligible buyer, that means being able to buy with a deposit of as little as five per cent, without paying lender's mortgage insurance. It can mean getting into a home years sooner, rather than not getting into a home at all.</p><p>So I'd say to Senator Bragg and the coalition that they need to get serious about their housing policy. I'm not convinced that we'll ever see a coalition housing minister. We have to base their actions on what they did while they were in government and, as I've said, for most of those nine years, they didn't care enough to even have in the Australian parliament someone responsible for housing. I reject this&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="506" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.194.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" speakername="Barbara Pocock" talktype="speech" time="18:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We are living in a house price tornado. House prices have surged by more than 400 per cent nationwide since 1999, when changes to the capital gains tax discount were introduced. Through the 27 years of coalition government and Labor government, we've seen nothing but a rising disaster in house prices confront first home buyers trying desperately to get into the market. Over that 27 years, we have seen housing turn from being a roof over your head to something in your investment portfolio. Thank you, major parties! What a gift to the young people and to the generations ahead! What a disaster to present to them as they turn to the creation of their own homes and families.</p><p>Senator Bragg mentioned his concern about rent increases. If he's really worried about rent increases, let's have a look at the increase in rent from 2000, when it started at $150, to now, when rent is over $700 per week and the minimum wage is $1,000 a week. That's 70 per cent of your before-tax income to pay in rent, on average, across our nation. That's the gift of the major parties to those younger generations, especially those lower income households that don't have a parent as their banker and that have no-one to turn to for assistance to get into that market. Indeed, one in two of those 20- to 30-year-olds are living at home with their parents because they have no other option. They can't afford the rent and they can't get to a deposit.</p><p>In Adelaide, median house prices have increased from around $125,000 in September 1999 to nearly a million dollars right now. That is a 680 per cent increase. This is a brutal housing market&#x2014;and it is a market; it's not a roof over your head. It is not the human right that it should be. Yet the second we see house prices start to cool down&#x2014;as soon as prices for those luxury houses on the waterfront in the eastern suburbs of Sydney come back a bit and prices for those luxury houses in Melbourne start to turn around&#x2014;we're in a disaster. What a disaster! We hear from the banks endlessly. We hear from brokers and from property spruikers. What about listening to those young people who have been trying to accumulate their deposit? Every time six months goes by, they have to put forward another $30,000 to get to that deposit. The housing market is running ahead of them and is impossible to meet. There is incredible disappointment and deep depression in so many young people's households as they try to find their way to stable and secure housing.</p><p>If you are an investor, it's time we did see a cooling-off. It's time we did see investors step away from competition with first home buyers. It's time we saw those house prices that have gone up by 400 per cent come back a bit so that first home buyers have the beginnings of a shot of getting into their own homes.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="420" approximate_wordcount="712" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.195.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" speakername="Kerrynne Liddle" talktype="speech" time="18:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Everyone in this place should know that the first job of any government is to keep its citizens safe. What could be more urgent? Fundamental to keeping people safe is them having a roof over their heads. The evidence of Labor housing failure is both significant and alarming. This is urgent for the increasing numbers of men, women and children who are living in cars, living on the streets, in tents or couch surfing, not just because of a housing crisis but because of Labor's induced economic crisis. Those Australians are waiting, waiting and waiting for Labor to get its act together to do what it said it would do&#x2014;that is, not to hold Australians back nor leave them behind. Remember that? It's another broken Labor promise writ large in housing.</p><p>Labor's out-of-control spending is fuelling the cost-of-living crisis, the exorbitant rents and the higher mortgages and interest rates. You cannot bring 1.4 million people into Australia, as Labor has done in its term&#x2014;about the population of Adelaide&#x2014;and not have somewhere to house them. But that's what Labor did. It is urgent because homeowners cannot weather 17 mortgage interest rate rises, let alone more. It is urgent because a severe shortage of tradespeople will just add to the crisis. Walk into any pub, any shopping centre, any playground, anywhere there's people and they are not applauding Labor's outcome. Right now, as we speak, everyone is losing under the Albanese government&#x2014;renters, investors, first homeowners and owner occupiers.</p><p>The policy decisions made in Canberra have real consequences. Labor is overseeing a once-in-a-generation housing downturn that everyone except Labor saw coming as a consequence of the policies Labor is delivering. Auction clearance rates have dropped to 40 per cent, the lowest since COVID. The latest ABS lending data shows the total number of new home loans fell 15 per cent in the September quarter alone. This is a record decline. Labor is building around 30,000 fewer homes a year than the coalition did when in government. Now Labor's higher housing taxes are discouraging investment when Australia desperately needs more homes. Lending to owner occupiers was down by 5.3 per cent this quarter and, even worse, lending to first homebuyers fell by 8.6 per cent. Investor lending was smashed by more than 30 per cent compared to a year ago. The total number of new home loans is down by over 21 per cent. The number of loans to owner occupiers is down by 9.8 per cent and down by a massive 12.3 per cent for first homebuyers.</p><p>Labor's economic incompetence has pushed interest rates to their highest level since 2008, adding $33,000 a year to the average new mortgage. Who on earth can sustain that? Not the ordinary hardworking Australians Labor does not see, does not hear and does not believe. A rise in negative equity as house prices soften has particularly impacted first homeowners. We have the highest inflation and interest rates amongst comparative advanced economies, so the persistent failures we're experiencing cannot simply be dismissed as international affairs. The focus must instead be on Labor's failure.</p><p>The urgency of this issue was loud and clear at the Senate Economics References Committee inquiry into social housing, which I chair. The committee heard from Treasury that the Housing Australia Future Fund that we heard about before has delivered only 530 social and 1,080 affordable homes so far, and yet Labor claims there will be 40,000 new social and affordable homes across Australia by mid 2029. How is that believable? Officials could not say that they will deliver them. They said that is their target.</p><p>The Master Builders Association told the inquiry that it has become more difficult to deliver high volumes of new home building since the May 2026 federal budget, and it will only get worse. Labor's so-called tax reforms impacting negative gearing and capital gains tax and self-managed super funds have made it less attractive and more expensive to provide rental accommodation to the market, in turn putting greater pressure on social housing. As the committee heard from the Australian Institute of Architects, it was bad news too. The Australian dream is, for many, now a nightmare. The coalition will repeal Labor's housing taxes because Australians shouldn't pay for this incompetence. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.195.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="18:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion moved by Senator Bragg be agreed to. A division is required. It being after 6:30 pm, the division will be deferred until it suits the chamber, probably tomorrow.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.196.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.196.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
National Health and Medical Research Council </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="667" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.196.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="speech" time="18:36" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In respect of the National Health and Medical Research Council's annual report for 2025-26, I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the document.</p><p>This report notes that the National Health and Medical Research Council's ongoing review of the clinical practice guidelines for the care of trans and gender-diverse people under 18 with gender dysphoria. Just yesterday, as part of this review, the council released for public consultation its draft advice on the use of puberty suppressants in the care of trans and gender-diverse people aged under 18. The advice from the National Health and Medical Research Council reaffirms that puberty suppressants for young trans people remain a legitimate treatment option when clinically appropriate.</p><p>Importantly, the advice makes it clear that these decisions should be made by young people, their families and their treating clinicians and that they should be informed by medical advice and individual circumstances. That, colleagues, is exactly where these decisions belong. Where they don't belong is in the hands of people like us or in the hands of ministers and governments from states like Queensland. They don't belong in the parliament, they don't belong on the front pages of the Murdoch press and they certainly don't belong in the discretion of politicians who have developed an unhealthy, perverted obsession with the gender identities of children. These decisions belong in the hands of medical experts and in the hands of young people and their families. Governments should listen to the experts and follow the evidence, as the National Health and Medical Research Council has done, and that means that the Queensland and Northern Territory governments should immediately lift the bans that they have imposed on puberty suppressants in their public health systems. They should do that right now.</p><p>There's something particularly grotesque about a political movement that looks at the housing crisis, the cost of living, the climate crisis, the destruction of nature and the obscene concentration of wealth in this country and decides that the real problem we're all facing is transgender kids. The TERFs, the transphobes and their fellow travellers in the culture wars&#x2014;the ultra-right-wing media led by the <i>Australian</i>, a once-great newspaper that's now just a pamphlet&#x2014;have nothing to offer Australians who are struggling to pay the rent or put food on the table, and instead they manufacture enemies with a stale, reheated culture war campaign imported directly from the biggest losers in the world, the MAGA movement in the United States. When medical experts are telling us there are deeply personal clinical decisions requiring careful assessment, informed consent and ongoing medical supervision, the transphobes and the far-right culture warriors demand that the politicians intervene anyway. Apparently, the judgement of doctors, the wishes of families and the wellbeing of young people have to all be subordinated to the prejudices of people who spend their days unhealthily obsessing about young people's genitals.</p><p>Now, make no mistake, they know exactly what they're doing. They're perfectly happy to put kids into the firing line. They're perfectly happy to expose them to cruelty, to humiliation and to abuse, if it means another opportunity to distract from their own complete moral emptiness, the misery in their own lives and their failure to have solutions to the real problems facing this country. They should keep their grubby political hands off the health care of transgender children. These kids deserve care, they deserve compassion, and they deserve the best medical treatment and support. They do not deserve to have their lives turned into political footballs by a bunch of ideological zealots.</p><p>As we remember trans people whose lives have been lost to hatred and violence, we should be absolutely clear about where we stand. We stand with trans people here in the Greens. We stand with trans kids, with their families and with the medical professionals who care for them. And we stand against those who would sacrifice their safety for a vicious and cynical culture war.</p><p>I seek leave to continue my remarks.</p><p>Leave granted; debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.197.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.197.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Community Affairs Legislation Committee; Additional Information </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="39" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.197.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="18:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On behalf of the Chair of the Community Affairs Legislation Committee, Senator Whiteaker, I present additional information received by the committee on its inquiry into the National Disability Insurance Scheme Amendment (Securing the NDIS for Future Generations) Bill 2026.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.198.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Public Accounts and Audit Joint Committee; Report </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="23" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.198.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="18:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I present the <i>519th report of the Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit</i>, on the administration of the National Disability Insurance Scheme.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.199.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Public Works Joint Committee; Report </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.199.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="18:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I present the <i>Sixth </i><i>report of 2026 of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Works</i>.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.200.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Defence Joint Committee; Report </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="480" approximate_wordcount="1161" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.200.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="speech" time="18:43" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I present the advisory report of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Defence, on the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026 and move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the report.</p><p>On behalf of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Defence I do present this report, noting it's the first report to be tabled by this parliamentary joint committee. The bill before the committee was introduced to the parliament on 27 October 2026. The committee announced its inquiry into the bill on 29 October and invited submissions by 3 November. Whilst the committee recognises that this short inquiry timeframe limited the ability of interested parties to consider the bill in detail, the committee accepts the rationale for the need for Defence to be able to ensure Australia's military personnel, assets and activities are secure and to ensure that the ADF and the Department of Defence have the clear authority to respond to ongoing and persistent threats against Defence facilities and personnel.</p><p>The bill was presented to the parliament in the context of a significant transformation within both the ADF and the broader national security community, with the most recent <i>2026 </i><i>National defence strategy </i>describing Australia's strategic environment as 'deteriorating', marked by intensifying competition between the United States and the People's Republic of China. That same strategy warned the strategic risks and threats were intensifying and that the <i>National defence strategy</i> noted that technological advancements are rapidly changing the nature of warfare and competition between states, and that Australia must be prepared to meet these threats.</p><p>The committee understood from evidence received during the inquiry that current legislative arrangements constrain Defence's ability to appropriately respond to threats such as drone incursions which occurred over RAAF Base Williamtown in July and August this year. Across Australia these incursions pose a growing threat to defence bases, assets and personnel, with some 147 drone incursions being reported in 2024-25, more than double the 60 reported in 2023-24. The bill seeks to address these and other issues by instituting two key frameworks. The first is the Defence Capability Framework, which seeks to accelerate the delivery of Defence capability to allow Defence to keep pace with technological advancements and equip ADF personnel with the best equipment and capacities available. The second framework is the Defence Security Zone Framework, which will strengthen protections at defence bases, associated facilities and during military activities.</p><p>The committee's report acknowledges that Australia's military bases and training areas are more than simply places of work. They are key to the ADF's operational readiness and capability development, and they support ADF personnel, enable the sustainment of critical assets and increasingly accommodate and test advanced technologies and systems that contribute directly to Australia's national security. As the strategic environment deteriorates, the risks to critical platforms and facilities increase. Protecting military capabilities and facilities from interference, intrusion, espionage, sabotage and other threats is a necessary element of safeguarding Australia's security and national interests, and this becomes even more critical as Australia undertakes one of the most significant capability transformations in our military history with the AUKUS partnership that will shape and influence Australia's future defence planning for decades to come and requires Australia to be prepared for a new set of responsibilities.</p><p>The committee considers that careful implementation of the Defence Capability Framework and Defence Security Zone Framework will be critical to assuring the Australian community and defence industry that the significant powers set out in the bill will be used appropriately. On this basis, the committee has recommended that the bill be passed by the parliament. The committee, however, made a further five recommendations with particular focus on oversight and transparency, reflecting the powers given to the Minister for Defence and/or his or her delegates in this bill. This includes a recommendation that the minister adopt a practice of proactively providing this committee with details of any declaration that is not a legislative instrument at the same time as those details are provided to the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force. This recommendation will clarify and strengthen the committee's oversight role, including mandatory reporting on declarations that are non-legislative instruments. The committee has also recommended that annual reports of the Department of Defence include a list of declared defence security zones for each financial year, with the committee considering that the inclusion of this information in defence annual reports will represent a practical and proportionate mechanism for promoting transparency while supporting confidence in the administration of this legislative framework.</p><p>The committee has also recommended that it receive an update within 12 months on the implementation of both of these frameworks. Further, the committee recommends the proposed five-year independent review of the operation of the Defence Capability Framework be expanded to include an assessment and review of the Defence Security Zones Framework. This will ensure that both major elements of this bill are assessed to ensure they are fit for purpose in a changing strategic environment and allow for the examination of appropriate safeguards within both frameworks. The committee's final recommendation seeks clearer, more accessible and plain-language explanations from the Department of Defence on how legislative instruments will operate and how they might affect individuals, communities and other stakeholders.</p><p>In questions on notice answered by the Department of Defence, the committee also received further information on how Defence view the implementation of capability declarations, and importantly the committee heard the view from Defence that nonregistrable capability declarations, which would not be legislative instruments, were not intended to be routinely used. With respect to defence security zones, the committee was also advised by Defence of important safeguards in place in the legislation to protect rights of peaceful assembly, protest and industrial action.</p><p>The inquiry highlighted the importance of clear, timely and transparent communication by the Department of Defence with a broad range of stakeholders, and the committee is of the view that ongoing engagement and consultation from the Department of Defence will be critical to building public understanding and awareness of the new frameworks, addressing concerns as they arise and ensuring that the declaration and operation of defence security zones are appropriately implemented.</p><p>The work of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Defence examining the frameworks implemented by this bill will not end upon tabling or passage of the legislation. As the committee's report made clear, the bill, alongside the recommendations by the committee, if adopted, will provide the PJCD with expanded oversight functions to ensure proper oversight that guarantees that powers granted to Defence are, in the words of the report, 'being exercised appropriately, proportionately and consistent with the parliament's intent'.</p><p>On behalf of the committee, I wish to thank the individuals and organisations who contributed to this inquiry by making submissions and by appearing at the public hearing at short notice. This engagement has greatly assisted the committee during its consideration of the bill, and I commend the report to the Senate. I seek leave to continue my remarks later.</p><p>Leave granted; debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.201.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Education and Employment Legislation Committee, Intelligence and Security Joint Committee, Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee, Public Accounts and Audit Joint Committee; Government Response to Report </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="1080" approximate_wordcount="2160" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.201.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="18:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I present four government responses to committee reports as listed on item 15 on today's Order of Business. I seek leave to have the documents incorporated in <i>Hansard</i><i>.</i></p><p>Leave granted.</p><p> <i>The document</i> <i>s</i> <i> read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">Education and Employment Legislation Committee&#x2014;Government response</p><p class="italic">Dear President</p><p class="italic">I am writing to advise you that the Australian Government responded to additional recommendations contained in the Australian Greens' dissenting report and Senator David Pocock's minority report to the Senate Education and Employment Legislation Committee inquiry into the <i>Universities Accord (Opening the Doors of Opportunity) Bill 2026 </i>through debate in the Senate on 16 September 2026.</p><p class="italic">I have enclosed the relevant Hansard extract from 16 September 2026.</p><p class="italic">Yours sincerely</p><p class="italic">Jason Clare</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">Australian Government response to the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security Advisory report:</p><p class="italic">Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026</p><p class="italic">OCTOBER 2026</p><p class="italic">Mr HILL (Bruce&#x2014;Assistant Minister for Citizenship, Customs and Multicultural Affairs and Assistant Minister for International Education) (09:33): I present a replacement explanatory memorandum to the bill and a supplementary explanatory memorandum to the bill. I ask leave of the House to move government amendments</p><p class="italic">(1) to (25) as circulated together.</p><p class="italic">Leave granted.</p><p class="italic">Mr HILL: I move:</p><p class="italic">(1) Clause 2, page 2 (table item 2), omit the table item, substitute:</p><p class="italic">2. Schedule 1 1 July 2027. 1 July 2027</p><p class="italic">(2) Schedule 1, item 1, page 4 (line 12), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(3) Schedule 1, item 1, page 4 (line 14), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(4) Schedule 1, item 1, page 4 (line 22), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(5) Schedule 1, item 1, page 4 (line 25), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(6) Schedule 1, item 1, page 5 (after line 4), after subsection 77A(1), insert:</p><p class="italic">(1A) Before making the legislative instrument, the Minister must seek advice from the AUSTRAC CEO and must have regard to that advice.</p><p class="italic">(7) Schedule 1, item 1, page 5 (line 6), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(8) Schedule 1, item 1, page 5 (line 18), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(9) Schedule 1, item 1, page 5 (line 21), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(10) Schedule 1, item 1, page 6 (line 4), omit "making", substitute "Minister makes".</p><p class="italic">(11) Schedule 1, item 1, page 6 (line 5), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(12) Schedule 1, item 1, page 6 (lines 16 and 17), omit "the AUSTRAC CEO is not required to consult under subsection (1) if the AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "subsection (1) does not apply if the Minister".</p><p class="italic">(13) Schedule 1, item 1, page 6 (line 21), omit "comply with", substitute "have consulted the persons mentioned in".</p><p class="italic">(14) Schedule 1, item 1, page 6 (line 27), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(15) Schedule 1, item 1, page 6 (line 32), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(16) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (after line 7), at the end of section 77B, add:</p><p class="italic">(7) The explanatory statement (within the meaning of the <i>Legislation Act 2003</i>) for an instrument made under subsection 77A(1) must describe the consultation (if any) that the AUSTRAC CEO undertook under and in accordance with this section in relation to the instrument.</p><p class="italic">(17) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (line 12), omit "making", substitute "the Minister made".</p><p class="italic">(18) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (line 16), omit "making", substitute "the Minister made".</p><p class="italic">(19) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (line 22), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(20) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (line 25), omit "AUSTRAC CEO", substitute "Minister".</p><p class="italic">(21) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (line 26), omit "unless the AUSTRAC CEO:", substitute "unless:".</p><p class="italic">(22) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (line 27), before "is satisfied", insert "the Minister".</p><p class="italic">(23) Schedule 1, item 1, page 7 (line 29), before "has consulted", insert "the AUSTRAC CEO".</p><p class="italic">(24) Schedule 1, item 1, page 8 (line 10), omit "comply with", substitute "have consulted the persons mentioned in".</p><p class="italic">(25) Schedule 1, item 1, page 8 (after line 22), at the end of section 77D, add:</p><p class="italic">(7) The explanatory statement (within the meaning of the <i>Legislation Act 2003</i>) for an instrument made under subsection (1) must describe the consultation (if any) that the AUSTRAC CEO undertook under and in accordance with paragraph (2)(b) in relation to the instrument.</p><p class="italic">I'll just briefly explain the amendments to the House. In its advisory report on the bill published on 11 August 2026, the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security made seven recommendations, three of which, if accepted, as the government has, require amendments to the bill. In its advisory report, the committee recognised that the power in schedule 1 of the bill responds to a gap in the legislative framework but concluded that this power should be exercised by the responsible minister rather than the AUSTRAC CEO. The government has accepted that recommendation. The committee noted the consultation requirements and recommended that, to achieve a better parliamentary oversight of the exercise of these powers, the minister should publish details of what consultation was completed when making an instrument. The government has accepted this recommendation.</p><p class="italic">The committee further noted that the recent commencement of the AML/CTF obligations on 1 July introduced new compliance requirements. It recommended that delaying the start date of the proposed changes in the bill would help to reduce the regulatory burden and allow time for industry to understand the changes and get ready for its commencement. Therefore, in response to the PJCIS report, the government is moving amendments to the bill that reflect those recommendations.</p><p class="italic">Firstly, they will amend schedule 1 of the bill to give the minister responsible for the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006, rather than the AUSTRAC CEO, the power to restrict or prohibit reporting entities from using a product, service or delivery channel or thing&#x2014;the so-called high-risk mechanism</p><p class="italic">to provide a designated service. This responds to recommendation 1 of the PJCIS's advisory report.</p><p class="italic">Secondly, they will establish a requirement that the minister describe the consultation process that was undertaken in relation to the exercise of the high-risk mechanism power. This is in response to recommendation 3 of the committee's advisory report.</p><p class="italic">Finally, they will delay the commencement of schedule 1 and the power to restrict or prohibit high-risk mechanisms to 1 July 2027, and this responds to recommendation 6 of the committee advisory report.</p><p class="italic">Question agreed to.</p><p class="italic">Bill, as amended, agreed to.</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">Australian Government response to the Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee report:</p><p class="italic">Senate Inquiry into offshore processing and resettlement arrangements</p><p class="italic">NOVEMBER 2026</p><p class="italic">Recommendation 1: The committee recommends that, consistent with the recommendations of the Review of Integrity Concerns and Governance Arrangements for the Management of Regional Processing Administration by the Department of Home Affairs (Richardson Review), the Department of Home Affairs continue to implement and strengthen integrity and due diligence measures and enhancements to its integrity risk process and culture.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Government agrees to this recommendation.</p><p class="italic">In August 2024, the Department of Home Affairs (the Department) implemented an Integrity Culture Strategy (the Strategy) as part of its broader transformation agenda, supported by initiatives informed by the Australian Public Service Commission Integrity Taskforce's Louder than Words&#x2014;APS Integrity Action Plan. The Strategy continues to be shaped by lessons from the Richardson Review, the Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme, and the establishment of the National Anti-Corruption Commission. Supported by the Department's Integrity Framework, the Strategy promotes a strong integrity culture by embedding integrity considerations into daily decision-making and operations.</p><p class="italic">Following the release of the Commonwealth Integrity Strategy in December 2025, the Department reviewed the Strategy to ensure alignment with contemporary Commonwealth integrity guidance. The review confirmed strong alignment across the key themes of culture, systems and accountability.</p><p class="italic">In February 2025, the Department established a High-Risk High-Value Oversight Committee, chaired by the Chief Operating Officer and reporting to the Executive Board, to provide enhanced governance oversight of high-risk, high-value procurements and contracts. In addition, the Department's Procurement and Contract Management Framework and Due Diligence Better Practice Guide continue to play a critical role in supporting staff to undertake due diligence and ensure suppliers are genuine, capable and reliable, financially and commercially viable, and of good repute and integrity.</p><p class="italic">From a regional processing contract management perspective, following the Richardson Review, the Department implemented a standard operating procedure for subcontracting arrangements in Naoero, and reviewed and revised the standard operating procedure in June 2026 to further enhance due diligence processes.</p><p class="italic">The Department will continue to strengthen its integrity framework, culture and due diligence processes, consistent with the recommendations of the Richardson Review, and regularly review its approach to maintain alignment with evolving Commonwealth standards and expectations.</p><p class="italic">Recommendation 2: The committee recommends that the Department of Home Affairs consider making information on offshore processing contracting arrangements more publicly accessible, noting commercial-in-confidence considerations and other sensitivities.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Government agrees to this recommendation.</p><p class="italic">The Department publishes performance information relating to regional processing arrangements through its annual corporate reporting, including reporting against corporate plan targets.</p><p class="italic">Key contract information is published on AusTender, and any significant procurements are included in the Department's annual procurement plan.</p><p class="italic">The Department recognises the importance of transparency in government operations. All regional processing procurements are conducted in accordance with the Commonwealth Procurement Rules and departmental policies and procedures. At the same time, contracts with service providers contain confidentiality provisions that reflect the sensitivity of operational and bilateral arrangements, as well as commercial considerations.</p><p class="italic">As with all requests for information relating to regional processing and the contracts that support these operations, the Department will continue to balance transparency obligations with public interest considerations when determining whether information should be released.</p><p class="italic">Recommendation 3: The committee recommends that the Auditor-General give consideration to providing independent oversight of Australian government offshore processing and resettlement contractual arrangements by conducting regular audits to assess where these contracts are appropriately managed and represent value for money.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Government notes this recommendation.</p><p class="italic">As an independent officer of the Parliament, the Auditor-General determines the Australian National Audit Office's (ANAO's) work program independently. As such, responses to parliamentary committee recommendations directed to the ANAO are not included as part of the Government's response. The ANAO has provided a response directly to the Committee.</p><p class="italic">Recommendation 4: The committee recommends that the Australian Government fully implement Recommendation 3 of the Review of Integrity Concerns and Governance Arrangements for the Management of Regional Processing Administration by the Department of Home Affairs (Richardson Review) regarding the development of a protocol for the lawful and appropriate disclosure of law enforcement and intelligence information.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Government agrees to, and has completed, this recommendation.</p><p class="italic">The Department of Finance, in consultation with the Australian Federal Police (AFP), and the Office of National Intelligence (ONI) on behalf of the National Intelligence Community (NIC), has developed and distributed a protocol for lawfully sharing law enforcement and intelligence information with Commonwealth entities, to inform procurement and contracting decisions in high-risk environments.</p><p class="italic">Information on the protocol is available at: Guidance on law enforcement and intelligence information for Australian Government procuring entities I Department of Finance (https://www.finance.gov.au/government/procurement/buying-australian-government/guidance-law-enforcement-and-intelligence-information-australian-government-procuring-entities)</p><p class="italic">Dissenting report from Australian Greens</p><p class="italic">Recommendation 1: End third country resettlement arrangements and offshore processing, with Nauru and PNG and ensure refugees subjected to this system have a permanent home.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Government disagrees withthis recommendation.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Government is committed to maintaining a migration system that is robust, effective and in the national interest. It is a longstanding Australian Government policy that people who attempt to travel to Australia irregularly by sea will not settle in Australia. This approach has been instrumental in reducing dangerous irregular maritime ventures to Australia, deterring people smuggling operations and preventing loss of life at sea.</p><p class="italic">The third-country reception arrangement with the Republic of Naoero forms part of the Australian Government's response to the NZYQ decision. The arrangement provides a lawful removal and long-term residence pathway for eligible non-citizens who have no legal right to remain in Australia and who cannot be removed to their country of origin or another country.</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">Australian Government response to the Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit report</p><p class="italic">Report 488 Commonwealth Financial Statements 2019-20</p><p class="italic">OVERVIEW</p><p class="italic">On 31 March 2022, the Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit (the Committee) tabled Report 488&#x2014;Commonwealth Financial Statements 2019-20 (Report 488).</p><p class="italic">Report 488 made recommendations to Commonwealth entities, including one recommendation directed to the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, relevant to matters within the National Indigenous Australians Agency's portfolio responsibilities.</p><p class="italic">The Committee recommends that the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet investigate potential amendment to the Aboriginal Land Rights (Northern Territory) Act 1976 to accommodate for situations where payments cannot be distributed to traditional owners within the timeframe nominated due to the absence of identifiable traditional owners.</p><p class="italic">GOVERNMENT RESPONSE</p><p class="italic">The Government notes the recommendation. Given the passage of time since the report, the Government provides the following update:</p><p class="italic">In relation to the Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1976 (Cth), the Commonwealth works in consultation with the Northern Territory Land Councils.</p><p class="italic">The National Indigenous Australians Agency meets regularly with the sector.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.202.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DELEGATION REPORTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.202.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Australian Parliamentary Delegation to 46th ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Assembly </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="27" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.202.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="18:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I present the report of the Australian parliamentary delegation to the 46th ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Assembly, Malaysia, which took place from 16 September to 22 September 2026.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.203.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
MINISTERIAL STATEMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.203.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Environment </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="2039" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.203.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="18:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;Deputy President, you and I are two of the millions of Australians who are proud to be stewards of this incredible country we call home. We're blessed with amazing terrestrial and marine environments all around us, and we share it with plants and animals that, in many cases, don't exist anywhere else in the world. For most Australians, living in such a beautiful place imbues a sense of responsibility to care for it.</p><p>As we are hearing very strongly at COP this week, there is an increasing need for global action on climate change and for protecting our environment. At a time of global uncertainty and major challenges, Australia's task as president of the COP31 negotiations is to try to bring more than 190 countries together and build agreement on practical climate action that benefits people and communities around the world. Participating in, and this year leading those efforts, is unquestionably in Australia's national interest because whether we're talking climate change, pollution, invasive pests and diseases, what happens somewhere else in the world does eventually impact our region and our island nation.</p><p>Australia's supply of food and water, our health and wellbeing, our employment and industries, and our national security all rely on a healthy and sustainable environment. That's why Australia doesn't shy away from using our voice on the international stage to call for change. We lead by example on environmental issues. We foster cooperation between countries, and we put our money where our mouth is when it comes to taking action. We know there is still more to do in our own backyard, but, as we continue to grow our efforts, hopefully our achievements to date can help guide other countries to see what is possible down the path.</p><p>Ocean health is one clear area where every country needs to do its part, but we all need to work together to solve the issues that plague our marine environment. Australia is proud to be an ocean leader. Our beaches and oceans are truly world-class. East to west, north to south, we are home to a unique and precious array of marine life. The Great Barrier Reef is often held up as an example of the pressure that coral reefs are under globally from climate change and other threats. That pressure is real, but we can be proud of the fact that the reef is one of the best managed coral reefs in the world. Our government, along with successive Queensland governments, have invested heavily in the future of the reef and the 77,000 jobs that rely on it. This year, it was very pleasing to see the World Heritage Committee in Busan acknowledge our progress on climate action, water quality, land clearing, sustainable fisheries, involvement of traditional owners and crown-of-thorns starfish control.</p><p>As well as our ongoing investment in the reef, Australia has made other exciting leaps in ocean conservation in 2026. This year, we ratified the High Seas Biodiversity Treaty. This means Australia joins over 100 countries from around the world in a landmark framework for global ocean governance, protecting areas outside of national jurisdiction. Australian marine parks now cover 52 per cent of our ocean, and we're now focused on increasing high levels of protection from around 24 per cent to 30 per cent by 2030 through the expansion of marine-protected areas around Lord Howe and Norfolk islands.</p><p>Recently, we released Australia's first ever Sustainable Ocean Plan. This has brought together governments and interest groups with a written shared direction for our ocean. We're advocating for the connection between the world's ocean and climate change to be prioritised at this year's COP31 and also putting forward the protection of the ocean as a pillar of Australia's United Nations Security Council campaign, because we believe that protecting the ocean, addressing climate security and upholding the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea are fundamental to preserving peace, security and prosperity for future generations.</p><p>We're working with our Indo-Pacific neighbours, including Indonesia, Papua New Guinea and Timor-Leste, to tackle shared challenges, such as declining ocean health and ghost nets, which can continue to trap and kill marine creatures while undermining the livelihoods and wellbeing of coastal communities. We also continue to lobby for global plastics action, pushing for a legally binding global plastics treaty that addresses pollution. And we are helping Pacific nations reduce single-use plastics through investment in the Pacific Ocean Litter Project.</p><p>We know there's still more work to be done on plastics and recycling here in Australia as well. In September, Australia's federal, state and territory environment ministers agreed to a circular economy roadmap creating national priorities through to 2035 and nailing down national consistency on hard-to-recycle products. The Albanese government also continues to work with state, territory and local governments to improve access to recycling facilities, boost demand and harmonise systems across the country. We know Australians and particularly the recycling industry want to see more action from their federal government in this space, and we will continue to work with them on that.</p><p>When I stood before the Senate to deliver my first annual statement last year, H5 bird flu was a disease ravaging every continent, bar Australia. It appears we escaped the inevitable for as long as possible, and, now, as it reaches our shores through migratory species, we've benefited from international experience and are well prepared. We've adopted a coordinated one-health approach, recognising that the health of our people, our animals and our environment is inextricably linked. This approach has involved working with state and territory governments, First Nations groups, communities, conservation organisations and industry. To date, the Albanese government has committed more than $270 million to H5 bird flu surveillance, preparedness and response measures. We've been investing in population resilience for our most at risk native species so they're in a stronger position to withstand and recover from the impacts, and we're already seeing tangible benefits: sea lion pups in South Australia treated for hookworm are healthier, and sooty terns returned to Willis Island, in the Coral Sea Marine Park, began nesting within 24 hours after rapid weed removal. These outcomes are complemented by what we believe is the world's most ambitious targeted vaccination program for priority native bird species, a program guided by Australia's leading national risk assessment to focus action where it's needed most. We'll keep working across governments to ensure our bird and mammal species are as resilient as possible.</p><p>At this time last year, our government was also still making the case for EPBC Act reform. Since then, we have secured the passage of the most significant reforms to Australia's national environmental laws in more than two decades. Today, a fundamentally redesigned environmental framework is in place, led by Australia's first ever National Environmental Protection Agency, delivering stronger environmental protections and faster, more predictable project assessments and approvals. Within the last financial year, there's been a five per cent boost to the number of on-time decisions made under the EPBC Act. Ninety-three per cent of statutory decisions were made on time, a far cry from when the coalition government delivered just six per cent of project approvals on time.</p><p>The Office of Impact Analysis noted our reforms could deliver potential median savings for businesses of between $3 billion and $7 billion per year, based on reduced delays, duplication and regulatory costs. Of course, that's leaving aside some of the major environmental gains that will result from these reforms, including a new legislated definition of what is an unacceptable impact on the environment and also requiring environmental offsets to deliver a net gain for the environment rather than the previous no net loss requirement. As I speak, the new framework is being implemented across Australia. We're consulting stakeholders on the detailed settings and giving proponents and decision-makers time to prepare for the changes.</p><p>This speech would be hours long if I covered off every important piece of environmental work achieved in the past 12 months. While I'm incredibly proud of the work of my department and our project partners, to benefit the chamber, I'll keep it brief and mention just a few more. We've now hit 25 per cent of Australia's landmass being protected, with an extra five million hectares added since my last statement, helping safeguard vital habitat for some of Australia's threatened species. We continue to conserve more land through nationally agreed strategies like the Nature Repair Market, the Australian Bushland Program and the Protecting Important Biodiversity Areas Program and by expanding Indigenous protected areas. We're making sure First Nations voices are heard on water policy, on parks and land management and on cultural heritage reform. We're working steadfastly and collaboratively to protect Australia's unique plants and animals from threats like bird flu, as I mentioned, but also invasive species, climate change, natural disasters and overdevelopment, including through our Urban Rivers and Catchments Program and Saving Native Species program.</p><p>We recognise the ongoing environmental pressure on the Murray-Darling Basin, listing the Lower Murray and Macquarie Marshes ecosystems as critically endangered, and we're making progress on a plan for Australia's most precious resource&#x2014;water&#x2014;by improving accessibility, building more water-efficient infrastructure, investing in environmental water and reviewing the Water Act and the Murray-Darling Basin Plan so they're fit for purpose. Australia continues to be a leader in Antarctic and Southern Ocean science. We continue to learn more about the region through the Million Year Ice Core project, our recent research and environmental management expeditions to Heard Island and McDonald Islands, and the construction of the new Southern Ocean Research Aquarium in Hobart.</p><p>We've also hosted a number of significant international events in the last 12 months, using our voice to advocate for the environment, including the 70th International Whaling Commission meeting in Hobart, the recent meeting of the Commission for the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources also in Hobart and the pre-COP meeting that we were pleased to co-host in Fiji. This year we expanded recognition of nationally and internationally significant heritage sites to protect them for the future, including the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras parade route and World Heritage nominations for the Flinders Ranges and the Melbourne and Broken Hill trades halls.</p><p>But, for all this progress, make no mistake: Australia's natural environment is still facing many challenges in the world today, both natural and human made. Any honest assessment of our environment must acknowledge the pressure nature is under. The latest <i>State of the </i><i>environment</i> report, published in 2021, found that overall conditions were 'poor and deteriorating as a result of increasing pressures from climate change, habitat loss, invasive species, pollution and resource extraction'. The report also found that the multiple stresses were causing 'cumulative impacts' and Australia had experienced 'abrupt changes in ecological systems' since 2016. The Albanese government is working hard and investing in targeted species programs, habitat restoration and land protection programs, environmental water and First Nations led management, which have maintained or improved conditions in a range of areas. We're supporting Australia's transition to renewables, delivering ambitious but achievable net zero targets and holding companies to account through our strengthened safeguard mechanism. But these challenges show why more action is needed, and that's exactly what the Albanese government is doing.</p><p>Success relies on the collective efforts of governments, environmental groups, scientists and researchers, philanthropists, private landholders and local communities to take meaningful steps towards restoring and protecting Australia's biodiversity, because nature is in the best hands when governments, industry and community work together towards the same goal. When up to 90 per cent of Australia's threatened species are wholly or partly found on private land, it's critical we work with everyone who uses land or ocean and everyone who owns it to protect it. We must embrace new science and new technology to monitor and learn about what is happening to nature, and we must keep talking and sharing what we know so that our country's natural environment can thrive well into the future. Sadly, not all share our commitment to protecting Australia's natural environment. We cannot take our progress for granted. We must keep fighting for those without a voice. We owe it to future generations to get this right.</p><p>I now table the statement.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.204.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.204.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Australian Law Reform Commission </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="24" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.204.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="19:07" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On behalf of the Attorney-General, I table the summary and final reports of the Australian Law Reform Commission on its review of surrogacy laws.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.205.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Senate Estimates: Questions on Notice; Tabling </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.205.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="19:07" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I table a document relating to an order for the production of documents concerning unanswered estimates questions on notice.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.206.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.206.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Economics References Committee; Reference </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="840" approximate_wordcount="1797" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.206.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="speech" time="19:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the following matter be referred to the Economics References Committee for inquiry and report by 18 November 2027:</p><p class="italic">Foreign currency loans (FCLs) issued by Australian banks, with particular reference to:</p><p class="italic">(a) the issuance of FCLs in the 1980s;</p><p class="italic">(b) the economic and consumer basis for FCLs;</p><p class="italic">(c) the governance of FCLs by Australian banks;</p><p class="italic">(d) responses to any complaints relating to FCLs;</p><p class="italic">(e) compensation arrangements;</p><p class="italic">(f) any outstanding claims for compensation;</p><p class="italic">(g) historical laws governing FCLs and their enforcement;</p><p class="italic">(h) law reform opportunities; and</p><p class="italic">(i) any other related matters.</p><p>Foreign currency loans were a significant issue in the 1980s, when they were issued to people, often farmers or small-business people, on a basis that they could never understand but also potentially on a basis upon which they could never actually win or benefit from the financial transaction that was undertaken. These loans were issued by banks all around Australia in the eighties, and this was done on a large scale. There were as many as 5,000 of these loans, ranging from a quarter of a million dollars to as much as $4 million. The point of these foreign currency loans is that they were pegged to other currencies, so the Australian dollar was linked to the Swiss franc or to the Japanese yen. What happened is that a lot of people were very badly damaged financially and psychologically. It was a very ugly chapter in the Australian financial services history.</p><p>It was the subject of a significant parliamentary inquiry which was established during the Hawke government but reported just at the end of the Hawke government, before the Keating government was to be consummated in December 1991. The House of Representatives committee which looked at these matters, the Martin inquiry, made effectively a number of structural recommendations to the financial sector. It didn't recommend compensation. It did recommend that there be mediation undertaken by the banks. But it made structural recommendations, and it made recommendations that were later adopted by the Wallis inquiry, including prudential regulation and stronger disclosure regimes and the like. For example, the Martin inquiry recommended that the RBA at the time, in 1991, be granted stronger authority over banking supervision, but it was the Wallis inquiry in 1997 which led to the creation of the twin-peaks framework in APRA and ASIC as we know it today and enhanced prudential supervision but also supposedly enhanced consumer protection rules.</p><p>That is where the Martin inquiry got to. It gave you structural recommendations but also a proposal that the banks should deal with mediation. It didn't really deal with the issue at hand in many of the cases, which is the reason I'm talking about it today, because the inquiries that went after the Martin inquiry were not parliamentary inquiries but were financial system inquiries. We had the Wallis inquiry and the David Murray inquiry, and we also had the Hayne royal commission into banking. All of these things which were related to foreign currency loans were not substantively considered in these bigger inquiries, so the Martin inquiry of 1990, reporting in 1991, was really the only serious attempt, from a parliamentary sense or from an executive sense, of investigating these matters.</p><p>What has happened in the years after the Martin inquiry has been the emergence of a lot of new evidence that there was significant wrongdoing inside the banks. We've all now lived through a lot of bank scandals. We've lived through the financial advice scandals. In recent months, we've lived through the failure of the banks to link mortgage offset accounts to mortgages. We've had a situation where people are not actually benefiting from those offsets that they have in their own name against their mortgage. So I think today is frankly a very different environment to what we saw in the early nineties, where we've seen a complete collapse in trust in the banks. The banks operate with extraordinary licence from this parliament and extraordinary protection, whether it be the four pillars or the deposit guarantee or all the other instruments which protect their market position&#x2014;I would say unfairly. Ultimately, anyone who thinks that we owe the banks a favour needs to have their head read. We have a pretty sick and sclerotic economy, where the banks are a big part of this.</p><p>I make these points because, if you look back at the 1991 effort to investigate these things, it was to me not really a genuine and comprehensive attempt to try and address all the different elements of wrongdoing. Of course, the parliament and the system of committees is not a court. There were, through the judicial branch, many cases of the 5,000 foreign currency loans, many of which were progressed to the point where the people who were wronged were satisfied. There was the emergence of the Westpac letters, which led to the Westpac executives having to offer all sorts of different apologies and public statements. Different banks treated them differently. The fact is that there wasn't the Australian financial complaints tribunal that we have today, which has been established after years and years of bank wrongdoing being exposed. Today, for better or worse, there is at least a funnel and a pipeline where people who have been wronged by these institutions can go and have things properly dealt with as they would by an ombudsman. But back then we had a parliamentary inquiry say, 'Basically, you're on your own. We hope the banks might do some mediation. They may. We're just going to talk about some things that should change in the future.'</p><p>Now, that's not really good enough when up to 5,000 of these loans were issued, where the evidence I'd say that has emerged in the years since is that the people who were given these loans were in no position to understand their complexity. They may not have actually been on the hook themselves legally. It may have been the banks that were responsible for making up the differences in the payments that were due because of changes in the currency.</p><p>The point of this inquiry is to consider all of the new information that has come forward. Professor Evan Jones from the University of Sydney has published forms of correspondence from people who worked inside these banks in years gone by, including a John McLennan, who was an adviser to foreign currency borrowers, who said:</p><p class="italic">I have attended many of the cases heard before the court and frankly, I am disgusted at the tactics used by the Bank's counsel. It appears the whole circus is run for the benefit of the Legal profession with little or no interest in the real legal issues. I sat through one session in Spice -v- Westpac where the Bank's counsel &#x2026; cross examined Mr Spice for four hours over the meaning of a pencil line drawn across a page in his diary.</p><p>There have been letters and correspondence from former Commonwealth Bank officials like Mr Hilton Wood that have exposed the internal culture of the banks in the eighties and the existence of documents and letters that were in some cases not made available in the judicial processes. It was also not possible for the parliamentary inquiry of 1990-91 to consider them.</p><p>I make the point again that I understand that the parliament is not a court. Again, I understand the parliamentary committees are not there to run a judicial process. I understand that. But I think it is a reasonable expectation that there's no time limit that can be put in place here. If people have been wrongly treated in a way where they have lost their financial health, their physical health, their psychological health, we should never give up on trying to get justice for them in a country where, if you undertake a business deal, you should be doing it on the basis that the other person is doing the right thing and acting in good faith.</p><p>As has now been made quite clear, there is a large treasure trove of documents which exist within these banks and have been made available since 1991, which does give cause for us to reconsider the fate of these foreign currency loans and the impact on the borrowers. I don't think we owe the banks a favour here. I think we need to look very carefully at their activities, and I don't think we should be prepared to give up on things just because of the passage of time. As I say, the Martin inquiry could have done more to look at the impacts on these people. Not all the court cases necessarily delivered a reasonable outcome for all of these people.</p><p>This is an opportunity now for this Senate to consider the new information that has come to light, to try and deliver justice for the people who were wronged. There may be up to 500 of them that were never properly compensated or dealt with out of the original 5,000 loans&#x2014;so as many as 10 per cent. This is an opportunity to look at the historical culture of these institutions that still have great power in our society today. It's an opportunity for us to consider whether the past parliamentary inquiries actually did what they were supposed to do. It is an opportunity for us to again consider whether the regulatory arrangements, as put in place pretty much after the Wallis inquiry of 1997, are still fit for purpose in relation to these matters, and for us to try and give people the peace of mind that they deserve&#x2014;that we live in a country where, if you are dealing with a major institution, where there is a major power imbalance, the country will take care of you and protect you if the wrong thing has happened. We don't want to have a country where people feel that they can get ripped off and there are no consequences. That's not the sort of country we've ever had.</p><p>I'm very much keen for the Senate to support this inquiry, so that we can properly investigate these matters and provide peace of mind in a thorough way, some 40 years after the fact. I'd make the point that it doesn't matter how much time has passed; we will never give up on getting the best possible outcome&#x2014;and, indeed, justice&#x2014;for people who have been done over by the strongest people in our society. After all, it's the mark of a good society that it is able to protect the people that are not strong, who can be vulnerable to being damaged by great power. That has always been the way that we've run this country, and I don't think that should change now in 2026.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.207.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.207.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7516" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7516">Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="37" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.207.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="speech" time="19:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The committee is considering the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 and amendments (1) to (3) on sheet 4133 as moved by Senator Shoebridge.</p><p class="italic">
  <i>(Quorum formed)</i>
</p><p>The TEMPORARY CHAIR: Senator Shoebridge, are you seeking leave?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="113" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.207.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="19:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thought it might be convenient to the chamber, otherwise we would have to go on to another bill with three minutes. But I'm more than happy to have leave denied and have the vote.</p><p>The TEMPORARY CHAIR: Leave is not granted. The question before the chamber is that amendments (1) to (3) on sheet 4133, as moved by Senator Shoebridge, be agreed to. A division is required. It being after 6.30 pm, this will be a deferred division. The bill cannot proceed until a vote can be taken.</p><p>Progress reported.</p><p>Further consideration of the bill in Committee of the Whole made an order of the day for the next day of sitting.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.208.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7527" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7527">Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.208.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="speech" time="19:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Grogan, are you seeking the call?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="18" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.208.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="interjection" time="19:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It may suit the chamber, if everyone is in agreement, to move to adjournment a few moments early.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.208.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="interjection" time="19:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Are you seeking to move that the Senate&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.208.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="interjection" time="19:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm merely expressing to you that it may be for the convenience of the chamber, given that there is approximately one minute left to go.</p><p>There's nothing wrong with me suggesting it, Senator Shoebridge.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="38" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.208.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="interjection" time="19:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question before the chamber is that the second reading amendment, as moved by Senator Shoebridge, be agreed to. A division is required. It being after 6.30 pm, the division will be deferred. The debate is adjourned accordingly.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.209.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
ADJOURNMENT </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.209.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Tasmania: Small Business </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="736" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.209.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" speakername="Tammy Tyrrell" talktype="speech" time="19:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Last week I attended an event led by the Council of Small Business Organisations Australia. The Small Business Growth Academy event was all about how small business in Hobart can come together to learn and uplift each other to be even more amazing human beings. It was really cool to see all the clever and quirky people that came together and hopefully took away lots of useful tips and tricks to make their small businesses just that little bit better, like Bett Gallery. Carol has owned the gallery for over 40 years, and still runs it, and has sold pieces to collectors and institutions all over the world. Her children both work there and will take over the family business one day, but apparently Carol will never willingly retire. Her passion for art runs too deep and she has far too much fun in the gallery.</p><p>Or how about Matilda Rose, the founder of Wild Island Collective, telling positive stories about Tasmania and focusing on kindness. She shares positive stories, visits wild places and celebrates creativity. Matilda offers a way for people who may not be able to go out exploring to do so virtually, enjoying some of the places she visits and people she meets through live streams, photographs and videos. Her business is new and growing, and that's what small businesses should be about, figuring out what works and what you bring to Tasmania.</p><p>It's small businesses like these that are the heart of our local communities. One of my favourite parts of this job is going out across the state and seeing the new businesses set up and meeting the people that make it happen. We have about 43,000 small businesses in Tassie. That's 43,000 stories worth sharing, but I don't think I have quite enough time for that tonight. More than half of small business owners in Tassie are aged&#x2014;like me&#x2014;over 50. In fact, I recently found out that small businesses make up almost 97 per cent of all Tasmanian businesses. Together, they're actually the strong workhorse majority in our little state, not the big corporate giants.</p><p>It's great to see that nationally there are more than 180,000 additional small businesses since July '22. And despite what the media might pump out, small businesses are growing in Tasmania. Tasmania added a net 850 new businesses last year. Tasmania was also recently ranked the only state with both positive business confidence and business conditions. Our exports continue to grow to record levels, but we all know that global events are causing higher global inflation, slower global growth and extreme economic uncertainty at home and abroad. Small businesses are feeling these impacts directly as they tackle rising costs, supply chain pressures and slowing growth in consumer spending. That's why the Labor government is investing over $3.8 billion in new measures that deliver business tax relief to support resilience, investment and growth. Key measures include: making the $20,000 instant asset write-off permanent; introducing the new working Australians tax offset, which will provide an ongoing annual tax cut for over 13 million Australians, including sole traders; enabling small businesses to use current-year tax losses to claim a refund for the tax they paid in the prior two income years; and introducing loss refundability to support startups to invest and grow in their first two years of operation.</p><p>We're also supporting small businesses to use digital tools to improve efficiency and cut costs through the Digital Solutions program. I also want to point out we're legislating a digital duty of care, and this will help small businesses not harm them. It will build safety into digital platforms from the start and provide dispute resolution options for you when problems might arise, like if you accidentally or incorrectly0have been deplatformed, which I know is a real problem for small businesses at the moment.</p><p>But apart from government support, I think it's so great to see events like COSBOA growth academy that give you access to new skills, resources and, maybe most importantly, access to a network of other passionate and clever people. With our small business community scattered across the state, it's even more important that we have events to bring the community together to learn from each other. It's so important to me that we keep listening to the small-business community and do whatever we can to encourage more jobs and better wages for everyone in Tassie.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.210.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Social Cohesion </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="752" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.210.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="19:34" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On 21 October, I was so grateful to join ICSOA's interfaith and social cohesion event titled 'Multiculturalism&#x2014;Strengthening Australia's Future Through Unity, Inclusion and Shared Values' at the New South Wales parliament. This year's event was especially significant as it was organised through an historic collaboration between the Indian Crescent Society of Australia and Hindus for Human Rights, two organisations for which I have immense respect. It was especially heartening to see the room filled with representatives and devotees of a diversity of other faiths too&#x2014;Christian, Sikh and Jewish amongst them. I understand from the organisers that this collaboration marked an historic first for Australia's oldest parliament because the same night also celebrated Diwali. Together, the occasions saw two organisations representing the Muslim and Hindu communities coming together to jointly contribute to events promoting interfaith understanding, multiculturalism and social cohesion. It was a powerful demonstration that through linking our diverse religious and cultural traditions we can unite around shared values, we can celebrate tolerance and diversity, and we can work together to strengthen Australia's future. To both Hindus for Human Rights and the Indian Crescent Society of Australia and to all those who attended: thank you so much for filling us with faith and hope for a better future.</p><p>I wish to acknowledge the Federation of Hazara Councils of Australia and its national symposium on Hazara genocide that took place at Australian Parliament House, our place, on 25 November under the theme 'From Commemoration to Recognition'. For generations, Hazaras have experienced persecution, discrimination and targeted violence. Today, serious human rights concerns also affect other ethnic and religious minorities in Afghanistan. The return of the Taliban has been horrific for so many. The federation has actively raised these concerns through United Nations forums, international advocacy, engagement with Australian parliamentarians and community initiatives across the country.</p><p>We have also seen important parliamentary progress in states across the country. On 15 October 2026, the New South Wales upper house passed a motion recognising the historic Hazara genocide and designating 25 September as Hazara Black Day. I commend all of those in the New South Wales upper house, my former workplace, who came from across politics&#x2014;Greens and Labor and others&#x2014;to pass that motion and to designate 25 September. In South Australia too, I understand there are steps that I hope will see a motion passed before the end of the year. Again, I hope to see that historic stepping across the chamber, and I commend my Greens colleagues for taking action in that space. I also commend the federation for its continued advocacy and its efforts to bring these important issues to the attention of the Australian parliament. I say on behalf of my party to all the members of the Hazara community across this country you have our support, you have our solidarity and we recognise the historical truths that you're bringing to parliaments.</p><p>On the Saturday just passed, 14 November, I joined hundreds of people in Warwick Farm in Western Sydney for the 18th Australian Muslim Achievement Awards. These awards are hosted by Mission of Hope, which was founded by Dr Hanan Dover. Stopping there, Dr Hanan Dover is perhaps one of the hardest working, most tireless community activists I have ever seen. The work that she and others and the volunteers around her did to bring the 18th awards to Warwick Farm and to celebrate so many achievements is absolutely extraordinary. For nearly two decades, they have shone a light on the incredible achievements of Muslim Australians, who give so much to this country, often with little recognition from those in this place. It's important we recognise it.</p><p>The finalists included doctors, teachers, youth workers, artists and volunteers&#x2014;those who turn up for their communities week after week. On Saturday night, I was deeply honoured to receive the Abyssinian of the Year Award at the 2026 Muslim Achievement Awards. The award takes its name from the actions of a Christian ruler of Abyssinia known as Negus, who offered refuge to Muslims fleeing persecutions in one of the earliest recorded acts of interfaith support. It was humbling, but I say to the Muslim community and I say to Dr Hanan Dover and all of those at the night I feel we owe so much to the Muslim community, who teach us these truths about history and who came together as they did again to celebrate their commitment to Australia, their collective achievements and all of the work they do to make this country so much better.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.211.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
AUKUS </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="770" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.211.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="speech" time="19:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Acting Deputy President, it is good to see you in the chair. Earlier this month, the so-called independent public inquiry into AUKUS delivered its report. It proved the point that I had already made in this chamber a few months ago&#x2014;that vague questions and concerns are not constructive and that, if you oppose a plan, you owe Australians an alternative. I was in Tokyo at the time, leading a delegation of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, and, back home, a report landed calling on Australia to walk away from the most important defence commitment that we have made in a generation. Serious people can disagree on AUKUS, but a serious argument must meet its own standards, and this report simply does not.</p><p>Let's start with the word 'independent'. The inquiry was coordinated by the Australian Peace and Security Forum. Its secretariat was headed by one of the forum's founding members, a former chief of the Defence Force and a former member of this chamber, a former senator. Both had campaigned against AUKUS long before the inquiry began. Four of the five commissioners had publicly criticised AUKUS, and the fifth co-leads the Australia Institute, which clearly has been campaigning against it for some time. This clearly is not an independent inquiry. Let's also consider the evidence that was heard before the inquiry. Three weeks before the first hearing, a group of Australians gathered at the Chinese consulate in Melbourne to praise the study tours that they undertook recently in China. According to the Chinese state media that reported, they gave the trips 10 out of 10. Wow! The tours were organised by an adviser to a Chinese provincial government. Three members of that group then gave evidence to this so-called independent inquiry arguing against AUKUS, with one suggesting that AUKUS was a product of foreign interference. Can you believe it?</p><p>Australians rightly have a question front and centre of their minds: who paid for these tours? Australians deserve to know. None of this is a defence of our sovereignty. In fact, it is an insult to it. Meanwhile, the inquiry heard from a former Labor defence minister who went on to serve as an ambassador to Washington and in fact a leader of the Labor Party. We also had a former department secretary and two former Liberal defence ministers appear. Between them, they carried decades of experience at the highest level of government from both sides of politics. In the 113 pages of that report, each is quoted just once. The report claims that our Navy could be forced to act on Washington's orders. It never explains how an Australian submarine with an Australian crew and an Australian commander would stop answering to Australia. It also claims to be worried about nuclear risk, yet it would abolish the very regulator that would be responsible for nuclear safety in this country. Let me be clear once again: a nuclear-powered submarine is not a nuclear-armed submarine. The report demands a plan B and then says choosing one is beyond its scope. What a cop-out! It ignores the 68 per cent of Australians who, according to the Lowy Institute, support acquiring these very submarines.</p><p>But what troubles me the most is what the report leaves out. The word 'deterrence' does not appear anywhere in the findings. Deterrence is the whole bloody point. These submarines exist to ensure that no-one is ever tempted to test us or our partners or our allies or friends. We are an island trading nation. Our fuel, our exports and our way of life all travel by sea, and, beneath the sea, around 99 per cent of our internet traffic runs through just 15 cables. So, if we walk away, who's going to protect these cables? As I said in June, nuclear-powered submarines are the boltcutters that ensure that Australia is never wrapped in chains. Nothing in this report changes that. AUKUS followed years of submarine programs that were started, changed and abandoned. If we walk away now without a plan, we leave a massive gap in our defences in the 2030s. We also send a message to every partner that Australia's word comes with a use-by date. So let us continue scrutinising this program on costs, workforce and delivery. That is our job, and we must keep doing it. But Australians deserve a debate that is honest about the threats that we face. This report preaches transparency but does not practice it, demands answers but refuses to provide them and claims independence it cannot show. AUKUS remains the right plan for the security of our country.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.212.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Victorian State Election, Donations to Political Parties </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="756" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.212.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="speech" time="19:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Victorian Labor is the party of privatisation. After 12 years in government, they have sold off just about everything that Jeff Kennett and the Liberals left behind: the Port of Melbourne, public housing, the land titles office and VicRoads. And now they've got their sights on Melbourne Water. Apparently nothing in Victoria is too important to flog off to the highest bidder, not even our drinking water. And what a fantastic deal Victorians have gotten&#x2014;roads riddled with potholes, exorbitant tolls just to sit in traffic, public housing demolished and communities in Melbourne's west crying out for hospitals and health care. Instead, they're getting fast tracked AI data centres.</p><p>Labor has spent 12 years selling off the things Victorians own, and somehow we've ended up paying more for everything. Housing, groceries, transport, energy&#x2014;everything is getting more expensive while wages stagnate. Meanwhile, we've got corporations making a killing off assets that used to belong to all of us, and Labor has the audacity to tell Victorians that there's no money left for the services that they need. Well, of course there is no money left. You have sold off all of the bloody revenue. Is it any wonder that people are turning their backs on the major parties?</p><p>At this election, Victorians have a choice: more of the same from Labor and the Liberals, the corporate parties, or a government that actually puts people ahead of corporate profits. The Greens have got a plan to bring down costs and make life better for Victorians, and that includes publicly owned supermarkets to bring down grocery prices, double the public housing, capped rents and free and frequent public transport. These are the things we should all rely on as being for the public good, not for private profit. This election, a vote for the Greens is a vote for putting people before corporate profits in Victoria, and the choice is in those voters' hands.</p><p>If you've ever wondered how much it costs to buy access to Australia's political elite, well, I've got news. There is something for every budget&#x2014;every budget, that is, if you are a corporate lobbyist. Here's a round-up of this year's corporate capture. First up: shopping with Labor. For a cool $10,000 a head, you could have enjoyed dinner with the Prime Minister at the private mansion of Fortescue executive Mark Barnaba. Nothing says 'party of the workers' quite like a $10,000 dinner at a billionaire's mansion! For another $10,000 you could have ended up in Point Piper, rubbing shoulders with CommBank chief, Matt Comyn, and former Victorian premier Dan Andrews. Well, perhaps Adelaide's more your scene. For the same $10,000 you could have dined with Anthony Albanese, Labor secretary Paul Erickson, Santos CEO Kevin Gallagher and the Minerals Council boss, Tania Constable. That's the fossil fuel lobby, the mining industry and the Prime Minister all around the same dinner table. And people wonder why we don't get a tax on gas exports.</p><p>But let's see what the Liberals had on offer. For 17 grand, you could have scored two seats at their business policy exchange, with Angus Taylor and Tim Wilson. That's 17 grand. Or if you're a property developer with 50 grand in your pocket, there's a Liberal lunch celebrating Queensland industry. But don't worry; the Liberals also cater for the budget-conscious lobbyist. Just $200 could get you into their 'Bling it on!' fundraiser, with former PM Tony Abbott. I wonder why he's in the discount bin!</p><p>And finally, if orange is more your flavour, well, One Nation has got some offers for you. For 15 grand you could dine with Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce aboard Gina Rinehart's private plane. And, for a mere $3,000, you could have enjoyed lunch at Vue de monde. But, if you wanted to be seated next to Pauline Hanson, that was an extra two grand&#x2014;because some things are truly priceless!</p><p>So there you have it: different menus, different price tags, the same corporate capture of our political elite in this country. Here's the thing: while ordinary Australians are struggling to pay rent, afford groceries or keep the lights on, the people running this country are sitting down to expensive dinners with corporations that are making record profits. It is sickening. The banks, the mining companies and the fossil fuel giants have got a seat at the table, and ordinary Australians are picking up the bill. We, the Greens, don't think democracy should come with a price tag. Political influence shouldn't be something that only the wealthy can afford.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.213.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Workplace Relations </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="659" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.213.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" speakername="Michelle Ananda-Rajah" talktype="speech" time="19:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>If you think inflation is bad, pushing up the prices of your groceries and latte, do you know what's worse? Losing your job. Right now, too many Australians either have lost their jobs or fear that they may be next. Acts of corporate malfeasance, indifference or sheer bastardry abound. Some notable mentions include WiseTech, a company stained by the sleazy scandals of its founder; it shed around 1,700 jobs this year. PwC shed about 670 workers not because they did anything wrong but because of their bosses' scant regard for integrity. David Jones, having survived two world wars, could not withstand the cold hand of private equity, with 6,000 jobs under threat. Canva, the tech darling of Australia, got its unsuspecting workers to build generative AI, only to have it eat their jobs; over 1,200 roles may be restructured. This follows the loss of 500 jobs from Atlassian, announced in March this year. Westpac and NAB are shedding 1,500 and 2,500 jobs respectively. One has a newish CEO trying to make a profit splash by throwing workers overboard.</p><p>To top it all off, we have Qantas, under the spell of Accenture, offshoring 850 jobs despite getting a $2.7 billion lifeline from taxpayers during COVID. The ghost of Alan Joyce looms large. Clearly, its $90 million penalty to the Transport Workers' Union, awarded by the Federal Court last year, was not enough. Qantas does not need a restructure, folks; it needs an exorcism.</p><p>Share buybacks, exec bonuses and dividend payouts are prioritised over business investment in R&amp;D, which, ultimately, is the thing that grows the economic pie. When it comes to R&amp;D, Australian businesses have vacated the field. Business expenditure in R&amp;D has fallen to 0.9 per cent of GDP, well below the OECD average of two per cent. Yet businesses lament that government should do all the heavy lifting on productivity. There's a term for this corporate short-termism: 'financialisation'. It's as sterile as minutes from a corporate board meeting in 2026. Financialisation has been normalised in Australia. It's a fine art. We are the oligopoly nation, after all, where corporations make profits and socialise the losses&#x2014;workers included.</p><p>With corporate Australia using the smokescreen of AI to slash and burn while their execs bank the bonuses, it's time to join a union. There are 1.8 million Australian workers part of a union because they know that they are stronger together. Union membership has been typically low for white-collar workers, but that's changing. Professionals Australia has seen a surge of 40 per cent in its membership over the last year. For over 100 years, unions have fought for higher pay, stronger safety in the workplace and a better work-life balance, with things like the right to disconnect; the banning of noncompete clauses; payday super; increasing the minimum wage; banning pay secrecy clauses; improved bargaining for workers in the same industry; banning zombie agreements; better rights for gig workers; criminalising wage theft; protected penalty rates; more affordable housing; a stronger safety net; family and domestic violence leave; expanded paid parental leave; taking super up to 12 per cent; and banning labour hire. It's quite a roll call. These rights were hard won by the union movement and made law by Labor governments, and many of those measures were introduced by the Albanese Labor government&#x2014;all of which, every single one of them, were opposed by One Nation and the coalition.</p><p>Founded in 1927, the ACTU is the peak body for 30 unions. In this era of churn and change, AI related disruption and trigger happy corporates too quick to resort to cost-cutting at the expense of workers stand unions who bring heart, fight and an over-100-year track record to the game, rebalancing power towards workers. That's the same DNA in Labor. We are here to protect workers rights. We see workers as the assets that they are rather than problems to be managed. Join your union, choose Labor, and protect your job security.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.214.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Women's Reproductive Health </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="544" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.214.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="19:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Acting Deputy Speaker Stewart, I'm sorry to tell you and everyone perinatal deaths have just reached a 19-year peak in Tasmania. At the same time, birth rates are dropping as cost-of-living pressures make it harder and harder for young people to feel financially secure enough to start a family. We need to be doing all we can to support mums to be. We need to ensure they have access to adequate health care during pregnancy to help babies be healthy at birth. We need to ensure parents have adequate parental leave and cost-of-living relief, and we need to ensure that mums and babies have the best care possible during birth.</p><p>For some, that means giving birth at home, where they feel safe and supported. But, on New Year's Day, that will no longer be an option for women right around the country. This is because, on 31 December this year, the professional indemnity insurance exemption that applies to privately practising second attendance at home births is currently scheduled to end. For a safe home birth, two appropriately qualified persons are required. Removing the PII exemption for the second attendant means that up to a third of private practising midwives will no longer be able to work, as there is no suitable insurance product offered. The PII products on the market require midwives to be endorsed. Only five per cent of midwives are endorsed. Endorsement is an additional accreditation which requires completion of 5,000 hours of work. For most midwives who work part time, it would take six years or more to become endorsed. A lot of midwives working towards endorsement do their required time as second attendants. They will no longer be able to do that. Not extending the PII exemption will shrink the available workforce, particularly in rural and regional areas, where women give birth at home because that is the only option. There are no maternity wards nearby. Without the exemption, it doesn't mean women will stop giving birth at home. All it will mean is that they will give birth in situations declared to be unsafe.</p><p>At the Senate inquiry into postpartum care that I attended in Sydney recently, in response to a question that I asked about what the impact will be if this exemption is not continued, I was shocked. I was told it's a matter of life and death. Today I was told a group of mums with their babies or mums carrying their babies yet to be born attended outside Rebecca White MP's office in Tasmania, peacefully protesting with placards in hand, pleading for the exemption to be extended. The response was to call the police. It doesn't have to be this way. The exemption has been in place since 2010. It has become the rule and not the exception. It can be extended, even just for a year to allow time for a more permanent solution to be developed, such as using that time to establish a system where endorsement is not required for a second attendant to access insurance to reflect the realities of the workforce. This federal Labor government needs to urgently extend the exemption before the end of this year. Mums, unborn babies, mums planning to have children&#x2014;their families are dependent on it.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.215.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Defence Estate </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="655" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.215.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" speakername="Richard Mansell Colbeck" talktype="speech" time="20:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Last week, as I assume many of us did, I attended the Remembrance Day service in my local community in Devonport, where we as communities come together to commemorate the end of World War I and to remember those who made the ultimate sacrifice in those terrible circumstances of war and since that time, and to remind ourselves of those consequences and, hopefully, prevent us from getting into those circumstances again. I'd like to thank Devonport RSL club and all of those who supported the service that was conducted in Devonport. I know the council, for example, provided an element of support to ensure that the service could go ahead.</p><p>After the service was completed, I received a number of approaches from members of the RSL club and the local defence community, as I have on a number of previous occasions, in relation to the proposed sell-off of defence assets around the country but particularly in Tasmania. It was striking to me the stories that they had of the importance of the local availability of those defence assets to sustain local Army, Navy and air cadets in communities like Burnie, Devonport, Launceston and all around the state.</p><p>Historically, Tasmania has a very proud record with respect to defence personnel. Per capita, we've provided a higher ratio of defence personnel than any other state in the country, so we have a very proud record. A lot of that's due to the fact that young people who live in our local communities, particularly in the regions of Tasmania, have access to Army, Navy or Air Force cadets at a local level, not 50 or 100 kilometres away or some distance down the road. They have access locally. If we want to continue that level of engagement into the future, that local access is absolutely critical for people who are interested in attending these things. People aren't travelling 50 or 100 kilometres down the road, particularly in Tasmania, to another community to access these facilities. They want to be able to access them locally because they've got school drop-off and they've got all of the other activities&#x2014;sport and those sorts of things. So these community assets are absolutely vital.</p><p>One of the assets in Devonport is the 44th Transport Squadron. That's a significant asset. In fact, I was told last week that every single member deployed to East Timor from Tasmania was deployed out of the 44th Transport Squadron in Devonport. No-one from the rest of Tasmania was part of that first deployment&#x2014;so very proudly. Those defence assets like vehicles, the permanent defence jobs and the reservists who all operate out of the 44th Transport Squadron are at risk because this government has proposed that that property be flogged off. That's of major concern to my local community. Quite frankly, in my view, that Defence capability must remain on the north-west coast of Tasmania. That is a must.</p><p>There are some solutions. There are some solutions if the government wants to listen. One of the interesting things is that the <i>TS Sheean</i>, named in honour of Victoria Cross recipient Teddy Sheean&#x2014;a long-fought battle on the north-west coast of Tasmania&#x2014;is another asset that the government is looking to remove. If everything went to <i>T</i><i>S</i><i> Sheean</i>, the government could sell off the 44th Transport Squadron site, and those resources and those assets could remain in the region&#x2014;a simple solution.</p><p>But what concerns me is the government's attitude to this. From a defence point of view, the Deputy Prime Minister, Mr Marles, says it really matters that we get off these sites. Well, it matters to the community that those assets are available locally. What is clear is that the government has no plan as to how to manage this. It should have a plan before it deserts these sites and deserts these communities, because that's what it's doing, and it should rethink this whole program before it goes any further.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.216.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
International Men's Day </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="792" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.216.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" speakername="Tyron Whitten" talktype="speech" time="20:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I want to speak tonight on an issue that should unite this parliament and indeed all parliaments around Australia, and that is the 2,500 men and boys who are taking their own lives every year in Australia. On Thursday, International Men's Day, we will see 2,500 pairs of shoes laid out on the lawn of parliament for the fifth year in a row to commemorate all the men and boys lost to suicide in the last year. I would like to thank Paulo Withall for his tireless advocacy against this scourge that is taking away fathers, brothers, sons and husbands before their time. I want to call on all members of parliament to join me on Thursday morning on the lawn to see the true scale of this blight. It is our duty as parliamentarians to look at the darkest parts of our societies and work out what we can do to help.</p><p>Many in this parliament are happy to talk about the fashionable issues, like climate change, gender inequality and land rights. I wouldn't ask anyone to give up the issues that they are passionate about&#x2014;there's no shortage of important issues&#x2014;but, when we're losing 2,500 men and boys every year, it affects all of our lives. It affects every community that we represent. Every corner of this place, every party and Independent, should make the trip down to the lawn to stand and remember those men and boys that lost their way&#x2014;those who left this world too soon, those who felt there was nowhere to turn, those who were led to dark places. The reverberation of their loss is felt throughout our communities. To all the men and boys out there: the world is a better place with you in it. You have a lot to give and a lot to live up to. You might not see it now, but the world needs strong, good men more than ever, and you can be that. You can be that for your family, you can be that for your community and you can be that for your country. Hang in there.</p><p>I've been calling for stronger action on men's issues. I would like to see an office for men established to address the challenges that men face. That is because the needs of men and how we communicate are different from those of women. This isn't to take anything away from women. It isn't a zero-sum game. The better we can make our men, the stronger and more resilient they are, the better life is for women, and, for every life we can save from the scourge of suicide, there is one less grieving mother and one less grieving father. An office for men would look at the ways we have fallen short of supporting and promoting good men in our society and how we can better lay out the path to being good men for our boys.</p><p>I feel for the younger generation of men in this country. Everywhere they look, barriers are being put up in front of them. There is such a dearth of encouragement in our institutions. Universities, schools, workplaces and our media all celebrate and encourage young girls to reach their full potential, as they should, but young men are taught that they are privileged and they haven't earned what they have. Then we recoil in shock and dismay when suicide is the leading cause of death for men between 15 and 44. I'm not asking for boys to be given anything extra. All I'm asking for is that we have equal, merit based treatment for our young people. I'm asking for the same enthusiasm and encouragement that we are so good at giving our girls. After all, our girls will spend the rest of their lives dealing with these men. Don't we owe them a generation of capable, strong, caring and responsible men?</p><p>The only way to get there is to start taking the concerns of men seriously. I'll be attending another event this Sunday, on 22 November, on the Gold Coast&#x2014;the Ripple Effect. It's a fantastic day dedicated to recognising and celebrating the positive impact men, boys and fathers have on our families and communities. This is a family day, and all are welcome. This is a day to celebrate fathers, brothers, sons and husbands and all that good men do for our society. One Nation cares about good men and women. We care about a culture where strong, responsible men are celebrated. Men are not optional. We will always be here. It is our choice if we want strong men or weak men. But a word of caution: if you think strong men are dangerous, you should see what weak men are capable of.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.217.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Defence Estate </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="715" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.217.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" speakername="Leah Blyth" talktype="speech" time="20:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Now, there are some things that a government should sell and there are other things that a government must never sell. This government accepted every recommendation of the Defence estate audit. It then announced the largest military property sell off in Australian history. The headline was $3 billion, but the costs are forecast to be about $1.8 billion, leaving a net return of 1.2 billion. Now, I don't think this is a defence strategy. This is a garage sale that Labor is conducting to try and make up for a budget black hole. I'm sure we could find savings elsewhere, and perhaps $500 to change a light bulb on a defence base may be too much. Now, let no-one say that we support waste. Any sensible household clears out the shed. If a site is vacant, if it's decayed and if it serves no purpose for our defence, we should sell it. That is prudent. But a prudent household does not sell the roof of their house to pay their electricity bill. Where a sale weakens our capability or our posture, it is reckless.</p><p>Victoria Barracks Sydney was to be sold in full. Then, after months of public pressure, the Prime Minister announced it would stay in public hands but, like with this Labor government, the devil is always in the detail. Now staying in public hands, only the heritage parts of the base and that of Victoria Barracks in Melbourne, Fort Queenscliff and RAAF Williams, will this government keep in public hands. Those sites are still on the list to be divested and will be transferred to the Department of Finance to be divested, maybe not in full but certainly there will be commercial aspects to it.</p><p>So that announcement by the Prime Minister wasn't a backflip. It wasn't a change of heart. It was purely a change of headline. Victoria Barracks in Sydney will no longer be a defence facility. It will have the soldiers leave and they will be leaving by the end of this month. Tourists may or may not come in, depending on what that divestiture looks like.</p><p>Victoria Barracks is the home of the Australian Army. It has stood for generations in the heart of one of our biggest cities, a reminder that those who defend us also live among us. The Army should stay there, not be rehoused in a soulless commercial office tower. It belongs where it has always been, right there on that ground in Victoria Barracks. Its home is where it is and where it must remain.</p><p>The same is true on the other side of the continent. Irwin Barracks is the headquarters of the 13th Brigade. It is home to the 10th Light Horse, raised in 1914. Those men rode at Gallipoli. They fought in the deserts of Palestine. They are the heart and soul of the Army Reserve in the West, and this government wants to move them to Palmer Barracks near the Perth Airport so that developers can build on their ground. I say, no, you do not sell the home of the Light Horse to fix the mistakes of a Treasurer. Using our defence assets and our capability to fill a budget black hole is not in the national interest. It is the politics of the short term, and the short term is a poor guide to the defence of a nation.</p><p>If this government must find money, there is a better place to look than the barracks of the army. Look at net zero. Look at the subsidies and the mandates that Labor has piled on to the Australian taxpayer. That spending dwarfs anything this fire sale could raise. We have on this side of the chamber abandoned that policy, and I would urge the government to do the same because a nation that cannot defend itself is not going to be capable of defending anything. A government that is looking to sell off our defence history, sell our barracks, sell the home of the Army in Sydney, is a government that has its priorities all wrong.</p><p>Our soldiers are asked to stand between us and danger, and the least that we can do is let them stand on their own ground and not sell their house from under them.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.218.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Economy </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="540" approximate_wordcount="1274" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.218.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" speakername="James McGrath" talktype="speech" time="20:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>After more than four years of Labor, Australians are paying dearly for this government's economic incompetence. There have been 17 interest rate rises since they came to office. Productivity growth has stalled. Household budgets are stretched to breaking point. They have a Treasurer who is utterly incapable of understanding that his government's reckless spending is the main driver of these problems.</p><p>Australia now has a cash rate of 4.85 per cent, significantly higher than any other advanced economy in the world. While Australians are desperately trying to get ahead, Treasurer Chalmers and Prime Minister Albanese keep pulling them backwards. Families are paying more for mortgages, more for their groceries, more for their electricity and more for almost every essential item. Australians were promised cheaper power, cheaper mortgages and a better standard of living. But this was another promise that was broken by Prime Minister Albanese. Instead, Australians have received the exact opposite.</p><p>And what is Labor's response? More spending, more taxes, more government intervention and more broken promises. Commonwealth spending has reached 26.9 per cent of GDP&#x2014;the highest level in four decades, outside the COVID-19 pandemic. That is almost $787 billion in annual spending. Yet, despite this extraordinary level of expenditure, Australians are struggling to see what they are getting in return. Our productivity is dismal, our housing crisis continues, our hospitals are under pressure and our standard of living has been battered.</p><p>The fundamental problem is that Labor believes the solution to every economic challenge is another government program, another subsidy, more bureaucracy and another billion dollars of taxpayers' money. The government spends more; Australians pay more. And the Reserve Bank is left to do the heavy thinking, because, while the Treasurer keeps his foot on the spending accelerator, the Reserve Bank is forced to keep its foot on the monetary brake. The result has been five interest rate rises this year alone. That's more than the United Kingdom, the United States, New Zealand and Canada combined. Nobody disputes that international pressures exist, but the Albanese government cannot keep pretending that its domestic decisions have no consequences. When Labor pours more money into an economy already struggling with capacity constraints, it makes inflation worse. When it fails to tackle productivity, it makes it harder for businesses to grow, invest, hire workers and pay higher wages. And when it refuses to exercise spending restraint, it makes the Reserve Bank's job that much harder. This is not complicated economics. It is basic economic management, something that Labor will never work out. And Australians are paying the price every day.</p><p>Perhaps the most extraordinary thing about this government's economic record is what happens when Labor finally decides it needs to save money, because, after spending hundreds of billions of dollars, after expanding government programs, and after refusing to confront its own waste, where does Labor turn? To veterans and older Australians&#x2014;the very people who've served this country, contributed to our economy and helped build the Australia we enjoy today.</p><p>Let's start with our veterans, because that's where Labor started. Earlier this year, the Albanese government announced a disgraceful proposal to impose a $5,000 annual limit on allied health services for veterans. This was a measure designed simply to deliver savings. And who was expected to bear this burden? The men and women who've put their lives on the line to defend our nation&#x2014;veterans who rely on physiotherapy, psychology and other services to manage injuries and conditions arising from their service. The coalition warned Labor about the consequences. Veterans warned Labor. Health professionals warned Labor. But the government pressed ahead, insisting its policy was appropriate. Only after an enormous backlash&#x2014;only after veterans laid their medals down at the entrance to Parliament House&#x2014;did Labor finally retreat. It was a disgraceful approach to treating our veterans.</p><p>Now we've had the government's extraordinary proposal to sell off historic defence sites&#x2014;sites with deep connections to Australia's military history and the generations of Australians who've served. Instead of respecting that heritage, Labor saw an opportunity to put a price tag on it. Once again, veterans and the defence community have been forced to stand up against their own government.</p><p>This doesn't stop with veterans. The Albanese Labor government is now attempting to strip older Australians of their private health insurance rebates. Under Minister Butler's proposal, millions of older Australians will be hit with higher private health insurance premiums. For couples, the additional cost will be up to $1,600 a year. At a time when pensioners and self-funded retirees are already struggling with rising living costs, Labor wants to send them another enormous bill. These are the people who have worked hard, paid taxes, raised families and contributed to their communities. Many have carefully budgeted to maintain private health insurance because they value the choice and security it provides. Yet Labor wants to punish them for it.</p><p>Consider the broader consequences. When older Australians can no longer afford private health insurance because of Labor, many will be forced to rely on our public health system, simply shifting the cost burden onto the states. This comes at a time when our public hospitals are already under immense pressure, emergency departments are overcrowded and patients are waiting for beds. Right now, public hospitals are at breaking point, dealing with significant bed block because Labor has failed to adequately resource the aged-care system, leaving older patients stranded. What's Labor's solution? To make private health insurance more expensive for these people, pushing even more patients into an already overstretched public health system. It makes absolutely no sense, but this is the twisted logic of Labor's spending priorities&#x2014;billions for its pet projects, climate ideology and gerrymandered grant schemes. Remember the $6 million for Albo's golf club? But, when it comes time to making savings, Labor goes after veterans and older Australians. It is a disgraceful indictment of this government's priorities.</p><p>The contrast between the government and the coalition when it comes to savings cannot be clearer. Under the leadership of Angus Taylor and Matt Canavan, the coalition has already identified more than $31 billion in proposed savings over four years&#x2014;real, costed savings that benefit Australians, not disadvantage them. Our savings demonstrate there is a better way to manage the nation's finances. Our proposed savings include winding back expensive green subsidies, getting rid of net zero, abolishing unnecessary bureaucracies and ending poorly targeted government schemes. Rather than forcing veterans to fight for health care or older Australians to pay more for private health insurance, we are prepared to confront Labor's spending priorities.</p><p>The coalition believes Australians should keep more of what they earn, the government should live within their means and the federal budget should be managed with the same discipline that Australian families are forced to exercise every day with their household budgets. Our $31 billion savings package is a substantial down payment on restoring budget discipline and delivering meaningful tax relief. Unlike Labor, we have put forward independently costed proposals well before an election, because Australia cannot tax, borrow and spend its way to prosperity. We need a government focused on productivity, private investment, economic growth and restoring Australia's standard of living. The difference is simple. Labor spends recklessly and then asks veterans and older Australians to pay the price. The coalition will cut waste, protect essential services and put Australians first. That is the choice before the country. After four years of Labor's economic failures, Australians deserve a government that will fight for them, not against them, and only the Liberals and Nationals have the strong leadership, the strong team and the strong plan to restore Australia's standard of living and protect our way of life.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.219.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme, Youth Allowance, Queensland: Data Centres </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="480" approximate_wordcount="994" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.219.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" speakername="Penny Allman-Payne" talktype="speech" time="20:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We're coming to the end of another year of this Labor government, and they still haven't implemented the recommendations from the robodebt royal commission in full. In most places in Australia, debt cannot be pursued after six years. Yet we still have Centrelink pursuing debts that are more than 40 years old. Most people don't even remember the specifics of who they worked for six years ago, let alone 40. Where there is no limitation on when debts can be raised, people are effectively required to obtain information from businesses that may no longer exist. You're screwed if your previous boss didn't give you regular payslips, if you left a dodgy employer on bad terms or if you followed the ATO's advice and only kept your tax records for five years. But the government doesn't care about that. It's completely divorced from the realities of ordinary people who are just trying to keep their heads above water.</p><p>9 News has reported on a single mum named Jodie, who's recently been told by Centrelink that she owes a debt from 12 years ago. Jodie was a robodebt victim, and now, on top of raising her kids, she has to track down financial information from 2014. I know I'd struggle to find my information from that time, and I doubt that the ministers for social services and government services would have their records readily available from back then either. Why are people accessing social security made to jump through hoops? Centrelink is supposed to be a safety net, but, because this Labor government refuses to treat social security recipients with dignity and respect, these debt notifications are traumatising people all over again.</p><p>When Commissioner Holmes handed down her recommendations in the final report of the robodebt royal commission, she said:</p><p class="italic">There is no reason that current and former social security recipients should be on any different footing from other debtors.</p><p>There's no legal reason for it and certainly no moral or practical reason. It's pure discrimination. At Senate estimates last month, I asked the minister if the government will reinstate the six-year time limit on debt recovery by the end of their second term. They couldn't give me a clear answer. The Greens will not rest until all 57 recommendations from the robodebt royal commission are implemented in full and until we have a social security system that is fair, that is just and that actually helps people instead of punishing them.</p><p>Many young people want to study, but they literally can't afford to. Youth allowance is supposed to help young people with their living costs while they're at university or TAFE, but the maximum rate the government permits is $677.20 a fortnight, even if you're over 18 and living away from home. That's $200 a fortnight less than the JobSeeker payment, which is already about $600 a fortnight below the poverty line. Last I checked, your rent isn't discounted just because you're under 24 years old, and your uni fees aren't discounted either. When you're a young adult living independently, as many uni students from regional Australia do, you pay the same amount in electricity and water bills as anyone else, so why is Labor punishing young people for simply being young?</p><p>The maximum rate is before your parents' income gets taken into account. If you're 21 or under and your parents earn about $66,000 a year combined, your youth allowance starts to get reduced. Parental income shouldn't even be a factor in determining who gets support once a person turns 18, and I'm not sure how the government expects $66,000 a year to cover three people's living expenses, because it barely covers one anymore. If we want young people to get the best possible start, then we need to give them a liveable income so they can focus on their education. Labor need to increase the youth payment, and they need to abolish the parental income test.</p><p>AI data centres are pushing up power bills, guzzling water and stealing artists' work, and regional communities are being lined up to host these mega data centres whether they like it or not. First Nations traditional landowners aren't getting a say, despite this all happening on unceded First Nations land. Governments are bulldozing over the top of real community concerns about the impacts on the environment and water quality. Labor's new AI regulator doesn't have any new legal powers. It's just more platitudes from the government, in the hope that regional towns will just shut up and let big tech do whatever they want.</p><p>The residents of Dalby, a community in my home state of Queensland, are asking very real questions about this. The $32 billion digital park slated for the middle of local farmland will use as much power as about 1.5 million Australian households. They're apparently going to get that power from gas. How much is that going to push up Queensland's emissions? How much is that going to push up the cost of our energy bills? The data centre plan for Dalby is unprecedented in its scale, including the noise, the hot air and the carbon that will be produced, yet the Queensland LNP signed off on it without giving any consideration to these impacts on the Dalby community and the rest of our state. Federal Labor hasn't done anything about it either&#x2014;not since they've rolled over to the antirenewable lobby.</p><p>The company behind this plan is the United States tech giant Anthropic, whose AI is stealing artists' copyright and forcing people out of work. Make no mistake, if the Dalby data centre goes ahead, it will set a dangerous precedent for big tech to extract whatever they want from us without giving anything in return. We need a moratorium on data centres now. The Dalby data centre must not proceed until we have stronger regulations, environmental protections and a demonstrated benefit to regional communities, not just to the profits of American tech bros.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.220.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Myanmar: Human Rights, Green, Ms Zoe Grace, Vafaei Sani, Mr Mohammad Javad, Bangladesh Puja and Cultural Society </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="600" approximate_wordcount="1269" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.220.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="speech" time="20:31" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Since the military coup in Myanmar in February 2021, I've frequently spoken in this place of the atrocities committed by the ruling junta against the people of Myanmar, including through air strikes. I've sought to give voice to the Myanmar Queensland diaspora community, who seek freedom, democracy and peace for the people of Myanmar. I've also spoken about the great work various organisations have undertaken to support refugees who have found safety in Australia, including those from Myanmar. I should also acknowledge my friend and colleague Senator Smith who is here. He has also been an outstanding advocate for the people of Myanmar.</p><p>Skill Path Australia is an organisation which empowers refugees to access higher education, training and professional recognition in Australia. I recently met one of the students they support, Elma Sun. Elma is a wonderful woman who is studying a Master of Business at my old university, the University of Queensland. Elma came here in the first cohort of students under the Refugee Student Settlement Pathway. I found out last week that Elma's beloved 12-year-old niece, Esther, was killed in an air strike on her school&#x2014;a school for displaced children&#x2014;in Myanmar. This was another atrocity committed by the military junta in Myanmar. I've seen photos of the school. I've seen photos of the abandoned school bags of the students. In honour of Esther and with the deepest respect to Elma and her family, I want to put on the record Elma's words in relation to her niece, Esther:</p><p class="italic">This tragedy happened in my village, and one of the children who lost their lives was my niece.</p><p class="italic">I have been struggling to find the words to express the pain I feel. Whenever I spoke with the children back home, they would often tell me that I inspired them. I always encouraged them to study hard, do their best, and never give up on their dreams. I wanted them to believe that, despite everything they were going through, education could open doors to a better future.</p><p class="italic">But now, how can I continue encouraging children to pursue their dreams when even the journey to school puts their lives at risk? It breaks my heart to know that children in my country must risk their lives for something as basic as education.</p><p class="italic">No child should have to choose between their safety and their education. No family should have to fear that sending their child to school might mean never seeing them again.</p><p class="italic">To my beloved niece and the other innocent children whose lives were taken far too soon, Rest in peace.</p><p class="italic">Your lives mattered. Your dreams mattered. And you will never be forgotten.</p><p class="italic">Please do not look away from the suffering of children in Myanmar.</p><p>This parliament must not look away. We must continue standing in solidarity with the people of Myanmar, seeking their freedom, democracy and peace.</p><p>I was delighted to attend the award of the Baden-Powell Scout Award to a wonderful young Queenslander, Zoe Grace Green. This award ceremony took place at the Raceview Scout Den. It reflects years of dedication, leadership, personal growth, service to others and commitment to living the values of scouting. In Zoe's words, 'This milestone is not only a celebration of my personal achievement but also a recognition of the incredible support, guidance and encouragement provided by the many leaders, mentors, friends and members of the scouting community who have contributed along the way.' Zoe is an outstanding young Queenslander&#x2014;just outstanding. In particular, I applaud Zoe for the work she is undertaking promoting understanding and connection with neurodivergent young Australians. It really is inspiring. So congratulations, Zoe.</p><p>I rise today to speak in honour of Mohammad Javad Vafaei Sani, a political prisoner in Iran who has been awarded the esteemed Magnitsky Award for Outstanding Human Rights Activist. In doing so, I stand in solidarity&#x2014;and I'm sure my fellow senators stand in solidarity&#x2014;with the people of Iran and the Iranian diaspora around the world seeking freedom, democracy and peace in Iran. The Magnitsky Awards began in 2015. They are named after the Russian lawyer Sergei Magnitsky, who was murdered in Russian police custody after exposing a massive government corruption scheme.</p><p>Mohammad Javad Vafaei Sani was unable to accept his award in person at the ceremony held in London last Thursday, 12 November 2026. Why? Because he is a political prisoner in Iran. Mohammad is 31 years old. Before his imprisonment he had established himself as a national boxing champion and built a career as a boxing coach. But, in Iran, his courage outside the boxing ring has come at an extraordinary cost. Arrested in 2020 following the November 2019 nationwide protests, he was accused of supporting the opposition party the People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran and charged with so-called corruption on Earth. His death sentence was overturned twice, only to be imposed for a third time in September 2024. Iran's Supreme Court upheld that sentence in October 2025. He has endured torture, prolonged solitary confinement and years of imprisonment, yet he has refused to surrender his dignity or his beliefs. The <i>Guardian</i> reported:</p><p class="italic">In a written message from Vakilabad prison in north-eastern Iran, he said: "I accept this award in the name of all those who, for the 'crime' of aspiring to a free Iran, have been imprisoned, tortured, threatened, or sentenced to death; in the name of my comrades in the resistance units and the generation that is paying the price of freedom with their lives."</p><p class="italic">He added: "The regime demands repentance, televised confessions and surrender from us. But our answer is clear: 'We will never surrender; we will never submit to humiliation.'"</p><p>These are the words of a man who has been sentenced to death not once but three times and yet still refuses to surrender. His bravery deserves international recognition, but, above all, his life must be protected.</p><p>Today is the 147th week of the No to Executions Tuesday campaign in Iran. Political prisoners in 66 prisons across Iran are on hunger strikes. I say to each and every one of them: the freedom-loving people of Australia stand in solidarity with you. We say no to the executions in Iran. We call for freedom for the people of Iran and freedom for Mohammad Javad Vafaei Sani, whose words resonate throughout the world and will now be recorded in the Australian parliament for all time.</p><p>I congratulate the Bangladesh Puja and Cultural Society for its successful Durga Puja celebrations and its 20th anniversary. This is an outstanding organisation. It is now 20 years since it was established, and I want to thank the special people who were the founding committee members&#x2014;its president, Professor Tapan Saha, vice-president, Dr Jahar Lal Saha, secretary, Dr Debdas Guha, treasurer, Dr Kalyan Pandit, and cultural secretary, Mitali Chakraborty. I want to quote from a speech that Professor Tapan Saha, the founding president, gave on the evening. He said:</p><p class="italic">Tonight, we are not simply celebrating the 20th anniversary of an organisation. We are celebrating:</p><p class="italic">20 years of culture.</p><p class="italic">20 years of friendship.</p><p class="italic">20 years of service.</p><p class="italic">And, most importantly, 20 years of togetherness.</p><p>He went on to say:</p><p class="italic">Twenty years ago, we planted a small seed. Today, it has grown into a strong and vibrant community.</p><p>I also want to congratulate the existing, current executive and committee members who are carrying on this great tradition. To the president, Mr Joy Dassgupta, vice-president, Dr Subrata Chakroborty, general secretary, Dr Kamanashish Biswas, treasurer, Dr Debashish Der, and cultural secretary, Kyoshic Chowdhury: thank you so much for everything that you contribute to our wonderful multicultural society and to the people of Queensland.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.221.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Ukraine </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="600" approximate_wordcount="1541" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.221.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="speech" time="20:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>When President Trump was campaigning for his second term, he told Americans and the world that he would end Russia's illegal war in Ukraine in 24 hours. But, instead of doing that, Trump invited President Zelenskyy to the White House and then abused him in the Oval Office in front of the world's media&#x2014;shameful! Then he invited President Putin to a red-carpet summit in Alaska. That was the first time the Russian president had been on US soil since Russia got kicked out of the G8 after invading Crimea.</p><p>Trump has lifted sanctions on Russia. He has cut military and economic assistance to Ukraine. He has threatened to withhold intelligence from Ukraine. He has accused Ukraine of being the aggressor and has demanded that Ukraine give up territory. When the Russians invaded Ukraine in 2022, they clearly thought it would be all over and done with in a matter of weeks, but they didn't factor in the resilience, courage, fight and the goddamn endurance of the Ukrainian people. Slava Ukraini! President Putin knows how to play the long game. For decades, the Russian leader has bullied Ukraine, and, for decades, Putin has been cultivating his relationship with Donald Trump. I don't know what Putin has on Trump, but, jeez, it must be great.</p><p>To most Americans and most Australians, Russia is the enemy. America used to be the country that stood up for democracies and against dictatorships, but President Trump loves dictators, especially Putin. Russia's war in Ukraine is now in its fifth year, and Ukrainians are facing the worst winter since the war began. Ukraine targets infrastructure that supports Putin's war; Putin targets people and civilian infrastructure.</p><p>What's been happening in the last few weeks is even more shocking. Starshield is a satellite network created by Elon Musk's SpaceX. It is designed for national defence and security and provides military-grade internet speeds and communication capabilities for the US government and supposedly its allies. It's basically the military version of Starlink, and it's crucial to the Ukrainians. It's how they track Russian drones and how they target Russian missiles.</p><p>In mid-October, Ukrainian officials told the world that Elon Musk's SpaceX had abruptly capped the speed of Starshield. Media reporting suggested that it was because the Ukrainians were attacking Russian oil refineries. There was an outcry, and the service was restored on 24 October, but last Friday it happened again. President Zelensky told the media:</p><p class="italic">Unfortunately, the speed restrictions remain in place along the entire front line and in the temporarily occupied territories of Ukraine.</p><p>Trump's Department of War and Elon Musk say they know nothing. Oh, really? They have yet to explain why the service has been throttled for a second time. I'm waiting for your explanations, you men! Elon Musk's SpaceX has told the media the speed restrictions are technical&#x2014;what a load of crap! I'll call you out now, Musk. President Zelenskyy says that the decision to impose speed limits appears to be political&#x2014;yes, he is correct&#x2014;rather than technical. Yes, he is correct again. I know who I trust and I know who I believe.</p><p>The Starshield outage comes after an intense US-led diplomatic push this week, with the Americans pressuring Zelenskyy to make territorial concessions to Putin. How about that. Put two and two together. Poor Donald. Oh dear, got your backside kicked in the midterms, did you, mate? Well, well, well, what do you know. He wants to win, but he appears to want to win for Russia, not Ukraine. That's where that man's head is. Russian negotiators insisted that Ukraine hand over four Ukrainian provinces. I don't think so, Trump. I don't think so. That includes cities and villages that Russian troops have been unable to conquer.</p><p>The Russians are also calling for a new security architecture in Europe. Here they come for the rest of Europe. This is a demand that would push NATO back to where it was in 1997, before eastern European nations joined the organisation. For the safety of the rest of the world, this cannot be allowed to happen. It was Russia that invaded Ukraine. It was Russia, by a long shot, that invaded Ukraine. Let's see if Trump can understand that single line. I can tell you now giving them parts of Ukraine is just appeasement. It is rewarding very bad behaviour of Putin, who comes up with these plans. Trump does this, and that must not be allowed to happen. If Russia think they can get away with it in Ukraine, then other nations are at risk. If the West had stood up to Russia in 2014, when Russia invaded and seized Crimea, we may not be here having this discussion this evening. Russia is already terrorising Europe. Air travel across Europe was disrupted in early November by a series of bomb threats. Russian drones have violated Poland's airspace multiple times, with a Russian missile landing inside the Polish border. Security experts have claimed that the large-scale cyberattacks on retailers bear all the hallmarks of&#x2014;guess who? Yes, Putin. Russia. That's what they trademark with.</p><p>The recent US midterm elections will hopefully change this. In just the last few days, Democratic US senators have told Elon Musk to preserve all records related to the company SpaceX's restrictions on Ukraine's use of its Starlink and Starshield satellite services. Ukraine's struggle against Russia is a cause that many US Democrats and Republicans have championed for some time. When the newly elected senators and congressmen take up their jobs in January, they have a big to-do list, but they shouldn't forget what most Americans think of Russia and President Putin. A Pew Research Center poll in 2025 showed that 67 per cent of Americans don't trust Putin and six in 10 view Russia as an enemy, just like we do. In Australia, the view of the population is even worse, with only five per cent of Aussies having favourable views of Putin and the Kremlin. Thank God for that.</p><p>According to Ukraine's minister of energy, 80 per cent of their energy infrastructure has been destroyed or damaged by Russian attacks. The average temperature in Ukraine today is between one and seven degrees. In the winter, temperatures can reach minus 20 degrees Celsius. Imagine having no heat and having to deal with temperatures like that. Putin and Trump are threatening Europe and demanding they stop financing weapons for Ukraine. My god, talk about a madman. Russia isn't just a threat to Ukraine. The Prime Minister of the UK, Andy Burnham, told the media recently that Russia spends a billion dollars a year creating internet content designed to destabilise Western democracies.</p><p>Australia has contributed A$1.9 billion in total assistance to Ukraine since Russia's full-scale invasion in February 2022. This total includes more than $1.6 billion in military support, alongside economic, energy and humanitarian aid. In September 2026, Prime Minister Albanese and President Zelenskyy signed a bilateral security agreement that included a new $60 million package. That's all good, and I know the Ukrainians are extremely grateful, but we need to keep up the pressure. Part of the bilateral security agreement is a $10 million contribution to energy support. But, given the increased attacks on Ukraine's energy infrastructure, we need to continue our contribution to the Ukraine Energy Support Fund. The Treasurer is presumably days away from delivering the Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook. If there is any extra cash, I would ask that the Prime Minister and the Minister for Foreign Affairs think about giving some to Ukraine and keep topping them up where we can, like other Western countries. If we don't, Russia will keep going. They will keep attacking Europe and keep undermining and attacking the democracies of Europe and the world.</p><p>Next week, President Xi of China, President Putin and President Trump will meet at the APEC summit. Trump has hinted that he is also hoping for a meeting with North Korea's Kim Jong Un. You couldn't make this stuff up, could you, Western world? Just how dangerous is this getting? President Trump is saying: 'That will be good. We have a chance to accomplish a lot.' Jeez, really? How about some peace around the world? How about you try accomplishing that? I'll tell you what; your record so far is you're on zero&#x2014;absolute zero. You've brought no peace anywhere the whole time that you have been in. Trump loves the old dictators, and his inability to stand up for democracies should frighten all of us. President Xi has his eyes on Taiwan, Putin has Trump in his pocket and the President of the United States has in just two years made America an unreliable Western partner.</p><p>America is no longer the protector of democracies. We need to accept this and look to our allies. We need stronger partnerships with nations that share our respect for the international rule of law, like Canada, the UK and the European nations. And we need to stand strong and remain strong with Ukraine, and that means keeping support going. We need to show the world that we will stand with Ukraine, no matter who else is in the picture, because it is the best thing that we can do for Western democracies, going into the future.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.222.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Wellington, Mr Dennis William, Albany: Bicentenary </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="600" approximate_wordcount="1335" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.222.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" speakername="Dean Smith" talktype="speech" time="20:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise today to pay tribute to Dennis Wellington, the former mayor of Albany, who passed away on 16 October, leaving an extraordinary legacy of public service to Albany and to Western Australia's Great Southern region. Dennis was more than a mayor. He was a tireless advocate, a passionate community champion and a driving force behind the transformation of Albany into the thriving regional city it is today. For 23 years Dennis served on Albany council, including four years as deputy mayor and 12 years as mayor, from 2011 until 2023, making him the city's longest serving mayor. But his contribution is measured not simply in years of service but in the projects he championed, the opportunities he created and the lasting improvements he delivered.</p><p>I first came to know Dennis as a newly elected senator for Western Australia. He warmly welcomed me to Albany, offered his encouragement and, as I quickly discovered, was never reluctant to contact me on matters affecting his beloved city. Dennis was a straight talker who knew exactly what Albany needed and was never shy about telling politicians, regardless of their political persuasion, what he expected them to deliver for him and his community. He was persistent, persuasive and occasionally very demanding, but his motivation was always the same&#x2014;always what was best for Albany. That simple principle guided his public life.</p><p>Dennis believed regional communities deserved the same opportunities, infrastructure and services as those in our capital cities, and he was determined to secure them. His leadership helped deliver some of Albany's most significant projects, including the redevelopment of Centennial Park, improvements to Middleton Beach, the Albany Town Hall redevelopment and the Albany Ring Road. He also championed educational opportunities, including the expansion of the University of Western Australia Albany campus. Among his proudest achievements was the $40 million redevelopment of the Centennial Park Sporting Precinct. A talented cricketer and footballer himself, Dennis understood the importance of sport in building strong communities and creating opportunities for young people. He took particular pride in seeing thousands of local children playing football and soccer on the sporting grounds that had once been little more than waterlogged paddocks. For Dennis this was public service at its best&#x2014;delivering practical improvements that would benefit generations to come.</p><p>He also played a central role in Albany's Anzac Centenary commemorations, recognising the city's unique place in Australia's military history as the departure point for the first convoy carrying Australian and New Zealand troops to the First World War and to Gallipoli. Through projects including <i>Field </i><i>of </i><i>L</i><i>ight</i><i>: </i><i>Avenue of </i><i>H</i><i>onour</i>, Dennis helped ensure Albany's remarkable history received the national recognition it deserved. His vision also laid the foundation for Albany's bicentennial celebrations in 2026.</p><p>Dennis's leadership was equally evident during times of crisis. During the devastating Albany bushfires of 2018, he spent time at the incident control centre and on the fire grounds, and throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, he provided steady, calm leadership and reassurance to his community. He understood that leadership meant being present when his community needed him most.</p><p>In May this year, Dennis was awarded Albany's highest civic honour, being named the Honorary Freeman of the City in recognition of his extraordinary service. His successor and close friend, Mayor Greg Stokes, perhaps best captured Dennis's approach when he recalled his simple philosophy: if it's good for Albany, let's have a go. That was Dennis Wellington. He was not interested in political grandstanding or political or personal recognition. He wanted results and he delivered them. Dennis once remarked that he simply liked Albany and loved living there. That affection was returned by a community that recognised his honesty, determination and unwavering commitment.</p><p>Western Australia has lost an outstanding regional leader and Albany one of its longest and greatest champions. I extend my sincere condolences to Dennis's partner, Fran; his children Erin and Tim; his family, friends and entire Albany community. Dennis Wellington leaves behind a stronger, more confident and more prosperous Albany. His legacy will endure for ages. May he rest in peace.</p><p>In December this year, Western Australia will commemorate a remarkable milestone: the bicentenary of Albany, our state's oldest permanent European settlement and the birthplace of colonial Western Australia. On Christmas Day 1826, the brig <i>Amity</i> sailed into King George Sound carrying Major Edmund Lockyer, soldiers, convicts and supplies to establish a British settlement on Australia's southern coast. The following day, Lockyer and his party came ashore, beginning a chapter that would help shape Western Australia's future.</p><p>On 21 January 1827, the settlement was formally proclaimed as 'Frederick Town' before being renamed 'Albany' in 1832. Albany's importance extends well beyond its status as Western Australia's first permanent European settlement. Its magnificent natural harbour, King George Sound, made it one of the most strategically significant locations on the Australian continent. Explored by Captain George Vancouver in 1791 and later surveyed by Matthew Flinders, its sheltered waters attracted explorers, traders and naval vessels from around the world. Indeed, British concerns about French expansion helped prompt the establishment of the settlement in 1826. Albany soon became Western Australia's principal maritime gateway, connecting the emerging colony with Britain, the eastern colonies and international markets. For almost 70 years, Princess Royal Harbour was Western Australia's only deepwater port until Fremantle Inner Harbour opened in 1897. Generations of settlers, immigrants, merchants and travellers passed through Albany, helping build the economic and social foundations of our great state.</p><p>Albany's distinguished history also includes several memorable royal visits. The late Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip visited in 1954 as part of their first royal tour and again returned in 1977 as Albany celebrated its 150th anniversary. King Charles III first visited Albany as Prince of Wales in 1979, returning in 2015 with the then Duchess of Cornwall during the centenary year of the Albany campaign, when they visited the National Anzac Centre. Albany's international connections extend well beyond royalty. Among its notable visitors was a young American mining engineer, Herbert Hoover, who arrived in 1897 before travelling to the West Australian Goldfields. Hoover helped develop the famous Sons of Gwalia Mine before eventually becoming the 31st President of the United States of America.</p><p>But perhaps Albany's greatest contribution to our national story came in November 1915. From King George Sound, the first great convoy of Australian and New Zealand troops departed for the First World War and Gallipoli. Thirty-eight troop ships assembled in its sheltered waters, carrying tens of thousands of servicemen and thousands of horses towards an uncertain future. For many of these young men, the hills of Albany were their final glimpse of Australia. Many would never return. In 1923 Albany held what is recognised as Australia's first Anzac Day service, establishing a tradition that remains central to our national identity. Today, the National Anzac Centre overlooks King George Sound, preserving the stories and sacrifices of those who departed its shores. It stands as a powerful reminder that Albany's history is not merely Western Australian history; it is an integral part of Australia's national story.</p><p>Albany's bicentenary is an opportunity to honour not only the defining events of the past but the generations who transformed a remote colonial outpost into the thriving regional city we know today. From maritime trade and pastoral development to agriculture, tourism and defence, Albany has played a vital role in Western Australia's growth and prosperity. Its historic buildings, spectacular coastline and rich Indigenous and multicultural heritage reflect generations of enterprise, resilience and community spirit. I congratulate the City of Albany, the Albany Historical Society and the many community organisations, volunteers and residents working to make this historic occasion a great success. For two centuries, Albany has been a gateway to Western Australia, a witness to defining moments in our nation's history and a community that has helped shape our state's identity. Its bicentenary is an opportunity to reflect on that extraordinary legacy, celebrate its achievements and look confidently towards the next 200 years. I congratulate the people of Albany on this historic milestone.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.223.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Howard Government </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="720" approximate_wordcount="1477" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-17.223.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="21:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A17%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Many Australians say this Albanese Labor government is the worst government Australia has ever endured, but is it? Tonight, I have a quiz, as one of many steps to restore active democracy in our country, which in the last 50 years has declined alarmingly, with huge and needless increases in Australians' cost of living, needless dishonest reductions in standards of living and the gutting of personal and national finances and security. For each quiz question, name the Prime Minister, the PM.</p><p>Who was Prime Minister of the government that legislated the Renewable Energy Target, mandating solar and wind power, giving us unaffordable electricity and cutting stability, reliability and security? Which Prime Minister's government stole farmers' property rights and deceitfully bypassed the Constitution to comply with the UN's Kyoto climate and energy protocol? Which Prime Minister's government concocted the National Electricity Market, a bureaucratically controlled electricity racket making electricity unaffordable? Who was the first major party leader to adopt as policy an emissions trading scheme&#x2014;a carbon dioxide tax? Who was the Prime Minister, the PM, whose government claimed these policies and legislation were based on climate science? Yet, six years after leaving as PM, he admitted in distant London that, on the topic of climate science, he was agnostic. He did not have the science, after his government said it did.</p><p>Which PM's government started mass immigration and doubled immigration across its term, and removed house prices from the consumer price index, thus hiding a major damaging impact of mass immigration? Which PM's government rewrote the banking code of conduct to remove banks' obligations to provide a fair level of service and honest conduct? Years later, we needed a royal commission to identify the resulting abuses of borrowers, businesses, investors and citizens. Which PM, after losing the election, was appointed to an advisory role for JP Morgan?</p><p>Which PM, on his return to Australia from America, strode into cabinet and, according to his Foreign minister, announced, 'We're off to Iraq,' based on his government's claims about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction, claims the same government later admitted were false? They were lies. Who was that Prime Minister? Whose government blindly followed the American president into what would become Australia's longest war, Afghanistan, exposing our young men and women to needless harm and death? Who was that PM?</p><p>Which PM's government implemented the United Nations Agenda 21 across Australia, right across the country, without naming it? Which PM's government legislated the Water Act, specifying compliance with international agreements? Which PM's government legislated the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act, controlling private land use? Which party leader initiated Pauline Hanson's booting from the Liberal Party and then pursued her and teamed with the then Queensland state Labor premier and government to jail her to perpetuate 'uniparty' governance?</p><p>Which PM presided over North West Shelf gas contracts selling out and cheaply transferring Australia's wealth to foreign multinationals? Which PM's government signed Australia up to the unaccountable International Criminal Court, which then piled unfounded constraints and burdens onto our country? Which PM's government introduced the National Curriculum with its roots in the unelected United Nations, corrupting education into indoctrination, hurting children and families and driving one of the foundations in Australia for the UN's antihuman ideology?</p><p>Which PM's government gave $20 million to the WWF that's working to shut down our beef, coal and fishing and to control private property? Which PM's government introduced middle-class welfare? As famous author Alexis de Tocqueville said, once people get a taste of government largesse, there's no going back. They want more and more. People become dependent on government and surrender to government control. Which PM's finance minister said in recent years that he, the Treasurer and the Assistant Treasurer worked to stop the PM's wasteful spending, seemingly aimed at winning votes and elections to stay in power? According to the book <i>Anglophobia </i>on pages 103 and 104, which PM initiated the Aboriginal Voice concept? Which PM's government strongly supported multiculturalism, while portraying himself as a supporter of Anglo-Celtic heritage? Which PM's government extended the nuclear ban? Which PM's government outsourced and started destroying the Defence department?</p><p>Which PM spoke about federalism and states' rights as a cover for his centralist actions? Which PM talked about the Constitution, borders, property rights and other issues, falsely cultivating his image as a conservative patriot and nationalist, while pushing globalist UN policies? Which former PM entered federal parliament in 1974 and the next year became Minister for Business and Consumer Affairs? In 1976 he was in the federal ministry that ratified the UN Lima Declaration, shipping manufacturing overseas. Rising rapidly, he became Treasurer in 1977. Which PM's government used taxpayers' money to bail out a bankruptcy&#x2014;a company his older brother headed, as non-executive chair? Which PM's government took guns from honest everyday Australians without detailed formal investigation into the Port Arthur mass shooting?</p><p>Now for the answers: in every question, the Prime Minister, the PM, was John Howard. Here are excerpts from the late conservative politician and author Viv Forbes's global newsletter of 26 April 2019: 'Then came the Howard era, and again Australians went to sleep, allowing Howard to plant the seeds of many current problems. He had a good careful treasurer who balanced the books. Howard was a Fabian who reassured everyone, scared no one, but went steadily in the wrong direction for too long. He clung to power by appeasing his enemies while betraying his supporters and his principles. He showed that democracy has a fatal flaw&#x2014;you must buy votes with promises.' Forbes continued: 'The good, the bad and the awful among Australians politicians,' he said, were, 'Good: Menzies/Fadden, Hawke/Keating, Tony Abbott; bad: the LNP lightweights, such as Peacock, Hewson and Don Chipp; very bad and chaotic: Whitlam/Cairns, Gillard/Rudd/Greens; second worst: Turnbull.' And&#x2014;quoting Viv Forbes&#x2014;the worst Australian government since World War II was John Howard's. Forbes explains: 'I am sure many will be surprised by my assessment of the Howard era. Howard was a consummate politician&#x2014;he knew how to win and keep power without frightening the electorate, but had few political scruples or guiding principles. Property rights and freedom to trade were no obstacles to him. He introduced retrospective legislation, levied the fringe benefits tax on the wrong people because he was scared of the unions and invented the GST in a messy form to get Democrat support. He started the carbon wars by implementing the UN Kyoto protocol, and conspired with the states to steal property rights from farmers to achieve the UN Kyoto targets. He concentrated power in Canberra and ratified the UN handcuffs fashioned by Keating in UN Agenda 21. Many great anti-industry "industries" were established or boosted on Howard's watch. They were based on "saving" icons like the Great Barrier Reef, Murray-Darling Basin, forests, wetlands and world heritage.'</p><p>Forbes continued: 'Howard also managed to disarm law-abiding Australians and then wastefully destroyed the thousands of confiscated small arms that Australia will surely need one day.' Forbes said: 'I remember seeing pictures of British soldiers during World War II training with broomsticks and then the British Home Guard being supplied with sporting rifles donated by private Americans.'</p><p>Forbes said: 'Whitlam would have done far more damage than Howard had he managed to stay in office, but Howard had more time to do more damage, slowly.' That's the end of my quote from Forbes.</p><p>Now my confession: I originally perceived John Howard as one of the best Australian prime ministers. I now admit my mistake. After 20 years thorough research, I agree with Viv Forbes. Although the Liberal-National government from 1996 to 2007 had Australia's worst Prime Minister, it contained redeeming MPs, including Peter Costello, who skilfully rode the resources boom; Nick Minchin; John Anderson; Bronwyn Bishop; Kevin Andrews; Russell Broadbent; Ross Cameron; and Brendan Nelson.</p><p>Despite these people, Australia's five decades of accelerated demise are due to our deeply troubled democracy slipping from active democracy to passive. People feel hopeless about MPs blindly, corruptly bowing to self-serving personal and party agendas, harming the people and our country. Both parts of the uniparty, Labor and Liberal, are saying they're the parties of government. Yet look around at Australia in decline. That's what you lot, the self-proclaimed so-called parties of government, are inflicting on Australians.</p><p>Some of us One Nation MPs have dirty fingernails. We're from the real world and proud of it. In my case, I was working at 15 and later worked as a vineyard labourer, in restaurants, at the coalface in underground mines around Australia and in kitchens. Our country needs government of the people, by real people, for the people&#x2014;people, not party. Please help us restore our country. Be active. Be involved. Be informed. In Australia's Constitution, the people are No. 1 and supposedly in charge. Please get involved. Restore democracy's only true form, active democracy.</p><p>Senate adjourned at 2 1 :11</p> </speech>
</debates>
