<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<debates proof="1">
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.3.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.3.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Meeting </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.3.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="speech" time="10:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As there is no objection, the meetings are authorised.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.4.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.4.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Social Security and Other Legislation Amendment (Technical Changes No. 2) Bill 2026; Third Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7515" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7515">Social Security and Other Legislation Amendment (Technical Changes No. 2) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.4.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="10:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill be now read a third time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bill read a third time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.5.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7448" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7448">Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="1826" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.5.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="10:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise on behalf of the coalition to contribute to the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026. The coalition will support the passage of this legislation, but that, of course, is following the amendments that were made to it in the House of Representatives.</p><p>Australia faces increasingly sophisticated threats from money laundering, organised crime, scams and terrorism financing. These threats, as we know, are evolving, but, more so, they are growing rapidly. Criminal organisations are becoming more technologically sophisticated, more internationally connected and more proficient at exploiting weaknesses in our financial systems. Our legislative and regulatory frameworks must therefore be capable and ever more capable of responding as effectively as possible to these mounting threats. Where there are gaps in those legislative and regulatory frameworks, the parliament therefore has a duty to act. In principle, that is why the coalition now supports the fundamental objectives of this bill.</p><p>However, supporting the objectives of legislation, such as this, did not mean that we were going to accept every element of the design of the original form of this particular piece of legislation, nor did it mean giving the government a blank cheque to expand regulatory powers without ensuring that those powers were appropriately targeted, proportionate and subject to proper safeguards. These were the most basic of the tenets that guided the coalition's approach when we were assessing this legislation, and they were also the reasons that we insisted that the bill before us should be subject to detailed examination before it came to the Senate.</p><p>One of the most significant challenges that the content of this bill seeks to address is the increasing exploitation of emerging financial technologies by criminal organisations. A particularly striking example of that trend has been the extraordinary proliferation of cryptocurrency ATMs across Australia. In 2019, there were just 23 cryptocurrency ATMs operating in Australia. Today, that number has grown to more than 2,000. Obviously, that is an extraordinary increase, especially over such a short timeframe. While cryptocurrency and other emerging financial technologies also have perfectly legitimate uses, there is growing evidence that certain facets of them are being exploited by criminals on a worryingly wide scale. AUSTRAC has identified that approximately 85 per cent of frequent cryptocurrency ATM transactions are actually associated with scams or money-mule activity. That is a finding that should represent a concern to all of us, not least because these transactions typically take the form of sophisticated criminal operations preying on innocent, unsuspecting, ordinary Australians. It is no exaggeration to say that they have many times ended in people actually losing their life savings or, at the very least, substantial sums of money.</p><p>These kinds of financial infrastructure can also make it easier for nefarious individuals to launder the proceeds of other serious offences. We know, for example, that Australian banks recently closed around 22,000 money-mule accounts in a single 12-month period. That figure alone provides an indication of the scale of the challenge facing our financial institutions and law enforcement agencies in this space. Indeed, the criminal exploitation of these new financial channels is not some marginal or theoretical issue. Instead, it is a significant and growing problem that demands an active and effective response. Accordingly, the coalition recognises the importance of providing AUSTRAC with appropriate powers to respond quickly to high-risk financial mechanisms. We will also support measures that genuinely and sensibly strengthen Australia's counterterrorism financing laws.</p><p>However, in our consideration of this bill, the question before us has not just been whether those additional kinds of powers are desirable. It has also been about how those powers are conceived and then implemented. In that context, our most fundamental concern in examining the original content of this bill was related to the new and sweeping set of powers that was going to be vested in the chief executive officer of AUSTRAC. Those powers had substantial potential impacts on businesses, financial services and other participants in the Australian economy. We were particularly uneasy about the delegation of those powers away from the minister, especially as concepts such as 'significant harm' and 'the public interest' were not defined, in our view, with sufficient clarity and precision. In short, there were accordingly a number of serious questions for us about how the powers would actually operate in practice. That included questions about the extent to which AUSTRAC would or would not need to consult with affected parties, especially as there were provisions enabling consultation to be bypassed in certain circumstances. There were also other provisions that meant that failures by AUSTRAC to comply with consultation requirements might not necessarily invalidate those decisions.</p><p>The coalition, of course, does not oppose the existence of strong powers to combat serious financial crime. We recognise that regulators and law enforcement agencies must have a range of tools at their disposal in order to respond to sophisticated and rapidly evolving criminal threats. But the fundamental point here is that these tools must be accompanied by commonsense application. Strong powers and strong safeguards are not competing objectives. They should actually be complementary features of effective legislation. In fact, it will almost always be the case that powers that are carefully defined and subject to appropriate oversight will better command public confidence and will operate more effectively over the longer term than powers that are devised in a more ad hoc form.</p><p>That is why the coalition considers it essential that the original legislation be examined through a parliamentary committee inquiry. The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security provided an important forum for testing the government's proposals as well as examining their practical consequences. It also gave industry representatives, consumer groups and other stakeholders an opportunity to express their concerns directly to the parliament. That scrutiny was not an unnecessary impediment to reform. It was an essential part of getting the reform right.</p><p>To add to that, our concerns about the original bill needed to be understood against the broader background of the Albanese government's approach to anti-money-laundering legislation and regulation. That's because, sadly, the Albanese government has an atrocious record when it comes to introducing major regulatory changes. When it comes to this bill, the anti-money-laundering changes legislated in 2024&#x2014;including the substantial expansion of the regime commonly referred to as tranche 2&#x2014;provide a particularly important and relevant example. As the coalition warned repeatedly, even from the time those changes were in their infancy, they have subsequently come to impose new major obligations on thousands of Australian businesses&#x2014;and, sadly, poorly designed and poorly implemented new obligations at that.</p><p>In particular, legal practices, accounting firms conveyancers and real estate businesses have all now faced the prospect of implementing incredibly complex compliance arrangements, often with little previous experience of operating under the anti-money-laundering framework. Overwhelmingly, the most affected entities have not been large corporations with extensive regulatory and compliance departments; they have been small and medium enterprises. They also typically operate in regional communities. And, like other enterprises right across the country, they already face a raft of stifling regulatory and administrative pressures. Yet they are now being expected to implement new risk assessment, anti-money-laundering programs, compliance arrangements, staff training, customer due diligence processes, suspicious-matter reporting systems and&#x2014;wait for it; there's still more&#x2014;additional record keeping obligations.</p><p>What wasn't recognised by the government, despite the fact that this was raised by businesses and by the coalition at the time, was that these new responsibilities have involved additional cost, additional administrative burdens and far-reaching legal complexity&#x2014;not to mention, when you talk to these businesses that are now struggling under the burden of the additional regulatory compliance, considerable anxiety and annoyance. Indeed, the government's own impact analysis estimated the additional regulatory burden associated with its broader anti-money-laundering reforms at a staggering $13.9 billion over 10 years. Naturally nobody, other than the criminals themselves, would seriously dispute the need to prevent people from exploiting legitimate businesses and professional services. However, there is a Grand-Canyon-like gulf, or difference, between imposing necessary, proportionate safeguards and creating an excessively burdensome compliance regime that captures law-abiding businesses without sufficient regard for the practical consequences that these businesses are now feeling.</p><p>Those concerns are not confined to the financial cost. One of the most troubling aspects of the government's earlier reforms was the extent to which businesses were expected to prepare for substantial new obligations before much of the practical detail had been settled by the government. Since the passage of the 2024 changes, AUSTRAC has repeatedly amended and then had to clarify its guidance. As recently as August and September this year, further guidance was still being issued or updated on matters including real estate, professional services, customer due diligence and reporting timeframes. That is absolutely unacceptable. Businesses should not have been expected to make major investments in compliance systems while essential elements of the rules that they are required to follow were still being clarified, if not written, nor should they have been expected to absorb unnecessary costs because the government had failed to adequately sequence the implementation of what is a substantial regulatory change.</p><p>There is a fundamental principle here. It is a responsibility of government to make the rules clear, workable and proportionate before expecting people to comply. The coalition's concerns about this bill were therefore, sadly, informed in part by those earlier experiences. We do not want to see another round of significant regulatory changes in relation to anti money laundering introduced without adequate consideration of their practical consequences. Within that general setting, the scrutiny undertaken by the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security was particularly valuable. The committee process reinforced the coalition's view that the original bill required amendments to at least two important aspects. The first concerned the proposed new powers of the AUSTRAC chief executive officer. The second major issue concerned the timing of the commencement of certain measures. The coalition therefore advocated amendments to address both sets of matters. I am pleased to say that the government listened to the coalition and addressed the legislation. That is why we are now in a position to support the legislation.</p><p>We need to get the balance right. The bill is rightly directed towards protecting Australians from scams, disrupting organised crime and strengthening our national security. However, its original composition, sadly, like so much that this government sloppily puts on the table, could have been better. The coalition is therefore pleased to have aired out what were our very legitimate concerns, insisted on appropriate scrutiny and advocated for changes to positively address those concerns. Ultimately, the measure of legislation like this is not simply the number of additional powers it creates. It is whether those powers actually help stop criminals, protect Australians and strengthen our national security, all without imposing unnecessary burdens on those who are doing the right thing. It is on that basis&#x2014;that the government did accept the coalition's amendments to the legislation&#x2014;that we are now in a position to support the bill. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="480" approximate_wordcount="1006" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.6.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="speech" time="10:17" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise in support of the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026 as chair of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, which reviewed this bill.</p><p>It starts with a phone call out of the blue&#x2014;the caller says that they're from the bank, the police or the tax office&#x2014;or it's a new friend online. The message is always the same: 'Your money is at risk. Act now. Withdraw cash. Go to the local service station down the road, go to the supermarket or go to your local tobacconist. Feed it into a machine in the corner. Scan the code, and everything will be fine.' But it won't be. It is not fine. Within minutes, that money is converted into cryptocurrency and sent to a criminal's wallet&#x2014;sent offshore&#x2014;and is rarely seen again. That machine is a crypto ATM. The Minister for Home Affairs has said:</p><p class="italic">Australia has the highest number of CATMs&#x2014;</p><p>crypto ATMs&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">in the region, and the third highest in the world.</p><p>Our committee heard deeply concerning evidence. Australians over 50 account for more than 70 per cent of crypto ATM transactions by value and people aged 60 to 70 for nearly 30 per cent. These are our parents and grandparents. When an AUSTRAC taskforce examined 90 of the 100 most prolific users, it estimated around 85 per cent of their transactions were the proceeds of scams or mule activity. Industry questions that finding, and the committee weighed its evidence. But the AFP warns that reported losses are only the tip of the iceberg because many victims are too ashamed to come forward.</p><p>This bill delivers on the commitment that the minister made in the National Press Club in October last year to crack down on money laundering through high-risk mechanisms, particularly crypto ATMs. Schedule 1 creates a power to restrict or prohibit reporting entities from using a high-risk mechanism, such as a product, service or delivery channel, where it is causing or likely to cause significant harm in action and where it is in the public interest. Restrictions can be targeted or, where warranted, a mechanism can be prohibited outright. Breaches carry civil penalties of up to $33 million for companies.</p><p>Such a power must be used carefully and accountably. Of the committee's 11 recommendations, three go to its design, and the government accepted all three, amending the bill in the other place. The power will now be exercised by the responsible minister on advice from the AUSTRAC CEO, so decisions are accountable to this parliament. The minister must set out the consultation undertaken, and, because businesses are already absorbing obligations that begin on 1 July, schedule 1 will commence on 1 July 2027.</p><p>Schedule 2 aligns the definition of financing of terrorism with the state sponsors of terrorism offences this parliament passed last year. Australia lists one state sponsor of terrorism, and that is Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Earlier this year, our committee reviewed that listing, and we received more than 180 submissions. Many were from Iranian Australians who showed extraordinary courage in coming forward. We proudly back that listing. As I said then, no Australian should accept foreign state directed terrorism on our streets. In fact, this government has sanctioned more than 200 Iranian individuals and entities, and more than 100 of them have been linked to the IRGC. These measures are not symbolic. This bill just adds another measure, which is following the money.</p><p>ASIO has assessed that the Iranian regime directed the firebombing of the Adas Israel Synagogue in my home city of Melbourne. As the minister said at the time, Australia was attacked and Australia was harmed. And the threat has not gone away. Last month, ASIO confirmed that Iranian intelligence operatives had targeted journalist Sharri Markson, a prominent Jewish journalist on News24. Over two months, they posed as a former US official, using a hijacked account to lure her to a fake meeting with researchers from a Washington think tank. It is alleged that they gained access to her personal files. ASIO says that she was targeted for her media profile, her support for Israel and her criticism of the Islamic regime.</p><p>Former Victorian Liberal president Michael Kroger was also on the same target list because of his support for the State of Israel and the Jewish community in Australia. ASIO detected the operation and warned him before his accounts were compromised. Broadcaster Erin Molan also told the media that ASIO had informed her that she was the third Australian targeted after she had clicked a fake meeting link from someone posing as a US think tank expert. In Melbourne, Dr Minoo Ghamari, a dentist and someone who I know and have known for a little while now and one of the regime's most outspoken critics, was branded as a traitor on a portal used by regime loyalists to monitor critics abroad. Her photo and workplace were published, and graphic death threats followed. What was her crime? It was organising rallies and lobbying for the IRGC to be listed as a terrorist organisation.</p><p>Other Iranian Australians have also been targeted in the same way, and it is very clear that this is transnational repression. It has no place in Australia or in our society. The Director-General of Security has warned that Iran sees Australia as a legitimate target for covertly directed acts of violence, including arson, vandalism and even assassination. Every one of these operations needs money to run, and financing that kind of terrorism must be treated as terrorism financing.</p><p>I want to thank my committee colleagues across the parliament for their bipartisan approach, thank the secretariat and thank everyone who gave evidence which resulted in the bill before the Senate today. Criminals will always look for the weakest point in our system, and this bill ensures that we have the tools to close it so that their next phone call doesn't end with someone's life savings disappearing into a machine at the local service station. I commend this bill to the Senate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="1969" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.7.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="10:25" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise on behalf of the Greens to speak to the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026. In 2024, the Greens backed in tranche 2 laws to counterterrorism financing, and we backed them in on the assumption that they'd be implemented in good faith. We backed them in on the assumption that Australians' personal data would be protected, and we backed them in on the basis that the world needs to coordinate in this space to deal with, in particular, counterterrorism financing and money laundering. We remain committed to those projects. Bringing lawyers, real estate agents and accountants into the regime keeps dirty money out of housing, and the Greens will be consistent in doing that.</p><p>But, of course, it's being implemented by the Australian Labor Party, and you just can't trust them with anything, can you? Australians' data has been being supplied through to AUSTRAC since 1 July. Critical data about their personal lives, their finances and their real estate deals&#x2014;some of the most important data&#x2014;is being fed into AUSTRAC, as it should be, to test for money laundering and to test for whether or not it's been potentially diverted for terrorism. It's a good scheme. It's good legislation. What does Labor do? They tell AUSTRAC to enter into a contract with this US bottom feeder called Palantir, a notorious pro-fascist, far-right data-harvesting company owned by some of the nastiest people on the planet, to review that data. Every time you give this mob a chance, they'll sell out Australians' data, they'll sell out our sovereignty, and they'll sell it out to US interests like this. It is extraordinary. I'll speak a little more on that in a moment.</p><p>So of course we're going to closely review any further legislation put forward by Labor in this space. What do these changes propose to do? They put in place a new ban power. The minister, after getting advice from AUSTRAC, can restrict or ban any 'product, service, delivery channel or thing'&#x2014;'thing' is a fairly broad term&#x2014;used by a business that AUSTRAC regulates. Of course, the rationale for this legislation is crypto ATMs. Crypto ATMs are the most obvious target. They operate in plain sight, you can identify where they are, there are a couple thousand of them across the country, and they have really grown like mushrooms across the place. The clear need at the moment in the anti-money-laundering space is to actually ban crypto ATMs. Just legislate a national ban on crypto ATMs. But, instead, this government comes in with this broad, hard-to-understand power that may lead&#x2014;may lead&#x2014;to the banning or regulation of crypto ATMs. It is a restriction or a ban on any 'product, service, delivery channel or thing'. The Greens say that this legislation should have been clear and targeted and should expressly ban crypto ATMs.</p><p>The bill also has a wider definition of terrorism financing. The definition picks up last year's 'state sponsors of terrorism' offences, and we know that that's focused primarily on Iran. It also lets the government add sanctions offences by regulation without coming back to parliament. The Greens believe there should be parliamentary scrutiny. It's important, but we note the rationale for those amendments and the intent to have common terms across this part of Commonwealth regulation.</p><p>The legislation also puts in place changes to when banks and other businesses must recheck or review their customers. They currently do so only when issues are raised about a customer's information. Under this bill, however, there's a requirement to do so where there are reasonable grounds for suspicion. How that is intended to work in practice is not clear and hasn't been fully explained by the government, and I will touch on some of the very real concerns that members of the Australian community have been having about the way largely unregulated banks and financial institutions are debanking Australians without any fair review.</p><p>The Greens don't oppose this bill, but we want to make it absolutely clear that the government must to listen to the compelling evidence the committee received about the scam nature of crypto ATMs and about older Australians with less financial capacity being more vulnerable to online scams. It's older Australians who are being scammed by crypto ATMs. They're being targeted by international organisations that see weaknesses in regulation across the globe and go looking for countries where they can find weak governments, weak regulation and wealth. They've done that here in relation to crypto ATMs, with Australia's weak federal legislation, weak government and vulnerable Australians being targeted. Crypto ATMs are a scam pipeline that hurts mostly older Australians. We should just ban these crypto ATMs in the bill. Instead, this bill gives the minister an incredibly broad discretion that's less clear and less useful than what should be done here: a clear and direct ban.</p><p>We also have concerns that these measures, taken together, will lead to a risk of increasingly unfair debanking amongst members of the Australian community. This has been a particular problem for the Iranian-Australian community, but we know there are multiple communities that have faced this debanking problem without fair reviews, without rationale and without anywhere to go when they have an issue with the way a bank debanks them.</p><p>While we can see some rationale for the 'reasonable grounds' change, without clear regulatory oversight it risks increasing surveillance by banks of their customers without any clear review or consumer rights. It does seem a sensible reform to include a reasonable-grounds review, but we're concerned about how that will play out in practice with an absent regulator, without consumer protections and without clear review processes.</p><p>This would be a good moment to consider how Palantir has got its claws into yet another Commonwealth agency. Palantir has been contracted with AUSTRAC since 2017. In case anyone has forgotten who Palantir is, it is a hard-right, neofascist corporation from the US whose name actually comes from the all-seeing stones used by Sauron in <i>The Lord of the Rings</i>. They chose a particularly all-seeing power to name their company after and&#x2014;surprise, surprise&#x2014;it turns out they're an evil global company. They've said that their goal in the US culture wars is to help the US military and to always put US interests ahead of those of any other country on the planet. They've also said they have a hard-right political agenda that they want to implement globally with the cooperation and support of the US government and the US military wherever they can.</p><p>That's Palantir: a noxious US firm that has clearly stated that it wants to engage in a global culture war on behalf of the US and the US military. So what does the coalition government do? Enter into contracts with Palantir in 2017 through AUSTRAC, and the Labor government has continued it. Palantir is now AUSTRAC's biggest technology supplier. In April this year, under Labor, Palantir got another $5.06 million contract from AUSTRAC without even going to open tender. They just literally invited AUSTRAC in with a closed shop and no competitive tender.</p><p>Since 1 July, AUSTRAC has been receiving reports from real estate agents, lawyers, accountants and conveyancers about millions of Australians who are buying homes, setting up businesses and getting legal help, and that information is being fed into Palantir's platforms. Did I mention Palantir is a US far-right neo-fascist corporation who's openly said this? That's who this government is feeding Australia's data into. When we asked the government if this anti-money-laundering counterterrorism financing data was going to Palantir, they very clearly said yes. They said yes. They're proud of it.</p><p>This bill expands AUSTRAC powers and widens the terrorism net, which means more data flowing into Palantir systems. Did I mention they are a hard-right neo-fascist corporation owned by US billionaires who are putting US interests ahead of ours? Did I mention that, in case no-one's heard it? Another contract with Palantir from Labor&#x2014;this substantially reduces trust and public buy-in into what are critically important reforms. We supported these reforms in 2024 because there's a need to crack down on money laundering and counterterrorism, and then Labor implement it with their mates in Palantir. You can't make this stuff up. Australians' financial data should sit on systems under Australian control and not depend upon a US bottom-feeder surveillance company owned by neo-fascists. That seems pretty simple, and our ask in this regard is simple: put every future AUSTRAC data contract to a genuinely open tender and get Palantir out of AUSTRAC and out of every single government agency. That's why I move the second reading amendment to this bill that's been circulated. I move:</p><p class="italic">At the end of the motion, add ", but the Senate:</p><p class="italic">(a) notes:</p><p class="italic">(i) that:</p><p class="italic">(A) the Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC) has relied on Palantir since 2017,</p><p class="italic">(B) Palantir is now AUSTRAC's largest technology supplier, and</p><p class="italic">(C) in April 2026 AUSTRAC awarded Palantir a further $5.06 million contract after inviting only Palantir to bid; and</p><p class="italic">(ii) community concern that the vast amount of personal information collected for anti-money laundering purposes (which since 1 July 2026 includes reports from real estate agents, lawyers, accountants and conveyancers) is being fed into Palantir's platforms; and</p><p class="italic">(b) calls on the Government to put any future AUSTRAC data contracts to genuinely open tender and to develop a plan to move AUSTRAC off Palantir and onto systems under full Australian control".</p><p>I commend that second reading amendment to the Senate.</p><p>I did indicate our concern for the way in which Australians&#x2014;it's been particularly hard against Iranian Australians and Iranian Australian businesses&#x2014;from across many multicultural communities have been being increasingly debanked by their financial institutions. I want to give particular credit to some of the work that was being done by SBS to pull together some of the stories about how Iranian Australians have been debanked simply because they've got a business that might involve some financial transactions with people or businesses in Iran. Of course, if there's any evidence that it's going towards the Iranian regime or going towards money laundering or in any way involved with the IRGC, there is clear legislation and clear intent to ban that kind of transaction. The Greens were the party who first called for sanctions against the IRGC, and, a couple of years later, the government came on board and did it. But what we are seeing across the Iranian Australian community is legitimate businesses that have been operating for years getting a message from their bank saying: 'We're shutting down your account. We're shutting down'&#x2014;basically&#x2014;'your business, because you've been flagged as being a risk or a commercial risk under anti-money-laundering laws.' When businesses are challenging it and saying, 'Hang on, what's the risk here? We've been operating for years. Tell us the customer that's a concern,' they just get a blank wall. When they then complain to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority hears the complaint and then says:</p><p class="italic">What we are not able to look at is to go behind what are the commercial or business reasons &#x2026; why a particular person may have been told the bank isn't going to offer them services anymore &#x2026;</p><p>So the Australian Financial Complaints Authority says, 'Well, we can't challenge the bank's commercial decisions,' and people's businesses have been destroyed&#x2014;at scale.</p><p>There needs to be an independent review in this space. There needs to be some government agency that can look behind these banks that are just arbitrarily debanking people and shutting people's businesses down. This needs to be joined-up policy. Let's be clear about this: if you have an issue&#x2014;as the Greens do&#x2014;with scam ATMs from cryptos, ban them. Let's get Palantir out of AUSTRAC, and let's give people with legitimate businesses a real remedy when they get debanked.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="600" approximate_wordcount="1204" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.8.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" speakername="Richard Dowling" talktype="speech" time="10:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Just metres from the front door of my electorate office in Tasmania stands a cryptocurrency ATM, and most people walk straight past it. But, for someone being manipulated by a scammer, it could be the final stop before their life savings disappear. In September, Tasmania Police revealed that, over a three-month period earlier this year, Tasmanians lost more than $1.5 million through scams involving cryptocurrency ATMs. In 2021, Tasmania had just one of these cryptocurrency machines. By September this year, we had 28 of them&#x2014;28 across a small state, up from just one.</p><p>Police also found that some victims were directed to these machines after their banks had questioned suspicious transfers. Think about that. A bank spots the warning signs. A criminal finds another way around these safeguards. A person is told their savings are at risk, that a loved one urgently needs help, that an investment opportunity will disappear if they hesitate, and they're pressured to withdraw cash and feed it into a machine. Money built up over decades can be gone in minutes. That is not stupidity; that is calculated exploitation, and the responsibility belongs to the criminal, not to the victim.</p><p>This is an issue that I care deeply about. In my first speech in this place, I spoke about financial literacy and why it needs to be treated as an essential life skill&#x2014;because understanding money isn't a luxury. It shapes whether someone can pay their bills, manage debt, avoid exploitation, buy a home and retire with dignity. We expect Australians to navigate increasingly complex financial products, yet too often we expect them to learn by making mistakes they cannot afford. That is why I co-chair the Parliamentary Friends of Financial Capability group. We launched this non-partisan friendship group in August, bringing together parliamentarians, educators, researchers, community organisations, regulators and industry. Our purpose is straightforward: to turn good ideas and existing programs into better financial outcomes for Australians at every stage of life.</p><p>Financial literacy is knowing how money works. Financial capability is having the skills and confidence to put that knowledge into practice. It means understanding interest before signing a loan, knowing where your superannuation goes and recognising the signs of a scam&#x2014;and feeling confident enough to stop, ask questions and seek advice. That starts in the classroom, but it cannot end when we leave school. Just this month, education ministers from across Australia agreed to strengthen financial literacy in our national curriculum. Changes to the early-years mathematics curriculum will build stronger foundations in consumer and financial literacy, with further work to extend this focus into years 3 to 6. This is significant progress, and I welcome it. But financial capability is bigger than what happens in the classroom. It is something we need to build throughout our lives, and it requires a shared effort from government, industry, educators and the community.</p><p>The evidence shows how far we have to go. Last year, the Ecstra Foundation surveyed 2,123 Australian students, parents and teachers. Just 20 per cent of students said they had learnt about scams in school. That's one in five who've learned about scams in school. That's not good enough. Only 12 per cent said they had learnt about digital financial products such as cryptocurrency, yet 70 per cent of students said they'd used social media to learn about money. Think about that. Young Australians are increasingly turning to social media for financial information, but many have not been taught the basics of how to assess what they are being told. These aren't obscure, specialist topics. They are basic survival skills in a digital economy. We teach road safety before young people start driving; we should teach financial safety before they begin making decisions that can affect their entire lives.</p><p>Education cannot carry this burden alone. Scammers are organised; they manipulate fear, love, trust and urgency. Even well-informed people can be caught by a convincing lie. Good financial education helps someone recognise the danger, good regulation makes it harder for the criminal to exploit it, and the national evidence demands action. AUSTRAC estimated that almost 150,000 cryptocurrency ATM transactions take place each year, moving around $275 million. When AUSTRAC and law enforcement examined 90 of the most frequent users, 85 per cent were scam victims or money mules who'd been tricked or coerced into moving money. People aged 50 to 70 accounted for almost 72 per cent of transaction values through these machines. Think about what is at stake for someone approaching retirement. The loss of their savings can mean selling a home, delaying retirement or depending on family for help. The financial loss is terrible; the loss of confidence and independence can last even longer.</p><p>Cryptocurrency ATMs are only just part of the picture. In 2025, Australians made more than 481,000 scam reports across major reporting organisations. Reported losses reached $2.18 billion That is an extraordinary amount of money, and behind every dollar is a person, a family or a business dealing with the consequences. That brings me to the legislation before us. This Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026 gives the responsible minister, after seeking and considering AUSTRAC's advice, the power to restrict or prohibit high-risk mechanisms used to provide financial services. These powers can be exercised where the use of a mechanism has caused or is likely to cause significant harm to the community or financial system and intervention is necessary in the public interest. This means the government can respond where mechanisms such as crypto ATMs present unacceptable risks. Indeed, the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security specifically recommended that restrictions or prohibitions on cryptocurrency ATMs be considered as a priority.</p><p>This legislation gives us the tools to respond to that risk. The bill also updates terrorism financing provisions and fixes practical issues in the anti-money-laundering framework. Importantly, this is not a blanket ban on cryptocurrency. Innovation does have a legitimate and important place in our financial system, and so do strong safeguards. The legislation provides for consultation, transparency and parliamentary scrutiny. The new high-risk mechanism powers are scheduled to commence on 1 July 2027 giving affected businesses time to prepare. We should want a financial system that embraces technology without giving criminals a free pass, and we should want financial capability to sit alongside these reforms, not to be treated as an afterthought. Give people the knowledge to make decisions, give regulators the tools to respond, and give criminals fewer options to exploit people. A scammer does not know how somebody votes. They do not care what their victim earns, where they live or how hard they've worked. They want the money; that's all. No party owns the responsibility to protect Australians from financial crime. It belongs to every one of us. This bill deserves the support of the Senate not because of who introduced it but because of the people who it seeks to protect. I want Australians to be financially capable, confident and secure. I want young people equipped before they make major decisions. I want older Australians to enjoy their savings and not lose them to criminals. Education is essential. Protection is essential. We cannot choose one and ignore the other. I commend this bill to the Senate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="751" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.9.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" speakername="Tyron Whitten" talktype="speech" time="10:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I foreshadow my second reading amendment. The issue with the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026 is the issue that we have had with so many Labor bills. It is not a bill to address a particular problem. All of the chatter around this bill talks about crypto ATMs being a menace to society, but the bill doesn't legislate against crypto ATMs. Instead, what it does is hand sweeping powers to the minister to designate anything that they believe may cause serious harm as a high risk mechanism and prohibit or restrict its use. That is where the issues with this bill lie. That is the pattern we see out of Labor. It is lazy politics, and it is potentially dangerous politics.</p><p>Any time that you see legislation with these sorts of broad powers, you shouldn't consider it from the perspective of what you would do with those powers. Of course you would use it wisely and judiciously. Instead, think about what those powers would look like in the hands of someone with malintent. Legislation isn't there just to regulate what the public can do. It is there to protect the public against government intervention in their lives. These powers can be invoked immediately and can only be disallowed during a parliamentary sitting. Imagine a minister banning a platform that you use vexatiously, locking up your investments or cutting you off from banking. If they did that on a Thursday next week, it could be overturned until February next year. And that's if you can make sure you have the numbers to disallow it in the first place.</p><p>Under this bill, the minister can ban what they like with no consultation for up to six months. Labor loves this sort of legislation. Businesses and Australians don't. How can we expect investment and growth in Australia when we continue to make laws that aren't rules? Who would want to play a game where the referee can change the rules at any point? This bill has the potential to sweep up perfectly legitimate businesses without the ability for parliament to properly scrutinise before it comes into effect. There are times during the year where parliament won't have the ability to overturn bad ministerial decisions for months. I know that Labor is critically short of real-world experience. They don't seem to understand that shutting down a business for months at a time is a death sentence.</p><p>There were some protections included in this bill for businesses and public. There is a mandatory consultation period of 30 days that must be undertaken. However, in typical Labor style, there is, of course, a shortcut. If they choose to skip the consultation process due to urgency, they can only keep their injunctions in for six months. Once again, that is long enough to crush businesses and make them think twice before they invest in Australia.</p><p>The worst part of this bill is that we have many recommendations and concerns by parliamentary committees ignored in the final bill. The scrutiny committee in particular had issues with the fact that the consultation period could be ignored. This isn't just One Nation saying this. Parliamentary committees are seeing the potential danger of having these powers vested in the hands of a minister with little in the way of safeguards. The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security made six recommendations that it wanted to see before this bill was passed. There is no evidence that recommendation 4 was taken into account to provide additional clarity on the wording in the explanatory memorandum.</p><p>We don't want to see more powers in the hands of ministers that could have such major impacts on Australians lives. We want to make sure that all legislation is proportional and that safeguards are in place. Most of all, we need to have certainty in this country. We need to ensure that the people know the rules and can work within reasonable limits. This bill does not achieve that. It falls short of the expectation of Australians that the government lays out properly formulated and coherent rules for business. We will see more of this during this sitting. The government will push through more ministerial control and uncertainty. This needs to stop if we're going to see Australia and its economy get back on track. Now, don't be mistaken in thinking that what I've just said means we support scammers or criminals. We don't. But we expect the government of the day to govern appropriately.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="812" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.10.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" speakername="Barbara Pocock" talktype="speech" time="10:54" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise to speak to the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026. We in the Greens don't oppose this bill, and I associate myself with the comments of my colleague Senator Shoebridge, who has canvassed a range of issues and concerns about the bill. I want to focus on two particular issues: one is the nature of the contract let by AUSTRAC in relation to this work, and the second is the process by which contracts are let by this government.</p><p>We don't oppose this bill, because we know we've got to keep dirty money out of housing, out of financial transactions. There's a lot of bad money floating around the world, doing great damage, undermining the integrity of financial systems and real estate transactions. It is vital that we have regulation to ensure that the damage is minimised and that organisations are held to account. Australia's financial data is supplied through AUSTRAC, as it should, to test for money laundering. We think that's a good idea. Our concern is with who is getting access to this data and the process of the contracts to let it.</p><p>We've heard Senator Shoebridge describe Palantir. It is notorious around the globe for its pro-fascist, open political agenda. It's a corporation, a company, a contractor, a consultant with a clear political agenda to influence politics in the worst right-wing ways we can possibly see. It's a contractor to the US government in its ICE raids on its citizens. My concern is with Palantir and the fact that we are, through this contract from AUSTRAC into Palantir, creating the potential for data harvesting by one of the most pernicious organisations in the world of contracting. Australia has entered into a large contract, and Palantir will have access to that data.</p><p>Palantir has its claws in our information&#x2014;information about the financial transactions of Australian citizens&#x2014;and we should be worried. We should be worried about that because this is a company that cannot be trusted. It's hard right in its politics, as I said. It cannot be trusted with this information, and the goal it has is always oriented to the interests of the US and particularly oriented to the right-wing, pro-fascist interests of the US and its politics. It's a corporation with a political agenda, and it should not have access to our information. Anyone who is holding or has access to Australian citizens' information in relation to financial transactions or other data should be a platform based in our country&#x2014;an Australian supplier.</p><p>Palantir is engaged in a global culture war, and it has been completely open about its transactions, its political intentions and its active involvement in politics around the globe. We know that our transaction data are being fed into this company, and we're seeing an expansion of Palantir's scope through AUSTRAC's contracting. Public buy-in by a big, US, politically active company into this data is dangerous. It is wrong, and we should not be allowing this.</p><p>Most importantly, in any such process we need to have an open tender, at the very minimum. If you think about the amount of attention that this Senate and the current Labor government over the last term and this one have put into trying to improve the integrity of procurement and then if you look at the nature of this contract, you can see what a failed effort that procurement improvement has been. This is a contract let to this notorious right-wing agency at over $5 million without any tender. What sort of procurement process is that? There is no integrity, and there are real dangers. We need to make sure that we push for the open tender of any such contract, and we need to make sure, given the political objectives of Palantir&#x2014;the open discussion of its political objectives&#x2014;that Palantir has no role in any Australian contracts.</p><p>They are very strongly contracted into the US immigration enforcement system. They are agents for ICE and the military intelligence operations in both Gaza and Israel. They are a company that we should not be doing business with. They should be out of all of our agencies and government departments. And, in particular, we should be making sure that they have no role in the investment basket that is part of the Future Fund. Palantir currently have up to $165 million invested in them through our sovereign Future Fund. It is entirely wrong given the politics of this company and its failure to have proper probity over its investments.</p><p>It's time we got Palantir out of AUSTRAC, out of Australian data, it's time we have Australian platforms that actually securely manage our data and it's time we make sure that all contracts we give not only don't go to right-wing operatives like Palantir but are properly subjected to the procurement systems that keep our contracts and consultants honest&#x2014;barely.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="660" approximate_wordcount="576" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.11.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="10:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank honourable senators for their contributions to the debate on this bill. The Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026 responds to the continuously changing financial crime environment, which facilitates serious crimes and harms to both Australia's financial system and the community. The bill will empower the minister responsible for the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 to restrict or prohibit high-risk mechanisms being exploited by criminal actors to move money. The bill will also make several technical amendments throughout the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 to ensure reporting entities have clarity when implementing their anti-money-laundering or counterterrorism financing obligations.</p><p>The reforms in this bill signify the Australian government's commitment to preventing the criminal abuse of our economy and the harm and suffering caused to the Australian community. The bill will introduce a new framework enabling the minister to restrict or prohibit a reporting entity from using a high-risk product, service, delivery channel or thing to provide a designated service. The power will support a flexible risk based response to emerging and evolving money-laundering and terrorism-financing risks, ensuring that Australia does not become a harbour for illicit financing. Restrictions or prohibitions will prevent harm being caused to the Australian community.</p><p>The bill also contains amendments to the definition of 'financing of terrorism' to reference new offences in the Criminal Code Act 1995. Further, amendments to the definition will allow new sanctions offences to be prescribed in the future, ensuring Australia unequivocally meets its commitments as a member of the Financial Action Task Force.</p><p>Following the passage of significant anti-money-laundering and counterterrorism financing reforms in 2024, the bill will make technical amendments to concepts introduced by those reforms. These amendments will clarify certain obligations introduced by the reforms, making compliance easier for Australian businesses that have anti-money-laundering and counterterrorism financing obligations.</p><p>I might just briefly address the points that have been made in the debate about Palantir. It is disappointing to see the Greens party are continuing to push mistruths about what is going on here. I understand that the Greens party has a political objective to cause fear in the Australian community about the involvement of Palantir and other external providers. But, as is often the case, the Greens' claims are untrue. AUSTRAC's use of Palantir technology is subject to contractual, privacy, security and data management requirements consistent with Australian government frameworks. These arrangements include access controls, monitoring, audit logging, security requirements and contractual obligations governing how information is handled, accessed and managed. AUSTRAC retains ownership and control of its information and determines how that information is accessed, used and managed. Palantir personnel do not have default access to AUSTRAC information. Any access is governed by contractual security and access control requirements and is limited to approved circumstances. No offshore access is permitted, and AUSTRAC retains ownership and authority over its information and controls access to information held within its environment. The services provided comply with the government's Protective Security Policy Framework and information security manual controls that apply to the protection of data. Any employees or Palantir employees who provide services are subject to strict Australian security clearance obligations.</p><p>In conclusion, these reforms will benefit the Australian community by hardening our response to criminal exploitation by ensuring the minister can restrict or prohibit high-risk mechanisms that enable illicit financing, money laundering and other financial crimes. These reforms will make an important contribution to protecting Australia from serious and organised crime.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.11.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="interjection" time="10:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the second reading amendment moved by Senator Shoebridge be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.12.1" nospeaker="true" time="11:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7448" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7448">Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="11" noes="25" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="no">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="no">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="no">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="540" approximate_wordcount="191" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.13.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" speakername="Tyron Whitten" talktype="speech" time="11:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">At the end of the motion, add ", but the Senate:</p><p class="italic">(a) notes:</p><p class="italic">(i) the broad prohibition powers in this bill around unspecified 'high-risk mechanisms' continues the trend by this Government to hand sweeping powers and discretions to ministers through regulation, rather than through primary legislation that is open to proper debate and scrutiny in Parliament,</p><p class="italic">(ii) the Government has provided crypto-ATM fraud and money-laundering as the reason that these ministerial powers are necessary, however, primary legislation should be targeted at the issue identified, rather than creating broad ministerial powers which cause regulatory uncertainty and that are open to abuse, and</p><p class="italic">(iv) as noted by the Scrutiny of Bills Committee, the bill requires a consultation period before making regulations, however, the regulations are not invalidated where the Minister has not consulted, allowing for the government of the day to create highly consequential regulations without adequate consultation; and</p><p class="italic">(b) calls on the Government to commit to preparing complete legislation to limit regulatory uncertainty and allow for proper parliamentary scrutiny and consultation, as opposed to relying on framework legislation that requires broader powers than necessary in the hands of the minister".</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="23" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.13.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="interjection" time="11:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the amendment moved by Senator Whitten be agreed to.</p><p class="italic"> <i>A division having been called and the bells being rung&#x2014;</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="22" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.13.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" speakername="Sean Bell" talktype="interjection" time="11:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I request there be a four-minute bell to give other people a chance to get to the chamber if they need to.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="11" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.13.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="interjection" time="11:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As there is no objection, we'll move to a four-minute bell.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.14.1" nospeaker="true" time="11:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <bills>
   <bill id="r7448" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7448">Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
  </bills>
  <divisioncount ayes="8" noes="33" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" vote="aye">Pauline Lee Hanson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" vote="aye">Jacqui Lambie</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="no">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="no">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="no">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.15.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026; Third Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7448" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7448">Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.15.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="speech" time="11:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>No amendments to the bill have been circulated. Does any senator require a committee stage? There being no indication, I call the minister to move the third reading.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.16.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="11:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill be now read a third time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bill read a third time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.17.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7516" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7516">Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="1790" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.17.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="11:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise to speak on the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. I have to say that, sadly, this bill is yet another reminder of the extraordinary incompetence with which the former attorney-general, Mark Dreyfus, approached the reform of Australia's administrative review system. Mr Dreyfus, as we know, was determined to abolish the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Sadly, for the Australian people&#x2014;and this has now been borne out in the statistics that we will go through shortly&#x2014;that was a politically driven decision dressed up as administrative reform. But, rather than fixing the existing system, he abolished it and replaced it with an entirely new institution.</p><p>At the time, when he was allocating around $1 billion of taxpayers' money to his new politically driven system, he promised Australians a more accessible, efficient and effective system of administrative review. As I said, he had around $1 billion over five years that he utilised to establish and support the new tribunal and address what he said at that time were associated migration related court backlogs&#x2014;$1 billion of taxpayers' money. I challenge any taxpayer: if you were given $1 billion over a five-year period, what would you do to utilise that? Certainly, it wouldn't be what the former attorney-general ended up doing. With $1 billion of taxpayers' funding, one might say that Australians are entitled to expect a carefully designed, properly resourced and competently implemented reform. Instead, what have Australians got since this reform took place? Well, it was the most expensive changing of one letter. AAT went to ART&#x2014;$1 billion of taxpayers' funds. But this has been the result of what the former attorney-general did: growing backlogs, extraordinary delays and a government now repeatedly having to return to the parliament to repair Mr Dreyfus's failed legislative framework. That is now the legacy of the $1 billion reform.</p><p>The coalition is going to support this bill. Why? Because we believe that Australians need an administrative review system that works. But our support for this legislation should not be mistaken for approval of the way Labor have sadly handled this exercise. Mr Dreyfus designed the new tribunal, Labor implemented it, and the Albanese government must now answer for its abysmal performance. Sadly, it cannot run away from the figures, and those figures are damning. According to the tribunal's 2025-26 annual report, the ART received 86,980 applications during this year, but it only finalised 65,900. By 30 June 2026, it had 133,749 applications on hand. Remember, this is Mr Dreyfus's new whiz-bang tribunal. That was an increase of over 19 per cent from the previous year. In other words, we're not getting any better. The $1 billion dollars of the taxpayer funding that has been allocated to this disastrous reform is getting worse. That was June&#x2014;133,749 applications on hand. Worse than that, a few months later, in September&#x2014;July, August, September, 12 weeks later; you've got to love this&#x2014;the outstanding caseload has actually risen to 136,236 applications. In other words, this new whizz-bang tribunal meant to go back to what was promised&#x2014;carefully designed, properly resourced and competently implemented&#x2014;has now more than 136,000 matters that are awaiting resolution. You can't run away from that because they're the tribunal's own figures. But that is the reality behind Labor's promise of a faster, more efficient tribunal.</p><p>What is even worse&#x2014;and this should worry all taxpayers&#x2014;is that the position is particularly alarming on both migration and protection. At the end of September, the tribunal reportedly had 85,221 migration matters and 34,546 protection matters on hand&#x2014;almost 120,000 outstanding applications, around 88 per cent of the entire backlog&#x2014;and more than 54,000 student visa review matters alone. As I said, you can't run away from these figures, because they're the tabled figures from the Administrative Review Tribunal. They now expose the enormous pressure of Labor's migration failures. They can only be described as failures. If you were doing something positive, you'd actually be going backwards, heading towards zero, in terms of the figures. Sadly, that is not what is actually occurring.</p><p>When it went to a committee, we heard evidence that approximately 90 per cent of protection visa applicants who seek merits review are unsuccessful, while fewer than three per cent of the relevant judicial review applications were allowed in 2024-25. Those figures alone demonstrate why Australians deserve a system capable of resolving matters efficiently and identifying applications without merit. Remember, it's the Australian taxpayer that's paying for these reviews. A review system overwhelmed by delay is failing the people who genuinely need it, but it's also failing the Australian taxpayers, who are paying for it.</p><p>Again, the delays are actually staggering. The tribunal's September quarter figures reportedly show median finalisation times of 64 weeks for migration reviews, 89 weeks for protection reviews and 136 weeks for family and partner visa reviews. Multiply that out. It's 136 weeks. There are 52 weeks in a year. That's more than 2&#xBD; years for the median family and partner matter. How, when you allocated $1 billion of taxpayers' money over five years, can you describe that as timely access to administrative justice?</p><p>So what exactly did Australians receive for the billion dollar redesign? The tribunal's performance against its targets is equally concerning. In 2025-26, it reportedly finalised only 42 per cent of migration and protection matters within 18 months against a target of 75 per cent. So we don't even ask them to reach 100 per cent. We ask them to reach a target of 75 per cent. They miserably failed at that at 42 per cent. Across the tribunal, only 43 per cent of applications finalised during the year were completed within 12 months. The annual report also records that the tribunal was 90.4 full-time-equivalent member positions below its budgeted establishment at 30 June 2026. So you chuck out the system and bring in a new one. You promise the earth to the Australian taxpayers because it's their billion dollars that you're actually utilising. Your completion times go backwards. You have fewer members than you need to actually get the job done. I have to ask the government: how do you expect to reduce the backlog when you've not ensured the tribunal has enough decision-makers to actually make the decisions? Managing demand, recruiting members and ensuring systems are fit for purpose is actually a basic responsibility of government. Sadly, I remember the speeches that were given when the billion dollars of taxpayers' funds were allocated to this new system. The former attorney-general was out there crowing and wanting the political credit for doing this. Well, guess what? If you want the political credit for doing it, the bad news is this: you also have to take the political backlash when the tribunal fails so miserably.</p><p>But it's not only that. It gets worse for the Australian taxpayer. After the original billion-dollar commitment, when it started failing almost immediately, the Labor government had to say to the Australian taxpayer: 'Sorry about that. We know it was a billion dollars we allocated. We know it hasn't quite done the job we thought it would do, but what's worse is we're now going to dip back into your pockets.' They actually provided, via the Australian taxpayer, another $69 million of hard-earned taxpayer funds over two years to address what has now become a disgraceful backlog&#x2014;more money from the Australian taxpayer because the system they implemented was failing. Instead of getting better&#x2014;we gave you another $69 million&#x2014;the system has actually got worse. So the Australian taxpayer is quite entitled to ask, when they are under so much financial pressure at the moment, 'What in God's name have we actually received from this government after it expended our funding?' The bad news for the Australian taxpayer is that you actually receive nothing. You've received nothing but a backlog&#x2014;worse than that, an increasing backlog.</p><p>It's a further indictment of this government that they have now had to come back to the parliament. This is the fourth major legislative repair package that we have had to do on behalf of the taxpayer. The government has had to come, cap in hand, to the Senate yet again, for the fourth time, to clean up the mess that Mr Dreyfus created. You had the original establishment and then the consequential legislation. You had the miscellaneous measures legislation. They had to draft it like that because they couldn't actually call it what it was, which was the 'cleaning up Dreyfus' mess' legislation. There were further amendments again, in 2025, to clean up the mess.</p><p>The tribunal have now recognised that this is still a mess, and they've had to come to the government to say, 'You've got to draft another piece of legislation,' because this is now out of control because the original legislation was politically drafted not properly drafted. The taxpayer's now paying for it. Now, this attorney-general has had to come to the parliament to say, 'Sorry, I've got another bill to clean up Labor's mess'&#x2014;another correction, another adjustment and another attempt to make the system function, as we pointed out at the time, sadly. It wasn't like the Labor government weren't told, 'Your legislation is fundamentally flawed. You need to make amendments to it.' But, at the time, oh no, they knew better than us. They knew better than us because it was politically motivated. It wasn't actually drafted to do the job that the new tribunal was meant to do. Sadly, it's the Australian taxpayer who is paying a very, very high price for the Albanese government's incompetence.</p><p>That is why, as I said, we are prepared to support this legislation. We are prepared to work with the government to clean up the former attorney-general's disgraceful mess. It was Labor who chose to abolish the AAT. Mr Dreyfus designed, incompetently or for political purposes, its replacement. Labor committed the funding. They oversaw the implementation. They now can't resile from the results that are tabled by the new body. They committed around a billion dollars of taxpayer funding over five years. They then took another $69 million from the taxpayer for backlog measures. We currently have around 136,000 applications outstanding and around 120,000 migration and protection matters awaiting resolution. We are now onto the fourth major legislative package to actually deal with the disaster that this new framework has been.</p><p>Sadly, this is the record of the former attorney-general, Mr Dreyfus. As I said, the coalition will support this bill because Australians deserve a tribunal that works. We are pleased the government will put forward amendments suggested by the coalition to make the bill even better. But Labor promised a better tribunal, and sadly, after a billion dollars, all the Australian taxpayer has is growing backlogs and round 4 of fix-up legislation.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="540" approximate_wordcount="1107" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.18.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" speakername="Jana Stewart" talktype="speech" time="11:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise today to speak in support of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. This bill was examined by the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee, which I have the privilege of chairing. I want to thank individuals and organisations who contributed to the inquiry. Their evidence and engagement played a really important role in informing the committee's consideration of the bill and its recommendation that this bill be passed. The evidence before the committee reinforced a simple but important point: government decision-makers must make quality decisions, and merits review and judicial review matter. That is why, two years ago, the Albanese government established the Administrative Review Tribunal.</p><p>Under the former coalition government, more than 80 Liberal and National associates and failed candidates were appointed to the AAT. An institution that should have stood for merit and independence had become tainted. The Albanese government abolished the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, the AAT, because Australians had lost confidence in it and instead legislated a new merit based appointment process. The ART now independently reviews a broad range of government decisions made under over 400 Commonwealth acts, helping to ensure that government power is exercised lawfully, fairly and transparently. Among the matters that the ART can review are certain decisions about visas made by the Department of Home Affairs, the Minister for Home Affairs or the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship. In certain circumstances, individuals can submit an online application through the tribunal's website and ask for the decision to be independently reconsidered based on its merits. This gives applicants the opportunity to explain their circumstances, to provide relevant information and to have their original decision examined through fresh eyes. Together with the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which hears applications for judicial review, these institutions help ensure government decisions can be reviewed properly. Most importantly, these systems help protect individuals and vulnerable community members against unfair or incorrect decisions. This strengthens accountability and promotes public confidence that Commonwealth laws are administered fairly and transparently.</p><p>Recently, there has been an exponential increase in applications to review migration decisions. As this caseload grows, it is especially vital that matters are resolved in a timely and efficient manner. Efficient review procedures are important to reduce delays in decision-making and provide genuine applicants with timely outcomes. That is why this bill is about strengthening Australia's merits and judicial review system to support the ART and the Federal Circuit Family Court of Australia to more effectively respond to their significant and increasing caseloads.</p><p>The first set of reforms in this bill will improve the efficiency and operation of the ART. These reforms include allowing the tribunal to explain their decision orally with written statements of reasons available upon request&#x2014;notably, this change will exclude reviews of social security, veterans' entitlements, aged-care and National Disability Insurance Scheme matters&#x2014;requiring applications to review eligible migration or protection decisions to be submitted using an approved form; giving tribunal members greater flexibility to move between salaried or sessional roles; giving additional powers to registrars, including to reinstate applications in certain circumstances or dismiss applications that have no reasonable prospects of success; allowing members to correct an obvious error in a decision or statement of reasons made by the registrar; and making other minor technical amendments, including clarifying that the president of the tribunal is assigned to every jurisdictional area, standardising timeframes for review for certain taxation matters and excluding 24 December to 14 January from the calculation of time for original decision-makers to provide certain documents. This matters because it allows the ART to spend less time on unnecessary administrative steps and more time resolving cases. Clearer application requirements, flexible staffing and greater powers for registrars will help matters move through the tribunal more quickly while still preserving written reasons and additional safeguards for reviews involving essential supports such as social security, veterans entitlements, aged care and the NDIS. Put simply, these reforms are about reducing avoidable delay without compromising fairness and quality of decisions. For applicants, that means greater certainty, more timely decisions and a review process that can focus its resources where they are needed most.</p><p>Secondly, this bill will strengthen the integrity of Australia's migration review system. It introduces a new power requiring applicants seeking review of certain protection and other migration decisions to verify their identity. At the same time, the bill exempts classes of people or applicants from the verification process. The rationale for this measure is straightforward: it helps ensure the applications are made by people who genuinely intend to engage with the review process and gives the tribunal and the court greater confidence in the integrity of that process. It also encourages active participation from the outset and helps ensure that the scarce resources are directed towards genuine applications.</p><p>This bill will also discourage frivolous applications that can consume valuable resources and cause unnecessary delays for applicants who are genuinely seeking review. This measure also complements earlier reforms that allow appropriate migration matters to be considered on the papers, without requiring an oral hearing in every case. Where the relevant information is already before the decision-maker, resolving a matter in this way can reduce unnecessary delay and allow resources to be focused on cases that require more detailed consideration.</p><p>Identity verification provides an additional safeguard within that more efficient process by confirming that the applicant is aware of and engaged with the review. For matters before the tribunal, an applicant who is required to verify their identity but does not do so will have their review application dismissed. It is important to note that the bill also includes important safeguards to ensure that fairness remains at the centre of the review process while recognising the distinct role of the courts under our constitutional framework. Applicants who are unable to satisfy identity verification requirements are not left without an option. Mechanisms exist for matters to be reinstated and, where proceedings are before the courts, judicial discretion is preserved so that individual circumstances can be properly considered. This ensures the system remains accessible to genuine applicants while supporting the integrity of Australia's merits and judicial review framework.</p><p>Taken together, these reforms reflect the Albanese government's commitment to strong, independent and effective institutions. These reforms will improve efficiency without sacrificing fairness. They will strengthen the integrity of the migration review system and help ensure that Australians have confidence in decisions made by government and the mechanisms available to review them. This practical reform builds on the government's broader work to restore trust in administrative review and ensure our review institutions remain fit for purpose. I commend the bill to the Senate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="2303" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.19.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="11:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise on behalf of the Greens to indicate we have significant concerns about the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026, and we'll be moving amendments to the legislation to seek to address those. If those amendments are not supported&#x2014;and it seems clear that Labor and coalition senators are on a unity ticket to create unfairness&#x2014;we will not be supporting this legislation.</p><p>The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill seeks to make three major changes to the operation of the Administrative Review Tribunal. All are crafted as producing efficiencies, and we just heard from the government senator, Senator Stewart, the argument that this is all designed for fairness and to ensure people's rights are protected. It's far from it. The entire thrust of this legislation is to take away rights, to take away fair process and to greatly limit the rights of people before the Administrative Review Tribunal, all dressed up by the government and the coalition, who are on a unity ticket here, as efficiency, but what it actually means is meanness and the taking away of people's rights.</p><p>We do know how to actually make the system fairer. We do know how to make the system more efficient. The way you do that is by providing legal assistance to genuine applicants, and you do that in the migration stream and across the board in the ART. It's been done before and, each time it's been done before, it's worked. Between 2006 and 2009, there was a pilot program instituted in the then AAT and in the community legal centres that support refugee claims. That was incredibly successful. The community care pilot also saw caseworkers instead of going out to put people in detention who were in breach of their visa conditions who might have overstayed. They sent caseworkers out to work with people and work out what was going on in their lives. It turns out that, when you treat people as people, not problems, you resolve matters. There was a radical improvement in compliance. Many people just had significant financial barriers to getting their visa situation sorted. Some of them just had a financial barrier that meant they couldn't go home. Some of them had children that they needed to stay for in order to be parents. They just needed help. It turned out that, when caseworkers went instead of Border Force, that the compliance rate was in the mid to high 90s. If you treat people like humans, like they matter, and don't punch down on them like Labor, the coalition and One Nation seem to do, it actually works.</p><p>We know that, in more recent history, there was a short-lived&#x2014;should be permanent&#x2014;program to give legal assistance to people, particularly to legal aid and community legal centres, to provide legal assistance to help people who are otherwise unrepresented bring an asylum claim to the ART. What did you find in that? You again found rapid turnarounds, matters being rapidly resolved instead of hanging around for months or for years, meritorious applications being approved rapidly, people getting their visas sorted, and people who didn't have a meritorious application being told that by a well-qualified, capable lawyer. Those applications just won't run. I really want to commend the work of legal aid and community legal centres across the country who made that project work. Of course, the government then cut the funding, but, if you look, for example, at what Victoria Legal Aid did with that funding, they had that increased funding from July 2024 to June 2025. They assisted 620 unique clients with more than 2,000 legal services provided to them. That provided 800 separate pieces of legal advice and 147 separate representations, and 90 per cent of those matters saw positive outcomes, including decisions refusing protection visas being overturned, matters remitted to the ART for further review and, when they went to the ART&#x2014;because they'd gone with careful legal advice, they were determined quickly&#x2014;90 per cent of those protection visa reviews had significant positive feedback from the tribunal.</p><p>The tribunal is thankful when this happens. As one tribunal member said: 'Any tribunal member who's presided over a matter with an unrepresented applicant would appreciate the work of lawyers in representing the applicant's case so well.' Hearings were shorter, decisions were made quickly, and, in the majority of times, decisions were delivered in just three weeks after the final hearing because the issues are crystallised, the evidence is narrowed down, and the case is presented. That is the answer to the backlog. Reinstate the legal funding that used to be applied so that meritorious cases are run well and efficiently, that the tribunal is given the assistance they need and that unmeritorious cases are given early legal advice that they just won't get up. But, of course, what does this government do? What does Labor do? They just reject all of that evidence and decide to punch down on migrants, like they do so often.</p><p>It's for those reasons that I move the second reading amendment circulated in my name. I move:</p><p class="italic">At the end of the motion, add ", but the Senate acknowledges that:</p><p class="italic">(a) wait times in visa processing began to increase in 2014 after cuts to legal assistance; and</p><p class="italic">(b) the way to reduce backlogs and ensure a fair and fast visa processing system is to fully fund legal assistance".</p><p>I commend that second reading amendment to the Senate, because that's actually how you fix backlogs and how you produce efficiency.</p><p>Instead, what do this government do? They do three things. The first is expanding the registrar's role, and registrars aren't even always legally qualified. They absolutely don't have security of tenure, like permanent members do, and they do not have the security of appointed members. They're basically employees of the executive. They are not full tribunal members. They're employees of the executive open to be hired and fired by the executive. What does this government propose to do? It wants to grant registrars the power to dismiss applications if the registrar is 'satisfied there are no reasonable prospects of success'.</p><p>Submission after submission to the inquiry said that this was wrong. I want to particularly point out the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre, the Kaldor Centre and the Law Council of Australia. Every submission from a credible entity said don't do this. For example, Carina Ford from the Law Council of Australia said:</p><p class="italic">I think the difficulty with migration decisions is that they are not generally objective. They do require a level of assessment at the level of a member. There might be some cases that could fall within it. For example, there could be a case where English language testing wasn't attached to a time of application case. But overall there is a level of assessment. A good example is the student visa case load. That has moved to decisions on the papers, and it still requires the criteria to be assessed because it is subjective.</p><p>The proposal is we'll give employees of the ART, not tribunal members, the ability to dismiss matters on a subjective test. That's a fundamentally judicial or quasijudicial power, and it should not be exercised by employees who can be hired and fired by the principal registrar.</p><p>As the Kaldor Centre noted&#x2014;here I particularly want to credit the work of Professor Daniel Ghezelbash. They noted:</p><p class="italic">Not only do these amendments have significant adverse impacts on the ability of applicants to access review of their protection visa applications but they are also likely to generate further litigation and appeals, shifting delays downstream to the Federal Circuit and Family Court rather than resolving them.</p><p>That's what we're likely to see here&#x2014;the ART making decisions, alleging that there are no reasonable prospects for success, making that decision on the papers, having it done by a registrar and then that leading to appeals in the ART and then a raft of separate appeals to the Federal Circuit and Family Court, clogging up the system, costing taxpayers' money and failing to address with the merits of the case. These changes are bad law. They are bad law, and they will undermine the integrity of the ART, and, for those reasons, the Greens will be opposing them, and we're in good company with pretty much every credible legal organisation and advocate in the space saying these laws should not be made.</p><p>The second problem with this legislation is about the proposed changes about verification of identity. There is a proposal here for the mandatory dismissal of applications that don't meet as yet unspecified identity verification requirements. The details of that information on this change are absent from the bill, totally absent, and, instead, the government have claimed that they're going to somehow be implemented through regulations and that, of course, that's sufficient. Regulations have much less parliamentary oversight and less engagement from key stakeholders. This lack of knowledge about how it worked was made clear when we asked, for example, the principal registrar of the ART what the procedures would be like. Mr Hawkins&#x2014;credit to him&#x2014;said:</p><p class="italic">We understand that the applicant will need to present to a tribunal either in person or virtually, the details of which I'm yet to see, their identity.</p><p>The tribunal has no idea how it's going to happen. Then he said:</p><p class="italic">Given that we're dealing with a current caseload, I understand that it's from applications from a particular period in time onwards.</p><p>Then, when pressed about it, he said very clearly that the tribunal had no idea how it would work. Then, when we asked the Attorney-General's Department how it worked, this is the exchange we got. I asked Ms Inverarity of the department:</p><p class="italic">So the Hazara woman has fled with her children to Australia from Afghanistan. She has never had a passport and never had travel documents and has come onshore. The Afghan embassy has shut. She obviously isn't going to go and approach the Taliban in Afghanistan for identity documents because then her family could well be persecuted and killed. What processes will there be in place for a woman in that situation to have her identity verification assessed and not have a mandatory dismissal of her application?</p><p>The department said:</p><p class="italic">I can't give you an answer with the precision that will make you happy other than that I have referred already to the fact that this is an issue that is already well known to the Australian government. The National Identity Proofing Guidelines cover the need for alternative proofing arrangements for people who do not have the traditional suite of identity documents.</p><p>There are no answers&#x2014;no answers to the tribunal and no answers to the parliament&#x2014;and yet this legislation is being rammed through.</p><p>This change disproportionately impacts the most marginalised, such as people experiencing domestic and family violence. It's well documented that control over identification documents is a common form of coercion by abusers. That's true of family abuse as well as abusive employers. And yet this government is pushing through legislation knowing who's going to be harmed by it&#x2014;the most marginal people&#x2014;adding that coercive control power to employers and abusive partners, who can just withhold the documents. It's outrageous.</p><p>Then the third issue of concern for us is the proposal to allow members to not provide written reasons for their decisions. As the Refugee Council of Australia noted in its submission:</p><p class="italic">Timely written statements of legal decisions are central to administrative justice and transparency. Written notices provide an authoritative record of the Tribunal's findings, decision making process and help inform applicants about the basis of the decision. This is significant for refugee claims when matters of life and death are under consideration.</p><p>Then there was confusion as to why this was happening between the department and the ART. Again, Mr Hawkins made clear that they weren't expecting to use the power in complex cases, although there's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided was for its use in successful cases. As Mr Hawkins explained:</p><p class="italic">I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons. They are probably very straightforward decisions. In cases where it is set aside, it is up to the department whether it seeks the written reasons.</p><p>But there's no limitation in the bill to have it only on successful applications&#x2014;none at all. Matters can be dismissed with no reasons given and then, if you want reasons, you've got to go through this further complex process to try and get reasons, all while your appeal rights are ticking away and the time limits are ticking away. There's more complication and more bureaucracy. Who's going to be impacted most in this? The most marginal people. Each of these elements punches down on the most marginal people in the system.</p><p>Of course, that's what Labor are doing in the migration space because they're not actually chasing fairness. They're not actually chasing efficiency. If they wanted efficiency and fairness, they'd properly fund the legal system. They'd give people actual representation and make it better for the tribunal. They'd make the Department of Home Affairs make good decisions in the first place so they're not constantly being appealed. But they don't want to make the department do their work properly. They don't want to properly fund actual legal representation. They want to chase One Nation. That's what this is about. Again, Labor are chasing One Nation with their meanness, their nastiness and their punching down on migrants. That's what this legislation is. They can speak what they like about efficiency. The only efficiency here is meanness. That's why the Greens will be opposing it.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="995" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.20.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="11:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise in support of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. Last financial year, the median time to finalise a family or partner visa review was more than 2&#xBD; years. For a family living apart, it can mean another birthday over a video call. It can mean telling your children again that you still don't know when you all will be able to live together.</p><p>The Albanese Labor government established the Administrative Review Tribunal in October 2024. Political appointments had damaged confidence in the old Administrative Appeals Tribunal. We put transparent, merit based appointments into law so that people could trust that the people hearing their case have been chosen for their expertise. The tribunal gives people an independent place to challenge a range of Commonwealth decisions. It can look at the facts again, consider new evidence and decide on what the correct or preferable outcome is. Through judicial review, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia can examine whether a migration decision was made according to the law. Our government has funded the tribunal to work through older migration and protection cases. The tribunal finalised more than 27,000 of those cases in the first year of that work. But even with that progress, it has almost 134,000 applications on hand at the end of June. Nearly nine in 10 were migration or protection matters. We absolutely owe it to the people waiting to make sure that the tribunal's time goes to where it's needed.</p><p>Under this bill, the tribunal's president can authorise a registrar to dismiss an application if there is no reasonable prospect of success. Take a case where the law sets out a clear eligibility requirement and the facts show that the applicant may not meet those requirements. An authorised registrar could deal with that case. The president can set conditions on that authority and it can also authorise registrars to reinstate certain dismissed applications. It gives tribunal members more time for the cases that need it. Someone seeking protection may have to tell the tribunal about some of the most frightening things that have happened to them. That member needs time to hear their account, weigh the evidence and consider what could happen if that person absolutely had to return home.</p><p>Earlier reforms gave the tribunal more scope to decide some cases on the papers. This bill gives it more flexibility in how it explains its decisions. In eligible cases, a member can give reasons orally. The parties can still get the outcomes in writing; if a party asks for written reasons within the time allowed, the tribunal must provide them. Where the parties already have the explanations they need, the member can spend that time on the next case. Written reasons will continue to be provided as a matter of course for reviews concerning social security, veterans' entitlements, aged care and the National Disability Insurance Scheme. If you're seeking a review of your NDIS plan, a written explanation gives you something that you can sit down with an advocate or a family member and work through. You can take the time to understand what the decision means for the support that you rely on every single day.</p><p>I'd like to extend my thanks to Senator Jana Stewart for chairing the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee's inquiry, and also the secretariat and everyone who gave evidence to this inquiry. We heard how hard it can be to take on a decision and all the reasons in it in one sitting, especially if you're relying on an interpreter or representing just yourself. In a migration review, an applicant would generally have 14 days from an oral decision to ask for written reasons. The usual deadline for seeking judicial review is 35 days from the decision. If you need those reasons to get legal advice, you could still be waiting for them as the court deadline approaches. The Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee recommended that the applicants be given both deadlines in writing and that the tribunal provide any requested reasons as quickly as possible.</p><p>This bill will require an approved form for certain migration and protection reviews so that the tribunal can get the information it needs upfront. It will allow tribunal members to correct obvious errors in the registrar's orders. The Immigration Advice and Rights Centre told the inquiry about people who had applications lodged in their names without their knowledge or their consent. It also told us about people who had missed hearings because of unscrupulous operators who had failed to pass on correspondence from the tribunal. The bill introduces identity checks in certain migration and protection matters. These checks give the tribunal and the court a way to confirm who is seeking review and help make sure that people know that an application has been made in their name. Applicants covered by the requirement will be told in writing what they need to do. The tribunal must dismiss an application if the person fails to comply. The person can ask to have their case reinstated, and the tribunal must reinstate it if it considers that it is appropriate. The court can give someone more time, waive the requirement where it's appropriate or give them permission to continue if they haven't met it. Regulations will set out which cases are covered and how the checks will work.</p><p>The Attorney-General's Department told us it expects online verification to be a key part of those arrangements. In regional and remote Western Australia, it can spare someone hours of travel for a single appointment. The department also acknowledges the need for other ways to prove identity. Someone who has fled their home may have very little choice about which documents they could bring. The process needs to work for that person too. The committee recommended that this bill pass, and I thank the Attorney-General for bringing these reforms forward. I commend the bill to the Senate.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="1703" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.21.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="speech" time="12:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Of course, I listened closely to the contribution from the previous speaker Senator Cox and want to indicate that the Australian Greens do not agree that the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 should be passed. This is a fundamentally flawed piece of legislation which will, as is so often the case when the political duopoly in this country gets together, impact on some of the most marginalised people in our community.</p><p>The first concerning change in this legislation is the change to expand the registrar's role to include merits assessments. There are multiple issues with this proposal, but chief amongst them is a very basic question of justice. Registrars are employees, not appointed members, and it is proposed they be given powers well beyond their traditional, quite limited role of determining issues of process and procedure. That is the first issue with this legislation. During the inquiry process on this legislation, Mr Strutt from the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre said:</p><p class="italic">You have rigorous merits based appointments at the tribunal for people to engage in merits based assessments of applications through members and senior members. We understand that registrars may not be put through the same processes or have the same qualifications and experience as members. So we are quite concerned that this may mean that registrars are being asked to participate in a merits review process without the appropriate training or qualifications. We also know that applicants also put forward review applications without legal advice. As you are saying, there is a lot of unrepresented applicants. They may not know what the facts in issue are or what to put in the review application in order to assist the decision-maker to make that assessment as well.</p><p>Clearly, there are concerns centred around the application of justice and, indeed, the provision of natural justice to people who are going through the processes.</p><p>Of course, the government is saying that this is all about efficiency. For anyone who needs that translated, that means it's saving money for the government. This is a government that hands out tens of billions of dollars every year to massively profitable, highly polluting corporations to encourage them to keep burning fossil fuels. This is a government that's going to spend $350 billion on AUKUS nuclear submarines that are going to make Australia a more dangerous place to be if we ever get them in the first place, and, if we do get them, they'll not only make us more dangerous but be obsolete by the time that we get them. This is a government that has got plenty of cash to splash on corporate welfare, on subsidising the heating of the planet and on nuclear submarines that we may never see, but somehow they have to find efficiencies by punching down on some of the most marginal people in our community and compromising natural justice in one of our most important judicial institutions.</p><p>Another change of concern in this legislation is the mandatory dismissal of applications that don't meet identity verification requirements. Well, what I'm going to say here is: here we go again. Just about every significant erosion of human rights in the immigration space in this country has been led by the Australian Labor Party&#x2014;mandatory immigration detention brought to Australia by the Australian Labor Party; offshore prisons on Manus Island brought to Australia by the Australian Labor Party; offshore prisons in Naoero brought to Australia and still run, at massive cost to the taxpayer, by the Australian Labor Party. They are a carceral political party. They were a party of White Australia back in the day. They've engaged in a race to the bottom and are still engaged in a race to the bottom on immigration with a coalition that is still desperately trying to outflank the fascists in One Nation on the right. And here we go again, punching down on immigrants.</p><p>Let's just imagine a case here. Let's say a woman from Afghanistan, a Hazara woman, has somehow managed to escape the clutches of the Taliban and flee with her children, some of whom are daughters, young girls, and they've managed to get to Australia. She hasn't had a passport. Her immigration documents were confiscated from her while she was escaping Afghanistan. She's come to Australia. The Afghan embassy is shut. Obviously, she can't approach the Taliban for her identity documents because who knows what would happen to the rest of her family that remain in Afghanistan? They could be abducted, tortured, killed or stoned to death. What processes are going to be in place for that woman and her family? Is she going to face a mandatory dismissal of her application because she can't prove her identity to the satisfaction of some bureaucrat in Home Affairs or some appointed official in the tribunal? What is going to happen? When these questions were raised, quite recently, by Senator Shoebridge during the inquiry into this legislation, the best that the respondent could provide was, 'Oh, well, the government's aware of this problem.' Well, that's not very reassuring! The government's aware of the problem, but it's still proceeding with a piece of legislation in the complete and utter absence of a solution. Here we go again.</p><p>This country, which used to have a White Australia policy officially and now just runs it unofficially, which exiles black-skinned and brown-skinned people to be tortured in the offshore torture centres in Manus Island and Naoero&#x2014;there's not a single white-skinned person. And I can tell you, colleagues; I was there. I went to Manus Island many times, and people who've been in this chamber long enough will recall my advocacy for the men who were exiled to Manus Island and my very firm view, supported by Amnesty International, that what was done to those people constitutes the legal definition of 'torture' under international law. And I'm telling you, as someone who went to Manus Island, who was inside the Lombrum detention centre at the time the Australian government&#x2014;albeit then a Liberal government but with the full support, I might add, of the Australian Labor Party&#x2014;withdrew the food, the drinking water and the medical supports and cut off the electricity to 650 people who'd been incarcerated there illegally under Australian and international law for years. And do you know how many white-skinned people there were? I'll tell you. None&#x2014;not a single white-skinned person.</p><p>Don't tell me that, if a boatload of South African farmers had arrived on our shores, they would have ended up exiled to Manus Island. We know they would not have, because offshore detention was and remains, today, a racist policy in this country. The impacts of these changes will be racist because they will have greater impact on a larger number of non-white people. Let's name these changes for what they are. But it won't just be about the colour of people's skin. Some of the most marginalised people in our community will fall foul of these changes, including people who are experiencing and trying to flee from domestic or family violence.</p><p>The final aspect of concern in this bill that I want to talk about are the proposed changes to allow members to not provide written reasons for their decisions. Senator Bleyer, as a lawyer&#x2014;I'm going to make an assumption here&#x2014;will have something to say about these changes. Just imagine this scenario, colleagues, should this legislation pass and there's removal of the obligation to provide written reasons when decisions are made. Yes, applicants will be able to request written reasons, but that process can take as long as 28 days, when you have an appeal window of 35 days. So, instead of someone getting their written reasons on day one and having seven weeks to consider whether they want to prepare and lodge an appeal, they will now have as little as seven days to do what they previously had seven weeks to do. This is manifestly unfair. It is an absolute abrogation of natural justice.</p><p>You can measure a government by the way it looks after some of the most marginalised people it governs. I've been through some of the ancient history of the Australian Labor Party; the recent history of the Australian Labor Party in caring for vulnerable and marginalised people has been abject. Just in the last month, we've seen huge cuts to the National Disability Insurance Scheme that will place the very lives of disabled people at increased risk and mean that large numbers of disabled people in our community will no longer be able to lead lives with a measure of human dignity. Off the back of that, we now have these changes, which, again, are a denial of natural justice and procedural fairness.</p><p>It is worth pointing out that most migration applicants appear unrepresented at the ART. For many of them, English is a second, third or fourth language, and their English-language skills may not be of the highest order. Removing the requirement for written reasons when decisions are made means that people who may not have comprehensive English understanding are going to verbally have presented to them a complex rationale for a decision that may ultimately be life or death for them. Then, they'll have to go through the process of requesting a written reason, which, before it gets provided to them, can take four-fifths of their appeal window.</p><p>And I'll tell you something else about not having to provide a written reason. It will almost certainly degrade the quality of decision-making. I'll use an example that will be familiar to every single sitting senator in this place, and that is jotting down notes for a speech. The actual act of writing a speech can help you clarify your thinking. We all know that. But, if there's no requirement for written reasons, then decisions will almost inevitably be based on a gut feeling, and then you will find people will reverse engineer an argument if they are required to provide written reasons. That is the problem here. You will get written reasons that are reverse engineered to fit a decision that was made without the person having to sit down and write out the reasons. <i>(Time expired.)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="960" approximate_wordcount="1774" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.22.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="12:20" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 should not be passed. When I was an immigration lawyer, a young lady, a 19-year-old Chinese citizen, obtained a student visa to come to Australia, to experience another country and to pursue her tertiary education. It was the first time she had ever left home, and it was a very big deal for her and her family. A reason why she decided to take that big step was because her boyfriend, also a 19-year-old Chinese citizen, successfully obtained a student visa to travel to Australia to undertake his tertiary studies.</p><p>Sadly for both of them, during their time studying in Australia, they broke up. Like happens sometimes, their break-up was messy. During the course of their break-up, the young man went to the police and had the young lady charged with assault for hitting him with a container of chilli. But through that process the police came to her apartment. The police arrested her. The police took her to the cop shop. They interviewed her. They charged her with assault and then she was released on bail. That was a traumatic experience for her and her family.</p><p>She went back home to her apartment in this country and took some time to recover from that terrifying experience she had suffered. Then there was a knock at the door, and who pushed through the door? A number of Border Force officers. They detained her and they put her in immigration detention. Why? Because that criminal offence, despite pleading not guilty to it, was decided by the government to mean that she was a risk to the safety of the Australian community. A 19-year-old Chinese citizen with no prior criminal history in her home country, this country or anywhere else in the world, who was innocently attending this country as an experience to fulfil her tertiary education, was now in immigration detention. She contacted me to act as her immigration lawyer, and, of course, I immediately filed an appeal with the tribunal appealing the decision to cancel her visa.</p><p>As a result of that, I was able to participate in an efficient system in the tribunal, a system that says if you are appealing a visa cancellation decision and you are locked up in inhumane immigration detention then within a couple of days you can apply for a bridging visa to be released from immigration detention. We embraced that efficiency. Despite that she was in immigration detention in Melbourne and despite that I was working as an immigration lawyer between Tasmania and Victoria, the first available tribunal member to hear her application to get her out of immigration detention was in Sydney. But that was okay; we would take every opportunity that we could to right this injustice and get her out of jail. So we went to Sydney; Border Force flew her there. She was brought into the tribunal room in shackles&#x2014;a 19-year-old Chinese citizen who was defending an alleged criminal offence was in shackles. The application for a bridging visa to release this young lady from immigration detention was successful. That is an example of an efficiency rightly placed in favour of a victim of the system.</p><p>Let's have a look at what changes this federal Labor government is proposing in a race to the bottom with One Nation and the Liberals on migration. There is a proposal to deny student visa holders to have their family come to Australia to be with them. Had that been the case for this young lady, she would have been deprived of the opportunity to have her family with her when she was going through her first relationship break-up, with her first boyfriend; when she was arrested and interviewed by the police; when she was criminally charged by the police&#x2014;to which she pleaded not guilty; and when she was released on bail.</p><p>Her bridging visa application was granted. She proceeded to defend the criminal charge that she had been confronted with for hitting her then boyfriend with a container of chilli. But, understandably, she left this country, deprived of her opportunity for travel to broaden the mind, by reason of the atrocious experience that she had when she was here.</p><p>Again, I'll go back to the good news story in this terrifying set of circumstances, and that is the existing efficiency in the tribunal system that meant she was able to be released from immigration detention within a handful of days.</p><p>When I was an immigration lawyer, I acted for a young man who was about 20. He's a New Zealand citizen, and he travelled to Australia. As I expect my colleagues in this chamber are aware, he was naturally granted a temporary 444 visa, as New Zealand citizens are. He came here to fill a labour shortage. Whilst at an Aussie pub, watching an Aussie game of AFL, with a few blokes who'd probably had one too many beers, he engaged in a minor scuffle amongst others at the pub. He was criminally charged for assault. After he was arrested, after he was interviewed by the police and after he was charged with a minor assault and released on bail, what do you know? Border Force officers turned up at his place and dragged him off to immigration detention because he was also suddenly a risk to the safety of the Australian community.</p><p>Again, I was able to embrace the efficiency of the tribunal and have an urgent hearing to have him released on a bridging visa. He stayed here and defended the criminal charges. But, before the criminal hearing was determined, we had the tribunal hearing to appeal the visa cancellation decision. To the shock of me and my legal colleagues at the time, we did not succeed, and the visa cancellation decision was upheld. That meant that the bridging visa came to an end and that he could choose to sit in immigration detention while he was waiting for the criminal matter to be dealt with or he could go home to New Zealand, but he was on bail&#x2014;now what was he going to do? But, in any event, we appealed the unsuccessful visa cancellation decision to the Federal Court system, and we were able to give him sound advice as to whether he had any grounds for appeal and, if so, what his prospects of success were because we had not just the decision but the written reasons for the decision. I can tell you that it would be hard for you to find any competent lawyer in this country that can tell you that they can properly advise their client as to whether they have grounds for appeal and whether those grounds have any prospects of success without having the written reasons of the decision-maker.</p><p>This proposed amendment to create an efficiency by enabling tribunal decision-makers to not provide written reasons for decisions will only create inefficiencies later. Let me tell you how. We would have to take a punt and say: 'Well, just like we told you, you should have had prospects of succeeding at the tribunal. We can only tell you again that the decision must be wrong, so you must have prospects of success in the Federal Court system.' We would file an application in the Federal Court, supported by flimsy grounds for appeal, then we'd be requesting the written reasons from the tribunal. We'd have to wait for them. Meanwhile, the Federal Court process would have commenced, then we'd have to cause an inefficiency in the Federal Court, because we'd have to seek leave to amend the grounds for appeal because we would finally have the written reasons.</p><p>What if the situation arose where, when we get the written reasons for the decision, we're in a position to advise the client that there aren't really grounds for appeal with prospects of success? We've wasted the time of the Federal Court&#x2014;further time, because we now need to withdraw the appeal to the Federal Court system. The client has paid the thousands-of-dollars filing fee to the Federal Court, which isn't refundable, and the client has paid the lawyers. I was quite affordable, but who knows how many thousands of dollars the client has paid the lawyer to draft the application and the grounds of appeal&#x2014;only to have to withdraw it by reason of having to wait for the written reasons for decision.</p><p>There is no way that these amendments allowing tribunal members to not provide written reasons for decision when they make their decision will bestow any efficiencies on this system. We have to look at the bigger system&#x2014;not just the tribunal system but also the court system that can, and often does, follow it. The reason that we have appeal processes is that there are times when decision-makers get things wrong. When decision-makers get things wrong, we need a fair appeal system, and it is not a fair appeal system to give someone a decision without any written reasons, because it sets them up for failure in respect of an unfair appeal system. This bill's attempt at efficiency instead promotes inefficiency and seeks to cut corners at the cost of fairness and people's rights. Our legal system in this country is governed by the principle of procedural fairness. How can we be in this chamber and say that we support our fundamental principle of procedural fairness when we are seeking to pass a bill today that is designed to create an even more unfair system than that which already exists?</p><p>As senators, we should be here to make better laws. We should be here to turn unfair systems into fair ones. We are not here and should not be here to make unfair systems more unfair. I don't know what lawyers this federal Labor government might have been talking to when they thought it was a good idea to let tribunal members off the hook and not have to give written reasons for decisions, but it wasn't me. It wasn't any of my immigration law colleagues that I worked with for plenty of years. It wasn't any of my immigration law colleagues who I've had the opportunity to consult with over this bill. Every single one of them will tell you what I have said today, and that is that letting tribunal members off the hook and not give written reasons for decisions has an adverse impact on fairness and procedural justice, and interferes with the rights of people who should have an opportunity to participate in a fair justice system. It's our responsibility to make it so. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="600" approximate_wordcount="1504" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.23.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="12:36" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The purpose of the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 is to enhance the efficiency and responsiveness of the Administrative Review Tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia to more effectively respond to the significant and increasing caseloads. The bill further strengthens the tribunal by empowering it with more tools to make decisions in an efficient and timely manner while ensuring applicants have a meaningful opportunity to present their case to the tribunal. The bill also enhances the operations of the tribunal and the court in relation to migration and protection matters. The bill recognises that merits and judicial review processes should be efficient and proportionate to the complexity of the issues and the importance of what is at stake. Efficient review procedures are important to reduce delays in decision-making, provide genuine applicants with the benefit of a timely and effective remedy and strengthen the integrity of the review system.</p><p>This bill has been informed by the tribunal's operational experience over almost two years, and the bill makes a range of amendments to ensure the tribunal can make decisions effectively and without delay. In particular, the bill amends the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 and the Migration Act 1958 to enable the ART to give reasons for a decision orally, rather than always in writing, with written statements of reasons to be given at the request of a party. A written record of decision will continue to always be provided to parties. These changes apply to matters in the ART's migration caseload as well as other caseloads where the ART resources could be saved because written reasons may not always be required. The bill provides important safeguards for vulnerable applicants of the ART and will not apply these changes to reviews relating to social security, veterans entitlements, the National Disability Insurance Scheme, aged care and where written reasons may play an important role.</p><p>The bill also makes several other efficiency amendments, including to enable the president of the ART to authorise registrars to exercise additional powers, recognising the important role that they play in running the ART smoothly. Registrars will support members to reinstate applications in certain circumstances and to dismiss applications if satisfied there are no reasonable prospects of success. We'll also require applicants to seek ART review of a reviewable migration or reviewable protection decision by using an approved form. This ensures the tribunal has relevant information it needs upfront and avoids unnecessary chasing of information when a tribunal could be dedicating its efforts to managing its significant caseload. It will also permit any member or other authorised member of the ART to correct an obvious error in a decision or statement of reasons for the decision made by the registrar.</p><p>The bill will require the government to take into account the president's advice on more matters when considering the reappointment of a non-judicial member, including on the ART's operational needs and financial capacity. The bill will enable the Governor-General to vary the appointment of a non-judicial member to a salary to sessional or vice versa during the term of their appointment. This creates greater flexibility to respond to change, including in response to varying case load demands. It also specifies when certain documents need to be provided to the tribunal, assigns the president to every jurisdictional area and, subject to the passage of the government's amendments, further streamlines the tribunal appointment processes by creating a new appointment process for suitably qualified and experienced general members to be promoted to senior member before the end of their current term without requiring a full further merit-based recruitment process.</p><p>To improve the integrity of the migration review framework, the bill will also introduce a new requirement for the verification of the identity of an applicant and for review of the prescribed reviewable migration or protection decisions. The requirement would apply to applicants seeking merits or judicial review of a prescribed protection or migration decision in the tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2). This would establish a mandatory engagement point with the tribunal and the court to ensure that applicants understand precisely what it is that they are seeking to do and so that the tribunal and the court can have confidence that the applicant is who they say they are. The particulars around when, where and how the identity verification process would operate are intended to be set out in regulations. The regulations would be subject to parliamentary oversight through a disallowance process. The new requirement would not be enlivened without regulations prescribing the case loads to which it would apply.</p><p>Where applicants in the tribunal did not comply with the identity verification requirement, it would result in the tribunal being required to dismiss the matter, with its existing reinstatement powers available if necessary. Applicants who failed to comply with the identity verification requirement in the federal court and family court proceedings would require leave of the court to continue proceedings. To ensure consistency and compliance with constitutional limitations relating to the status of the court as a chapter III court, the court, where leave is not granted, may&#x2014;rather than 'must'&#x2014;dismiss the proceeding. The court would also be empowered to dispense with, or extend time to satisfy, the identity verification requirement.</p><p>The government has considered the report of the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Legislation Committee, following its inquiry into the bill. We thank all submitters, witnesses and senators for their participation in the inquiry. The government agrees to the committee's recommendation that applicants who receive oral reasons be provided with clear written notice of the period for requesting written reasons and the applicable judicial review deadline and that the tribunal provide any requested written reasons as expeditiously as possible. The tribunal will provide written advice to parties upon receiving an oral decision, outlining further review rights, how they may seek written reasons and the timeframe in which to do so. As currently occurs, a fact sheet with information about the decision and information about seeking judicial review will be given at the time of written notification of the tribunal's decision. The government also agrees that the timely provision of written reasons following a request is important, and the tribunal must provide written reasons to both parties within 28 days after a request for written reasons is received; within 14 days for reviews subject to the 35-day deadline for seeking judicial review under the Migration Act; or as otherwise prescribed in regulations or practice directions.</p><p>The government notes the comments from Senator Cash and coalition senators and the recommendation that the government consider, in consultation with the tribunal and the Department of Home Affairs, a limited reconsideration mechanism under the migration framework to allow clear and objectively identifiable administrative errors or oversights to be returned to the Department of Home Affairs while a review remains on foot. There are bespoke remittal settings that already apply to migration and protection reviews under the Migration Act to preserve the current framework that ensures the certainty of a person's visa status and when an application is considered finally determined. The tribunal has efficient triaging processes in place to identify and remit decisions impacted by an obvious error, such as a decision to refuse a student visa where the original decision-maker overlooked a valid English language test result or where an applicant inadvertently failed to attach an English language test result to their application. Further to recommendation 2 by coalition senators, the government agrees in principle to the recommendation that additional data relating to powers exercised by the tribunal registrars be included in the tribunal's annual report.</p><p>The government is committed to ensuring transparency and public accountability in relation to ART operations and the exercise of certain tribunal powers. Accordingly, subject to the passage of government amendments, the president of the tribunal would be required to report every financial year on the following items: the number of applications dismissed by registrars on the basis that they have no reasonable prospects of success, the number of reinstatements following any such dismissal, the number of matters remitted by registrars to a decision-maker for reconsideration under section 85 for each jurisdictional area and the number of those applications subsequently withdrawn by applicants. This would ensure that there is publicly available information relating to the exercise of these powers by registrars, recognising that appropriate accountability and transparency should accompany both existing powers of ART registrars and expanded powers introduced in the bill.</p><p>Taken together, these reforms will support a more efficient, effective and robust review system, particularly in relation to the migration system by encouraging active participation in the process and dissuading frivolous applications while ensuring that appropriate balances are in place. The tribunal and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia have a crucial role in enabling review of government decisions. The bill will support this role by tailoring procedures and operations to enhance efficiencies and ensure the significant migration caseload pressure can be effectively responded to.</p><p>Question negatived.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="16" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.24.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" speakername="Leah Blyth" talktype="speech" time="12:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>For efficiency, we won't call a division but would like our support for the amendments noted.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.24.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="12:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm happy to record your support for the amendment.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bill read a second time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.25.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7516" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7516">Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="540" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.25.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="12:47" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I move government amendments (1) and (2) on sheet IE114 and amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116 together:</p><p class="italic">SHEET IE114</p><p class="italic">(1) Schedule 1, page 4 (after line 4), before item 1, insert:</p><p class="italic">1A After paragraph 242(2)(g)</p><p class="italic">Insert:</p><p class="italic">(ga) the number of applications dismissed by registrars under paragraph 101(1)(b) (no reasonable prospects of success) during that year; and</p><p class="italic">(gb) the number of applications reinstated under section 102 of this Act, or section 368C of the <i>Migration Act 1958</i>, during that year after having been dismissed, at any time, by a registrar under paragraph 101(1)(b) of this Act; and</p><p class="italic">(gc) the number of decisions remitted to decision-makers under section 85 by registrars during that year in each jurisdictional area; and</p><p class="italic">(gd) in relation to decisions remitted to decision-makers, at any time, under section 85 by registrars&#x2014;the number of applications withdrawn by applicants under section 95 during that year in each jurisdictional area; and</p><p class="italic">(2) Schedule 1, page 4 (after line 13), before item 3, insert:</p><p class="italic">2A Annual report &#x2014; application of amendment</p><p class="italic">The amendment of section 242 of the <i>Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024</i> made by Division 1 of this Part applies in relation to an application made to the Tribunal on or after 1 July 2028.</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">SHEET IE116</p><p class="italic">(1) Schedule 1, page 10 (after line 19), after item 18, insert:</p><p class="italic">18A After subsection 208(4)</p><p class="italic">Insert:</p><p class="italic"> <i>Promotion of general member to senior member</i></p><p class="italic">(4A) Paragraph (2)(b) does not apply in relation to the appointment of a person as a senior member if:</p><p class="italic">(a) immediately before the start of the appointment as a senior member:</p><p class="italic">(i) the person holds office as a general member; and</p><p class="italic">(ii) the person has served at least 2 years of the person's appointment as a general member; and</p><p class="italic">(b) the Minister has sought, and taken into account, the advice of the President in relation to:</p><p class="italic">(i) the person's performance against the performance standard; and</p><p class="italic">(ii) the person's compliance with the code of conduct; and</p><p class="italic">(iii) the person's leadership and management skills, at an appropriate level for the appointment as a senior member.</p><p class="italic">(2) Schedule 1, page 11 (after line 10), after item 21, insert:</p><p class="italic">21A At the end of section 208</p><p class="italic">Add:</p><p class="italic"> <i>Effect of promotion</i></p><p class="italic">(11) If a person is appointed as a senior member as mentioned in subsection (4A):</p><p class="italic">(a) the person's appointment as a general member is, by force of this subsection, terminated immediately before the start of the person's appointment as a senior member; and</p><p class="italic">(b) the <i>Remuneration Tribunal (Compensation for Loss of Office for Holders of Certain Public Offices) Determination 2018</i> does not apply in relation to the termination of the person's appointment as a general member.</p><p class="italic">(3) Schedule 1, item 23, page 12 (line 25), omit "The amendments", substitute "(1) Subject to subitem (2), the amendments".</p><p class="italic">(4) Schedule 1, item 23, page 12 (after line 28), at the end of the item, add:</p><p class="italic">(2) Subsections 208(4A) and (11) of the <i>Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024</i>, as inserted by Division 1 of this Part, apply in relation to the appointment of a senior member made on or after the commencement of this item.</p><p>I also table two supplementary explanatory memoranda relating to the government amendments to be moved to this bill.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="297" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.26.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="12:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On the amendments moved by the government, the coalition will support the government's amendments to the Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. In particular, the government has brought forward an amendment to strengthen the tribunal's annual reporting requirements. This was actually a recommendation made by the coalition during the Senate committee process, and it was the coalition that identified the need for greater transparency about the exercise of powers by tribunal registrars. It was the coalition that argued parliament should have access to better information about applications dismissed on the grounds that they had no reasonable prospects of success. We also identified that there be greater scrutiny of applications subsequently reinstated, decisions remitted to original decision-makers and applications withdrawn following those remittals. These, of course, are not insignificant matters, which is why we proposed the amendment. We are pleased that the government has accepted the coalition's amendment to the bill. The amendments go directly to the fairness, accountability and integrity of the administrative review system. The amendment will provide additional information in the tribunal's annual report, allowing greater scrutiny of how these powers are exercised.</p><p>The government is also proposing amendments to the arrangements for promoting existing general members of the tribunal to senior member positions. These amendments will allow suitably experienced general members who have served at least two years to be promoted through an alternative appointment pathway. The minister will be required to seek and consider advice from the tribunal president concerning the member's performance and compliance with the code of conduct and leadership and management skills. The coalition considers these to be sensible administrative arrangements that recognise experience while retaining important safeguards. As I said, the coalition will support these amendments because they improve accountability and strengthen the operation of the ART.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="67" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.27.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="12:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I have some questions for the minister. During the course of the inquiry associated with this bill, the Greens repeatedly asked what the identity verification requirements are, and we were told time and time again that they would be made on the regulations. Now, lawyers and migration agents still have no idea what they are. Can you please let us know what the identity verification requirements are?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="68" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.28.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="12:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thanks very much for the question. As you know, the bill provides for those requirements to be made through regulation, and they will be prescribed through regulation. It is set out in the bill how they will be made and what they will cover in terms of requiring someone to present in person or also online, and, as I said in my speech, those regulations will be disallowable.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="93" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.29.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="12:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On the identity verification, what ID will be required for the identity verification process? Surely, some work has been undertaken around ID requirements. For example, is an Australian driver's licence required? For example, would a passport be required? Would identification verification be conducted through non-photo ID? Surely, some work must have been done around what ID will be required. This is not the first time in a legislative scheme that there have been ID verification processes. Plenty of lawyers and migration agents are asking us. Please tell us what ID will be required.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="156" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.30.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="12:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's the same question that I just previously answered in that the government's intent is that the new requirements will ensure that applicants are actively engaging with the review process in early stages of the proceeding, and the regulations will provide the identity documents that must be provided to comply with that requirement. As has been stated already through the committee process, the government's intention is for the substantive identity verification component to be a straightforward requirement that can be met by applicants who are subject to the requirement. The National Identity Proofing Guidelines were updated in 2025 to provide best practice guidance on how to conduct identity proofing both for people with a full suite of traditional types of identity documents and also for alternative proofing arrangements for people who do not have those types of identity documents, and the regulation-making power enables the government to be responsive and provides flexibility to adapt that process.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="227" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.31.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="12:54" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>What will happen if a person doesn't have sufficient ID? I'll give you an example of where it really can be problematic. My sister has Down syndrome. She does not have a driver's licence. She does not have photographic ID. There are occasions where people just don't have the ID that is required under verification-of-identity schemes. In other legislative fields&#x2014;look at, for example, electronic conveyancing&#x2014;there are very strict ID verification processes. I know, from my time as a property lawyer and from having run a conveyancing practice for many years, that there were occasions when people did not have the ID required to meet the verification process. So what will happen if a person doesn't have sufficient ID? Surely this federal Labor government would have undertaken some work on the ID verification process and will not just simply stand here today and push it off to regulations that we have to only guess what they will contain, particularly in circumstances where plenty of lawyers and migration agents are trying their best to help their clients, trying their best to help people who need access to justice and trying their best to spend the money they can find to implement these new and drastically different systems within their businesses? Surely this government can give us an idea of what will happen if a person doesn't have sufficient ID?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="758" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.32.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="12:56" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I think the question goes to two issues that I'm very happy to address. In the first instance, I think the question is around vulnerable people who might have diverse needs or perhaps even people who are in rural or remote areas and may not have a particular type of identity verification. I can address in the first instance what safeguards will apply.</p><p>The identity verification requirement is intended to ensure that applicants seeking review of certain migration and protection decisions actively engage with the tribunal or the court in the early stages of seeking that review. The government acknowledges that some applicants, subject to this new requirement, may be vulnerable, have diverse needs or live in regional or remote communities. The identity verification requirement provides certain certainty and consistency as to the steps applicants must take in reviews to which the requirement is to apply, while there is also flexibility for the tribunal and the court to dispense of the requirement where appropriate.</p><p>The details of the steps an applicant must take to satisfy the identity verification is going to be set out in regulation. The regulations will be designed so as not to disadvantage vulnerable applicants. The bill enables regulations to provide for both in-person and virtual identity verification processes to ensure access for people with diverse needs and people who live in rural and remote areas. Regulations could also provide for classes of applicants that the requirement would not apply to. If an application is dismissed in either the tribunal or the court, as a safeguard, the applicant could seek to have their application reinstated and could explain their circumstances and why they were unable to attend. This would ensure that the tribunal and the court are able to dispense with the requirement where an applicant, through no fault of their own, is not able to satisfy the requirement.</p><p>The court is also able to, by application or on its own motion, dispense with the requirement at any time, not only as part of an application for reinstatement. Applicants will also be supported to understand options to seek reinstatement if they do not meet the identity verification requirements. For example, at the tribunal, when an applicant is notified of the dismissal decision, the notification letter includes information about applying for reinstatement and generally advises the date by which the applicant must seek reinstatement. If applicants have questions about the proceedings or processes of the tribunal or the court, they can use the translating and interpreting services to speak to registry staff in their own language.</p><p>The second issue which I think is being raised is essentially what will happen if someone is unable to meet the identity verification requirement. Putting aside the issue around vulnerable people, which I've spoken to, in practice, the requirement is intended to ensure that applicants are genuinely engaging. We wanted to ensure that key features of the new requirements specific to the tribunal would include mandatory dismissal of the application if the applicant fails to satisfy the requirements in accordance with the notice. As a safeguard, as I said, the tribunal would be able to reinstate an application dismissed for failure to satisfy the identity verification requirement where an applicant applies for reinstatement, if it considers it appropriate to do so.</p><p>In terms of the court's practices, there is a requirement for leave for the court be granted to continue proceedings if the applicant fails to satisfy the requirement in accordance with the notice, and, where leave is not granted, the court may, rather than must, dismiss the proceedings. As a safeguard, the court would also be able to reinstate proceedings which had been dismissed for failure to satisfy the requirement if it considers it appropriate to do so. The court, of course, can also reschedule or extend time for satisfying the requirement and dispense with the requirement altogether at any point where appropriate.</p><p>Just to reiterate and go back to the purpose of these changes, it is to ensure that applicants are genuinely engaging with the review process, that they are aware of the application that's being made in their name and to ensure that that happens in a timely manner. The bill sets out the procedures that would occur, and the regulations will set out not only the details around what types of identity requirements will be used but also how people can appear in person or online. The regulations will also set out where there might be certain types of cases that are excluded from the process.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="127" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.33.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In your answer, you spent some time talking about what can happen if ID verification is not met, so I find it difficult to understand how work has not been done by this federal Labor government around what identification documents would be required to meet the verification process. Will overseas identity documents be accepted? For example, there may be an occasion where someone does not meet a points test for identity verification from a photographic perspective, but they might be residing in a rental property where they have an energy bill with their name on it or an internet service provider bill with their name on it. Will overseas identity documents be accepted and will non-photographic identity documents of the kind that I just mentioned be accepted?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.34.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="13:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question goes to what's in the regulations, so I refer to my previous answer.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="245" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.35.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's disappointing that the work hasn't been done or the work that has been done isn't capable or that this federal Labor government isn't prepared to share with us and all of those in the community who will be impacted by the identity verification process&#x2014;that we can't be told anything more about what that ID verification process will entail. I'll accept that either you don't know, and that's a grave day for the making of new legislation in this chamber, or you're refusing to tell us more of what you do know, which, again, is a grave day for new legislation being passed in this chamber having regard to the millions of people who will be impacted by it. But I'll move on.</p><p>In amendments on sheet IE116, you have put forward changes to membership recruitment that were never flagged in the inquiry or referenced in the bill. They seem to be completely irrelevant to the legislation. Why has the government attached these changes to streamline recruitment of members without flagging at any point&#x2014;during what was a very lengthy inquiry&#x2014;that this is something you were considering? It would have been appropriate to raise it earlier, because an inquiry is the opportune time for amendments of that nature to be properly explored in the interests of justice and in the interests of the community. Was it an afterthought? Or was it a strategic decision by this government to hold out on it until the last moment?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="484" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.36.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="13:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>():&#xA0;&#xA0;In the Senate it is not unusual for Senate inquiries&#x2014;the good ones&#x2014;to make recommendations and to ventilate issues and for the government to consider amendments and bring those amendments forward to the chamber. That is a usual practice that occurs, and it is also the case that if the government seeks to do that then we are informing the chamber in two ways: through a supplementary explanatory memorandum, about changes that are in government amendments, and here at the in-committee stage, answering your questions. So I reject your characterisation in regard to transparency and categorically say that your accusation is untrue.</p><p>But I can talk to those amendments in detail, particularly those on sheet IE116, the government amendments around promotions and appointments. These amendments would further streamline tribunal appointment processes by creating a new process for promotion from general member to senior member. This would allow the Attorney-General to respond more quickly to changing operational needs of the tribunal while maintaining merit based appointment processes at appropriate times. Under the proposed process, a general member of the tribunal could be promoted to senior member before the end of their current term without requiring a full panel process where the Attorney-General is satisfied that the person is a suitable candidate for appointment as a senior member, the person meets existing eligibility and qualification requirements for senior members, and consultation has occurred with the president of the tribunal. Consultation would include consideration of the general member's performance against the performance standard, their compliance with the Code of Conduct, and whether their leadership and management skills are at an appropriate level for the appointment of a senior members. This is consistent with the current appointment framework in the ART Act, and the Attorney-General would seek approval from the Prime Minister for a member's promotion to senior member before making a recommendation to the Governor-General.</p><p>The amendments streamline administration without reducing the rigour of the appointment framework. That is incredibly important to this government. There are two things that we seek to balance when it comes to the effective management of the ART: having a system with fully qualified, merit assessed members who are capable of delivering administrative justice as well as making sure that that can happen in a timely way, to manage the case load of the ART. That is why the government is proceeding with these amendments. Nothing that is being proposed by the government with respect to appointments would change the fundamental precondition to be considered&#x2014;that an applicant is assessed as meritorious by an independent assessment panel. The proposals included in the original bill and those proposed in the government amendments seek to streamline that appointment process and make it more efficient. It is a fact that the tribunal needs more members, and the government is working to do that in an orderly way. We'll make further announcements in due course about its membership.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="260" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.37.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>All this talk about the identity verification process that we have had some exchange on this afternoon has caused a lot of interest from the community. I've just been asked by a person who is scared&#x2014;that's the word they used, 'scared'&#x2014;about what this new identity verification process is. One example I'm reminded of that was raised at the inquiry and that went unanswered was the following:</p><p class="italic">So the Hazara woman has fled with her children to Australia from Afghanistan. She has never had a passport and never had travel documents and has come onshore. The Afghan embassy has shut. She obviously isn't going to go and approach the Taliban in Afghanistan for identity documents because then her family could well be persecuted and killed. What processes will there be in place for a woman in that situation to have her identity verification assessed and not have a mandatory dismissal of her application?</p><p>Just before you answer that question, which remained unanswered at the inquiry, the department did actually reply to my colleague, the Leader of the Australian Greens, Senator Shoebridge, and say:</p><p class="italic">I can't give you an answer with the precision that will make you happy &#x2026;</p><p>Putting aside whether that kind of an answer is an appropriate answer from a public servant who is being paid by public money to answer questions for the public, putting aside for a minute whether that's an appropriate answer, now that you've had the time to sit with that question, can you now fulfil your duties to the public and answer that question?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="288" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.38.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="13:12" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>First of all, I can repeat the answers that I've given before about the impact that these changes may have on vulnerable cohorts. I've already answered that question. The details will be in the regulation. But the government recognises that in some circumstances an applicant may have a legitimate reason for why they are unable to verify their identity, including not having access to certain documents. While the mandatory dismissal procedures apply to all applicants to ensure a consistent approach, nothing in this proposal removes the ability for an applicant to seek reinstatement of their matter through an existing reinstatement process. In these circumstances, an applicant would have the opportunity to explain why they were unable to complete their identity verification, and the tribunal would have the discretion to determine whether to reinstate their matters with or without the identity verification requirement.</p><p>The bill also expressly contemplates that both in-person and virtual verification may be features of the new regulation, and the government will work closely with the tribunal in the development of the regulations to ensure the process is streamlined, accessible and fair. I don't seek to repeat the answers I've given before about how that will or won't impact. I also won't go to individual matters. Of course, I won't be giving advice about individual matters. I also reject the characterisation of the Greens in relation to public servants. I think it's pretty disgraceful that the Greens have now become anti public servant and seek to minimise the work they do. I think that answer, although you're not happy with it, is the appropriate one to give where the making of regulations is prescribed in the bill, and that is exactly what the government will do.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="268" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.39.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Since this bill was introduced, the Albanese government has quietly started charging people seeking asylum more than $1,800 to appeal their visas up-front at the tribunal.</p><p>It seems that this government's got a bit of a habit of making changes to the way that it operates or proposing new laws before having consulted or communicated with those parts of the community that are going to be impacted by those changes. Look, for example, at what occurred with the promised cuts to backpackers. We had the National Farmers' Federation and the Australian Tourism Industry Council running around saying that they had not been consulted in advance. The same thing has happened here, where people&#x2014;including migrant resource centres who exist to help these people, most often for free or on a shoestring&#x2014;were not told that people seeking asylum would be paying more than $1,800 upfront to appeal their visa decisions at the tribunal.</p><p>Why did the government not tell the sector about this change? What was going on at the governmental level that it thought that it was okay to impose upon part of the community who are among those who struggle most a requirement to come up with such a large amount of money, over $1,800, to exercise their rights to review in a tribunal a decision made by a government that is making decisions on visas that are designed to cut the net overseas migration rate? This government is putting the politics of migration before the real impact that those politics of migration are having on people. Why did the government not tell the sector about this change?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="108" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.40.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="13:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I may be wrong, but I think the question is irrelevant to the bill. It goes outside issues raised in the bill. It relates to the Home Affairs portfolio, I believe. I am very happy to have that redirected in a different way. If there's a question relating to the provisions of the bill or the consultation around this particular bill, I'm happy to answer that question, but I think this question goes to a policy area outside of this bill&#x2014;although related, given that 88 per cent of matters considered in the ART relate to migration. It is not something we can discuss in this committee process today.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="255" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.41.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:17" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you very much for pointing that out. I do have a question on that topic which I believe is related to the bill, but please help me out again if it's not. This bill allows registrars&#x2014;so not necessarily people with a strong legal background&#x2014;to throw out applications that are made to the tribunal to review government decisions on visa applications, although the people who are seeking asylum have to pay $1,800-plus. So the government's made a decision. If a person is lucky enough to have a lawyer, the lawyer has said: 'That's a bad decision. I think that's a decision that's wrong at law. I recommend that you appeal that decision to the tribunal, and I believe that you have prospects of success on those grounds of appeal.' This person is fleeing persecution or death. They now have to pay $1,800-plus to make that application. Then, without a proper or fair hearing, a registrar can throw out that application. What happens then to the $1,800? Is it like with the backpackers who, it has been promised, will have to go into a ballot and pay $1,000 for a lotto ticket, with a slim chance, or no chance, of having their name pulled out of the box? Is it like that, where they surrender their $1,000 to the coffers of the federal government? What happens to that $1,800 they have paid if a registrar, without even a fair hearing, throws out their application to review the government's decision to refuse asylum to someone fleeing death?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="538" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.42.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="13:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Just to reiterate, the changes that the government are proposing are about ensuring that genuine applicants have an opportunity to have their matter considered in a timely and efficient way. That is exactly what we are seeking to do. Many of the changes we are discussing today seek to ensure that people who have a genuine application and seek judicial review receive that review. That is what the ART are required to do, and they do that in the context of the right that people have to seek review of those types of decisions. The context of these changes is to ensure that those people, no matter what type of visa decision it is, are given an opportunity to have that decision considered.</p><p>I want to address some of the comments around registrars. We don't want to get into a legal qualification debate, but, suffice to say, I think that registrars are highly qualified appointees. Most are legally qualified or have experience in dispute resolution or experience related to the functions of the tribunal. It's incredibly important that that is respected. The power&#x2014;that is, the power that we are considering&#x2014;being performed by registrars can adequately be performed by an authorised registrar and would enhance the efficiency of the tribunal process. For example, the power is routinely exercised where an applicant fails to meet an objective visa criterion which requires them to be onshore in Australia at the time that the application is made because they are outside of Australia. The president would be able to issue directions in relation to the exercise of this power by a registrar&#x2014;for example, that the power may only be exercised when based on clear objective criteria.</p><p>Some of the examples of dismissal based on failure to satisfy an objective criteria include where an applicant is required to be onshore in Australia at the time the application is made but they are in fact not in Australia; where an applicant must be below a certain age when the application is made to the original decision-maker and they are older than that age; where an applicant is required to have a nomination in place at the time of their visa application to the decision-maker and the nomination has not been approved; and where an applicant is required to provide evidence when making their visa application that they have undertaken an English language test and achieved a specified score but they have not done so.</p><p>Under the ART Act, a person cannot be appointed as a registrar unless they have a degree or similar educational qualification of law, as I said earlier, and qualifications or training experience relating to dispute resolution. A comparable power to issue summary judgements, including on the ground that an applicant has no reasonable prospects of success prosecuting the proceeding, is delegated to registrars in the general federal law jurisdiction of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.</p><p>To reiterate, if those objective criteria are not met, it would mean that that application is dealt with quicker and in a more efficient way, allowing genuine applications to be considered in full by a member in a timely manner. That is exactly why the government is seeking to make these changes.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="265" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.43.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>When we look at what the bill says about registrars being able to throw out applications, it seems a lot broader, to me, than what the chief executive officer and principal registrar of the ART, Mr Hawkins, said. He made clear that the tribunal doesn't expect to use this power in complex cases. That's the first limitation that he was expecting to apply to the power for the tribunal to just throw out an application without a full and fair hearing. There's no limitation in the bill. In fact, the only clear example that was provided by him was for its use in successful cases. Mr Hawkins explained:</p><p class="italic">I am thinking that they would probably be set aside decisions where the applicant is the victor, so to speak. The applicant is happy with the outcome and doesn't really need to know the reasons.</p><p>It all strikes me as odd that this is what Mr Hawkins would say. When you look at what Mr Hawkins says on the one hand, and then you look at what the bill says on the other, you just can't see how they can peacefully coexist in practice at all.</p><p>If this is the example provided by the tribunal, why isn't the government only applying this change to successful applications? Why has the government gone along and given a broad and open power to the tribunal, without a fair and proper hearing, to just decide to throw out applications, instead of the having more refined way that the CEO and principal registrar of the tribunal himself expected to be the case?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="386" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.44.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="13:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you. I'm just checking, but I think the answer you are referring to from the President relates to the use of the tribunal from oral reasons. I'm assuming that your question actually goes to registrar powers. Okay, I'm getting some nods from your advisers. We can deal with the registrar powers and possibly the safeguards that are in place on that. I'm sure you'll have questions about oral reasons as well. But, just to be clear, and to be fair to Mr Hawkins, we don't want to take his comments out of context. He wasn't talking about registrar powers; he was talking about the use of oral reasons, which is a different power that is being considered under this bill.</p><p>I will go to the safeguards that are in place to ensure that registrars exercise these powers appropriately, because, of course, I'm sure that is of interest to the Senate. The President may issue directions in relation to the authorisation given to registrars to exercise the power to dismiss an application for review or make an order requiring an application to seek leave of the tribunal. The President may, for example, issue a direction that a registrar can only exercise the dismissal power in certain circumstances, for example where the basis of the dismissal is a failure to satisfy an objective criterion, which I took you through in my previous answer. This will ensure that an appropriate level of discretion is exercised. As a matter of procedural fairness, the tribunal will write to an applicant to seek their submissions before using the dismissal power, and the tribunal can also reinstate an application which has been dismissed for no reasonable prospect of success under either the ART Act or the Migration Act. Depending on the act, an application may be reinstated where an application has been dismissed in error or where the tribunal considers it appropriate to reinstate the application. Under the ART Act, a person cannot be appointed as a registrar unless they have those qualifications that I took you to earlier. That deals with the safeguards that are in place under decisions made by the registrar. We will work with the tribunal in terms of their development of any directions. But that is what is anticipated in practice by the use of these powers.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="74" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.45.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="13:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>When moving this bill under the guise of efficiencies by denying someone an immediate right to written reasons for a decision, when the actual decision is made in circumstances where the government complains about an increase in appeals following the government's decision on visa applications, did the government look at the increase in visa decision appeals coinciding with the government refusing more visa applications to artificially decrease the net overseas migration rate?</p><p>Progress reported.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.45.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="interjection" time="13:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We will now move to senators' statements.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.46.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
STATEMENTS BY SENATORS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.46.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Housing </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="236" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.46.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="speech" time="13:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In August 2026, Tanya Plibersek said that not in her lifetime had there been a better time for first home buyers in Australia. Well, if this is the best time, I'd hate to see the worst. Housing starts are down 17 per cent. Rents are expected to jump eight per cent in my home state of Western Australia next year, and that's on top of increases over the last four years. Mortgage payments are up tens of thousands of dollars per year since Labor came to power. New home buyers&#x2014;many, many thousands of new home buyers&#x2014;are now in negative equity under this Labor government. New investor loans are down 30 per cent; these are the people that build the houses that other people rent. And you'd think, 'Well, what about first home buyers? Maybe Labor has done something for them.' First home buyer applications are down by 10 per cent. First home buyers can't get into the market. Investors won't get into the market. People are in negative equity. Mortgage costs are up. Rental costs are up.</p><p>If you'd told me that this Labor government could make such a mess of the housing market, even I might have disbelieved you. But what a mess they have made. Everything they have touched in the housing market has turned to dust. Australians are paying an absolutely devastating price for Labor's ongoing failure to address our housing market issues.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.47.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Victoria: Schools </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="306" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.47.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" speakername="Jana Stewart" talktype="speech" time="13:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It was a real pleasure recently to spend the day in Tarnagulla, Koondrook and Cohuna, joining students, teachers, families and local community members to officially open new facilities and playgrounds at their primary schools. As someone who grew up in the Mallee, who grew up in regional Victoria, these visits are particularly meaningful to me. I know firsthand the opportunities, the challenges and the strong sense of community that come with growing up in a regional town. That's why I firmly believe that growing up in regional Victoria is something that you should absolutely be proud of, but it should never mean missing out on the same opportunities and facilities that we see elsewhere.</p><p>The Albanese Labor government is backing that belief with action. Through the Schools Upgrade Fund, with an investment of $215.8 million nationwide, public schools across Australia are receiving support to build and refurbish important infrastructure that improves the learning environments for students. Additionally, through the Capital Grants Program, with an investment of $98.8 million nationwide, non-government schools are also supported to improve their infrastructure.</p><p>In Tarnagulla, Koondrook and Cohuna, that investment has helped deliver brand-new playgrounds for local primary schools&#x2014;and I did get to give them a run, swinging on the monkey bars and heading down the slide! On behalf of the Minister for Education, Jason Clare, I was delighted to join all those school communities to celebrate these wonderful facilities.</p><p>While the new playgrounds and learning spaces themselves are fantastic, the highlight of the day was, of course, meeting the students and hearing directly from them about what these new facilities will mean to them. These aren't just places for them to play; they are places where they learn and grow and build new friendships. It was a privilege to celebrate these milestones with the Tarnagulla, Koondrook and Cohuna school communities.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.48.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Raise Our Voice in Parliament </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="297" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.48.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="speech" time="13:34" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Today I will be speaking not on behalf of myself or the Greens, but on behalf of a young person from my home state of South Australia. I'm taking part in the Raise our Voice in Parliament campaign, which gathers speeches written by young people from across the country and gives them an opportunity to have their views, their words and their ideas heard right here in parliament. I'll be reading a speech from 11-year-old Rhea, from my home state of South Australia, who lives in the federal electorate of Mayo. Rhea says: "Climate change is not a distant threat. It is already affecting Australians today. We see it in devastating bushfires, destructive floods and prolonged droughts. These disasters are costing lives, destroying communities and placing enormous pressure on future generations. A few more years, and our wildlife and nature will all be gone, all because we are too incompetent to wake up and look outside the window. Our country is crumbling around us because we cannot look after it.'</p><p>She continues: 'The current generation did not make this mess, though we are forced to deal with it. We are told we are the next generation, but a future cannot thrive on promises. It takes courage, leadership and action. Our country has everything it needs to be a world leader. The question is not whether we can act, it's if we will. The actions needed seem very big right now, but, if we don't do anything, the consequences will be far greater.'</p><p>Thank you, Rhea from South Australia, these are words that every single one of us here in this building should remember, and we should be focusing on and centring the voices of young Australians far more in our discussions, our debates and our policy deliberations.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.49.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Budget </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="355" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.49.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" speakername="Dave Sharma" talktype="speech" time="13:36" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>When he launched a budget assault on the Australian housing market and on small businesses, the Treasurer claimed he was standing with workers and first home buyers but, like much of the rest of the Australian economy, workers and first home buyers have been left behind by the budget and by this government. Australian workers do not just feel worse off, they actually are worse off. If you look at real wages today, they are at the levels last seen in 2011. That's over a decade ago, and, on current projections, they are not going to recover to where they were in 2021 until 2034. That's two decades of lost real wages growth.</p><p>With the government spending continuing to fuel inflation that eats away at and erodes the very foundation of real wages, the prospects for first home buyers to save or get into the market are looking increasingly bleak. Just last week, new figures released from the ABS show a complete lack of confidence in the housing market not only from investors hit by these new changes to capital gains tax and negative gearing but by first home buyers. In the September quarter alone&#x2014;this is the last quarter&#x2014;the first full quarter after the government's budget changes were announced, there was an 8.6 per cent reduction in first home buyer owner-occupier loan commitments. Meanwhile, new investor loan commitments fell by 30 per cent.</p><p>An 8.6 per cent reduction in new first home buyer loan commitments would, you think, have the alarm bells ringing. But, instead, the Treasurer describes these as 'encouraging signs'. He's saying it's making it easier for first home buyers to get into the market. How is it that first home buyers are taking out loans at a lower rate than before the budget if it's easier to get into the market?</p><p>It's not only first home buyers who are losing confidence. The Treasurer's own colleagues are losing confidence in him, so much so that Minister Watt had to use the media to beg his own colleagues to stop leaking against the Treasurer. Everyone is losing confidence in this government and this Treasurer.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.50.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Wong, Mr Joshua, International Relations: Australia and China </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="262" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.50.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="speech" time="13:38" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Earlier this month, a court in Hong Kong sentenced Joshua Wong to a further 10 years in prison. Joshua was 24 when they locked him up. He's now 30. He was due to walk free in January. His late 20s and how his 30s were taken from him simply for speaking up. When the national security law was imposed in 2020, I stood in this place and warned that it would be used to silence people. Joshua Wong is proof of that. His so-called crime was asking the world to pay attention. Some call it collusion; I call it courage. Jailing a man for a decade for asking foreign governments to act is not justice; it's punishment for having a voice. The law is designed to send one message to every Hong Konger: speak up and you will risk losing your freedom. I'm very proud that the Australian government joined nine of our closest partners in a joint statement speaking out against this sentence and calling for an end to this unjust prosecution. The statement also stood up for two former leaders of the Hong Kong alliance who were jailed for seven years for keeping the memory of Tiananmen Square alive.</p><p>This doesn't stop at Hong Kong's borders. Hong Kong authorities have also put bounties on people living here in Australia, in our suburbs&#x2014;those that are raising their families&#x2014;in my home state of Victoria particularly, in Melbourne, where there's such a large diaspora of people from Hong Kong. Intimidating our people on Australian soil will not be tolerated&#x2014;not now, not ever, never.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.51.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Housing, Employment </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="314" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.51.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" speakername="Malcolm Roberts" talktype="speech" time="13:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The September quarter saw a 15 per cent drop in home loan applications. Investor loans for rental properties fell 31 per cent. Home values are falling faster than at any time in the 40 years data has been kept, less than two per cent from being the largest fall on record. ANZ says 2.3 per cent of mortgage customers are in negative equity&#x2014;the borrower owes more than the house value&#x2014;which is up from 1.7 per cent a year ago. Inflation increased to 4.6 per cent. Interest rates increased to 4.85 per cent. Unemployment is up to 4.7 per cent, a five-year high.</p><p>Australia still added 168,000 jobs in the year to September. The bad news, though, is that there were more new workers than new jobs, with an increase in unemployment of 55,200. The Albanese government's extreme immigration program displaced 55,200 workers from jobs. ANZ shed 3,500 workers; NAB, 2,500; Canva, 1,200; Coles, 1,000; CBA, 1,000; Qantas, 850; and David Jones will displace thousands more. Extreme immigration has created a pool of unemployed that continues to bring down real wages, which have fallen one per cent this year and two per cent since Labor took office. Rents continue to rise, up six per cent in the last year. All of these new arrivals need somewhere to sleep. New home starts were 35,000 short of what's needed to keep up with the government's 240,000 target, meaning rents will get worse.</p><p>Every measure is moving against the people of Australia. This is failure after failure. The rancid, bankrupt, corrupt Victorian Labor government proves this is not just on the Prime Minister. It goes to the core of what the Labor Party is all about and has become. One Nation is now the party of the worker. Victorians have a choice: complete your slide into bankruptcy or vote One Nation and restore abundance and opportunity for all.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.52.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Motor Racing Series Australia: Shelley 300 </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="433" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.52.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" speakername="Ross Cadell" talktype="speech" time="13:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's a great privilege to be able to sit in this chamber, and it's a great privilege to work in this building. It gives us many great things and many opportunities. But there are also disadvantages. One big one is that we're away from our family so very often. So I'm going to be a little indulgent and speak about something that I had the benefit to do yesterday.</p><p>I've been down here since Wednesday and won't be back in the Hunter for a couple of weeks, but yesterday I had the ability to attend the Shelley 300 motor race in Goulburn, just up the road from here. My Barnaby-esque glow is from the vitamin D overload that I managed to get from that event. It was a great thing to be there because&#x2014;this is not the least of the reasons&#x2014;a young racer, a 17-year-old by the name of Mitchell Cadell was there and managed to get sixth place in his 222 MJC Nissan Pulsar. Well done to him. So many people participate in motorsport across Australia. It's a great industry that's not looked at. There would have been a hundred cars operating there, all costing thousands of dollars to get on the grid and have a crack.</p><p>I want to thank the people that go and do this. We have Steve Shelley, who bought the circuit and redeveloped it. There's Lachlan Mansell, who worked with him&#x2014;you might know him from the series called 'nerd and the babe' or something like it; it was a TV series. Now he's the commentator up there. We have people going right through the system. We have Terry Denovan, who runs the Motor Racing Australia series and put that on. There are all the competitors and drivers. In the Nissan Pulsar series, I want to thank Rod and Kris Albronda for the time they give up&#x2014;they're not racing themselves&#x2014;to do this. We have Leanne Potts who goes down and does all the social media. We have the Pirozzi brothers who, again, have stepped away from racing to help administer the series.</p><p>Motor racing is expensive. It is fun, but it is a great pastime that brings people together. It was great to be able to be there on that day, to see Mitch team up with Adrian Sarkis. I thank all the guys who were involved: Scott DiLegge, Lewis Bolton, Adrian Roach, Alex Roach and all of the guys through the years. Well done to you all. Motorsport is a great thing. Thank you for letting me be a part of it. I had a wonderful time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.53.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Western Australia: Manufacturing Industry </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="285" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.53.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" speakername="Ellie Whiteaker" talktype="speech" time="13:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's not unlike me to get up in this place and talk about all the great things that we make in WA&#x2014;ships, trains, iron ore, cars, batteries, wind turbine parts and more&#x2014;but, when we talk about Aussie manufacturing, I think we often forget about food and beverage manufacturing, but it's a big industry right across the country. In Western Australia, in Perth's outer southern suburbs, every single McDonald's bun that is eaten in WA is made there in WA at ARYTZA's new bakery in the Peel Business Park. This high-tech bakery can produce 40,000 buns an hour. That probably gives you a sense of how many McDonald's burgers are being eaten across WA each day. It supports more than 100 local jobs in Perth's south-west. It shows just what is possible in terms of making more here. Right next door is the Food Innovation Precinct, funded by our government, and it's set up to do just that&#x2014;make more things in Australia. It's enterprise support program backs small and medium food and farming businesses that want to develop a new product, turn research into something they can sell or start exporting, and I got to see that innovation firsthand. They told us someone was there making water out of thin air, and I didn't quite believe it until I saw it for myself in the work of Dr Ramadan, the co-founder of Drip.AI. I also visited Spinifex Brewing Co., who are trialling a way to clean their wastewater with electricity instead of harsh chemicals, saving them thousands of dollars, and it's better for the environment too. This is what a future made in Australia looks like&#x2014;food manufacturing here in Australia and supporting local jobs and innovation.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.54.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Discrimination </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="265" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.54.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" speakername="Mehreen Faruqi" talktype="speech" time="13:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I love cricket. I mean, how can you not love cricket? One of the happiest moments of my life was playing cricket at the SCG in a match between New South Wales politicians and the media. To my surprise, not only was I the only woman on either side, but I was the only brown person as well. The attacks on Usman Khawaja for telling his story in <i>Sabr</i> are a good reminder of why cricket in Australia is still such a white sport and why racism still persists. Sabr means patience, steadfastness, tenacity and endurance, and I know from experience how much sabr it takes to overcome constant hurdles if you're a first in a minority community, whether it's cricket or politics, and especially if you are outspoken.</p><p>Of course, new information about the sandpaper scandal should be scrutinised, but the ferocity of backlash piled on Usman makes it hard to deny that it has nothing to do with his race or religion. It didn't take long for the 'he should be grateful' trope to emerge, and with it came the 'go back to where you came from' slur and the horrific News Corp cartoon. Usman's book reveals structural racism in sport and in society. That story is being ignored. It must be taken seriously not flippantly dismissed as 'nothing to see here'. Telling our stories is hard, especially when we're already seen as outsiders, but our stories must be told so things can change for people who follow in the footsteps of the firsts. I am proud of Usman Khawaja for telling his.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.55.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Parliamentary Standards </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="303" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.55.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" speakername="Ralph Babet" talktype="speech" time="13:48" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Today, I find myself in a position that I had never imagined I would be in, and I want to say something that I didn't think I'd say for a million years, but lay off the Prime Minister, guys. Lay off the Prime Minister. Criticism of the Prime Minister over a hot mike conversation with Minister Chris Bowen about the effects of mobile phone radiation on his nether regions is actually a little bit ridiculous. He was having a joke with a mate, and this is what some of you want to be outraged about&#x2014;come on! If you want to be angry about something to do with the Prime Minister, I'll give you a few suggestions instead. Be angry about the five interest rate rises this year and the 17 since Labor came to power. Be angry about the sky high taxation. Be angry that the government's wild spending continues to fuel inflation. Be angry that, despite wage rises, the cost of living means that you're still going backwards. Be angry that your electricity bill is becoming unaffordable while the government throws billions of dollars at crazy schemes. There is a long and very distinguished list of reasons to be upset with the Prime Minister, but a silly conversation about phone radiation and his trousers&#x2014;come on!</p><p>Look, I don't want to defend the Prime Minister. Frankly, it feels very unnatural to me. I'm sure it's never going to happen again, let's be honest. But the Prime Minister is allowed to have a joke with his friend, even if his friend is a peanut. Look, if we're going to hold this government to account, let's at least hold it to account on things that actually matter. Of those things, we are spoilt for choice because there are so many things to be upset about.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.56.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Qantas </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="303" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.56.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" speakername="Tony Sheldon" talktype="speech" time="13:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Qantas and Accenture's game plan of using AI and offshoring to gut 850 Australian jobs is nothing short of a betrayal. We've already seen major corporations like Coles and Telstra strike deals with Accenture to strip Australian jobs and ship them offshore. Now Qantas is joining this shameless club. Rather than ensuring its workers and its workforce shares in the benefits of AI and technology, Qantas has chosen to abandon its people.</p><p>Here's how this deal works. First, Qantas ships Australian jobs offshore when Accenture takes over much of the work. Then Accenture bankrolls Qantas upfront to shift towards humanless technology to fatten Qantas's bottom line. In return, Accenture stands to pocket a share of the savings generated as more and more work becomes humanless. In other words, the more human work replaced by AI, the more money Accenture makes. This is a cowardly move that sets a dangerous precedent for corporations to sacrifice meaningful human oversight in pursuit of a quick cash high.</p><p>This is the same Qantas that recorded $2 billion in underlying profits last financial year. It's the same Qantas that received $2.7 billion from the then Liberal-National government during COVID to keep Australians employed, yet carried out the largest illegal sacking in Australia's history. You would think Qantas would learn its lesson, wouldn't you? But it seems determined to prove that even rock bottom has a basement.</p><p>In May this year, Qantas CEO Vanessa Hudson said:</p><p class="italic">&#x2026; I don't think it's the right thing to only think about the value that AI can give is through headcount reduction &#x2026;</p><p>Six months later, see what happened. As Australian Services Union NSW &amp; ACT Secretary Angus McFarland rightly said, if Qantas wants to prove it has changed since the Alan Joyce era, it can start by keeping Australians' jobs in Australia.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.57.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Tasmania: Health Care </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="396" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.57.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100910" speakername="Jacqui Lambie" talktype="speech" time="13:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Tasmanians spend years waiting to see a specialist; years waiting for a first appointment. I'm not making this stuff up. These are figures from the Tasmanian Department of Health's own website: over 1,000 days for a neurology appointment, nearly 2,000 days for a respiratory appointment and over 1,000 days for urology. The Tasmanian health system has been on its knees for years, and it has finally hit rock bottom.</p><p>In the 2025-26 financial year, Ambulance Tasmania recorded nearly 17,000 delayed activations, a 30 per cent increase on the previous year. A delayed activation is when people call for help and are told an ambulance is not immediately available. In October, two Tasmanians died following delays in getting an ambulance. On the west coast, a man died after an ambulance took 78 minutes to reach him. In Hobart, a family had to drive their loved one to hospital because they were told there were no ambulances available, and he died shortly after arrival. I extend my deepest sympathies to the families and loved ones of both of those men.</p><p>There is something very, very wrong, and it's only getting worse. The state is nearly $10 billion in debt, but the government has committed us to a multibillion-dollar stadium while cutting 1,700 public sector jobs. Last week, the AMA, nurses and midwives called for a commission of inquiry into our health system. Of course, the Tasmanian Liberal government said no, it would cost too much. Well, how much are you putting on a person's life? That's what I want to say to you, Rockliff, today. They also said that it would replicate the results of other reviews and the current parliamentary inquiry. Here's my issue: if we have already had inquiries and recommendations made that were working, then why are these issues getting worse?</p><p>We have a government in Tasmania that is happy to spend whatever it takes to make the AFL happy, but we won't spend the money investigating why our health system is falling apart and finally on its knees. Why did the Premier and Treasurer make a point of rejecting a 22 per cent pay rise, only to take it anyway? This is at the same time the government is offering nurses and midwives three per cent. We clearly need a commission of inquiry into Tasmania's health system with the widest terms of reference available.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.58.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
National Disability Insurance Scheme </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="265" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.58.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100946" speakername="Lidia Thorpe" talktype="speech" time="13:54" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This speech is by Corina Abraham:</p><p class="italic">My name is Corina Abraham. I am a proud Bibbulmun-Yok, Noongar elder, mother and grandmother. I am an academic and worked in the government sector for 20 years. I am a custodian and advocate for my people and Country and won the fight to save the Beeliar Wetlands.</p><p class="italic">I need one to one, 24/7 care but my NDIS plan has been downgraded compared to my plan from last year. I fought for 4 years to get that plan and I went to the tribunal. It ruled in my favour, except for in-home dialysis. That case is going to the Federal Court this week.</p><p class="italic">The plan I fought so hard for has been cut. My funding for Supported Independent Living has been taken away, as has the funding to coordinate my hours and my transport. I can't get an accessible van to keep my independence and relying on accessible taxis is excruciating.</p><p class="italic">My funding has not been calculated correctly and when I raise that with the NDIA I am told 'not their problem'.</p><p class="italic">I am a regular hospital in-patient and I can't have any supports with me in hospital.</p><p class="italic">Because of NDIS cuts, my choice and autonomy have been taken away. There's no care that I am an elder and a cultural woman. There is no respect, cultural awareness or understanding in the NDIS.</p><p class="italic">I have to fight for everything, which greatly impacts my mental health and wellbeing.</p><p class="italic">To all of you in this chamber, stop cutting our plans, listen to us, treat us as human beings and stop dictating.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.59.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Defence Properties </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="343" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.59.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" speakername="Jessica Collins" talktype="speech" time="13:56" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Last month, I co-hosted a rally with Dr Marjorie O'Neill, the New South Wales state Labor member for Coogee. The rally was a multipartisan show of support to stop Defence Minister Richard Marles's plan to evict the Australian Army from Victoria Barracks Sydney, after more than 180 years of successfully operating there. The multipartisanship on that day was unlike anything I've ever seen before. I saw Labor and Liberals side by side, waving the same flag. I saw Greens and One Nation members with their arms around each other. I've not seen anything close to that in this chamber. This is one of those rare examples where the things that unite us are so much more than our differences.</p><p>Every day, soldiers go to work in a uniform, and they don't wear that uniform for themselves; they wear it for you. That flag that they wear on their left shoulder is our flag, and the Australian Army is part of Australia's DNA, the DNA that all Australians share. I welcome the Prime Minister's intervention to stop the sale of Victoria Barracks Sydney, but I ask that he intervene again to stop the Army being evicted before Christmas, because the rally that brought us together was not just about ownership; it was about custodianship and capability. Victoria Barracks Sydney is far more than a heritage item; it's a fully operational Defence base with multiple security zones supporting classified work up to Top Secret. Labor, you need to know that despite what your defence minister has peddled to you all, Defence Plaza Sydney is not fit for purpose for the Army. Its breakout areas and telephone boxes might be fashionable in the corporate world, but they are not practical for a military setting. The Australian Army have always been willing to fight for us, and now we must fight for them so they are not evicted from a fit-for-purpose space and their spiritual home by the spiteful defence minister, Richard Marles, who has a fractured relationship with Defence and a complicated relationship with the truth.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.60.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
United Nations </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="209" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.60.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="13:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In October, I addressed the Second Committee of the 81st Session of the United Nations General Assembly in New York on behalf of Australia, Canada and New Zealand. We called for stronger climate action and for development that advances the rights of women and girls and people with disabilities. Our Pacific neighbours led the push for the UN Declaration on Sea Level Rise. Australia and Cabo Verde helped negotiate this. The declaration affirms that island nations can keep their maritime zones and remain sovereign as seas rise.</p><p>Multilateralism matters here at home too. From Pilbara iron ore to Wheatbelt grain, WA exports depend on ships to be able to move freely through our region. International law protects that freedom and gives countries a peaceful way to settle maritime disputes.</p><p>In New York, the Albanese Labor government launched Australia's bid for a non-permanent seat on the UN Security Council for 2029 and 2030. A seat would give Australia a stronger voice in decisions about international peace and security and a chance to bring our region's concerns to the council. Australia helped to establish the United Nations. Eight decades on, we have a stake in making it work better so countries can act together sooner when conflict threatens and disaster strikes.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.60.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="13:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I've got 20 seconds left. Senator Watt.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.61.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Cost of Living </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="70" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.61.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="13:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Albanese government continues to maintain our laser-like focus on supporting the many Australians facing cost-of-living pressures right now. Unlike the opposition, we have supported higher wages. Unlike the opposition, we've supported cost-of-living relief, like cheaper medicines and cheaper child care. Unlike the opposition, we've supported more funding for social and affordable housing. You can rely on us to focus on the cost of living, not what they are doing.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.61.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="13:59" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We'll now move to question time.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.62.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.62.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Taxation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="74" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.62.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Labor's toxic trust tax is a $4-billion-plus tax grab in its first year alone, and Australian small businesses and family enterprises will face even more financial pressure because of it. How many small businesses turning over less than $10 million will be forced to pay more tax under Labor's latest tax grab, and exactly how much will they be forced to pay?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="64" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.63.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Cash for the first question in this Senate-only sitting week, and I'm sure we're all looking forward to that. As I have indicated previously, Senator Cash, to you, the vast majority of small businesses do not operate through trusts. I'm advised that less than 10 per cent are affected in any given year. That is a very clear indication of the&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.63.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="interjection" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>What is that going to cost them?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="188" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.63.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I appreciate that you have the position you have, but the government has made clear why it is important that we progress these tax reforms, why it matters for the economy, why it matters for jobs and why it matters for fiscal sustainability. In relation to small business, I'd make a few points. The first is that there are a range of options for existing trusts, which the Treasurer has flagged. They include restructuring. They include choosing to be exempt from the minimum tax by ensuring they allocate distributions year to year and by paying a wage to beneficiaries employed in the trust. In relation to small business, I would remind those opposite of Labor's record of support for small business, measures to support cashflow and reinvestment, making the $20,000 instant asset write-off permanent and making two-year-loss carry back permanent. In fact, let's remember that the instant asset write-off was in fact a Labor initiative in 2011, unwound by the coalition in office and reintroduced by the Labor government and made permanent. It's similar with loss carry-back, building on our record of delivery for small business. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.63.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Cash, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="63" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.64.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="14:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>CPA Australia estimates that your toxic trust tax could cost businesses and taxpayers up to $2.8 billion in professional advice alone before one single dollar is spent on restructuring. With small businesses already battling soaring costs, higher interest rates and mounting insolvencies, why are you forcing them to hand over billions of dollars just to comply with a tax they've not asked for?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="154" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.65.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>First, in relation to tax-compliance costs, I'd make the point that the government has engaged in reform, which is about cutting tax compliance costs by over $500 million a year, including by making the instant asset write-off permanent, including by modernised 'pay as you go' to help businesses, including by abolishing nuisance tariffs and also including by ensuring that workers have a $1,000 instant tax deduction to make tax time simpler and quicker.</p><p>In addition, the wider productivity package that the Treasurer has introduced is reducing compliance costs for businesses by over $10 billion a year. Our reforms to trusts include expanded options to limit or eliminate restructure costs for small businesses and others using discretionary trusts. I'd also make the point that, in fact, what we see is new small-business registrations up 35 per cent under this government, and we are backing those businesses with tax relief and fairer competition law. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.65.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Cash, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="72" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.66.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="14:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, small businesses across Australia are living an economic nightmare under your government. These are the businesses that are the backbone of the Australian economy. They're supporting families, and they're keeping regional communities alive. Why are you ignoring their pleas to scrap your toxic tax, and why are you so addicted to taxing and spending that you are prepared to sacrifice Australia's small businesses just to pay for your own economic failures?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="94" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.67.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I might respond by way of putting a few facts on the record. The first is that&#x2014;there's a lot of hyperbole, but we'll just respond by talking about some of the facts&#x2014;new small-business registrations are up 35 per cent under this government. The second is that, under our government, we have 30 times more businesses opening than closing, and more businesses are being paid on time. Under this government, big businesses are paying small suppliers faster, and the Commonwealth government is paying twice as fast as the average. Now, I just make these points&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.67.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="interjection" time="14:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Small businesses are doing it so good under you!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="53" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.67.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, Senator Cash, I know you always want to go this route. What I'd say to you is that we have put in place $3.8 billion in new practical measures to support businesses. I know you don't want to acknowledge that, nor do you want to acknowledge that more businesses are&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.68.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Fuel Security </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="55" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.68.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="speech" time="14:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Resources, Senator Ayres. For two decades, Australian households and manufacturing firms have paid high and volatile gas prices despite Australia being one of the world's largest gas producers. Why is the Albanese government's domestic gas reservation important for Australian industry, Australian jobs and Australian households?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="231" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.69.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="14:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thanks very much, Senator Ghosh, for that question, from a state that has had a reservation policy in place since the early 2000s. This is an important week for structural economic reform for blue-collar Australia. That's what gas reservation will deliver&#x2014;lower gas prices. Australian gas should work for Australians. It's as simple as that. We have got, in Australia, plenty of gas. We have got plenty of gas in Australia. Australian families, Australian businesses and, in particular, Australian heavy industry should be able to access that Australian resource at an affordable price, and that has been denied to them by the failure of successive governments and parliaments to deliver this reform.</p><p>That's why the Albanese government is acting&#x2014;and acting this week. It's about making sure that we keep good, secure, blue-collar jobs in regional Australia. It's about making sure that manufacturing firms have got the confidence to invest in future industrial capability. It's making sure that Australian gas is available at affordable prices to power Australian factories. This is a once-in-a-generation opportunity for this parliament to set up low-cost gas as a source of future competitive advantage for Australia, not a drag on our competitive advantage. You can't talk about competitiveness and productivity reform and vote against gas reservation. You can't say you're for Australian manufacturing and vote against gas reservation. So I say to everybody in this parliament&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.69.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ghosh, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="53" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.70.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="speech" time="14:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In an open letter written today to the Senate, unions, manufacturing firms, energy users and business groups have all called on senators to pass the Domestic Gas Reservation Bill in the national interest. What does this broad support for the government's domestic gas reservation tell us about the importance of getting this done?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="5" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.70.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="interjection" time="14:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>What does Roger Cook think?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="116" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.71.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="14:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, Senator Cash, what manufacturing firms say and what energy users say and what Australian businesses say and what Australian trade unions say&#x2014;between them, those businesses represent hundreds of thousands of workers in blue-collar Australia and hundreds of thousands of jobs in blue-collar Australia. They are crystal clear to the parliament: do not waste this opportunity. Delay is disaster for Australian manufacturing. Deferral is disaster for Australian manufacturing. There may be people in this place who want to play politics with this reform, but this is an important structural reform for Australia. Industry have been very clear with this parliament about what they need from this parliament, and that is to act in Australia's national interest.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.71.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ghosh, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="39" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.72.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="speech" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It is clear that businesses, manufacturing firms, unions and energy users have shown strong support for the government plan, but who will lose out if this reform fails to pass and we don't reserve enough Australian gas for Australians?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="165" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.73.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="14:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That is something that this parliament should not allow to happen. Each of us have a responsibility here in this place. Industry has been very clear, through what's been an exhaustive process that has gone on now for more than 12 months. There is not a single firm on the producer or consumer side of the equation who has not been engaged in this process. What is the clear position that industry are saying? They are saying vote for the reform.</p><p>There are always vested interests who would rather that nothing got done and that we have the status quo. There are always vested interests who will take that position. They did in Western Australia in the period leading up to the 2005 reform, and some of the voices in our political system who said that the sky would fall in have found that the Western Australian reform has delivered blue collar jobs, blue collar investment. We want that for all of Australia. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.74.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Housing </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="90" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.74.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="speech" time="14:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Minister, the latest ABS figures show new home loans collapsed by 15 per cent and new loans to first home owners have plunged by 8.6 per cent in the last three months. The Australian dream of homeownership is falling apart. With the ABS identifying these disastrous impacts from Labor's tax changes, is it now the deliberate policy of the Albanese Labor government to crash Australia's housing market, or is this just another consequence of your failed housing policies?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="116" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.75.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The deliberate policy objective for this government is to level the playing field for first time buyers. That is what we are doing. Senator Bragg, I know you have a longstanding ideological position on not actually wanting federal government engaged in housing policy. You don't think supply should have anything to do with government, and you're quite happy with taxpayers continuing to fund tax breaks for investors. You are very clear about your belief that taxpayers&#x2014;workers such as cleaners, construction workers, tradies, teachers&#x2014;should all find tax breaks for investors. That's what you want.</p><p>We have a different view. We think it is important for first home buyers to enter the market and&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">Opposition senators interjecting &#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.75.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I called order, and a couple of you, including you, Senator Bragg, chose to yell more loudly&#x2014;and I think Senator McGrath, but apologies if it wasn't you. I expect you to listen in silence.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="161" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.75.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The second objective that we are clear about is we want to incentivise investors to add to supply. We want to incentivise investors to purchase new builds. Senator Bragg, I know, again, you have a very strong affection for tax breaks for investors; I appreciate that's your political position. That is not the position of the government. We believe that we should have more young people entering the market. We think that the desire for Australians to own their own homes should be something that can be realised, and that is what our policies are focused on and that is what they will deliver.</p><p>The point I would also make is that in the latest ABS data we saw first home buyers accounting for almost a quarter of all new lending, which is the highest share since December 2023. Senator, I know you may think that is a bad thing. We want to see more people entering the market. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="5" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.75.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:11" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Bragg, Minister, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="59" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.76.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="speech" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Labor promised 75,000 additional first home buyers over a decade. That's 3,750 every six months. Instead, first home buyer lending has fallen in two consecutive quarters, with 3,800 fewer loans over the past six months. How can the Prime Minister claim his own housing policies are working when Australians are being pushed further away from owning their first house?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="61" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As Senator Bragg knows and as those opposite know, you do have to add to supply, and that is what we are seeking to do. And what I point out is that housing approvals are up. They are at their highest level since 2021. Housing commencements are up, and housing completions are up. I know you don't want to believe this.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister Wong, please resume your seat.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.3" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="30" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order! When Senator Bragg asked his question, he was heard in silence, and I expect the same courtesy and respect to be shown to Minister Wong. Minister Wong, please continue.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="46" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I pointed out, the facts are that approvals are up, housing commencements are up, housing completions are up, more than 700,000 new homes have been built under this government, and a further 248,000 dwellings are under construction, which is the highest number since the 1980s.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Bragg!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="51" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator, you can interrupt me all you like, but these facts exist.</p><p>Well, you may not agree with them. Senator Bragg. We know that you don't agree with them. I am interested&#x2014;and I'll come back to some of your quotes&#x2014;whether you still agree with your own quotes from earlier this year.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.77.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Bragg, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="55" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.78.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="speech" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Completions are down, so you'll need some new pieces of paper. Minister, rents are rising, home lending is falling, first home buyers are being squeezed out, and housing supply is under pressure. If crashing the housing market isn't Labor's policy, why is the Prime Minister persisting with tax changes that risk making housing even worse?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="120" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.79.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I disagree with almost every single proposition in that question. But what I would ask, Senator, is whether you agree with yourself. In July you said, 'Prices are too high in Australia.' In June you said, 'The honest truth is that house prices in this country are too high, and they should go down.' In June you also said: 'Do I think house prices are too high? Yes I do.' They should go down. In May you said, 'I can tell you, as shadow housing minister, I think housing prices are too high.' So I am interested to know whether Senator Bragg agrees with Senator Bragg, because Senator Bragg made it very clear he wants house prices to go down.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="26" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.79.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister Wong, please resume your seat. Order! Senator Ayres! Order on my right! Senator Bragg! Order! Order across the chamber! Senator Bragg, did you still wish&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.79.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" speakername="Andrew Bragg" talktype="interjection" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I have a point of order on relevance. The question was about the Prime Minister's policy. I don't think, in the 40 seconds the minister has been going for, that's been addressed at all.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.79.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I will draw the minister to your question. Senator Shoebridge! Order! I would also ask you not to interject.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="45" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.79.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I think I did deal with it. I think it was a political riff that we don't agree with. We have a different view. We appreciate Senator Bragg has a range of views, some of which he now agrees with, some of which he doesn't.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.80.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
United Nations Climate Change Conference </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="55" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.80.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister. Minister, why on earth did the Prime Minister fly all the way to Turkiye for COP31 and fail to even mention fossil fuels in his address? Does your government think you can have a serious global conversation about climate change without even mentioning fossil fuels?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="114" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We are serious about responding to climate change. We are also serious about transforming the Australian economy. And you're correct; we are an economy that is heavily resource dependent, and we have in particular an energy system which has been very reliant on fossil fuels. And, unlike the Greens, we recognise that is serious economic business, serious economic transformation, to ensure that you shift the economy from the footing on which it has been for decades and decades onto a different path. Unlike you, we don't believe that yelling and condemning people and pointing the finger and saying things which are not particularly accurate and making people angry is actually how you initiate reform.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="36" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's a point of order on relevance. My question was about the Prime Minister's speech in Turkiye and him not mentioning fossil fuels. If you can, ask the minister to direct her answer to the question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The minister is responding to your question, and I'll continue to listen carefully.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="33" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I may say, through the Chair, if the senator chooses to use the tone he did and the contempt with which he constructs his question, then he is going to get a response.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Could I ask you to have the minister be relevant and not do her usual tone policing?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="23" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge, I'm going to ask you to withdraw that comment.</p><p>No, Senator Shoebridge. You stand up in this chamber and you withdraw.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Yes, I withdraw.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="49" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.10" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Leadership&#x2014;what I was going to say was the tone of the question, the way in which the question is framed, demonstrates a very big difference between the Labor Party and the Greens about the task. You see, we don't think complaining about it, making people angry, is actually reform&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="10" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>You don't even talk about it. Just answer the question!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.12" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order! Senator Shoebridge, come to order, please.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="85" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.13" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I was trying to have a serious discussion, Senator Shoebridge, about the sort of reform of our economy which is required and which the government is committed to. I come from a state where a very high proportion of our energy is provided by renewable energy. We have done that hard work against criticism from those opposite and, as I recall, not a lot of support or commendation from the Greens. But it is a path that we have undertaken, and it is&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.81.14" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="32" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.82.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="14:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, was it a direction from the Prime Minister himself to deliberately not mention fossil fuels in his keynote address, or did it come from climate minister Bowen? Who made that decision?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="76" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.83.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, I'm pleased that you are very focused on who drafts what. We're focused on policy. We're focused on delivering that policy. The policy we are seeking to deliver is the transformation of Australia's energy system and the transformation of an economy which has historically been fossil fuel based. Unlike you, we know that that requires serious economic policy, serious reform and a proper conversation with the Australian people and with working people in those sectors.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="37" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.83.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm taking a point of order on relevance. My question was very simple: was it a direction from the Prime Minister to deliberately not mention fossil fuels or from climate minister Bowen? The minister refuses to answer.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="16" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.83.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge, the minister is being directly relevant to your question, and I'll continue to listen.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="67" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.83.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The point I'm making about serious economic reform and the work to do that is evinced by some of the work that Senator Ayres and others have been doing in making sure we maintain a substantial manufacturing capacity, with all that that means for the workers and the regions concerned through this transition. That's the serious work Labor is doing, and we will continue to do it.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.83.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="38" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.84.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="14:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, was the decision not to mention fossil fuels by the Prime Minister in any way influenced by the over a million dollars in fossil fuel donations received by the Labor Party during the last federal election alone?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="44" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.85.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I know the Greens have received very large donations from gambling. I would make the point that you would find it very offensive for anybody to suggest that that change your policy position. You should apply that equally to other parties in this place.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.86.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Economy </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="70" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.86.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="14:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the fabulous Minister for Finance, Senator Gallagher. The Albanese Labor government has delivered savings in every budget and every update, and the minister and the Treasurer have both said the government will do so again at the approaching mid-year update. Why is it so important that sensible saving measures are supported to ensure that Australians continue to receive the support they need while growing the economy?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="273" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.87.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="14:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Cox&#x2014;and welcome back, on this side of the chamber. It is really important that we continue on the path we embarked on when we were elected, which is to repair the budget, to find sensible savings where we can, and to continue to invest in important and essential services that the Australian community rely upon. As the Treasurer has said and as I have said, we are currently going through the decision-making required for the mid-year economic and fiscal update, and there will be further savings in that update, just as there have been in every budget and every MYEFO since we came to government and started cleaning up the mess we inherited from those opposite.</p><p>And it was a big job. It's very easy to forget, isn't it, that Medicare was falling over, that you couldn't see a bulk-billing doctor&#x2014;that it was very hard to get in to see one. It's very easy to forget that the NDIS was running away because no attention had been paid to that spending area of the government, and it was continuing to blow out, and no changes had been made there. It's very easy to forget that the energy system was in turmoil, partly because of Mr Taylor and the fact that he hadn't attended to the significant economic transition that was occurring across the energy system. We have had to fix all that and invest in essential services. Remember the veterans' claims? Tens of thousands of them were left unattended to. We have fixed all that, found savings and repaired the budget over time, and we will continue to do so.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.87.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Cox, first supplementary.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="63" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.88.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="14:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Conflict overseas is putting pressure on people here at home, but the Albanese Labor government is working every day to support Australians and to grow our economy. How has the government balanced budget discipline with maintaining essential services and delivering reforms to strengthen our economy, repair the budget and provide cost-of-living support to Australians? And why is it important that this approach continues?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="168" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.89.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="14:27" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Cox for the supplementary question. This government has been dealing with all those challenges we inherited and making the investments we need to support Australians, including with cost-of-living help, most of which those opposite opposed when we brought them to this chamber. Indeed, we get lectures from those opposite about areas in which to reduce spending, but when we bring them to this chamber they seem to have a different position and don't like any of those particular measures, even where we're bringing measures like the EV changes that we want to get through this Senate; you're not engaging on that. On private health insurance, you've said no. Our modest changes to veterans' allied health: you've said no to them. On tax reform, you've said no. So you are a bunch of hypocrites when it comes to the lectures you give and what you say in the media and then how you come in here and vote. It is two entirely different positions. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.89.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:27" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Cox, second supplementary.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.89.3" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Hon. Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:27" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Honourable senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="47" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.90.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="14:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Albanese Labor government has found $180 billion in savings and reprioritisations&#x2014;the largest savings package in history. Why is responsible budget management important, particularly now, and how is the government delivering the services Australians deserve, like Medicare, aged care and the NDIS, while we're repairing the budget?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.90.2" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Hon. Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Honourable senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="38" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.90.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:28" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Before I call the minister, I'm going to remind the Senate that when senators ask their questions they are to be treated with respect and listened to in silence. Equally, when I call the minister, the same applies.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="149" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.91.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="14:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank Senator Cox for that question, because the question goes to the heart of the work we have been doing, not only finding savings but also asking how we deal with those pressures coming at the budget that are increasing, not decreasing&#x2014;in defence, in the NDIS, in aged care, in health, in hospitals, in all of those areas where we are seeing pressures grow, not reduce. And we have to make room across the budget to invest in those services. That's what we're doing. That's what we've done with the $180 billion worth of savings and reprioritisations we've already found. That is what we're doing when we're bringing sensible and modest reforms to this chamber, whether it be tax reform or changes to arrangements like the private health insurance rebate&#x2014;modest reforms that will provide room to meet increasing pressures. And you say no to each one of them.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.92.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Taxation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="90" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.92.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="speech" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is for the Minister representing the Prime Minister. Minister, the Greens have revealed that Australian motorists are being slugged with a fuel tax rate 15 times higher than that applied to private jet owners. At a time when families are wondering whether they can afford the fuel to visit their loved ones over Christmas, how can your government justify giving private jet owners, including billionaires like Gina Rinehart and politicians like Senator Hanson, a fuel tax discount that means that they pay 15 times less than ordinary motorists?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="108" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.93.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The first point I'd make is that obviously we've been very focused, as a government, on ensuring that we did what was required to ensure that Australian motorists, Australian farmers and Australian truck-drivers and our economy continued to have access to fuel, to petrol and diesel, through this crisis where we have seen the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, as, obviously, the majority of the oil to the Asian markets transits that passage&#x2014;or previously did. This has required the government to do a number of things. The first is to engage with other countries, and you might recall that the Prime Minister, I and other ministers engaged&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.93.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Wong, please resume your seat. Senator Hodgins-May?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="20" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.93.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="interjection" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>A point of order on relevance: my question was specifically as to private jet owners getting that fuel tax credit.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="12" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.93.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Senator Hodgins-May. The minister is being relevant to your question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="169" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.93.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I do intend to come to that, Senator, but I think it's relevant to talk about the circumstances of energy supply in this country, and a great deal of effort&#x2014;and also of taxpayer funds, underwriting contracts for difference&#x2014;was put in place to ensure that Australia kept running, because we're a very high per-capita user of diesel and diesel was critical for the Australian economy. And we did that.</p><p>In relation to aviation fuel, I haven't seen the detail of your proposal that you reference, but I am advised by the minister that excise on aviation fuel is applied at the terminal gate or comparable excise licence facilities, so there is no ready mechanism to have differential excise rates between private aircraft and other aircraft. But I will certainly be very interested in hearing&#x2014;I am sure we will hear over days to come&#x2014;more about your proposition.</p><p>I think you also mentioned a few other billionaires. I suggest Senator Hanson might be more able to respond in relation to that question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="5" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.93.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hodgins-May, first supplementary question?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="61" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.94.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="speech" time="14:32" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, mining giants like BHP and Rio Tinto receive billions of dollars in total fuel tax credits every single year while making superprofits and contributing to the destruction of our climate. How can your government justify handing billions of dollars in fuel tax credits to some of the world's wealthiest mining companies while ordinary Australians are being smashed by cost-of-living pressures?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="128" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.95.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, Senator, first, I would make the point that the government has invested a great deal of effort and also funds to underwrite supply into this country, for Australians, for motorists, but also because diesel inputs are critical to agriculture and critical to the supply of food in this country. So I think you're wrong to make a suggestion that somehow there's not a focus on the effect of the energy crisis on ordinary Australians. That has absolutely been the government's focus.</p><p>In relation to the resources sector, I appreciate that you have a view that you would like to shut those industries down. The government has a different view. They are important to our economy and they do operate within environmental standards which are set by governments.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.95.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:33" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hodgins-May, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="44" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.96.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="speech" time="14:34" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, just to avoid any doubt, can you stand up and please tell us who you actually work for. Do you work for everyday Australians trying to survive this cost-of-living crisis, or do you work for the billionaires flying around in their private jets?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="52" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.97.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:34" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I think that the Greens say things which are not true in order to make people angry and to contribute to their social media feed. If you're asking me personally, I've spent over 20 years of my life working for the Australian people and working for the sort of Australia I want.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.98.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects in Victoria </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="89" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.98.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. In just the first week of Victoria's Big Build royal commission, we've heard evidence of the CFMEU shutting down construction sites, contractors being warned that they could lose government work unless they've cooperated with the union and union officials boasting of a direct line to Premier Jacinta Allan's office. The Prime Minister has claimed that he had been given assurances that no federal taxpayer money was involved. Does the Prime Minister still have confidence in those assurances?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="92" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.99.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I have responded to you and Senator Cash in relation to this question previously, our government does not tolerate corruption, criminality and violence in any part of the construction industry, and we have taken federal action to clean up the industry. The administrator that has been appointed by us has achieved more progress towards cleaning up the union than occurred in a decade under the coalition and the ABCC. Following multiple referrals from police and regulators, there are over 100 active investigations, cases, audits and reviews ongoing into the construction sector.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.99.2" speakerid="unknown" speakername="Opposition Senators" talktype="interjection" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Opposition senators interjecting&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.99.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Order!</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.99.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>What I would say in relation to Commonwealth procurement&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="16" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.99.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Henderson, I've called order. It applies to you. Minister Wong, had you finished? Please continue.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="98" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.99.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="continuation" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>No, I had not finished. In relation to Commonwealth procurement, which I think goes to your question, Senator Hume, I have previously indicated that Minister King has written to state and territory counterparts on multiple occasions, reinforcing the obligations they have under federation funding agreements and the need to report instances of suspected criminal behaviour or corruption to the relevant regulator and department. Minister King has also written to GBEs involved in the delivery of Commonwealth led infrastructure projects, outlining expectations that all instances of suspected criminal behaviour or corruption are reported to the relevant regulator and department.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.99.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hume, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="76" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.100.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="14:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The royal commission has also criticised the Victorian government agencies for withholding evidence and providing heavily redacted documents, with warnings that failure to comply with compulsory requests could result in imprisonment. Whether it's election commitments or falling off a stage, Australians know that this prime minister has a problem with the truth, but can he assure Australians that no Commonwealth documents will be held or delayed in the same way if requested by the Victorian commission?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="66" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.101.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>():&#xA0;&#xA0;In relation to the first part of the question. I think that is not a question for the federal government.</p><p>If I may, Senator Cash, the first part of the question is a matter for the Victorian government. As to the second, what I would say is that the federal government will ensure we respond appropriately to any request from any legal body, including this one.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.101.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hume, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="53" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.102.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="14:38" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, before the latest revelations, the Labor Party has already voted four times against establishing a Senate inquiry into corruption in construction. How much more evidence does the Albanese government need before it stops blocking scrutiny of Commonwealth taxpayer funded projects and lets the Senate investigate corruption in construction across the entire nation?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="74" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.103.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator, I would say to you what I have said previously: that we have taken stronger action against the CFMEU than any previous government. We have taken action. We have appointed an administrator, we are seeing multiple referrals from police and regulators, and there are active investigations. So this government and this prime minister have taken stronger action against the CFMEU in relation to alleged criminality than any previous leader and any previous government.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.104.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Water </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="88" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.104.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" speakername="Pauline Lee Hanson" talktype="speech" time="14:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister for the Environment and Water, Senator Watt. Foreign ownership of Australian water entitlements has increased under Labor. In 2022, 4,503 gigalitres of water entitlements had a registrable foreign interest, according to the Australian Taxation Office. Under the Labor government, that number has increased by 13 per cent to 5,089 gigalitres as of 2025. That's enough fresh water to fill Sydney Harbour 10 times over. Minister, how many more litres of Australian water will your government allow foreign owners to buy next year?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="112" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Senator Hanson, for the question. I'll need to come back to you with precise details about the sort of figures that you're citing and requesting from me.</p><p>I am very much aware of one water buyback that involved a foreign company, and that was, of course, the foreign company that the now opposition leader, Mr Taylor, was associated with when Mr Barnaby Joyce, now a member of the One Nation party, organised a water buyback when he was the minister for water. I have found it amusing that Mr Joyce and One Nation are now so vociferously opposed to water buybacks when Mr Joyce organised water buybacks as the minister.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister Watt, please resume your seat. Senator Hanson?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" speakername="Pauline Lee Hanson" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Relevance to the question. I'm asking the government how much they intend to buy back next year from foreign ownership. It has nothing to do with the past.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="37" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Senator Hanson. You will note that the minister has indicated he doesn't have those figures in front of him, and he intends to come back to the chamber if he can assist. Minister, please continue.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="39" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="continuation" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I was saying, it was a Cayman Islands registered company, as I recall, that Mr Taylor had an association with&#x2014;oh, Senator Scarr's not happy about that. Senator Scarr's not happy about me talking about Mr Taylor's Cayman Islands&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister Watt, please resume your seat. Senator Scarr?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Relevance, President. If the minister's got nothing further relevant to add, he should sit down.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question went to water buybacks and numbers around that. The minister's being relevant to the question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="119" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="continuation" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's good to see Senator Scarr making a bid for a promotion in the reshuffle that we know is coming on the opposition side of the chamber. I have enjoyed very much watching the opposition wake up a little bit now that they've got a bit of an audience on both sides of the chamber&#x2014;an audience that they don't normally have.</p><p>Senator Hanson, as I say, if you'd like to know more about foreign ownership of water resources in Australia, I'm sure Mr Taylor would be able to oblige. I'm sure Mr Joyce would be able to oblige and talk to you about the buyback that they arranged when Mr Joyce was the water minister not so long ago.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.10" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister Watt, please resume your seat. Senator Hanson?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="33" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" speakername="Pauline Lee Hanson" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question was not about buybacks. Under the current government they have allowed foreign ownership of a further 13 per cent. Your government has allowed and extra 13 per cent. Answer the question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="57" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.12" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hanson, resume your seat. There have been a number of points of order. I've indicated the minister is being relevant, and I'll indicate once again that the minister is being relevant. I remind you that when you stand up to make a point of order, it's not an opportunity to make a statement. Minister, please continue.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="144" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.13" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="continuation" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In the time since Senator Hanson asked me the question, one figure I can provide is that approximately four per cent of foreign held water rights are held as irrigation rights in Australia, and that number has stayed fairly constant over the last few years. Senator Hanson, as I say, if there's any further information I can provide, I'll certainly do that.</p><p>I'm sure Mr Joyce would be happy to oblige in retelling stories of the days when he used to support water buybacks before, of course, he became a guy who opposed water buybacks. But that makes him fit in with One Nation because we know they like to say one thing and do the opposite. Now we've seen it from Mr Joyce when it comes to water buybacks, just like we've seen it on a series of other policies from One Nation.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.105.14" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hanson, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="54" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.106.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" speakername="Pauline Lee Hanson" talktype="speech" time="14:43" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I think Labor is more common for changing their position than anyone else. As I stated in my previous question, foreign ownership has increased 13 per cent under the Labor government from 2022 to 2025. How much taxpayer money has been given to foreign owners of water entitlements under your government's water buyback scheme?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="143" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.107.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="14:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, Senator Hanson, again, if there are specific details I can provide to you in terms of the figures that you're seeking, I'll let you know, but your question related to the water entitlements that you say are owned by foreign interests, and you're also asking to know about dollars that we have provided as a government to those individuals. We would only be providing money to individuals if we buy back their water entitlements. If those people hold water entitlements then we wouldn't be providing money to them. So I suspect that the answer to your question is zero. When we buy back water, we provide money for it. If people hold water, we don't provide money to them. So I suspect that the answer to your question is zero. If that's not the case, I'll come back with some further information.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.107.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hanson, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="36" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.108.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" speakername="Pauline Lee Hanson" talktype="speech" time="14:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Foreign ownership of Australian water entitlements is not in the interests of Australia. When will you adopt One Nation's policy of banning foreign ownership of water and requiring a connection to land to receive an entitlement?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="193" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.109.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="speech" time="14:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, Senator Hanson, you'll be sorry to hear that our government has no intention of adopting One Nation policies on a range of matters. We don't intend to adopt One Nation's policy that bosses should have it easier to sack their workers, for example. We don't intend to get rid of bulk-billing incentives to GPs in the way that One Nation has called for. We don't intend to get rid of the same job, same pay laws, which have resulted in coalminers, aviation workers and many thousands of other workers getting the pay that they deserve despite the fact that One Nation voted against those laws. So there are any number of policies that are being put forward by One Nation. I might just focus on one that came out from One Nation recently, and that, of course, was the policy to let Australians raid their own superannuation, a policy which shows exactly how untested One Nation is when it comes to governing this country and how much damage they would do to the Australian economy and the Australian people if they ever got to share the government benches with the Liberal Party.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.110.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Disaster and Emergency Management </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="79" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.110.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" speakername="Ralph Babet" talktype="speech" time="14:46" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Emergency Management, Minister McAllister. Minister, the United Kingdom recently advised households to prepare to be self-sufficient for three days, while Norway recommends one week. What assessments has your government undertaken of Australian households' ability to manage prolonged disruptions to electricity, drinking water, food supplies, telecommunications and electronic payments, including disruptions caused by cyberattacks, sabotage or armed conflict, and what has that assessment recommended to date if you've done one?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="254" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.111.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:47" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senators will know that we came to government with a very clear agenda: to improve Australia's preparedness for natural disasters. The Minister for Emergency Management is responsible for the National Emergency Management Agency. That entity was established by Labor for precisely the purpose of improving Australia's resilience and readiness for significant natural disasters. That's meant a range of investments, analysis and community work.</p><p>In our system of government, states and territories are responsible for being the first responders&#x2014;for responding in the first instance to emergencies. But the Australian government has a role to play if an emergency exceeds the capacity of a state jurisdiction. We also have a role to play in working with states and territories to support communities to recover, and senators will know that, from our government's perspective, that's meant a range of investments to make sure that across all those domains&#x2014;preparedness, response and recovery&#x2014;we are better resourced than we ever have been to deal with what is an increasingly challenging weather system and natural disaster profile.</p><p>You asked about preparedness. The most recent and significant example is Exercise Nexus, which was undertaken between 3 and 5 June this year, and it explored our national capability to respond to and recover from a catastrophic all-hazards crisis. That involves stakeholders from state government, but it also involves community stakeholders and people who work in business, because we increasingly understand that both the public and the private sectors and the community have a shared responsibility in preparing for and responding to natural disaster.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.111.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:47" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Babet, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.112.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" speakername="Ralph Babet" talktype="speech" time="14:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you. Minister. What period of self-sufficiency does your government recommend for essential supplies, and what's informed that recommendation?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="161" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.113.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I indicated in my answer to your first question, Senator, that emergency response is, in the first instance, a role for the states and territories. I know that, in different states and territories, they issue different advice to their communities depending on the particular risk profile that those communities experience. For example, people living in North Queensland commonly have to prepare for cyclones. Those communities, in my experience, are very well experienced and well practised in making such preparations, and the Queensland government works with their emergency management services to meet with communities in the lead-up to any cyclone season and provide information about how communities should prepare themselves and their households for an event of that kind. That does include recommendations about stocks that people might want to get in, but, as you can imagine, the kinds of preparations that are relevant in Far North Queensland look really different to what might be needed, for example, in Tasmania. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.113.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Babet, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="37" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.114.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" speakername="Ralph Babet" talktype="speech" time="14:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, what guidance or recommendations has your government issued to households on preparing for prolonged supply disruption caused by something like a cyberattack, a sabotage or armed conflict? You've talked about natural disasters, but what about those?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="149" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.115.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Babet, in directing a question to me&#x2014;I obviously represent Minister McBain&#x2014;you are implicitly asking about natural disasters, and my answers are couched in terms of the responsibilities that Minister McBain holds. I indicated to you in my answers to your first two questions that each state and territory provides advice to their local communities about how best to prepare for the emergencies that they might be likely to confront, and I indicated to you also that there's a good reason for that to be done at a state and territory level. We've got a really vast geography. We're a country at continental scale. Tasmania does look and feel very different to Darwin, and Darwin looks and feels very different to the south-western parts of Western Australia. The preparations that are necessary for communities living in those areas will necessarily look different for each of those communities. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.116.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
United Nations Climate Change Conference </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="97" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.116.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" speakername="Susan McDonald" talktype="speech" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. So far, for COP31, it's been revealed that Australian taxpayers have been billed $2.2 million for travel and accommodation costs, including $32,000 just for free coffee for delegates; over $700,000 to subsidise the flights of climate activists; $3 million for a climate change documentary&#x2014;that's $40,000 a minute&#x2014;and over $200,000 for basic diplomacy lessons from German climate spinners. Why is the Prime Minister more focused on making crude and embarrassing comments on the world stage than on delivering his promised $275 cuts to Australians' power bills?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="239" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.117.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you to the senator for the question. I would make the very important point that not only were we elected with a very clear, responsible and ambitious climate policy; we also understand that it is central to Australia's interests, particularly in the Pacific, for us to be active on climate. What we have done as a government, whether it's through our presidency of the negotiations at COP31 or the work in the Pacific, is to work with the Pacific to elevate Pacific experience&#x2014;and they have firsthand lived experience of climate change&#x2014;and we are continuing to do that. For example, you reference a video. It's a video which speaks about and goes to the experience of Pacific peoples in the face of climate change. The Pacific said very clearly to us and to your government when you were in government that climate is a national security issue. It is an economic issue. It is central to their engagement in the world, it's central to their experience, and it's central to the sustainability of their cultures.</p><p>I would also make the point that, in relation to the COP, we are serving as President of Negotiations, and the delegation and activities of the delegation reflect that role. It is a role, again, in partnership with the Pacific, who want us to bring global attention to the experience of their peoples. This has been central to our rebuilding of relationships&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.117.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator McDonald, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="65" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.118.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" speakername="Susan McDonald" talktype="speech" time="14:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, yesterday it was revealed that part of the COP31 $2.2 million accommodation costs includes hotel rooms for Minister Bowen at the luxury five-star Xanadu. How can Labor justify spending millions of dollars on luxury accommodation, coffee and climate propaganda while refusing to renew approximately $2 million in annual funding for Ask Izzy, a service helping vulnerable Australians to find food, housing and emergency support?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="143" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.119.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator McDonald, I certainly will come back to you on that last point. I don't have the figures in front of me, but I think I was asked it previously in a question a few weeks ago about the additional support we were giving to a range of charities.</p><p>But, in relation to costs, of course taxpayers have a right to scrutinise how their money is being spent. That is fair enough. I would make the point in relation to coffee being provided at the Australian pavilion that that tradition was started by no less than then minister Mr Taylor. It was his decision to provide free coffee to attendees back in 2021. I think he said then, 'Good coffee, good company.' I understand why you're making a political point, but this is a position that has previously been supported by&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.119.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:55" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator McDonald, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="53" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.120.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" speakername="Susan McDonald" talktype="speech" time="14:56" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Minister, I look forward to you looking into the Ask Izzy question given that it is on all of the government websites. They're directing people to that service which you've now cut funding for. How much in emissions have Minister Bowen and his presidential entourage spewed into the atmosphere attending Pre-COP and COP31?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="159" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.121.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="14:57" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator, we have a fundamentally different view that involvement in climate discussions globally is an important part of governing this country and of being part of a response to the climate internationally. I know you don't agree with that. You believe that we don't have to talk about this. That was the attitude that Mr Morrison had. You will know what happened in the Pacific islands region as a consequence of the attitude that Mr Morrison had, that Mr Abbott had and that Mr Dutton had. We lost all credibility and all capacity to engage because we were dismissive and arrogant about the issue that matters most to them. We have spent the last almost five years rebuilding our relationship with the Pacific, which is essential for Australia's security and stability. It is essential to the stability of the region. So those opposite, who do not understand the extent to which climate is a national security issue&#x2014; <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.122.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Medicare </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="78" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.122.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" speakername="Michelle Ananda-Rajah" talktype="speech" time="14:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Health and Ageing and Minister for Disability and the National Disability Insurance Scheme, Senator McAllister. November marks one year since the Albanese Labor government delivered our record investment into Medicare. That's because this government believes in a simple principle: when you're sick, you shouldn't have to worry about how much it costs. How has the government's record investment in Medicare helped more Australians see a GP for free?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="292" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.123.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="14:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ananda-Rajah is right. Last November our government delivered the largest-ever investment in Medicare's 40-year history. That was because we believe that, when you are sick, the only card that you should need is your Medicare card. This November, we are seeing the results of that investment. This November, more than 4,000 GP practices across Australia are fully bulk-billing practices. This November, more than 97 per cent of Australians live within a 20-minute drive of a GP that bulk-bills all their patients.</p><p>Senator Ananda-Rajah, in your home state of Victoria there are over 1,100 fully bulk-billing practices. In Senator Whiteaker's home state, the number of fully bulk-billing practices has more than doubled, and, indeed, in Senator Ruston's home state of South Australia, she will be delighted to know, bulk-billing has also doubled. We have made this investment because, behind those numbers and behind those statistics, there are real Australians and there are real families that feel the difference. It is a parent who doesn't have to think twice about taking a sick child to the doctor. It is somebody who is managing a chronic condition who can afford to see their GP regularly rather than putting off an appointment. It is someone who notices that something isn't quite right and gets it checked early without worrying about the bill. We know that, when cost is a barrier, people put off care, and too often a small health concern can become a much larger problem. That is why this is such an important investment. Treating health problems early is better than waiting until someone needs an ambulance or a more complex hospital treatment. This government understands that investing in Medicare today helps Australians with the cost of living and builds a stronger Australia.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.123.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="14:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ananda-Rajah, first supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="62" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.124.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" speakername="Michelle Ananda-Rajah" talktype="speech" time="15:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Albanese Labor government knows that illness and accidents don't just happen between nine and five. That's why, at the beginning of this year, the government launched 1800MEDICARE, giving Australians access to free expert health advice wherever they are and whatever the time. How is the government making it easier for Australians to access health care when and where they need it?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="151" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.125.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="15:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Whether it is midnight or midday, Australians want a place to turn if they have a health concern, and often the first thing that you need is not a trip to the hospital; it's a conversation with a health professional who can point you in the right direction. That is exactly what 1800MEDICARE does. In just 10 months, more than one million Australians have accessed free health advice through this service. It's a service that connects Australians with the right care, including to after-hours GP telehealth services, when needed.</p><p>More than 170,000 people have been diverted from busy hospital emergency departments or from calling triple zero. That means fewer people spending hours in emergency when they could receive the right care elsewhere. It means our hardworking paramedics and our hospital staff can focus on people who are seriously ill or injured. This is what responsible investment in health care looks like.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.125.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="15:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ananda-Rajah, second supplementary?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="54" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.126.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" speakername="Michelle Ananda-Rajah" talktype="speech" time="15:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Whether it's bulk-billing, 1800MEDICARE or Medicare urgent care clinics, the Albanese Labor government is delivering affordable and accessible health care and helping Australians deal with cost-of-living pressures. How does strengthening Medicare help Australians today while also delivering a stronger health system for the future? Does anything stand in the way of the government's approach?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="142" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.127.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="15:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We invest in primary care because it is better for Australians to get on top of their health concerns early. It's why we invested in Medicare urgent care clinics. It's early care and free care for urgent, non-life-threatening conditions. That is better for our health system. It prevents problems from becoming bigger or from becoming more expensive. Unfortunately, those opposite have never really understood this. They left bulk-billing in freefall, and they even tried to introduce a GP co-payment. Now, when we're turning that around and making a record investment in Medicare, what is it that they have to say? Recently Senator Ruston has accused us of 'bullying' doctors simply for encouraging local practices to bulk-bill. That is a very unusual posture, isn't it, Senator? The government makes it easier to see a doctor for free, and the opposition calls it bullying.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.127.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="interjection" time="15:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I ask that further questions be placed on notice.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.128.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
STATEMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.128.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Member for Indi </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="183" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.128.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241" speakername="Penny Ying Yen Wong" talktype="speech" time="15:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I just want to make some very brief comments in relation to Dr Helen Haines and acknowledge the statement that has been released today confirming she has moved into rehabilitation and out of hospital. I know I speak for everyone in this place in saying that all our thoughts are with Helen and that we all wish her strength as she embarks upon what will undoubtedly be a very challenging rehabilitation. It says a great deal about her character that, even as she faces these challenges, in her statement she looks ahead to the work she wants to do to improve the lives of children following the donations to Save the Children that Australians made at her request. It is an example of her determination and her generosity, which are so admired. We all look forward to welcoming her back to the parliament when the time is right. As the Prime Minister said, the day Helen resumes her seat in parliament will be a resounding moment for the Australian democracy. Until then, we wish her and her family all the very best.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="56" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.129.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="15:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I thank Senator Wong for her comments in relation to the very good news that Dr Helen Haines has been discharged from hospital. That is obviously warmly welcomed across the parliament. She has demonstrated extraordinary courage and resilience, and, on behalf of my coalition Senate colleagues, we wish Helen every strength during her continued recovery.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BUDGET </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Consideration by Estimates Committees </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="660" approximate_wordcount="51" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="speech" time="15:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Pursuant to standing order 74(5), I ask the Minister representing the Minister for Home Affairs for an explanation as to why an answer has not been provided to Home Affairs question SED25-092 of the 2025-26 Supplementary budget estimates relating to the Australian Border Forces purchase of fishing boats for certain purposes.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="15:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Watt, do you have a point of order?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="110" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="interjection" time="15:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's very well known by all senators that if a senator wishes to ask a question like this, they provide notice of that so that the relevant representing minister can come to the chamber ready to answer the question. In this case, I am the representing minister. I'm not aware of any notice having been provided to this. This is not the first occasion that Senator Payman has done this. I'd ask for your direction as to how we should proceed from here. I'm not sure why it is that every other senator in this chamber is able to provide notice but Senator Payman is not able to provide notice.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="70" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="15:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>As I said last time, it is a matter of courtesy, as you have raised, that such matters are notified. However, from the position of the Chair, it is impossible to enforce that effectively. It's in Senator Payman's hands whether she extends that courtesy or not. I'm happy to give you the call if you wish to say anything further. Otherwise I do have to give Senator Payman the call.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="84" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" speakername="Murray Watt" talktype="interjection" time="15:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Again, as you have suggested, I'd ask Senator Payman to reflect on what you've just said. You're correct that this has been pointed out to Senator Payman before. A senator is much more likely to get a more complete answer if they provide notice. I can foreshadow right now I'm not going to be in a position to provide Senator Payman with much of an answer, because, of course, I haven't had an opportunity to get any information from the minister who I represent.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1174" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.130.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="continuation" time="15:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate takes note.</p><p>The government speaks of courtesy and convention. I'm told that I should provide a heads-up when I intend to ask a question about an overdue question on notice. My question is: how much notice do you need? Because this question is almost a year old. Is a year's notice not enough, Minister? Should I come back in 2027? I would suggest that, when the government makes the decision to deliberately not answer a question, it should not expect the Senate to tolerate this refusal. It should expect the house of review to follow up on things using all procedural tools at its disposal. Now this question relates to reports that the ABF has been buying up fishing boats around the north coast of WA and the Northern Territory to give to illegal fishers and asylum seekers. It asks the ABF about the expenditure it has incurred in purchasing these boats, whether there was a tender process and what purposes these boats are used for.</p><p>Now, before I go any further, let's get something clear before the spin machine of the government gets into operation. I do not disagree with this policy.If our government has to choose between buying a boat to get people, including illegal fishers, back home safely or risk letting them drown at sea, I choose the boats. I do not want to live under a government that would choose to let a person die. This is obviously unacceptable when it comes to asylum-seekers, but, even in the case of illegal fishers, if they break Australian law, it must be dealt with through the proper legal processes.</p><p>What I have an issue with, when the taxpayer is paying for these boats, is all the secrecy around what is being done with these boats and how much is being paid for them. As the Senate can see, this is not an issue on which the government has been forthcoming. This question is nearly a year old, and it still remains unanswered. Why? Why is it taking so long to explain how much was spent on fishing boats, Minister?</p><p>In another question on notice on this topic, I asked, 'Is it the case that the ABF is giving illegal fishing crews boats to return home in?' That was followed by a series of supplementary questions. The response to that first question was no, and the supplementary questions were left unanswered. I want to note that Senator Shoebridge has also asked about this issue at estimates. He was told at a hearing in December 2025 that reports of these fishing boats being given away to illegal fishers and asylum-seekers was disinformation. Apart from that, officials were not willing to discuss the issue at all in front of the committee and took on notice Senator Shoebridge's questions about where these boats are going. The response to the question on notice, which arrived 71 days after the due date, did not use the word 'disinformation'. It said, 'A public interest immunity claim was made by the Minister for Home Affairs, the Hon. Tony Burke MP, on 9 February 2026, which was accepted by the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Committee on 4 March 2026.'</p><p>To those watching, just to clarify what happened, the Labor Minister for Home Affairs did not want to answer this question. So he asked the Labor controlled committee if he was allowed to not answer the question, and the Labor controlled committee said, 'Yes, no worries.' That's an absolute joke of process. The answer itself is strange too. If these claims were disinformation as the Legal and Constitutional Affairs Committee was told by officials, why would a public interest immunity claim need to be made? Could it be that there is more truth to this disinformation than we thought?</p><p>I presume Senator Shoebridge was not satisfied by that response, which I again note came 71 days after the deadline. I know it's not a competition, but at least he got an answer. My question on this topic still remains unanswered and is now more than 290 days overdue. We've got the government talking about convention and courtesy. Where's the courtesy in answering my question that is 290 days overdue. When the due date for this question first passed, I liked to imagine that there was a room in some government office where, at any hour of the day, public servants were sitting there, brows furrowed, stroking their chins and going, 'Hmmm'&#x2014;thinking about their response to this question. After several months passed without an answer, I began to suspect that there were no government officials pulling double shifts in the thinking room.</p><p>In September, I put in a freedom of information request to see what work has been done on this question. The government immediately requested a 30-day extension and then missed the extended deadline anyway. So the documents which relate to the overdue question also became overdue. Do you see a pattern here, people? They love extending questions that need to be answered, and, when it's overdue, they sit there saying, 'Well, there's courtesy; give us notice.' Again, you've had 290 days.</p><p>When these documents were finally released, I was disappointed but not surprised to learn that, since February, there has not been so much as an email related to developing a response to this question. Did they think the Senate would just allow this question to go unanswered? That's a shocking attitude to have. In the documents, one official declares that no boats have been provided to illegal fishers, but another suggests that this isn't certain and that they should confirm with Maritime Border Command.</p><p>We still don't know who was right, because, as I mentioned, the question remains unanswered. Ironically, in the most recent email on this issue, an official writes: 'Wonderful. Thanks for the fast response.' Well, I'm glad someone is getting a fast response, even if it isn't the Senate. In another email dated 6 January 2026, an official from the Operation Sovereign Borders joint taskforce notes in relation to this and another question which was eventually answered: 'From an OSB perspective, I think they can be dealt with fairly quickly.' Just to run that past everyone again, that is an official saying in January that this question, which is still unanswered 10 months later, can be dealt with fairly quickly, so it's really disappointing that I'm having to raise this in the Senate. Questions should be answered on time. That's a basic expectation. When they are answered, the answers should provide clarity on what taxpayer money has been spent on. It's not rocket science; it's basic maths.</p><p>We know through the grants rorts saga that the government see taxpayer dollars as their money that they can use for whatever they want. I'm here to set the record straight. It isn't. Taxpayers' money should be used effectively and transparently. Because they haven't answered the question, I don't know if the government are being effective, but they sure aren't being transparent. Lift your game.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="83" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.131.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="speech" time="15:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'd like to make a short contribution in relation to this. I think all of us are sent to this place by our constituents in our home states to ask questions in a house of review, and this is a house of review. Every single senator, including Senator Payman, has a right to ask questions in this place and has a right to reasonably expect that those questions will be answered within a reasonable period of time. Over how many days are we&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.131.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" speakername="Fatima Payman" talktype="interjection" time="15:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>290.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="152" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.131.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="continuation" time="15:16" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>290 days? For goodness sake! That is just appalling. We've heard from the Centre for Public Integrity. The Centre for Public Integrity has said that this government's record on transparency is worse than the previous government. It is falling down. This Labor government is falling down in terms of integrity, in terms of transparency and in terms of being accountable to the Australian people. We don't just come to this place and ask questions for our own entertainment. We're asking questions on behalf of the Australian people who send us here, because we want those answers in order to keep the executive government to account. It doesn't matter who's in power and it doesn't matter who asks the questions; these processes should be followed as part of transparency, as part of integrity of our process and as part of the objective of the Senate as a house of review.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.132.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.132.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Answers to Questions </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.132.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="speech" time="15:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in accordance with informal arrangements agreed by the whips.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="503" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.133.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" speakername="Richard Mansell Colbeck" talktype="speech" time="15:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answers given by ministers to questions without notice asked by Opposition senators today.</p><p>In moving that motion, I note that every single answer that was provided by the government today demonstrated just how untrustworthy this government is when it comes to dealing with the issues that confront people in this country. It's absolutely no surprise to me to see the circumstance that exists with respect to the Australian community' lack of trust for this government. We see obfuscation. We see tricky language. We see manipulated statistics to make things look better than they actually really are. We see the same old tactics of blaming somebody else&#x2014;the opposition, if you can; the war on Iran, if you can't&#x2014;and it goes on and on.</p><p>When we asked the government questions in question time today about how much tax small business might pay in relation to the tax that the government promised wouldn't occur&#x2014;that small business didn't ask for&#x2014;we got the same old tricks. When we asked about what compliance costs might be imposed on small business from these new taxes that the government promised they wouldn't bring in&#x2014;that small business didn't ask for and that CPA Australia has indicated will cost small businesses and taxpayers up to $2.8 billion annually&#x2014;they talked about something else. And when we asked about productivity in terms of small business and their operations, they didn't want to know about that either, because small business is being forced to comply with these additional costs of running their businesses and the $2.8 billion additional cost that's being imposed on their operations on an annual basis. It's absolutely absurd that we continue to get this approach of 'just try to blame somebody else or push it onto some other group that isn't the government'.</p><p>Then we started talking about homeownership. I've never seen a better manipulation of statistics in all my life. It is the most brilliant manipulation of statistics. This government is building 30,000 fewer houses a year than were being built under the coalition, and then they talk about more houses! They promised that 1.2 million houses would be built by 2029, and they're building something in the order of 40,000 or 50,000 fewer houses per year than their target dictates&#x2014;and they still talk about more houses. It is just a complete manipulation of the numbers to suit their narrative, to suit their spin.</p><p>When it comes to the Big Build, the Labor Party spent nine years voting against measures to deal with corruption in the building industry&#x2014;nine years. Then they come in and make the claim that they've done more than anybody else, when they were teaming up consistently with the Greens to stop anything of material value happening. And of course the Greens still voted against even the administration of the CFMEU, which is now in place. But for 9&#xBD; years the Labor Party tried to stop anyone from doing anything about it. No wonder nobody believes this government anymore.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="513" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.134.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" speakername="Josh Dolega" talktype="speech" time="15:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In relation to the CFMEU, we are the ones who took the strongest action to clean up the construction industry. The bill the coalition brought before the parliament was designed to bust unions and attack working people, so it was rightly voted down and sent to the bin, where it belongs. But I digress.</p><p>Our changes to taxation arrangements for trusts are part of our broader package of reforms in the federal budget that was handed down by Treasurer Chalmers in May. And yes, we are changing the taxation arrangements for some trust structures, because on this side we want to make the taxation of trusts fairer by more closely aligning income that is earned on investments with the taxation of income that is earned through labour. This is about fairness, and it complements some of our other tax measures&#x2014;lowering taxes and consecutive income tax cuts that we have delivered for working Australians over our term of government. That's in stark contrast to the other side. They went to the last federal election promising higher income taxes, which is absolutely unbelievable. Our government has delivered for working people a thousand-dollar instant tax deduction to simplify their preparation of income tax returns. We're also delivering the Working Australians Tax Offset and, again, we have more tax cuts in play.</p><p>In addition to the changes to the taxation of trusts, we have delivered changes to the capital gains and negative gearing regimes and we are levelling the playing field to allow first home buyers to have the opportunity to own their first home. This was described by Senator Bragg, in one of his supplementary questions to Minister Wong, as having a negative impact on first home buyers. We fundamentally disagree. Our policy positions are getting more people and more first home buyers into their homes, to realise the great Australian dream of being able to buy their first home. When you cut out all the noise in the papers, when you go and look in some of the property guides, you'll see stories of first home buyers at auctions who are not going up and bidding against professional property hoarders that are buying properties to increase their portfolio rather than to live in as a home. We're proud of our changes to taxation and of the budget measures that were handed down in May by the Treasurer.</p><p>We've also had other positive housing policies directed to helping first home buyers. There is our five per cent deposit scheme, which, I understand, over 270,000 Australians have taken part in to help them get into their first home. We also have our shared equity scheme through Help to Buy. Our approach is in stark contrast to those opposite. During their period of government, during their decade of neglect, they didn't even have a housing minister for a great portion of that, and they absolutely had the worst track record for building homes during their tenure. We, through our Housing Australia Future Fund, are delivering more social and affordable homes for those who need them most. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="533" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.135.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="speech" time="15:26" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Where do I start? I'd prepared a speech, but then I listened to Senator Dolega. I don't need to read my speech notes; I can just respond to the good senator.</p><p>In relation to small business: to a small business, their business is not an investment; it is their livelihood. The government talk about taxing investments differently from livelihoods, but for a small business their business is their livelihood. That's where the discretionary trusts tax changes introduced by the Albanese Labor government fall down. There are 350,000 small businesses that are going to be impacted by these changes to discretionary trusts. That is where the government's argument collapses. Small businesses are being hammered. It's a kick in the guts to Australian small businesses at the worst possible time.</p><p>It's been estimated that these small businesses are going to have to pay $2.8 billion just to get the accounting and legal advice they need for this change. That is dead money. That money could have gone into building up small businesses employing more Australians. We know small business employs over 40 per cent of Australians who are employed in the private sector. That money could have been used to boost productivity. Instead, it's dead money. It's a productivity killer at the worst possible time. And 60,000 of those small businesses who are being hit by this toxic tax on discretionary trusts are in the construction industry.</p><p>Senator Dolega talked about the changes to tax in terms of negative gearing, in terms of capital gains and in terms of self-managed super funds no longer being able to invest in property investments. He says this is helping housing supply. All the evidence is to the contrary. We are now building 30,000 fewer homes a year than we were under the previous coalition government. If we look at the latest statistics in relation to home loan approvals, in the last quarter new home loan approvals crashed by 15 per cent. The number of Australians going to their bank and seeking a new home loan so they can buy their house has collapsed by 15 per cent. In relation to the new first home buyers, who Senator Dolega referred to, the figures are down 8.6 per cent. It is 8.6 per cent less. Maybe the next speaker could address this: if these tax changes are actually helping first home buyers or potential first home buyers, why has there been a crash of 8.6 per cent in the number of first home buyers seeking a mortgage? If it's working that well&#x2014;if it's actually meeting its intended purpose&#x2014;wouldn't you expect that number to go up? But, in fact, the number is going down. It is 8.6 per cent less.</p><p>Then we come to Victoria's Big Build. The Victorian state election can't come soon enough. The CFMEU tax on construction across this whole country, under Labor's watch, has been an absolute disaster for all Australians. The cost of schools, hospitals and even Ronald McDonald House in my home state of Queensland, which is there for families who have got kids in hospital&#x2014;the cost to construct Ronald McDonald House blew out by between 20 and 30 per cent because of the CFMEU.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="570" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.136.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="15:30" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I also rise to take note of answers to coalition questions. Gee, where do I start with Senator Scarr's contribution on the back of Senator Dolega's? These are some of the tough decisions that the Albanese Labor government are making in relation to tax reform. It goes to the heart of my question to Senator Gallagher around the $180 billion that we found in savings and reprioritisations&#x2014;the largest savings package in history. Our government, our minister for finance and our treasurer continue to work, as we know, in relation to the global shocks that are happening and having an impact right here at home. Our tax reforms, as Senator Dolega already said, are delivering tax cuts for workers and a fair go for first home buyers, better aligning with the treatment of income earned in other ways. We on this side of the chamber are unapologetic about making those tough decisions. It means that Australians will look to investing and growing their wealth. Those concessions that are in the tax system are targeted at starting new, innovative businesses and investing in new builds, regardless of the mis- and disinformation that is being spread about that.</p><p>The legislation we're progressing means that the government is now delivering over $4 billion in new tax relief and concessions for businesses and startups as part of our tax reform package. We're also simplifying the tax system with reforms and reducing those compliance costs by $540 million a year, with our regulatory reforms to cut business compliance costs by $10 billion a year. These are some of the tough decisions that our government are making to ensure that people are able to invest, particularly in what Senator Scarr was talking about around housing and businesses.</p><p>I might just pick up on that point of housing. This year's budget is about building more houses and about getting more supply, and it levels out the playing field for first home buyers. We've heard from people like Senator Walker, who has talked at length in this chamber about young people and making sure that they can get into their first home. Too many Australians feel that the housing system is stacked against them, especially younger people, and I want to acknowledge that that has been part of the conversations that I've had with constituents in my home state of Western Australia.</p><p>We have the most ambitious housing agenda in generations. We didn't stop after building 373 social and affordable homes in nine years, like the coalition did. We are trying to make those systemic and structural changes to the budget and to legislation. When we bring those cost-of-living measures into this place, they are blocked by the opposition. They are not supported. Yet the hypocrisy is that you come in here and try to attack us about tax reform when we are finding $180 billion of savings just this year.</p><p>I want to quickly turn to some of the issues in the questions that were raised by Senator McDonald to Senator Wong, representing the Prime Minister. Our climate action is about Australia's national interest and national security&#x2014;more investment, more jobs, stronger energy security, a more resilient economy and a safer region with our Pacific partners. I've had the pleasure of being in the room with Senator Wong, as our minister for foreign affairs, overseas, talking to PIF leaders about the global uncertainty and the support Australia can provide.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="631" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.137.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="15:35" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, I feel like we must be living in a parallel universe. This government isn't making tough decisions; this government is making decisions that are crushing Australia's economy. Households are struggling. Small businesses are struggling. No-one is immune from what this government has done. They're sitting here and trying to tell us that this is all okay.</p><p>What I take a great deal of offence to is the suggestion that this has somehow been good for young people and that this has delivered an opportunity for young people to own their own homes. Well, I'll take you back to last year, when many of us stood up on this side of the chamber and warned&#x2014;warned&#x2014;that the open floodgate of the five per cent deposit guarantee that wasn't means tested was going to create a scenario that increased prices. And guess who has been hit by the falling prices that have been constructed by this government? Those very people that they lured into homeownership last year with the five per cent deposit guarantee. Have a think about that: people who had saved their five per cent deposit to finally enter the property market to own their own home are now entering negative equity, with all of their savings, all of that effort gone. We're being lectured to by those opposite that this is something good. It is not good; it is really, really bad.</p><p>Do you want to know who are making the tough decisions? The people that can't afford to feed their children, the people that are deciding what goes into the trolley and what doesn't go into the trolley, the people who are deciding how much petrol can go in their tank and how far they're going to be able to go, the parents that are deciding which one of their kids gets to go to the doctor&#x2014;because I can tell you most people are not just using their Medicare card to go to the doctor&#x2014;and the women that are making choices around the fact that they'll take their children to the doctor and leave their own health concerns till later, the families that are deciding who gets to buy their medicines and who doesn't. These are choices that Australians are making every single day, and it is fundamentally unacceptable that those opposite pretend that everything is okay. They cannot even answer the question around whether it was deliberate&#x2014;deliberate&#x2014;to tank the housing market. Because you know what? They don't know. Their own cabinet didn't even get briefed by Treasury in relation to the tax change agreement that they made with the Greens. I understand why they're all upset over there, because they're finding this stuff out second hand. So no wonder there are the disruption and the disunity over on the other side.</p><p>But I want to finish up on the CFMEU. You all know how important that is to me and others on this side of the chamber. We are sick and tired of taxpayer money being wasted on corruption, and I noticed the change in language today from Minister Wong. It was no longer, 'We are doing everything possible to combat corruption'; it's now, 'We're doing a lot to combat corruption.' Well, there's one thing that you can do to combat corruption in construction: you can support a Senate inquiry, because the Victorian royal commission is showing a lot to be concerned about. The Queensland commission of inquiry has shown that some $24 billion has potentially been saved because of the stick in the spokes of the CFMEU, and we should all be worried about what is happening in every other state of our country. If we sit here blindly and pretend to care about Australians and do nothing about that, we should be ashamed.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.138.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
United Nations Climate Change Conference, Taxation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="420" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.138.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="15:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I Move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answers given by the Minister representing the Prime Minister (Senator Wong) to questions without notice asked today.</p><p>Well, it's pretty remarkable, isn't it? We asked the Labor government how on earth they could send the Prime Minister off to Turkiye, to COP31, to speak at a global conference about climate where the world is trying to come up with a way of keeping global heating to at or below 1.5 degrees&#x2014;send Prime Minister Albanese to Turkiye to speak at a keynote address at that climate conference, kicking it all off&#x2014;and he fails to mention fossil fuels?</p><p>Fossil fuels, in case Labor hasn't been watching, are what are driving anthropic climate change across the globe. So just to be clear: if Labor somehow is getting advice that fossil fuels are irrelevant to climate change, the science, as the Greens understand it, says that fossil fuels have quite a bit to do with climate change&#x2014;some might say, are driving climate change. And Australia is, of course, one of the top three exporters of fossil fuels.</p><p>So, when we asked Senator Wong representing the Prime Minister, 'How is it that Labor's PM goes off to Turkiye to speak at a keynote address about climate change and doesn't mention fossil fuels?' what did we get from this government? We got this word salad. It's like trying to pin the tail on the jellyfish of avoidance, twisting and turning and saying, in the answer, anything but 'fossil fuels'. It was almost as though Senator Wong had the same speechwriter as Prime Minister Albanese, answering a question about climate change and fossil fuels and trying to do anything but actually answer the question or identify what the issue is.</p><p>That is this Labor government all over. It's all about shallow, meaningless messaging that no Australian thinks is going to change their life for the better. No Australian thinks that what they're doing on climate change is serious. It's about messaging and meeting the donors.</p><p>Then, when my colleague Senator Hodgins-May asked Labor about their support for their ongoing policy framework that gives a discount to Senator Hanson, when she fills up her private jet plane, and to Labor's billionaire donor mates and asked them: 'Are you going to get rid of the tax lurk that sees your billionaire mates paying much less?' as they pay one-fifteenth of the excise tax that ordinary Australians do, we got another word salad and avoidance. It's Labor all over! <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="392" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.139.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="speech" time="15:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise to speak on this motion by Senator Shoebridge to take note of answers from Minister Wong to questions asked about COP 31. Greta Thunberg said at COP that 'even a snail would agree' with that, when asked if Australia was acting too slowly on climate change, and I think even a weasel would be offended by the minister's response, or lack thereof, today! Almost 200 staff were present at the world's largest climate conference in Turkiye, and not one of them thought to mention the words 'fossil fuels' or 'coal and gas'? Maybe that's a generous reading. Were they directed not to mention the words 'fossil fuels' or 'coal and gas'? We may never know the answer to that question, because the minister refused to answer it. If we sound like we are angry, Minister, it is because we are furious. We have every right to be angry, when there is a monster El Nino poised to hit us this summer and cause catastrophic extreme weather events across this country.</p><p>It is a sorry indictment of corporate capture in this country. Labor is so beholden to its fossil fuel donors that it cannot even utter the words. Is it any wonder that the Prime Minister failed to mention fossil fuels or coal and gas, when he would then, of course, have been forced to defend the 38 new fossil fuel extensions and projects that this Labor government has approved since coming to power?</p><p>Communities in Australia and globally are begging for an end to the hypocrisy. They are begging for immediate climate action. We've had three all-time sea-surface temperature records broken this year. We'll have another summer of mass marine die-offs, including on the already fragile and battered Great Barrier Reef, and more cyclones, more extreme rainfall and more flash-flooding.</p><p>I take the interjection from Senator Hanson. You're so busy flying around on your taxpayer-funded jet, with the help of this Labor government&#x2014;as if you would even know the damage that's being caused to the Great Barrier Reef. You do not believe in science. You don't believe in climate action. So hold it. Keep it for your base.</p><p>Labor needs to confront the reality of the climate crisis. No more words and spins; no more avoiding the topic; stare down your donors, and take action. <i>(Time expired)</i></p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.140.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Water </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="458" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.140.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" speakername="Pauline Lee Hanson" talktype="speech" time="15:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the answer given by the Minister for the Environment and Water (Senator Watt) to a question without notice I asked today relating to foreign ownership of water in Australia.</p><p>Minister Watt was asked about foreign ownership of water in Australia. He couldn't answer the question. Actually, under this current government, from 2022 to 2025, you've got an increase of 13 per cent in foreign ownership of our water in Australia. We're actually in dire straits, especially in southern New South Wales. In the Murray-Darling basin, you've got the rice growers there. They haven't even got enough water. You've got dairy farmers going out of business because they haven't got the water. Minister Watt couldn't even answer my question in any way whatsoever. With regard to it, he had no idea. We're talking about an amount of water 10 times the size of the Sydney Harbour, and that is a tremendous amount of water. He tried to talk about going back to Angus Taylor and Barnaby Joyce. That's got nothing to do with it. The Labor Party have been in government for four years. You can't answer questions in this place. You've always got to throw it back to the previous government and blame them for everything. You cannot take responsibility or answer the questions that are put to you. You've always got to blame it on somebody else, and it's a lack of common sense and leadership as far as I'm concerned. I would probably have got more out of asking where he keeps his phone&#x2014;either in his pocket near his heart or in his pants pocket. I might have got a decent, straightforward answer with regard to that.</p><p>What we're talking about here and what I'm asking the question for is that we do have a lot of problems in Australia. One Nation's policy is to stop the foreign ownership of water. Minister Watt also went to something I know about: the difference between water buybacks and what we're talking about, ownership of water. It's quite hard to determine how much, but we're looking at probably about 20 per cent of the water in Australia actually being in foreign ownership. One Nation thinks that is wrong. Australians don't want our water in foreign ownership. They can regulate where they want to, and, if they want to sell it on, it is traded on the open market. Water should be connected to land and to the farming sector and not in foreign hands. Therefore, One Nation would actually change that completely. Minister Watts said he doesn't agree with One Nation's policy. Therefore he's got no problem with ownership of our water being in foreign hands. <i>(Time expired)</i></p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.141.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
NOTICES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.141.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Presentation </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="229" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.141.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" speakername="Katy Gallagher" talktype="speech" time="15:47" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I give notice that on the next day of sitting I shall move:</p><p class="italic">That the provisions of paragraphs (5) to (8) of standing order 111 not apply to the Commonwealth Electoral Amendment Bill 2026, allowing it to be considered during this period of sittings.</p><p>I also table a statement of reasons justifying the need for the bill to be considered during these sittings and seek leave to have the statement incorporated in Hansard.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p class="italic"> <i>The statement read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">STATEMENT OF REASONS FOR INTRODUCTION AND PASSAGE IN THE 2026 SPRING SITTINGS</p><p class="italic">COMMONWEALTH ELECTORAL AMENDMENT BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">Purpose of the Bill</p><p class="italic">The purpose of the proposed amendments is to provide regulated entities greater flexibility to manage funds for use in relation to federal elections. Key assurance features of the current framework would be retained and clarified. Various other technical provisions would also be clarified to ensure they operate as intended, including clarifying enforcement powers.</p><p class="italic">Reasons for Urgency</p><p class="italic">The amendments, which would make critical fixes to the funding and disclosure framework, must be progressed in time to commence alongside the existing reforms made by the <i>Electoral Legislation Amendment (Electoral Reform) Act 2025</i> taking effect on 1 January 2027. Without these amendments, the framework would not operate as intended. Progressing these changes after the framework commences would cause significant disruption for stakeholders.</p><p class="italic">(Circulated by authority of the Special Minister of State)</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.142.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BUSINESS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.142.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Leave of Absence </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="67" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.142.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="15:47" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I move:</p><p class="italic">That leave of absence be granted to the following senators:</p><p class="italic">(a) Senator Duniam from 16 to 19 November 2026, for personal reasons;</p><p class="italic">(b) Senator McKenzie from 16 to 19 November 2026, for personal reasons;</p><p class="italic">(c) Senator Paterson from 16 to 19 November 2026, for personal reasons; and</p><p class="italic">(d) Senator Canavan for 18 and 19 November 2026, on account of parliamentary business.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.143.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.143.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Reporting Date </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.143.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="speech" time="15:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>If there are no objections, the business is postponed.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.144.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.144.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Taxation Administration Amendment (Reinstating Credit Card Payments) Bill 2026; First Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="s1526" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/s1526">Taxation Administration Amendment (Reinstating Credit Card Payments) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="55" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.144.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="15:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the following bill be introduced:</p><p class="italic">A Bill for an Act to amend the <i>Taxation Administration Act 1953</i>, and for related purposes.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>I present the bill and move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill may proceed without formalities and be now read a first time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bill read a first time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.145.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Taxation Administration Amendment (Reinstating Credit Card Payments) Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="s1526" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/s1526">Taxation Administration Amendment (Reinstating Credit Card Payments) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="1820" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.145.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="15:50" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill be now read a second time.</p><p>I seek leave to table an explanatory memorandum relating to the bill.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p>I table an explanatory memorandum, and I seek leave to have the second reading speech incorporated in <i>Hansard</i>.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p> <i>The speech read as follows</i> <i/></p><p class="italic">I rise to speak to the Taxation Administration Amendment (Reinstating Credit Card Payments) Bill 2026.</p><p class="italic">This is a straightforward Bill.</p><p class="italic">It addresses a straightforward problem.</p><p class="italic">And it provides a straightforward solution to a problem that the Albanese Labor Government should never have created in the first place.</p><p class="italic">It is a Bill about fairness, certainty and common sense.</p><p class="italic">But more importantly, it is a Bill about backing Australia's small businesses.</p><p class="italic">Because at a time when small businesses are struggling under the weight of higher costs, higher taxes, increased regulation and declining productivity, the last thing they need is a government making it harder to meet their tax obligations.</p><p class="italic">Yet that is precisely what the Albanese Government has managed to do.</p><p class="italic">Across Australia, small businesses are doing it tough.</p><p class="italic">Whether it is a local caf&#xE9;, a family-owned construction company, a suburban retailer, a plumber, an electrician or a small professional services firm, business owners are confronting the consequences of an economy that is increasingly difficult to operate in.</p><p class="italic">Their energy bills have risen.</p><p class="italic">Their insurance premiums have risen.</p><p class="italic">Their compliance costs have risen.</p><p class="italic">Their financing costs have risen.</p><p class="italic">And the regulatory burden imposed by this Government continues to grow.</p><p class="italic">Every small business owner understands that profitability and cash flow are not the same thing.</p><p class="italic">A business can have a full order book, plenty of customers and a healthy pipeline of work, but still find itself under pressure because payments arrive later than expenses fall due.</p><p class="italic">And that is why the Australian Taxation Office's decision to remove credit card payments was such an extraordinary example of bureaucratic indifference to the practical realities of running a business.</p><p class="italic">For many businesses, paying tax liabilities by credit card is a legitimate and important cash flow management tool.</p><p class="italic">It provides flexibility in meeting GST, PAYG withholding and income tax obligations.</p><p class="italic">It allows businesses to manage the timing of payments without immediately drawing down working capital.</p><p class="italic">It can provide a short period of interest-free financing, depending on the card arrangements.</p><p class="italic">And it allows businesses to meet their obligations to the Commonwealth while managing the competing demands on their cash.</p><p class="italic">And yet the Albanese Government apparently thought that even this modest flexibility was too much to offer Australia's small businesses.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Taxation Office's decision to prohibit credit card payments exposed something deeply troubling about the way this Government operates.</p><p class="italic">A decision with significant consequences for small businesses was announced with just eight hours' notice.</p><p class="italic">Eight hours.</p><p class="italic">For a Government that claims to consult extensively with stakeholders, that claims to understand small business, and that claims to be committed to reducing unnecessary burdens, this was an extraordinary failure.</p><p class="italic">Small businesses were expected to rearrange their finances at a moment's notice.</p><p class="italic">There was no meaningful opportunity to prepare.</p><p class="italic">No adequate transition.</p><p class="italic">And seemingly no appreciation of the impact this decision would have on businesses already operating under considerable financial pressure.</p><p class="italic">The Government's response was even more extraordinary.</p><p class="italic">As my colleague, the Member for Goldstein, Tim Wilson, outlined in the other place, Ministers appeared unable to agree on whether the decision was appropriate, whether it should be reversed, or even whether the Government had the power to intervene.</p><p class="italic">Senator Wong reportedly suggested that the Government lacked the power to reverse it.</p><p class="italic">And then, remarkably, the Treasurer announced that credit card payments would be permitted for another twelve months.</p><p class="italic">Apparently, the powers the Government did not possess one day had materialised the next.</p><p class="italic">What an extraordinary way to govern.</p><p class="italic">Labor's position shifted from defending the decision, to questioning its consequences, to claiming it could not act, to announcing a temporary reprieve.</p><p class="italic">This was not considered economic management.</p><p class="italic">It was policy-making by panic.</p><p class="italic">And Australian small businesses deserve better.</p><p class="italic">Labor's temporary extension is not a permanent solution. It simply postpones the uncertainty.</p><p class="italic">Businesses making financial decisions today need to know what payment arrangements will be available tomorrow, next year and beyond.</p><p class="italic">They should not have to wait for the Treasurer to decide whether to grant another temporary exemption.</p><p class="italic">Nor should their ability to meet their tax obligations depend on the administrative preferences of the Australian Taxation Office.</p><p class="italic">That is why this Bill is necessary.</p><p class="italic">The Taxation Administration Amendment (Reinstating Credit Card Payments) Bill 2026 amends section 16A of the <i>Taxation Administration Act 1953</i>.</p><p class="italic">It inserts a new subsection 16A(2A), requiring the Commissioner of Taxation to make arrangements to accept payment by credit card for liabilities covered by that section.</p><p class="italic">Importantly, that requirement will apply despite existing provisions allowing regulations to prescribe payment methods.</p><p class="italic">This means that the ability to pay relevant Commonwealth tax liabilities by credit card cannot simply be removed through subordinate regulations or administrative decisions.</p><p class="italic">The Bill does not change the amount of tax owed.</p><p class="italic">It does not alter the underlying tax obligations of individuals or businesses.</p><p class="italic">It does not establish a new subsidy or concession.</p><p class="italic">It simply ensures that credit card payments remain an available method of meeting those obligations.</p><p class="italic">And it provides the certainty that the Government's temporary extension cannot.</p><p class="italic">There is a broader principle at stake here.</p><p class="italic">The Commonwealth has extraordinary powers when it comes to collecting tax.</p><p class="italic">Australians do not have the luxury of choosing a different tax collector.</p><p class="italic">A small business cannot shop around for another Australian Taxation Office.</p><p class="italic">It cannot negotiate with a competitor offering more convenient payment terms.</p><p class="italic">The Commonwealth exercises a legal monopoly over the collection of Commonwealth taxation.</p><p class="italic">With that power comes a responsibility to act reasonably and to recognise that taxpayers are people and businesses operating in the real economy, not simply entries in a government ledger.</p><p class="italic">Yet the approach of this Government increasingly seems to be that administrative convenience for Canberra should take precedence over practical convenience for taxpayers.</p><p class="italic">That is precisely the wrong way around.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Taxation Office should make it easier for Australians to comply with their obligations, not harder.</p><p class="italic">If a business wants to meet its tax obligations using a lawful, established and widely accepted payment method, why should the Commonwealth stand in its way?</p><p class="italic">Why should a small business be denied a payment option that could help it manage a temporary cash flow shortage?</p><p class="italic">And why should the Government impose restrictions on the very businesses it expects to absorb increasing costs across the economy?</p><p class="italic">There is a fundamental inconsistency here.</p><p class="italic">The Government expects small businesses to accommodate the payment preferences of their customers, while allowing its own tax collection agency to restrict the payment choices of those same businesses.</p><p class="italic">Small businesses are told to adapt.</p><p class="italic">But when the Commonwealth faces similar pressures, its instinct is to remove the option altogether.</p><p class="italic">This Bill also speaks to a much wider problem with the Albanese Government's approach to economic management.</p><p class="italic">Australia has a productivity problem.</p><p class="italic">Businesses are spending too much time navigating government requirements and too little time producing goods, delivering services, investing and creating jobs.</p><p class="italic">Every additional administrative burden has a cost.</p><p class="italic">Every unnecessary restriction reduces flexibility.</p><p class="italic">And every poorly considered government decision creates uncertainty that businesses must somehow absorb.</p><p class="italic">Individually, these decisions can appear modest.</p><p class="italic">But their cumulative impact is substantial.</p><p class="italic">And they make it harder for entrepreneurs to take risks, invest and employ Australians.</p><p class="italic">A government genuinely committed to improving productivity would be looking for opportunities to simplify its interactions with business.</p><p class="italic">It would be reducing unnecessary friction.</p><p class="italic">It would be making compliance easier.</p><p class="italic">And it would understand that the resources of small businesses are better spent growing their operations than accommodating the preferences of government bureaucracies.</p><p class="italic">That is the philosophy underpinning this Bill.</p><p class="italic">We should be making it easier to do business in Australia.</p><p class="italic">Not harder.</p><p class="italic">Small businesses are not asking for special treatment.</p><p class="italic">They are not asking to be excused from paying their taxes.</p><p class="italic">They are simply asking for a reasonable degree of flexibility in how they meet their obligations.</p><p class="italic">And they are asking for certainty.</p><p class="italic">The Government's twelve-month extension is an admission that the original decision was unsustainable.</p><p class="italic">But a temporary political fix is not a substitute for good legislation.</p><p class="italic">If the Government now accepts that credit card payments should remain available, there should be no objection to making that arrangement permanent.</p><p class="italic">If the Treasurer believes businesses should retain this flexibility for another twelve months, why not provide it on an enduring basis?</p><p class="italic">Why force businesses to confront the same uncertainty again next year?</p><p class="italic">Why leave open the possibility that another administrative decision could remove this payment method without adequate consultation or notice?</p><p class="italic">The Coalition believes that small businesses deserve better than government by temporary reprieve.</p><p class="italic">They deserve a stable, predictable and practical framework within which to operate.</p><p class="italic">And they deserve a Parliament willing to stand up for them when government decisions impose unnecessary costs and restrictions.</p><p class="italic">The Liberal Party has always understood that small businesses are the backbone of our economy and our communities.</p><p class="italic">This Bill tells Australia's small businesses that Parliament understands the importance of cash flow.</p><p class="italic">That Parliament recognises the need for flexibility.</p><p class="italic">And that Parliament will not allow an unnecessary bureaucratic restriction to make it harder for businesses to meet their tax obligations.</p><p class="italic">The Government has already demonstrated that it can reverse course when the political pressure becomes too great.</p><p class="italic">Now it has an opportunity to support a permanent solution.</p><p class="italic">The Coalition has brought forward legislation that is practical, proportionate and entirely consistent with the principle that government should facilitate compliance rather than obstruct it.</p><p class="italic">There is no compelling reason for the Government to oppose it.</p><p class="italic">No taxpayer will owe less tax because of this Bill.</p><p class="italic">No existing tax obligation will be diminished.</p><p class="italic">The Commonwealth will simply be required to continue accepting a payment method that Australian businesses have relied upon.</p><p class="italic">This is not a radical reform. It is common sense.</p><p class="italic">And common sense should not be controversial.</p><p class="italic">Australian small businesses have enough to worry about without wondering whether the Tax Office will accept their credit card.</p><p class="italic">They need certainty, not confusion.</p><p class="italic">Flexibility, not bureaucracy.</p><p class="italic">And a government that makes it easier to meet their obligations, not harder.</p><p class="italic">The Taxation Administration Amendment (Reinstating Credit Card Payments) Bill 2026 provides that certainty.</p><p class="italic">It restores a practical payment option.</p><p class="italic">It removes the threat of another arbitrary administrative restriction.</p><p class="italic">And it sends a clear message that the Parliament is prepared to back Australia's small businesses.</p><p class="italic">Liberals and Nationals believe that government should get out of the way of enterprise wherever possible.</p><p class="italic">That it should reduce unnecessary burdens.</p><p class="italic">And that it should respect the Australians who work, invest, employ and take risks to build our economy.</p><p class="italic">This Bill puts those principles into practice.</p><p class="italic">I commend the Bill to the Senate.</p><p>I seek leave to continue my remarks later.</p><p>Leave granted; debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.146.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Fair Work and Other Legislation Amendment (Value for Taxpayers' Money) Bill 2026; First Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="s1528" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/s1528">Fair Work and Other Legislation Amendment (Value for Taxpayers' Money) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="59" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.146.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="15:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the following bill be introduced:</p><p class="italic">A Bill for an Act to amend the law relating to workplace relations and Commonwealth procurement, and for related purposes.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>I present the bill and move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill may proceed without formalities and be now read a first time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bill read a first time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.147.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Fair Work and Other Legislation Amendment (Value for Taxpayers' Money) Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="s1528" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/s1528">Fair Work and Other Legislation Amendment (Value for Taxpayers' Money) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="780" approximate_wordcount="1674" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.147.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="15:51" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill be now read a second time.</p><p>I seek leave to table an explanatory memorandum relating to the bill.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p>I table an explanatory memorandum and seek leave to have my second reading speech incorporated in <i>Hansard</i>.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p class="italic"> <i>The speech read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">Thank you, President.</p><p class="italic">I rise to introduce the Fair Work and Other Legislation Amendment (Value for Taxpayers' Money) Bill 2026<i>.</i></p><p class="italic">There is a pretty simple principle behind this Bill.</p><p class="italic">When the Commonwealth spends taxpayers' money, contracts should be awarded on merit.</p><p class="italic">Can you do the job? Are you following Australian law? And are taxpayers getting value for money?</p><p class="italic">Those should be the tests.</p><p class="italic">Whether a business has a particular industrial arrangement should not determine whether it can compete for government work.</p><p class="italic">But earlier this year, Labor changed the <i>Fair Work Act 2009 </i>(the Fair Work Act)to create an exemption that allows exactly that to happen.</p><p class="italic">The Coalition opposed those changes.</p><p class="italic">When the Workplace Relations Legislation Amendment (Building Cooperative Workplaces No. 1) Bill 2026 came before the Parliament, we moved amendments in both Houses to remove Part 9.</p><p class="italic">Those amendments were defeated and the Senate will be shocked to hear that the Greens did not support the Coalition.</p><p class="italic">Labor's amendments have effectively created an exemption from the Fair Work Act's general protections for certain Commonwealth procurement, grants and related activities.</p><p class="italic">In practical terms, the Government removed a legal barrier that prevented businesses from being treated differently because their employees were, or were not, covered by an enterprise agreement.</p><p class="italic">That sounds strange, doesn't it?</p><p class="italic">The exemption was not inserted into the Fair Work Actas an academic exercise. The Government changed the law so enterprise agreement coverage could be taken into account in Commonwealth procurement.</p><p class="italic">Industry is right to be concerned about where this leads.</p><p class="italic">The Commonwealth is one of the biggest purchasers of goods and services in the country. Its procurement rules matter.</p><p class="italic">For many Australian businesses, government is either a customer or a potential customer. The conditions attached to government work affect who can compete and, ultimately, who gets the work.</p><p class="italic">That gives government enormous power to shape behaviour in the private sector.</p><p class="italic">And it is why we should be very cautious about using procurement policy to pursue an industrial agenda.</p><p class="italic">If two businesses comply with Australian law, treat their employees properly and are capable of doing the same work, why should one receive an advantage because of the particular industrial instrument covering its workforce?</p><p class="italic">Why should a business that complies with every workplace law passed by this Parliament be put at a disadvantage when competing for a taxpayer-funded contract?</p><p class="italic">Government should not use procurement policy to impose industrial arrangements that the law itself does not require.</p><p class="italic">Enterprise agreements are a perfectly lawful and legitimate part of our workplace relations system.</p><p class="italic">So are other workplace arrangements.</p><p class="italic">This is not an argument against enterprise agreements.</p><p class="italic">It is an argument against government using taxpayers' money to preference them.</p><p class="italic">If the Parliament wants to impose a new industrial obligation on Australian businesses, then bring it into this chamber, debate it and legislate for it.</p><p class="italic">Don't use access to Commonwealth contracts to achieve the same thing through the back door.</p><p class="italic">That is why the first part of this Bill repeals the exemptions Labor inserted into the Fair Work Act.</p><p class="italic">It restores the previous operation of the general protections and prevents the Commonwealth relying on these new exemptions to preference suppliers because of enterprise agreement coverage.</p><p class="italic">Businesses should compete for government work on their merits.</p><p class="italic">Their price should matter.</p><p class="italic">Their capability should matter.</p><p class="italic">Their record should matter.</p><p class="italic">Whether they can actually deliver the project should matter.</p><p class="italic">And, of course, whether they comply with Australian law should matter.</p><p class="italic">Whether they have adopted the Government's preferred industrial arrangements should not.</p><p class="italic">We have already seen the risks of allowing industrial arrangements to become entangled with access to government-funded work.</p><p class="italic">This is particularly obvious in construction.</p><p class="italic">Australia has a housing shortage and major infrastructure needs.</p><p class="italic">We need more businesses competing for work, not fewer.</p><p class="italic">We need more investment and more capacity in the industry. We certainly need better productivity.</p><p class="italic">The answer cannot be to narrow the field of businesses that can realistically compete.</p><p class="italic">There is another reason we should be particularly cautious about this.</p><p class="italic">As Geoffrey Watson found in his report,<i> Rotting from the Top,</i> the use of enterprise agreements in procurement allowed the CFMEU to increase its power and control over the market and facilitated corrupt schemes.</p><p class="italic">That experience should have caused governments to think very carefully before going further down this road.</p><p class="italic">Instead, Labor has created the legal architecture for enterprise agreement preferencing at a Commonwealth level.</p><p class="italic">And these changes are not confined to construction.</p><p class="italic">They potentially reach across Commonwealth procurement and across industries.</p><p class="italic">We should be making procurement more competitive and more focused on outcomes for taxpayers, not less.</p><p class="italic">That is why my Bill goes beyond simply repealing Labor's changes.</p><p class="italic">It also amends the <i>Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 </i>(the PGPA Act)<i>.</i></p><p class="italic">The PGPA Act is the central legislative framework governing the use and management of Commonwealth resources.</p><p class="italic">Under section 105B, the Finance Minister makes the Commonwealth Procurement Rules.</p><p class="italic">Those rules already recognise value for money as the core rule of Commonwealth procurement.</p><p class="italic">We want to put that principle beyond doubt.</p><p class="italic">This Bill inserts an overarching objective into the PGPA Act that Commonwealth procurement is to provide value for taxpayers' funds, efficacy and compliance with all Australian laws.</p><p class="italic">It also requires the Finance Minister, before making procurement rules under section 105B, to be satisfied that those rules are consistent with that objective.</p><p class="italic">Existing procurement instruments will have three months to be remade consistently with the new framework.</p><p class="italic">These are not radical requirements.</p><p class="italic">In fact, most Australians would probably assume this is how government procurement already works.</p><p class="italic">Value for money.</p><p class="italic">Can the supplier actually deliver what it says it can deliver?</p><p class="italic">Is it following Australian law?</p><p class="italic">That is what taxpayers should expect when government spends their money.</p><p class="italic">Governments will, of course, continue to make procurement policies.</p><p class="italic">There will be detailed rules and those rules will change over time.</p><p class="italic">But there should be some principles that sit above the policy of the government of the day.</p><p class="italic">A government should not be able to subordinate value for money and effective delivery to an industrial agenda.</p><p class="italic">And a business that complies with Australian law should not be punished because the government would prefer it to adopt a different lawful industrial arrangement.</p><p class="italic">I want to be clear about what this Bill does not do.</p><p class="italic">It does not say workplace standards are irrelevant to Commonwealth procurement.</p><p class="italic">Compliance with Australian law is expressly included in the objective we are putting into the PGPA Act.</p><p class="italic">Businesses seeking taxpayer-funded work should comply with their obligations.</p><p class="italic">They should pay their employees correctly.</p><p class="italic">They should provide safe workplaces.</p><p class="italic">They should comply with taxation law, competition law and workplace law.</p><p class="italic">Of course they should.</p><p class="italic">But if a business is doing all of that, government should not then apply another test based on whether it has organised its workforce in a way that suits the industrial preferences of the Labor Party.</p><p class="italic">That isn't enforcing workplace law.</p><p class="italic">It is favouritism.</p><p class="italic">Think about what that means for a small or medium-sized Australian business.</p><p class="italic">It might be more productive than its competitor.</p><p class="italic">It might be able to offer taxpayers a better price.</p><p class="italic">It might have an excellent relationship with its employees.</p><p class="italic">It might be able to deliver the work faster or to a higher standard.</p><p class="italic">But it does not have an enterprise agreement.</p><p class="italic">Why should that business be treated less favourably?</p><p class="italic">And why should the taxpayer potentially pay more as a result?</p><p class="italic">There is no public benefit in reducing competition for government work.</p><p class="italic">Competition puts pressure on suppliers to offer a better product at a better price. It gives new businesses the opportunity to challenge established players. It encourages businesses to innovate and improve.</p><p class="italic">When government starts putting its thumb on the scale for reasons that have nothing to do with whether a supplier can do the job, taxpayers lose.</p><p class="italic">And this matters even more in the economic circumstances Australia faces today.</p><p class="italic">We need productivity growth.</p><p class="italic">We need businesses prepared to invest and employ.</p><p class="italic">We need competition.</p><p class="italic">Government should be removing unnecessary barriers to doing business, not finding new ways to put them in place.</p><p class="italic">The Coalition supports fair workplaces.</p><p class="italic">Employees should be paid correctly and treated properly.</p><p class="italic">Businesses should obey the law.</p><p class="italic">Unions have a legitimate role in our workplace relations system.</p><p class="italic">And enterprise bargaining has an important role where employers and employees choose to bargain.</p><p class="italic">None of that means the Commonwealth should preference one law-abiding Australian business over another because of its industrial arrangements.</p><p class="italic">The Government is not spending Labor Party money.</p><p class="italic">It is not spending union money.</p><p class="italic">It is spending taxpayers' money.</p><p class="italic">And when you are spending somebody else's money, there is a responsibility to get the best possible result for them.</p><p class="italic">That is the principle at the heart of this Bill.</p><p class="italic">If you can do the job, if you comply with Australian law and if you can deliver value for taxpayers, you should have a fair opportunity to compete for Commonwealth work.</p><p class="italic">No Australian business doing the right thing should be told that following the law is not enough.</p><p class="italic">And the Commonwealth should not need an exemption from the Fair Work Act's general protections to pursue its procurement policies.</p><p class="italic">This Bill removes that exemption.</p><p class="italic">It restores the previous operation of the Fair Work Act and it puts a clear objective for Commonwealth procurement into the PGPA Act.</p><p class="italic">Value for taxpayers' funds.</p><p class="italic">Effective delivery.</p><p class="italic">Compliance with Australian law.</p><p class="italic">Government procurement should serve the public interest, not sectional interests.</p><p class="italic">Taxpayers deserve value for money and Australian businesses deserve the opportunity to compete on their merits.</p><p class="italic">It really should be that simple.</p><p class="italic">The objective of this Bill should attract support from all sides of this chamber.</p><p class="italic">I commend the Bill to the Senate.</p><p>I seek leave to continue my remarks later.</p><p>Leave granted; debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.148.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.148.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="69" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.148.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="15:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Henderson, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Communications, by no later than midday on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, all submissions from organisations on the exposure draft of the Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026 received by the Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.149.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Cybersafety; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="119" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.149.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="15:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Henderson, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Communications, by no later than midday on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, a copy of all correspondence sent by the eSafety Commissioner to digital platforms and other online services, and any responses received, in relation to the potential live streaming of an execution by firing squad in the United States of America, including in relation to the proactive obligations of the relevant digital platform or online service to assess and mitigate the risks associated with the proposed live stream under the unlawful material and age-restricted material codes and standards under the <i>Online Safety Act 2021</i>.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.150.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
NOTICES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.150.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Withdrawal </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="17" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.150.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="15:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Bragg, I withdraw general business notion of motion No. 760 for today.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.151.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.151.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Electric Vehicles; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="420" approximate_wordcount="77" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.151.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="15:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Henderson, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Climate Change and Energy, by no later than midday on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, all emails, including any attachments contained therein, created in August and September 2026 by the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water concerning the Australian Energy Market Commission's draft rule to enable the rollout of electric vehicle charging infrastructure.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.151.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="15:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.152.1" nospeaker="true" time="15:57" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="25" noes="30" pairs="7" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" vote="aye">Jane Hume</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" vote="aye">Dean Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" vote="no">Katy Gallagher</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921">Sarah Henderson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833">James McGrath</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.153.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
OnePath Network; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="77" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.153.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" speakername="Maria Kovacic" talktype="speech" time="16:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>At the request of Senator Henderson, I move:</p><p class="italic">That there be laid on the table by the Minister representing the Minister for Multicultural Affairs, by no later than 5 pm on Wednesday, 18 November 2026, a copy of all documents held by the office of the Minister for Multicultural Affairs and the Department of Home Affairs relating to the selection and payment of the $308,000 grant to OnePath Network under the Multicultural Media Transformation and Sustainability Program.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.153.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" speakername="Slade Brockman" talktype="interjection" time="16:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="4" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.154.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:01" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="25" noes="30" pairs="7" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" vote="aye">Jane Hume</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" vote="aye">Dean Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907" vote="no">Katy Gallagher</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971">Slade Brockman</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944">Sue Lines</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921">Sarah Henderson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903">Tim Ayres</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833">James McGrath</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.155.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
MATTERS OF URGENCY </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.155.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Prime Minister </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="176" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.155.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="speech" time="16:03" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Cash has submitted a proposal, under standing order 75, today, as shown at item 13 of today's Order of Business:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The Prime Minister's repeated failure to uphold the dignity and standards of conduct expected of Australia's national leader, from his vulgar comments about Kylie Minogue and remarks criticised as demeaning to Japan's first female Prime Minister, to his latest crude exchange with the Minister for Climate Change and Energy (Mr Bowen) about their private anatomy at a climate conference in Turkey, where taxpayers are footing a $32,000 bill for free coffee, while Australian families at home are left struggling with soaring inflation, rising interest rates, skyrocketing electricity bills and the consequences of the Albanese Government's economic mismanagement.</p><p>Is consideration of the proposal supported?</p><p class="italic"> <i>More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places&#x2014;</i></p><p>With the concurrence of the Senate, the clerks will set the clock in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="739" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.156.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="16:04" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The Prime Minister's repeated failure to uphold the dignity and standards of conduct expected of Australia's national leader, from his vulgar comments about Kylie Minogue and remarks criticised as demeaning to Japan's first female Prime Minister, to his latest crude exchange with the Minister for Climate Change and Energy (Mr Bowen) about their private anatomy at a climate conference in Turkey, where taxpayers are footing a $32,000 bill for free coffee, while Australian families at home are left struggling with soaring inflation, rising interest rates, skyrocketing electricity bills and the consequences of the Albanese Government's economic mismanagement.</p><p>This is an incredibly important motion because it goes directly to the character of the Prime Minister. What has been on display now for some time is that the Prime Minister of Australia, Anthony Albanese, does not have the character or the judgement that this office demands. Sadly for Australians, that was on full display recently when he was with the Minister for Climate Change and Energy, Chris Bowen, in Turkiye.</p><p>There they were hosting COP31, sitting on the world stage&#x2014;in fact, representing our great country on the world stage&#x2014;and just minutes before an international delegation, a business delegation, was to be pitched to by our prime minister about Australia what do they do? They behave not like a prime minister and a minister hosting an international climate conference, representing our country on the world stage. Quite frankly, they behave like two grubby little schoolboys at the back of a shed. They're making crude jokes about their anatomy. Now, this wasn't a comedy club. It wasn't a pub. This was an international conference where the Prime Minister was there paid for by the Australian taxpayer.</p><p>Sadly, this latest incident highlights a pattern of behaviour on behalf of the Prime Minister. Earlier this year, what did Mr Albanese do? He went on a comedy podcast; he agreed&#x2014;stupidly, I would say&#x2014;to play shag, marry, date; and his answer to all three, broadcast in the event globally, was Kylie Minogue. On that same podcast, he turned a diplomatic gift of melons from Japan's first female prime minister into a crude joke complete with hand gestures. He apologised, in the end, to Kylie Minogue&#x2014;as he should have&#x2014;but, sadly, to this date, he has refused to apologise to the Japanese prime minister. We have a pattern of behaviour: Kylie Minogue, the Japanese prime minister and now behaving like a dirty little schoolboy whilst on the international stage representing our great country of Australia. That's three embarrassing episodes in but a few months.</p><p>This is what is so telling about the Prime Minister. Instead of demonstrating the judgement the office demands, the Prime Minister each and every time finds an excuse. What was the excuse this time? Well, it was just light-hearted banter. Then he says, 'Oh, well, no-one was hurt by what I said.' Sadly for the Prime Minister, that is not the standard that Australians expect of the person who is leading our country and representing our country at an international conference on the world stage. Australians don't just expect their prime minister to avoid hurting someone. They expect him to respect the office that he holds. It is a very privileged office. It is the highest office in our country. They expect him to exercise judgement and when he is, in particular, on the world stage they expect him to represent our great country with dignity of office.</p><p>Sadly, though, what has made this latest grubby episode even more extraordinary is the bill that is now being picked up by the Australian taxpayer: more than $2.2 million in contracts for luxury hotels, events and hospitality at COP31, including $32,000 just for coffee for international delegates at a time when Australia and Australians are in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis, and around $150 million allocated to Australia's broader COP engagement. Think about that. Australian families are cutting back whilst this government is living off the largesse of the Australian taxpayer. Sadly, the only thing people now seem to remember about this international conference, which has cost the Australian taxpayer an absolute fortune, is the rude, crude behaviour of the Prime Minister and his climate minister, and, sadly, as I said, the Prime Minister of Australia does not have the character or the judgement that this office demands. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="715" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.157.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" speakername="Ellie Whiteaker" talktype="speech" time="16:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise to speak against this urgency motion. When I speak to Western Australians and, indeed, to Australians, what they want from their prime minister and from their government is to be focused on the issues that matter to them&#x2014;the cost of living&#x2014;and to be doing something about those issues. I don't mind that Senator Cash is giving me another opportunity to come and talk about all the great things that our government is doing to help with the cost of living.</p><p>The motion, which refers to Aussie families, somehow stops for a coffee on the way to getting to the point, which is odd. I'm a little surprised that those opposite would complain about the price of anything, given their record in government. After all, the cost of housing outpaced wages for years on their watch, and they never seemed to be that worried about the price of housing then. When the coalition were in government, they built 373 social and affordable homes in nine years and, for most of that time, didn't have a housing minister. They're still fighting to keep the tax breaks that make it harder for young people to buy a first home. If the coalition ran a coffee cart the way they ran the housing portfolio, it'd be about $32,000 a cup, and they'd be telling us to take out a small loan from the bank of mum and dad while telling everyone else that they'll just have to suck it up and miss out.</p><p>It's a good thing that Labor is in government, so that first home buyers can get into a home of their own with a five per cent deposit. We've changed our tax system and made it fairer, so that they're not bidding against someone buying their seventh investment property. That is real cost-of-living relief, and that is the work that our government is focused on. We know that Aussies are doing it tough, and they want their government to be focused on doing what it can to make life a little bit easier. That's why we continue to step in and deliver real cost-of-living relief for Australians&#x2014;cost-of-living relief for Australians that those opposite come in here and vote against time and time again, cost-of-living relief that the coalition and their friends in One Nation oppose, stand in the way of and complain about time and time again.</p><p>In July, every Australian taxpayer got another tax cut&#x2014;one of five that our government has legislated. Let's remember that Senator Cash, the Liberals and the Nationals voted against our tax cuts. PBS scripts now cost Australians no more than $25. More than three million Aussies have had their student debt cut by 20 per cent. Hundreds of TAFE courses are free. We're putting more money into bulk-billing so it's easier to see a doctor for free. We've opened 137 free Medicare urgent care clinics right across the country, including 14 in my home state of Western Australia. Paid parental leave is now for six months, with super paid on top. Families get three days of subsidised childcare a week. We know this doesn't fix everything, and there's plenty more to do. People are still under pressure. Interest rates have gone up, and we know that hurts. But only our government has a plan to get us through this challenging period and play our part in bringing inflation down.</p><p>The coalition voted against our tax cuts. They voted against tax cuts for every Australian worker. They even went to the last election promising higher taxes; it sounds unbelievable, I know, from the Liberal-National coalition, but that was their promise. They opposed free TAFE. Time and time again, they vote against our cost-of-living relief here in the Senate, and then they complain about it on their socials and in the media. But they have no real plan to help Australians with the cost of living. It was no different when they were in government. When we came to office, real wages were in freefall&#x2014;and two-thirds of the fall since the 2021 peak happened on the coalition's watch. This is the same coalition that tried to bring in a GP co-payment and froze the Medicare rebate for years. The coalition has a woeful track record on the cost of living.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="759" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.158.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" speakername="Sean Bell" talktype="speech" time="16:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I think we can all agree that the Prime Minister's performance at COP31 was pretty embarrassing, but equally embarrassing is the government's clear contempt for everyday Australians struggling with mortgages, rent, electricity and groceries. They may pay for their embarrassing performance at COP31. The waste, the vanity, their obsession with net zero, their determination to look important overseas while failing Australians here at home&#x2014;this Albanese Labor government has handed Australians the bill for all of it, and people are rightfully disgusted. In Western Sydney, families are struggling with mortgage repayments, rent and grocery bills. In the Hunter, workers want affordable, reliable power and the confidence that their jobs will be there for their kids. In the Riverina, farmers and small businesses watch every dollar because they have to, and they also have to watch as this government takes their dollars and wastes it.</p><p>People are making hard decisions each week. Australians are there putting groceries back on the shelves. They are putting off repairs on their house or their car. You've got people scared to turn on the air conditioner when it gets hot and scared to turn on the heating when it gets cold. And Labor's answer to all of this was to take a bit more of their money for an overseas net zero promotional conference. Their answer to this was to take 192 official representatives of the Albanese Labor government with them and pay for contracts for a pavilion costing more than a million dollars. It was hundreds of thousands of dollars for the hotels for this, and $32,000 to pay for free coffee&#x2014;$32,000 for coffee at a conference where Labor was pushing their net zero agenda, pushing policies that are going to drive up your electricity prices. All across New South Wales, people are cutting back on things like takeaway coffee to save a few dollars. At Labor's COP31, the Albanese government made you pick up the tab for their mates. This is something they are continuously doing.</p><p>Speaking of picking up the tab, Labor also reportedly spent $3 million on a net zero documentary&#x2014;an easy three million of your dollars to pay for Minister Bowen's agenda while families across New South Wales continue to struggle to pay for their electricity bills, electricity bills made more expensive by the Albanese Labor government's net zero obsession. Aussies in Wollongong, Dubbo and on the Central Coast are paying more for basics, more for groceries, and yet this government rewards themselves by paying for more overseas trips and more promotional net zero tours at your expense, which is a disgrace.</p><p>It was the Labor government that signed off on all of these expenses. The Labor ministers were there giving them the tick. It was the Labor ministers deciding that COP31, their net zero promotional tour, was their priority, and their priority was for taxpayers to fund it. I think the Labor government needs to remember that this money isn't coming out of the Prime Minister's pocket or Chris Bowen's pocket or their pockets. It's coming out of the pockets of hard-working Australians. It's coming out of the pockets of nurses working a night shift in Liverpool. It's being ripped from the pockets of tradies driving to jobs across Penrith. It's been taken from the family business in Tamworth that has to pay its staff and keep the lights on.</p><p>Every dollar that this government is wasting on net zero or wasting promoting net zero is a dollar someone else had to earn. Labor can just rustle up an easy $150 million for an overseas conference, but it's the families who are footing the bill. They're the ones being squeezed. That's where this government's priorities are&#x2014;more money for net zero publicity paid for by Australians struggling with the cost of living. While they're over there overseas spending it up big, people back in New South Wales are still being hit with huge power bills, and businesses are being savaged. Businesses need reliable electricity, for instance. Yet the Labor government's net zero agenda is taking that away from them, which is why One Nation will scrap net zero.</p><p>This is why One Nation always puts affordable, reliable electricity and energy security first. It is one of our No. 1 priorities. That's why One Nation is consistent when it comes to stopping the waste. Ministers shouldn't be allowed to just fritter away your money pushing their agenda. Clearly, the Albanese Labor government has forgotten who pays the bills, and it's time for the people of Australia to remind them. <i>(Time expired)</i></p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="291" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="speech" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Last week, in front of the world, the Prime Minister and his energy minister were caught on a hot mic behaving like a couple of schoolboys, trading crude jokes just minutes before they were supposed to be pitching Australia to the world, to international investors. This came after the infamous <i>Bush Deep</i> podcast&#x2014;what a choice that was&#x2014;and after the now infamous melons joke, which, of course, fell flat. We've now moved from double entendres to the ever-so-witty single entendre, and he has again brought ridicule to Australia on the world stage. No-one was hurt! 'It's okay. No-one was hurt,' says the Prime Minister. Well, isn't that the standard that Australians set their Prime Minister!</p><p>Isn't it fantastic that the Prime Minister is doing real damage, and not necessarily just to Australia's international reputation via a hot mic! No, no, no&#x2014;it's in the household budget where the Prime Minister is doing real damage. On Melbourne Cup Day, Australians the country over felt it in their hip pockets when they were hit with the fifth interest rate rise this year: February, March, May, September and then November. The cash rate is now 4.85 per cent. That's the highest it's been since 2008. And where was the Prime Minister when that rate rise occurred? He was in the Caribbean, and then he was in Turkiye, and now he's in the Philippines, and next he's going to China. I don't have a problem with the Prime Minister representing us on the world stage. I don't have a problem with that, but, if he's going to do it, at least he shouldn't make a git of himself.</p><p>Let's be honest: the Prime Minister is racking up frequent flyer points while Australians are racking up mortgage repayments.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="15" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="interjection" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Hume, order! If I heard correctly, I think you might be a bit unparliamentary.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="continuation" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Git.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="5" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="interjection" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I just wanted to clarify.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="1" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="continuation" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Git.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="interjection" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="11" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="continuation" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Git. Sorry, it's an old-fashioned term, Mr Acting Deputy President Ciccone.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="11" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="interjection" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>You were facing the other way. I just wanted to double-check.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="continuation" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Git, definitely. No.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.10" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="interjection" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="472" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.159.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" speakername="Jane Hume" talktype="continuation" time="16:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Inflation has now climbed to 4.3 per cent. It's still rising. Far from our homegrown inflation going down and far from the challenge being behind us, as the Prime Minister and the Treasurer so desperately want us to believe, that is not the case. It is still rising, and the Australian Bureau of Statistics is telling us that housing and electricity are driving this. That is remarkable, coming from a government that promised Australians $275 off their energy bills. Instead, energy bills have gone up&#x2014;by nearly 40 per cent in some places&#x2014;and the Minister for Climate Change and Energy has finally admitted that Australia has more work to do to get energy prices down. He just chose to say this to the world in Turkiye rather than to families back home who are paying the bills.</p><p>Let's talk about what this COP trip has cost us. Around 200 public servants were flown over to the conference. There was $36,000 worth of free coffee. I've actually done a bit of a calculation on this. Just bear with me, Mr Acting Deputy President. According to Google, disposable paper cups of coffee generate around 110 grams of carbon emissions per cup. Did you know that? So, assuming it's $5 per cup of coffee&#x2014;let's round it out to $30,000 worth of coffee&#x2014;that's 660 kilograms or 0.66 tonnes of carbon emissions caused by the Prime Minister's coffee cart. Oh, my goodness! But it's not just that. There was $2.2 million in hospitality and nearly $150 million in COP related spending overall. At the same time, families at home are thinking twice about their $5 cup of coffee. Because of the ATO's inability to pass on a surcharge, we've now seen that increase. At the same time, Labor is shouting Greta Thunberg a free latte overseas. This is not a one-off. The government's now operating its spending at its highest level in 40 years outside of the pandemic. The government's spending like a drunken sailor, putting pressure on prices, and the Reserve Bank has to respond now.</p><p>It's not all that much to ask that a prime minister take his job seriously and that he represent his country with pride and dignity on the world stage. But that's not what we're getting. We want a government that lives within its means, and we want Australians to have a chance to get ahead, not just get by. What we've got is a government for which the taxpayer is paying the bill and families are paying the price&#x2014;a government whose prime minister is all innuendo and no outcome. Why can't Australians rely on their prime minister to do what's important, not what's glamourous? Why can't they rely on a prime minister to do what's necessary rather than what's ideological? That's this Labor government and their failed economic model at work.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="657" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.160.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" speakername="Leah Blyth" talktype="speech" time="16:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It seems absolutely absurd that we would need to have a motion such as this because the Prime Minister of Australia continues to embarrass himself and Australia on the international stage. This is the Prime Minister that has spent years lecturing Australians about respect, integrity and the treatment of women, yet his own conduct has repeatedly been vulgar, immature and, quite frankly, unbecoming of any person who holds the office of Prime Minister. The Prime Minister himself has declared that it is completely unacceptable to demean, objectify, belittle or offend women. It is such a shame that he doesn't abide by the standards he sets for everyone else.</p><p>We can recall the <i>Bush Deep</i> podcast, where the Prime Minister engaged in a playful game. He was asked if he would sleep with, marry or date Kylie Minogue. The Prime Minister of Australia responded that he would do all of the above, which is outrageous. He then went on to have a discussion on that same podcast&#x2014;a really crude exchange&#x2014;about melons gifted to him by Japan's first female prime minister. He continued to use hand gestures referencing women's breasts in that exchange. This is the Prime Minister of Australia. This might be fine for some blokes chatting around a barbecue, but this is the Prime Minister of Australia representing Australia. I think it's fair to say that, with all of that, you could&#x2014;what else do we add? We haven't spoken about what sits in his pants. Don't worry, because the Prime Minister managed to include that one last week when he and Minister Bowen, who were supposed to be leading negotiations and Australia's delegation at COP, were caught on a hot mic talking about where they keep their mobile phones and that it's far more important to protect what sits in your pants then what sits in your chest. This is the Prime Minister.</p><p>I was thinking we could play bingo with the Prime Minister. You know, have we talked about shagging Kylie? Have we talked about melons? Have we had a penis joke? The Prime Minister has hit the trifecta on that. Rather than accepting the responsibility, this prime minister is always about making excuses. I think, rather than the Prime Minister obsessing himself with which Australian he's going to shag, perhaps he should stop screwing Australians. Australians are struggling. They are struggling to keep the lights on. They are struggling to pay their mortgages while the Prime Minister and the Minister for Climate Change and Energy are overseas discussing their private anatomy. While they're on the global stage, embarrassing Australians, they have allocated nearly $148 million to COP31 and all of the related activities. At the taxpayers' expense, they took 192 Australian government representatives from at least 20 different departments. They spent more than $32,000 of Australian taxpayer dollars on coffee in the Australian pavilion. They have also managed to give complimentary drinks to the climate delegates. While Australians, while they can't afford their own grocery bills, are footing the bill for paying for the drinks of the delegates, there was approximately $2.26 million in the pavilion and associated contracts. It goes on and on to get to $148 million of Australia's hard-earned taxpayer dollars.</p><p>You could say that we've got to present ourselves on the global stage, but what is the return on investment for the taxpayer from this enormous expenditure? Did it bring their power prices down by $275, like the government promised? No. Is it helping with the cost of living here in Australia? No. What is the point of this prime minister and this obsession with spending to keep their net zero fantasy going? It is absolutely obscene, not just in how this prime minister behaves on a global scale but in the amount that they are spending and the debt that they are putting Australians in while not addressing the cost-of-living crisis here on our shores&#x2014;instead gallivanting all over the countryside.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="720" approximate_wordcount="257" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.161.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" speakername="Anne Ruston" talktype="speech" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I think Australians can expect two things of their prime minister&#x2014;one, that he conducts himself like one, and the other, that he spends his time and their money on things that matter to them. This prime minister has failed on both accounts. On the first, as Senator Cash laid out in her contribution to this, there was a crude podcast, remarks about the Japanese first female prime minister that he won't apologise for and now a hot mic issue in Turkiye. This is a prime minister who told Australians&#x2014;and I quote&#x2014;'Australians that demean, objectify or diminish women&#x2014;it is completely unacceptable.' I agree with the Prime Minister, but perhaps he might like to listen to himself. Once again, the apologies came only after the cameras did.</p><p>But it's his second failure to Australians that is more important, really. And that is that, right now, every single Australian family are opening up their power bills and they simply can't afford them. Before the 2022 election, remember all those times that Labor and the Prime Minister promised that your power bills were going to go down by $275. Instead, Australians have paid $23 billion more on their electricity since the Prime Minister first made that promise. So what were the Prime Minister and the energy minister talking about in Turkiye? Not about how to bring down power bills and not about where they went wrong in delivering Australians the $275 energy bill relief that they promised; they were talking about where Chris Bowen keeps his phone. Taxpayers were paying $32,000&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="20" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.161.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="interjection" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Just to interrupt you&#x2014;please refer to others from the other place by their correct title. That is just a reminder.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="460" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.161.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" speakername="Anne Ruston" talktype="continuation" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Mr Chris Bowen. Taxpayers were paying $32,000 for free coffee. That coffee is part of almost $150 million that this government has put towards the climate conference program, and every single dollar of that comes out of the pockets of Australian taxpayers, the very same taxpayers who are struggling to pay their power bills. So not only do they pay once; they pay twice&#x2014;once on their power bills and then again on their tax bills. Australians just cannot afford more of Anthony Albanese and Chris Bowen.</p><p>It's not only their power bills that are being ignored. Our aged-care system is in complete crisis. Those aren't my words; they're the words of Labor's own health minister in New South Wales, who has called the situation a national crisis. Around 3,700 older Australians who are well enough to be discharged from hospital but with nowhere to go are stuck in our hospital beds, as well as nearly 200,000 older Australians who are either waiting for an assessment or waiting for the care that they've been assessed as needing. The average wait time for a homecare package is now out towards 12 months. So where is the Prime Minister? Not here making sure that older Australians get the care that they need, and not telling his ministers Mark Butler and Mr Rae to fix up the problems so older Australians can get the care that they need. Maybe it's because he doesn't consider older Australians to be his people. Here's what he has done: he has cut $1.4 billion from aged care and banked it to save his budget bottom line. His own finance minister, Senator Gallagher, here told Australians the budget had improved in part by spending less on aged care, spending less in a national crisis. That money was meant for aged-care beds and homecare packages. Instead, it is propping up Labor's budget mess. Then, from yet another overseas summit, the Prime Minister said he was trying to find savings to fund aged care. But he'd already found $1.4 billion. He just didn't spend it on aged care.</p><p>Australians aren't asking for much of their prime minister&#x2014;just for somebody who takes their job seriously, who takes them seriously, who deals with the issues that are important to Australians, who spends their money like it were his own and not just some free-for-all that he can spend as he likes and who is working on their problems, the problems that everyday Australians face every day, not on his next punchline. Right now, they do not have a prime minister who is doing that. Australians cannot afford Anthony Albanese and Chris Bowen, and I absolutely commend this motion to the Senate, because Australians expect nothing less and nothing more of their prime minister.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.161.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="interjection" time="16:29" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion moved by Senator Cash be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="5" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.162.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="23" noes="23" pairs="7" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="aye">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" vote="aye">Pauline Lee Hanson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" vote="aye">Jane Hume</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" vote="aye">Dean Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="no">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973">Chris Gatenby</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944">Sue Lines</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.163.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Data Centres </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="143" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.163.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="16:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Senate will now consider the proposal from Senator McKim, which is shown at item 13 on today's order of business:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The need for the Albanese Labor Government to put an immediate moratorium on building AI data centres that are driving up inflation, taking supplies and workers away from industries like housing and draining the community's energy and water, all to allow US billionaire tech bros to steal from Australian artists and creatives.</p><p>Is consideration of the proposal supported?</p><p class="italic"> <i>More than the number of senators required by the standing orders having risen in their places&#x2014;</i></p><p>The proposal is supported. With the concurrence of the Senate, the Clerks will set the clocks in line with the informal arrangements made by the whips. I call Senator Shoebridge to move the motion.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="427" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.164.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="16:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move the motion:</p><p class="italic">That, in the opinion of the Senate, the following is a matter of urgency:</p><p class="italic">The need for the Albanese Labor Government to put an immediate moratorium on building AI data centres that are driving up inflation, taking supplies and workers away from industries like housing and draining the community's energy and water, all to allow US billionaire tech bros to steal from Australian artists and creatives.</p><p>That's the question the Greens are putting before the chamber today. I can already see the coalition and Labor working out how they can try and amend this, strip it down or work their magic to get the US tech bros as much of our creatives' juices as they can and as much of our water and power as they can, because that's what they do. This is the AUKUS equivalent, isn't it? Whether it's a defence prime or one of their mates in the US tech bros, they've never seen a US multinational they don't want to feed with Australian money, Australian data, Australian real estate and, in this case, Australian power.</p><p>It is pretty extraordinary, isn't it? Right across this country, there are communities organising to save themselves from these AI data centres. They're turning up to these massive buildings&#x2014;not a window in sight, humming with somebody else's wealth, sucking down their water, sucking down their power, intruding into their communities. Communities are organising and opposing them. And hats off. In my home state of New South Wales, hats off to the communities in and around the Cooks River. Much of that campaigning has been driven by local Greens on the ground, but people are joining across the community. They stopped the data centre on the Cooks River, right in the heart of Sydney. So too did the locals in Lane Cove, getting together when their governments, state and federal, had abandoned them. They got together, they organised, and they fought off that data centre. And so too in the Blue Mountains, protecting the beautiful Blue Mountains.</p><p>Right across this country we are seeing communities doing the work that they thought they had governments to do&#x2014;to protect their water, to protect their land, to protect their power. But, instead, we have Labor and the coalition trying to work out this grand deal to sell our creatives and make Australia a pariah state in the global creative industry, all to drive profits to their mates in Silicon Valley and their US vampire tech bros. Will you support this motion and stand beside Australians? That's the question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.164.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="interjection" time="16:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Sorry&#x2014;can you give me one second, Senator Cadell. I'm just checking the list. Yes&#x2014;Senator Cadell, you have the call.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="964" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.165.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" speakername="Ross Cadell" talktype="speech" time="16:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's the season for getting a list and checking it twice, Acting Deputy President! Here we have this motion. Where the coalition sits, it's a very interesting prospect for us, because we've said we agree with so much. But we're just worried about this moratorium and this ban straight away, because we've been in this chamber, and we've been talking about exactly the same thing. We've been talking about problems with planning, land use and residency around wind towers and transmission lines, and we couldn't get an inquiry up to talk about those concerns.</p><p>The environment is like something out of an Orwell novel: if it happens in the cities or the suburbs, it's bad; if it happens in regional areas, they can deal with it. This is what we always hear about&#x2014;this duplicity of the Greens in not supporting development that hurts people where their vote is. People anywhere else can suck it up and see. That's what we're getting here today.</p><p>When we get to the specifics of data centres, there are concerns around them&#x2014;no question in the world. Australia has a compute deficit. We need to have data, and we need to have compute built in Australia so we can compete. Our researchers need it. We need all of those things so we can do that, and there is a right way to go about it. My concerns, and the reason we originally wanted an inquiry into these transmission lines and renewable energy zones, were about doing it right. That is what should be done here. There shouldn't be a moratorium straightaway. The government should very quickly get the guidelines right so that it is done right. I'm not sitting here saying they are doing things wrong. I'm not saying we're working with them. But I am saying that a moratorium isn't the answer. Sitting down the back of a data centre and saying, 'Listen to the hum'&#x2014;we know these things have problems. Find the right spots, do them the right way and get them done. That is what the coalition wants to do, just as we wanted to do with the rollout of the transmission lines, but we were denied the right 12 times to have an inquiry into that. Suddenly, the Greens have found the environment again this week. They'll walk away from it next week and do a deal.</p><p>The Speaker went into the AI aspect of this; let's talk about that. We do have concerns. When I gave my maiden speech, I spoke about the priority of property rights to me. Growing up in the Hunter, we had our family bus line nationalised by the government. Because my family are basically stubborn and mean at times, we buried the engines and burnt the buses rather than hand them over to the government. It cost a fortune, but it was okay because, being in the Hunter Valley, we still had mineral rights to the coal under the ground. In the seventies, that was taken off us.</p><p>There is no way we are going to support an AI system that takes away the property rights of creatives. There's no way we are going to support Australians having to hand over their hard work in the wrong way. But the industry is talking to people&#x2014;they're talking to the government and they're talking to us&#x2014;about the way they want this done. We're looking at methods that are working in Europe. We're talking about national court cases. We're talking about no change. All of these things are on the table, because, as I said in an interview once, there are so many things that this may do. It may revolutionise the workforce. It may make Australia one of the most productive countries. It may help our security. What it will definitely do, however, is drain power and water, put some workers at risk and, as things currently stand, harm creatives. We can't have that. I'm not willing to definitely hurt people for a 'maybe' outcome.</p><p>The coalition will support working through this to get it done right, because it is important to Australia. It is important for our data security. It's important for our regional security that we have onshore compute. It is important that we are involved in the AI world. We've seen a data attack on Coles today, whether it was AI induced or not. We've seen it happen in France, where the fridges got turned up. We've seen attacks all over the place, and, if we're not in the game, then we are at risk. We accept that. But, when we were talking about data centres in the Joint Select Committee on Artificial Intelligence, all the researchers and all the Australians who get out there and try to help said that we have this failure to compute. They're not getting enough time on compute. We need data centres, but the government should get out there quickly and urgently and say, 'This is how they're powered.'</p><p>I note that we've gone around and handed out almost $12.5 billion in subsidies for high-energy-use industries. That's $12.5 billion of taxpayers' money, and we're going to build these things that chew through more. The real numbers are that, if you look at the one proposed by Anthropic in western Queensland, it has a peak power use of 2.13 gigawatts. Up in Newcastle&#x2014;in the Hunter, where I'm from&#x2014;Tomago Aluminium has a peak use of 950 megawatts. It's less than half the size, and we've had to bail that out for $2.5 billion. But now we're going to build something that uses twice as much power. This is not being done right. We need to get it right. We can't support this motion, but we do need to build data centres and do it right.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="480" approximate_wordcount="125" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.166.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="speech" time="16:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Data centres and digital infrastructure are critical to Australia's modern economy. The government cannot support a motion that would put at risk critical infrastructure that underpins essential services Australians rely on, including hospitals, transport and security. We need to work across the parliament to ensure that investment in data centres and AI infrastructure works for communities and serves Australia's national interest. I seek leave to move an amendment to the motion as circulated.</p><p>Leave not granted.</p><p>At the request of the Leader of the Government in the Senate, Senator Wong, and pursuant to contingent notice, I move:</p><p class="italic">That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent me moving an amendment to the motion.</p><p>And I move:</p><p class="italic">That the question be now put.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="16" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.166.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="interjection" time="16:49" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question before the chair is the closure of the suspension motion moved by the minister.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.167.1" nospeaker="true" time="16:54" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="23" noes="35" pairs="7" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="aye">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="aye">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="aye">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="aye">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="aye">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="aye">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="aye">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="aye">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="aye">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="aye">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="aye">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="aye">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="aye">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="aye">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="aye">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="aye">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="aye">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="aye">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="aye">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="aye">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="aye">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="aye">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="aye">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="no">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="no">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="no">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="no">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="no">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="no">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933" vote="no">Ross Cadell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="no">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="no">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="no">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" vote="no">Pauline Lee Hanson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="no">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" vote="no">Jane Hume</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="no">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="no">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="no">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="no">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="no">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="no">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="no">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="no">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="no">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="no">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="no">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="no">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" vote="no">Dean Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="no">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944">Sue Lines</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947">Maria Kovacic</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973">Chris Gatenby</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864">Murray Watt</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.168.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" speakername="Dorinda Cox" talktype="speech" time="16:57" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We'll now return to the debate on the suspension of standing orders. Senator Hanson-Young, are you seeking the call?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="577" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.169.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" speakername="Sarah Hanson-Young" talktype="speech" time="16:58" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I will seek the call briefly, because what's clear here is that the government is trying to shut down a legitimate debate about data centres in this country. Why are they trying to shut it down? Why are they trying to amend things? Why are they trying to cover and paper over this? Because they know that big AI and their data centres have no social licence in this country. They know that they are losing every single day and they're scared. They are scared and they should be, because we've seen what happened in the United States during the midterms only a fortnight ago. Americans stood up to big AI, and big AI are now having to walk back with their tail between their legs. These same companies want to come to Australia and set up shop here with weaker rules, weaker laws and more government bending over backwards for them.</p><p>This is a debate that is about putting communities first and putting a moratorium on the approvals of the applications on the development of any new big AI data centres before communities even know what on earth they get out of this technology. All we do know is that these huge computer servers put in air conditioned sheds around the country across from people's homes, across from schools, across from hospitals and on prime agricultural land. You know what we do know? It's going to suck up a lot of water. It's going to take Australians' drinking water. It's going to take drinking water. In my home state of South Australia, this is an industry that wants to take water from our Murray, a river that is already crying out for protection because too much is extracted for greed and profit, and the big AI companies want to come in and take even more.</p><p>What else do we know? We know that they are very hungry when it comes to energy and power. There isn't the power to power these things, so how are they going to get powered? They're going to have diesel backups. Big diesel generators in people's backyards are going to be churning on and on and on, putting out pollution and making noise right next door to people's homes, schools and hospitals and in the middle of good farming land. Of course, if it's not diesel, it's going to be gas&#x2014;more for the fossil fuel companies, more for big AI. This is why we need a moratorium.</p><p>These companies, of course, are coming to Australia to set up shop here because they want Australia to be the loophole when it comes to being able to scrape, take and steal culture, intellectual property, our music, our artists' work, our stories and our journalism. They want to be able to do it here in Australia, feed their machines, the hungry machines that are spewing out pollution and taking all of our water. They want to feed their machines with the content that is made by other people, and these buggers don't even want to pay a cent for it. They don't want to pay anything, and the government wants to roll out the red carpet, let these centres be developed and let them have as many rules and regulations that suit them. That's why we say a moratorium&#x2014;because, until the rules are in place, until the laws are there, until communities are consulted first, not after, none of these centres should be built.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="60" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="speech" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>While I think a blanket permanent moratorium goes too far, we should absolutely be having a pause, a moratorium, on any new data centres being built until we have very strong, clear, stringent, mandatory national standards in place&#x2014;standards that actually protect communities and ensure that there is some level of community consultation to ensure that we have a mechanism for&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="11" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I think I have a point of order from Senator Sheldon.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="26" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" speakername="Tony Sheldon" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm reluctant to do it but appropriately doing it, and that is that it has to be on the suspension motion that's in front of us.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="60" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Yes. I remind senators that we are debating the suspension, so you need to be relevant to the suspension motion that's before us. We could just put this vote and then go back to the substantive debate, if you wish, but I'm in the hands of the Senate. So, Senator Pocock, please be relevant to the question before the chair.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="92" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="continuation" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Sure. This is urgent because we are debating this urgency about a moratorium on data centres. At a moment in time where we saw Goodman Group trying to build a data centre 16 metres from people's front doors, we absolutely need to be debating this as a Senate. We're seeing companies plan data centres relying on gas. We're seeing down in Tassie data centres saying, 'We'll use diesel for backup,' and now, 'No, we want to use it permanently to run diesel generators around the clock.' It is absolutely urgent that the&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="12" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I have Senator McCarthy on her feet, on a point of order?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="19" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>With the greatest of respect, we do need to stick to the suspension and the question before the chair.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="32" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'm listening carefully, and I will remind you, Senator Pocock, just to be relevant to the question before us, which is whether or not it is urgent or not urgent to suspend.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="172" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="continuation" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Acting Deputy President. This is urgent because we see the Beetaloo Digital data centre in the NT proposing to use some 400 terajoules of gas a day, the same as 16,000 ACT households would use in a year, in the middle of a climate crisis. It's urgent because we've had a Labor government that has been asleep at the wheel, in denial about the need for national standards and about the need to actually stand up to US tech companies rather than just rolling out the red carpet. That is why this is urgent, because we're in a moment in time where we can actually act as a country, put some standards in place and ensure we have a mechanism for long-term benefit from hosting this infrastructure. At the moment, all I hear about is how urgent it is to build the infrastructure. Don't worry that the RBA is saying that it's adding to inflation. Don't worry that we actually have no way of raising tax from these big multinationals.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.10" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Pocock, my job is to enforce standing orders, and you need to be relevant to the urgency of the suspension, so please bring it back to that.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="48" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="continuation" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Thank you, Acting Deputy President. This is urgent because allowing big multinational companies to build data centres in this country does not give us sovereign compute capacity. We have to delineate between sovereign data centres, sovereign compute and big multinationals, the hyperscalers who want to build the infrastructure.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.12" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Grogan on a point of order? I have ruled on this already.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="16" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.13" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Yes, indeed. This is just a point of clarity, really. Is Senator Pocock saying that we're&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="75" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.14" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>No. Senator Pocock, I understand your point. You don't have to understand what he's saying. That's not against standing orders. But I will remind senators of one way to resolve this. I just want to make a suggestion. We can just put it to a vote, and then there's no confusion over what we're actually debating. But I will insist, Senator Pocock, that you do have to be relevant to the suspension question. Thank you.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="188" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.170.15" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" speakername="David Pocock" talktype="continuation" time="17:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Acting Deputy President, this is urgent because we have a Labor government that doesn't understand the need for long-term benefit from hosting this infrastructure. We have a government that doesn't understand the difference between sovereign compute and just having hyperscalers here&#x2014;having multinationals set up shop here. That is why this is urgent. We have to, as a country, stand up to these tech companies, say it's on our terms and actually invest in the sovereign compute that our researchers need and that Australians want access to rather than just saying: 'Well, we'll just allow big multinationals who don't pay much tax here to come and set up. We'll cop all the downside. You can take our energy and our water and hoover up our creatives' works.' We've got to stand up to these companies. I hear some good things from Senator Cadell. He talks about the urgency to ensure that we're looking after copyright holders. But clearly it is very urgent that, as a country, we stand up to the United States government and the United States tech companies when it comes to artificial intelligence and data centres.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.171.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" speakername="Malarndirri McCarthy" talktype="speech" time="17:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the question be now put.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="27" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.171.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:08" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I've just been informed we have to wait 15 minutes before you can do that again, because you did already move it, and we're not quite there.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="121" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.172.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" speakername="Mehreen Faruqi" talktype="speech" time="17:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This debate on data centres is urgent. It is urgent because they are sucking up our energy and our water. They are sucking up the intellectual property, the minds, of our workers and our artists. What the government is doing here is taking up time that has been allocated for known government issues because they are afraid. They are really afraid that we are right. They are afraid that the community out there, who are fighting for their rights, energy and water, are right. You can see that. That's why you don't want to have this debate. That's why this debate is even more urgent. You're passing these piss-weak amendments to usurp a motion that was brought here by the Greens&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.172.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Faruqi, I'll ask you to withdraw. I believe that term is unparliamentary.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="236" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.172.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" speakername="Mehreen Faruqi" talktype="continuation" time="17:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I withdraw. Labor's breathless adoration of US tech companies would be really cringe-worthy if it weren't dangerous. That's why this debate is important. The way these data centres are being built now and the way that the red carpet is being rolled out for the US tech oligarchs&#x2014;that is why it's urgent to have this debate. Ask anyone if we should be cautious about a new technology built on the stolen efforts of Australian workers and artists. It's technology that happens to drain massive amounts of water and energy. It's technology that fuels misinformation, scams, racism and harassment of women. It's technology that further concentrates the egregious power that far-right billionaires have over our lives and our democracy. What could be more urgent than that? What could be more urgent than having a debate on that?</p><p>Do you know what ordinary people out there are saying to this? They are saying: 'Whoa! Hang on. We've got to hit pause for a second and think this through.' That is what this debate and this motion are about&#x2014;thinking it through, putting a pause or a moratorium on this and saying: 'Let's stop and see what the dangers are. What are the risks? What is this technology actually doing?' Do you know, when ordinary people fight, they win. Last week, a proposal in the Adelaide Hills was paused. All 79 Victorian councils now support a moratorium on data centres.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="9" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.172.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Faruqi, I'll bring you back to the question.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="215" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.172.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" speakername="Mehreen Faruqi" talktype="continuation" time="17:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That is why it's urgent. Out there, people are saying: 'This is really urgent. Stop this. Put a pause. Have a moratorium.' People power has already seen three Sydney data centres scrapped. Isn't that telling this government something? That is exactly what they are afraid of. We've seen it recently in the US midterms. It was a wipe-out, with 44 ballot measures restricting data centres being passed. Even they, under a Trump administration, think it is urgent.</p><p>Labor should heed this warning. Look at this urgency motion. Heed this warning. I don't know if you are. Your amendment says you're absolutely not. You have lost the ability to listen to the communities out there. You have lost the ability to actually represent your constituents. Why? That's the big question. Why have you lost the ability to do that? It's because big corporate donations are buying the feather-light regulations that you are thinking about.</p><p>Look at the half a million dollars that Amazon have handed Labor and the Liberals this decade while they have pursued massive data centre expansions across this country. If we want to avoid becoming a dumping ground for tech oligarchs rejected by the US, we need a moratorium on AI data centres and we need to properly regulate these capitalist nightmares urgently.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="38" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.172.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Before I give the call to Senator Ghosh, I'll clarify that the 15-minute rule isn't actually a rule. It's only when we're in committee. I've just been advised. It's my mistake there. I was given the wrong advice.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="152" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="speech" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I agree with Senator Hanson-Young in this respect: this issue requires a proper debate, and it is too important for Australians to do it on the premise that's been set out here. That's why it's so urgent for us to suspend. It's why it's essential to conduct this debate on a proper basis, and that is the rationale for the suspension. Let's look at the suspension in a bit more detail. Let's look at what happened. There was an attempt to suspend standing orders to amend the motion and conduct this debate on a proper footing. It was not the kind of facile nonsense that was in the original motion but a change that related to the way in which this debate is conducted, and leave was refused for that amendment. That's what made the suspension necessary and it's what creates the urgency of this debate and the way we do this.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="2" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="16" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Ghosh is not speaking to urgency. I ask you to direct his attention to urgency.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="34" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I was having a bit of conversation with the clerks, so I didn't hear it all, but, from the bits that I've heard, I believe he is being relevant. I'll continue to listen carefully.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="304" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.5" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="continuation" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The proper debate of this issue is urgent. It's the necessity of the suspension and the urgency of the suspension that I'm speaking to. I want to take you through the premises that I just set out in relation to why I say the suspension is urgent and the amendment is urgent and why we need to do this and why the fact that we have been prevented from doing it is now a matter of some debate.</p><p>Let's look at point 1, which is the moratorium. The urgency is embedded in this, but it's embedded in the kinds of signals it sends to the market. You might think I'm talking about something of substance, but I'm actually talking about the way this debate is conducted, which goes directly to the suspension motion and the amendment that we're talking about. The signals that a debate like this in the Australian parliament on this sort of topic can send into the market can cause problems because it's a closing window in this space. It goes to why the way we have this debate and the amendment to the motion are so important to what we're debating underneath it.</p><p>In its submission to the Senate inquiry into artificial intelligence and data centres, the UNSW AI Institute highlighted the nature of that closing window and the urgency of what we're talking about here and the urgency of getting the framing of this debate right. They said this technology gives Australia as a country an opportunity to close a gap, but that window is not open forever. Indeed, we're in a globally competitive environment for that. That means that, if we give a signal to the market through a debate like this on a motion that, in the first instance, is full of this kind of hyperbole, then&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.6" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Where's the urgency?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="77" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.7" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="continuation" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The urgency is in correcting this nonsense, Senator Shoebridge, but it is also in having this debate on appropriate terms and providing a proper basis for dealing with it. A moratorium would pause roughly $115 billion of investment, the RBA staff expect. That, of course, has a substantive impact on the Australian economy, but it also highlights the importance of debating these things on proper terms. It highlights the importance of getting the fundamentals right. That's what&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="5" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.8" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>You're not speaking to urgency.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="91" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.9" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="continuation" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>No, I am. That's why we need to suspend and that's why we need to amend. That's the urgency of it. That's point 1.</p><p>I now go to the second point in relation to this, which is that the concern is with the motion. It's the premise of the debate that I really have to take issue with and it's the reason for the urgency of suspending this debate. The motion says data centres are taking workers and supplies away from industries like housing and draining the community's energy and water.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.10" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>That's what the Reserve Bank said.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.11" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="continuation" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>No, it's not. The capacity constraints&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="3" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.12" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Through the chair.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="141" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.13" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" speakername="Varun Ghosh" talktype="continuation" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Sorry, Acting Deputy President O'Sullivan. I am, as usual, so eager to hear what Senator Shoebridge says that I can't help but engage with him. I apologise to the chamber.</p><p>Investment in data centres, according to the RBA's November 2026 <i>Statement on </i><i>m</i><i>onetary </i><i>p</i><i>olicy</i>, has been mostly met by stronger imports, which has limited the impact overall on supply or capacity constraints in Australia. This is predominantly done by imports. Why is this relevant to the urgency of the suspension motion? It's because you cannot debate these issues properly if you don't have the premises right and, when you need to try to correct premises on an issue that's as important and urgent to the Australian people as this, you need to suspend urgently. Acting Deputy President O'Sullivan, I think I might have convinced you that it is urgent we suspend.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="26" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.173.14" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:14" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>It's not my job to make that decision in this moment, Senator Ghosh, but thank you. We've got about 25 seconds. Go for it, Senator Hodgins-May.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="108" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.174.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" speakername="Steph Hodgins-May" talktype="speech" time="17:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, this matter is urgent because AI data centres are taking our water, they're taking our power and they are taking our jobs in this country. This issue is urgent because Australia's AI data centre boom only benefits big tech billionaires, no-one else. And this is urgent because last week the RBA revealed that AI data centres are also fuelling inflation, while mortgage holders face yet another rate rise. As things get even tighter, American tech billionaires are laughing all the way to the bank. Well, I dare you to tell the people in Victoria who are going to a state election that this issue is not urgent.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="50" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.174.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" speakername="Matt O'Sullivan" talktype="interjection" time="17:19" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The motion to suspend standing orders was not determined before the time of the urgency motion expired, so the motion to suspend standing orders has lapsed. The question is that the unamended urgency motion be agreed to. Just so we're clear, we're voting on the urgency motion that was unamended.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.175.1" nospeaker="true" time="17:25" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="10" noes="28" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="aye">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="aye">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="aye">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="aye">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="aye">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="aye">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="aye">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="aye">David Shoebridge</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="no">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="no">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="no">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="no">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="no">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="no">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920" vote="no">Jess Walsh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.176.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
DOCUMENTS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.176.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Strategy for Abolition of the Death Penalty; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="638" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.176.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" speakername="Dean Smith" talktype="speech" time="17:31" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That the Senate take note of the document.</p><p>Australia's opposition to the death penalty is longstanding, unequivocal and bipartisan. It is a fundamental principle that the state should not have the power to take a human life as punishment, regardless of the crime committed. Australia carried out its last execution in 1967, abolished capital punishment in all jurisdictions by 1985 and legislated in 2010 to prevent its reintroduction. Our opposition rests on compelling grounds. There is no conclusive evidence that the death penalty deters crime more effectively than imprisonment. It is irreversible. A miscarriage of justice cannot be corrected once a sentence has been carried out. It denies any prospect of rehabilitation and disproportionately affects the poor, the disadvantaged, minorities and those without adequate legal representation. These are not abstract concerns. They are fundamental failures of a punishment that has no place in a modern justice system.</p><p>The international movement towards abolition has made remarkable progress. When Amnesty International began campaigning against capital punishment in 1977, just 16 countries had abolished it. Today, 113 countries have abolished the death penalty for all crimes, while 145 have abolished it in law or in practice. More than two-thirds of the world's countries have now rejected capital punishment. Yet this progress conceals a deeply disturbing development. Amnesty International's latest annual report reveals that at least 2,707 people were executed across 17 countries in 2025. That represents a staggering 78 per cent increase on 2024 and the highest recorded figure since 1981. These figures exclude the thousands believed to have been executed in the People's Republic of China, where executions remain a state secret.</p><p>The overwhelming majority of recorded executions were concentrated in just a handful of countries. The oppressive Iranian regime alone executed at least 2,159 people, more than double its 2024 figure. Saudi Arabia executed at least 356 people, while executions in the United States rose to 47, the highest figure since 2009. Almost half of all recorded executions worldwide were for drug related offences, despite international human rights efforts to standardise and restrict capital punishment to the most serious crimes. The contrast is stark. While the overwhelming majority of nations are moving away from capital punishment, a small minority are increasingly resorting to it. Nowhere is this more troubling than Iran, where the death penalty is used not simply as punishment but as an instrument of political repression. Iran Human Rights reports at least 691 executions in the first 10 months of 2026, including those of protesters, political prisoners and members of ethnic minorities. These developments demand international condemnation.</p><p>But there are also reasons for optimism, including within our own region. Vietnam abolished the death penalty for eight offences in 2025, while Malaysia has recently established a working group to consider the abolition of capital punishment. Malaysia's initiative builds on the earlier reforms abolishing the mandatory death penalty and represents another encouraging step towards ending the practice altogether. Further abolition initiatives have emerged across Africa, while no executions or death sentences were recorded in Europe or Central Asia. These developments demonstrate that abolition is achievable, even where capital punishment has been deeply entrenched.</p><p>Australia must remain steadfast in its advocacy, including with countries we regard as friends and close partners. Our position must be consistent, not selective. The death penalty is no more acceptable when imposed by a democracy than when used by an authoritarian regime. The measure of a justice system is not its capacity to impose the ultimate punishment but its commitment to fairness, accountability and the protection of human dignity. Justice must be firm, but it must never be irreversible when the possibility of error remains. Australia has rejected capital punishment at home. We must continue to advocate for its abolition elsewhere. I seek leave to continue my remarks later.</p><p>Leave granted; debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.177.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Harrison.ai, Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, European Organisation for Astronomical Research in the Southern Hemisphere, Housing, Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, Veterans, Workplace Relations, Fuel and Fertiliser Security Facility, Defence Properties; Order for the Production of Documents </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.177.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I table documents relating to 11 orders for the production of documents as listed in the document available in the chamber.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.178.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.178.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Parliamentary Library Joint Committee, Selection of Bills Committee; Membership </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="13" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.178.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="speech" time="17:38" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The President has received letters requesting changes in the membership of various committees.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="37" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.179.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:38" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>by leave&#x2014;I move:</p><p>That senators be discharged from and appointed to committees as follows:</p><p class="italic">Parliamentary Library &#x2014; Joint Standing Committee &#x2014;</p><p class="italic">Appointed&#x2014;Senator Gatenby</p><p class="italic">Selection of Bills &#x2014; Standing Committee &#x2014;</p><p class="italic">Discharged&#x2014;Senator Collins</p><p class="italic">Appointed&#x2014;Senator Gatenby</p><p>Question agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.180.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.180.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Domestic Gas Reservation Bill 2026, Domestic Gas Reservation (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2026, Domestic Gas Reservation Levy Bill 2026; First Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7559" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7559">Domestic Gas Reservation Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7561" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7561">Domestic Gas Reservation (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7560" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7560">Domestic Gas Reservation Levy Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.180.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:38" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That these bills may proceed without formalities, may be taken together and be now read a first time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bills read a first time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.181.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Domestic Gas Reservation Bill 2026, Domestic Gas Reservation (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2026, Domestic Gas Reservation Levy Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7559" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7559">Domestic Gas Reservation Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7561" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7561">Domestic Gas Reservation (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7560" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7560">Domestic Gas Reservation Levy Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="1200" approximate_wordcount="2454" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.181.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:39" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That these bills be now read a second time.</p><p>I seek leave to have the second reading speeches incorporated in <i>Hansard</i>.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p class="italic"> <i>The speeches read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">DOMESTIC GAS RESERVATION BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">Australia's gas is a national asset.</p><p class="italic">Together, the three Bills of the domestic gas reservation package establish a nationally consistent domestic gas reservation framework. Australian gas supports jobs, investment, regional communities, export earnings, and provides energy security for our trading partners. Gas powers Australian homes, underpins Australian manufacturing and industrial activity, and contributes to the reliability of our energy system.</p><p class="italic">Australians expect our resources to serve the national interest.</p><p class="italic">Australians expect reliable supply of affordable gas at home&#x2014;and that's what a domestic gas reservation scheme delivers.</p><p class="italic">It is important to recall how we got to this point. When we were first elected to Government in 2022, the first thing we had to deal with was an energy crisis. A decade of chaotic policymaking from the Coalition, combined with weather events, coal power station maintenance backlogs from COVID, and the consequences for global gas supply due to Russia's illegal invasion of Ukraine, saw energy prices spike severely that winter. In some cases, gas was offered into the Australian market for well over $60 a gigajoule. This was clearly unacceptable and demonstrated that the regulatory framework we inherited to manage our gas market was weak and ineffective. The Gas Market Review concluded that fundamental reform of Australia's gas market was essential and recommended establishing a national gas reservation scheme.</p><p class="italic">Extensive consultation has been undertaken since the release of the Gas Market Review in 2025 and has been critical to developing a package that establishes a nationally consistent domestic gas reservation framework. Gas producers, exporters, peak bodies, manufacturers, unions, state and territory government and trade partners have been engaged through formal consultation processes, bilateral engagement, and webinars. An exposure draft of the package was open for comment from 10 to 24 September 2026. Over 25 bilateral meetings were held and 71 public submissions received. These have been published on the Department of Industry, Science and Resources' website.</p><p class="italic">At the heart of this reform is a simple proposition: exporters that benefit from Australia's gas resources should make an appropriate contribution to the domestic markets connected to those resources.</p><p class="italic">Under the framework, exporters of liquefied natural gas will be required to hold an export licence and meet a 'domestic supply obligation'. This will require LNG exporters to contribute up to the equivalent of 20 per cent of their exports to domestic gas markets. This obligation can be calibrated to domestic demand and market conditions. The scheme also permits adjustment of a domestic supply obligation to recognise existing export contracts, existing reservation arrangements or existing infrastructure constraints.</p><p class="italic">The framework does not limit the amount of LNG that may be exported. It instead establishes a predictable and proportionate domestic contribution while allowing exporters to continue participating in international markets.</p><p class="italic">Those contributions are in the form of gas sold to domestic customers, at prices agreed in commercial negotiations between buyers and sellers.</p><p class="italic">Australia will remain a reliable energy trading partner, now and in the future.</p><p class="italic">The Government recognises that the LNG sector operates through complex and long-term commercial arrangements. The Bill provides flexible compliance options, including renewable gas supply, and demand reductions. The Bill also includes targeted adjustment mechanisms for existing export contracts entered into on or before 22 December 2025. This reflects Australia's commitment to honouring established commercial arrangement.</p><p class="italic">The Bill also includes mechanisms to adjust the amount or timing of obligations to recognise existing infrastructure constraints and existing domestic gas reservation arrangements. These provisions balance legitimate commercial or technical constraints while maintaining the central objective of increasing gas available to Australian users.</p><p class="italic">Australia has two distinct domestic gas markets: the east coast gas market, which includes the Northern Territory, and the west coast gas market in Western Australia. They comprise separate networks of interconnected gas pipelines. Conditions in one market therefore do not necessarily reflect conditions in the other.</p><p class="italic">The Bill recognises this physical separation and provides scope for obligations to be calibrated to the supply and demand conditions of each market, based on the circumstances at the time. An exporter's domestic supply obligation will be directed to the domestic market which is physically connected to the export, ensuring that each exporter's contribution supports that domestic gas market.</p><p class="italic">Demand calibration will ensure obligations remain connected to forecast requirements in a domestic gas market. The Australian Energy Regulator must determine a demand-calibrated quantity for a licence holder unless exceptions apply, taking account of forecast domestic demand, forecast supply and an appropriate 10 per cent supply buffer.</p><p class="italic">Licence holders may meet their obligation flexibly while remaining accountable for the required domestic contribution. They may supply at least 90 per cent of the minimum quantity during a regulated period and, where prescribed requirements are met, defer the remaining portion. Any deferred quantity must be offset through increased domestic supplies over the following three regulated periods.</p><p class="italic">The Bill also protects the integrity of the scheme. Qualifying supplies will need to be the licence holder's own gas or additional gas. If a licence holder acquires, and exports, non-additional gas from the domestic market, that quantity is added to its obligation. Anti-avoidance provisions will deter arrangements designed to circumvent key obligations of the scheme.</p><p class="italic">The Bill takes a technology-neutral approach to infrastructure, to support the use of both traditional natural gas and future low-emission gases. This provides more options for cost-effective compliance and enhances the pathway to recognise lower-emissions alternatives while preserving domestic supply outcomes and energy security.</p><p class="italic">Export licences will generally run for a 20 to 50 years, providing long-term regulatory certainty for exporters. Before granting a licence, the Minister must be satisfied that the applicant is fit and proper to hold the licence and the applicant intends and is capable of being an exporter of liquified natural gas. A licence may be renewed, and a licence holder that no longer intends to export may seek the Minister's consent to surrender its licence. The Australian Energy Regulator will administer and enforce the scheme. Licence holders will be required to prepare compliance plans, report annually on their activities and maintain financial assurance. Monitoring, information-gathering and audit powers will support early identification of compliance risks.</p><p class="italic">A proportionate enforcement framework will include directions, civil penalties, enforceable undertakings and injunctions, supported by executive officer liability. Transparency, publication and review arrangements will provide appropriate accountability. The framework also regulates changes in control and allows licences to be suspended or cancelled where serious non-compliance occurs.</p><p class="italic">The framework will be introduced through an orderly transition. The principal legislation and licensing framework are intended to commence by proclamation. A backstop commencement date of 1 July 2027 has been included in the Bill to ensure certainty for industry. This approach offers an appropriate balance between providing surety for stakeholders and sufficient time to finalise the supporting arrangements needed for implementation. The export licensing requirement and domestic supply obligations will operate from 1 January 2028, giving industry and the regulator time to prepare.</p><p class="italic">This Bill makes reliable domestic natural gas supply a normal and predictable part of LNG export activity.</p><p class="italic">The related Domestic Gas Reservation (Consequential Amendments) Bill integrates the framework with the Gas Market Code and transitions from the Australian Domestic Gas Security Mechanism. The Domestic Gas Reservation Levy Bill provides for recovery of the costs incurred in administering and regulating the scheme.</p><p class="italic">Together, the package will deliver a streamlined, fit for purpose framework that strengthens Australia's energy security and improves the predictability of domestic supply in the long-term interests of Australian households and businesses, while providing greater regulatory certainty and maintaining Australia's position as a reliable LNG exporter and trading partner.</p><p class="italic">DOMESTIC GAS RESERVATION (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">Together, the three Bills of the domestic gas reservation package establish a nationally consistent domestic gas reservation framework. Australia's gas supports households, manufacturers, regional communities and our international trading relationships. Australians rightly expect our resources to serve the national interest, including by supporting reliable domestic supply.</p><p class="italic">This Bill makes the supporting amendments required for that framework to operate through existing gas market institutions and for an orderly transition from current arrangements.</p><p class="italic">This Bill has three principal elements. It amends the Competition and Consumer Act 2010, amends the Gas Market Code, and repeals the Australian Domestic Gas Security Mechanism in the Customs (Prohibited Exports) Regulations 1958.</p><p class="italic">Amendments to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 and the Gas Market Code establish an additional gas framework to ensure an exporter's domestic supply obligation makes a genuine contribution to domestic supply, rather than being met by reallocating gas already available to Australian users.</p><p class="italic">Gas produced above a baseline set by the Australian Energy Regulator will qualify as additional gas. The Regulator may also approve other gas as additional on application, if prescribed circumstances are met.</p><p class="italic">This is an important integrity safeguard. It helps prevent exporters from satisfying their obligations by purchasing or redirecting gas that would otherwise have remained available to domestic buyers.</p><p class="italic">The Gas Market Code amendments also prescribe carefully defined flexibility mechanisms. The core principle is that licence holders must supply, not merely offer, gas to the market.</p><p class="italic">A licence holder must supply at least 90% of its domestic supply obligation in the relevant period. For the remaining portion, up to 10 per cent in total, the licence holder may meet flexibility requirements where qualifying gas has been genuinely offered to domestic buyers on domestically competitive terms but is not purchased, where a contractual call option is not exercised, or where exceptional and unforeseeable circumstances outside the supplier's control prevent delivery. Any resulting deferred quantity must subsequently be offset.</p><p class="italic">This will balance the obligation to supply with bounded flexibility to ensure the scheme is workable in practice, recognising that markets and demand are dynamic. A regulatory framework which allows the market to operate is in the interests of all participants.</p><p class="italic">The Gas Market Code amendments support a demand-responsive scheme. The Regulator's methodology for determining the demand calibrated quantity must consider forecast aggregate demand, the target level of supply and forecast supply from sources other than licence holders. It must draw on the relevant Australian Energy Market Operator gas outlook for the domestic market.</p><p class="italic">The Regulator will also provide licence holders with forward estimates of a licence holders' demand calibrated quantity for the next four years and must publish demand-calibration determinations and estimates. This will improve transparency and give industry greater visibility of future requirements.</p><p class="italic">The Bill modernises and simplifies the existing gas expression-of-interest framework and streamlines the information required. It removes the prescriptive initial-offer and final-offer stages and repeals the $12 per gigajoule pricing cap and conditional ministerial exemptions, which were introduced in response to an energy crisis.</p><p class="italic">A decade of chaotic policymaking from the Coalition, combined with weather events, coal power station maintenance backlogs from COVID, and the consequences for global gas supply due to Russia's illegal invasion of Ukraine, saw energy prices spike severely that winter. In some cases, gas was offered into the Australian market for well over $60 a gigajoule. This was clearly unacceptable and demonstrated that the regulatory framework we inherited to manage our gas market was weak and ineffective. The Gas Market Review concluded that fundamental reform of Australia's gas market was essential and recommended establishing a national gas reservation scheme.</p><p class="italic">The Bill strengthens market conduct requirements. Suppliers must report expressions of interest to the Australian Energy Market Operator, keep these expressions of interest current, and retain relevant negotiation records. Good-faith requirements will expressly consider whether a licence holder has unreasonably refused an offer and whether proposed terms were fair and reasonable.</p><p class="italic">Experience has demonstrated that only requiring the offer of gas has not worked in the interests of gas users. Stronger conduct requirements reinforce that merely 'offering' gas to the Australian market is not enough: the reservation requires real gas, not paper compliance. The amendments are designed to shift the balance of bargaining power to help make sure Australian users can get a better deal.</p><p class="italic">The Bill also supports an orderly transition from the Australian Domestic Gas Security Mechanism and Heads of Agreement. The ADGSM and HoA have played important roles for responding to potential shortfalls, however it placed significant burden on the three Curtis Island Exporters, including by requiring regular reporting to the ACCC and meetings with Ministers. From 1 January 2028, it will be replaced with a regulatory model that is intended as an enduring legislative solution.</p><p class="italic">The amendments have staged commencement. The Gas Market Code amendments concerning additionality and demand calibration, as well as other amendments supporting the principal Bill commence with that Bill. The remaining Gas Market Code amendments commence on 1 July 2027, and repeal of the ADGSM commences on 1 January 2028. Transitional arrangements preserve the ADGSM for domestic shortfall quarters ending before that date, avoiding gaps or unnecessary overlap.</p><p class="italic">This Bill ensures that the new domestic gas reservation scheme works coherently with existing gas market legislation and delivers a practical transition to the new national framework.</p><p class="italic">DOMESTIC GAS RESERVATION LEVY BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">Australia's gas supports households, manufacturers, regional communities and our international trading relationships. Together, the three Bills of the domestic gas reservation package establish a nationally consistent domestic gas reservation framework that supports reliable domestic supply while maintaining Australia's role as a trusted LNG exporter.</p><p class="italic">This Bill imposes a levy on export licences.</p><p class="italic">The levy reflects the principle that the costs of administering a regulatory framework should be borne by the industry that benefits from it. It will ensure the efficient costs of regulating LNG exports under the new framework are met by licence holders rather than the wider public.</p><p class="italic">The levy will apply where an export licence is in force at any time during a regulated period and will be payable by the licence holder. The amount, or the method for calculating it, will be prescribed by regulations. Regulations may set different amounts or calculation methods for different classes of licence holders, allowing the levy to reflect differences in regulatory effort or scheme participation.</p><p class="italic">Under the principal Bill, a levy for a regulated period will be due on 31 January of the following regulated period. Unpaid amounts will attract a daily late-payment penalty, which the Australian Energy Regulator may waive where there are good reasons. Levy and penalty amounts will be recoverable as debts due to the Commonwealth.</p><p class="italic">The Bill will commence on 1 January 2028, aligning with the commencement of the export licensing requirement and domestic supply obligations contained in the principal Bill.</p><p class="italic">Together, the three Bills establish a nationally consistent domestic gas reservation framework that supports reliable domestic supply, a competitive gas market and Australia's ongoing role as a trusted LNG exporter.</p><p>Debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.182.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026, Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026; First Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7554" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7554">Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7555" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7555">Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.182.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That these bills may proceed without formalities, may be taken together and be now read a first time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bills read a first time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.183.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026, Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7554" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7554">Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7555" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7555">Income Tax Rates Amendment (Minimum Tax on Discretionary Trusts) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="720" approximate_wordcount="1544" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.183.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:40" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That these bills be now read a second time.</p><p>I seek leave to have the second reading speeches incorporated in <i>Hansard</i>.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p class="italic"> <i>The speeches read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">TREASURY LAWS AMENDMENT (TAX REFORM NO. 3) BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">Today, the Albanese Government is introducing the next tranche of legislation in the most ambitious tax reform package in a generation.</p><p class="italic">One that makes our tax system fairer, more sustainable, and funds income tax cuts for workers.</p><p class="italic">In June, the Parliament passed the first tranche of legislation which cut taxes for workers again and again.</p><p class="italic">It limited negative gearing to new builds for future investments, encouraging new supply.</p><p class="italic">And it returned the capital gains tax regime to its original intent by restoring the taxation of real gains.</p><p class="italic">In August, we passed the second tranche of legislation&#x2014;locking in a permanent instant asset write-off for small business and loss carry back for companies up to $1 billion in turnover.</p><p class="italic">Through these first two tranches of legislation, we have delivered tax cuts for 13 million workers&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">Support for more Australians to get into the housing market&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">And are rolling out $3.8 billion in measures that lower taxes for businesses and start-ups.</p><p class="italic">This Bill is the next step.</p><p class="italic">The first three Schedules to the Bill implement the core components of the minimum tax on discretionary trusts announced in the Budget.</p><p class="italic">This is all about better aligning the tax treatment of income from assets and income from work.</p><p class="italic">It's also about funding the income tax cuts for workers that we are delivering again and again.</p><p class="italic">We know there are legitimate reasons to use trusts, including succession planning and asset protection.</p><p class="italic">But the flexibility provided by discretionary trusts allows some people to plan their tax affairs in ways that aren't available to most workers and families.</p><p class="italic">This is not a new issue or a new challenge.</p><p class="italic">Over half a century, governments of both political persuasions have received many reviews and reports recommending trusts tax reform.</p><p class="italic">In 1972, the then Commonwealth Government commissioned a review of Australia's tax system.</p><p class="italic">When that review was handed to the Whitlam Government in 1975, it looked at the problem of income splitting through trusts in great detail and recommended reform.</p><p class="italic">Ten years later, the draft white paper prepared by the Hawke Keating Government in 1985 raised this issue once again.</p><p class="italic">In 1998, Prime Minister John Howard committed to reforming the taxation of trusts in 2000 -</p><p class="italic">And the need for change was repeated the following year in the Review of Business Taxation report, known as the Ralph Review.</p><p class="italic">While Howard and Costello followed through on the CGT reforms in the Ralph Review that introduced lasting distortions in the housing market&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">Their plans to reform the tax arrangements for trusts were not implemented.</p><p class="italic">The number of discretionary trusts has more than doubled over the past 20 years to over 800,000&#x2014;putting an increasingly unsustainable strain on the Budget.</p><p class="italic">But still, the vast majority of Australians do not have a trust.</p><p class="italic">More than 95 per cent of individual tax filers do not receive trust income and more than 90 per cent of small businesses will not be affected by these changes in any given year.</p><p class="italic">The majority of trust income also flows to the top earning 10 per cent of households.</p><p class="italic">And approximately 90 per cent of total private trust wealth is held by the wealthiest 10 per cent of households.</p><p class="italic">Treasury analysis shows that in 2022-23, families with discretionary trusts faced an average tax rate around 4 percentage points lower than families with similar incomes who do not use a trust.</p><p class="italic">And the widespread use of discretionary trusts as part of complex structures adds complexity to the tax system and compliance costs for taxpayers.</p><p class="italic">If we leave this issue for another day and another government, the risks to the integrity and the sustainability of the tax system will only grow.</p><p class="italic">The burden of that inaction will fall on regular people, on young Australians and on future generations.</p><p class="italic">That's why we are taking action with this Bill.</p><p class="italic">The minimum tax on discretionary trusts in this Bill will reduce a range of tax planning advantages available through discretionary trusts.</p><p class="italic">As set out in Schedule 1, from 1 July 2028, trustees will pay the 30 per cent minimum tax on the taxable income of discretionary trusts.</p><p class="italic">Beneficiaries other than corporate beneficiaries will receive non-refundable offsets for the tax payable by the trustee.</p><p class="italic">A 30 per cent minimum tax aligns with the marginal tax rate for workers on incomes between $45,000 and $135,000.</p><p class="italic">A range of trust types will be excluded, including fixed trusts, charitable trusts, special disability trusts and superannuation funds, as is primary production income and certain income relating to vulnerable minors.</p><p class="italic">Deceased estates and discretionary testamentary trusts established for genuine testamentary purposes will also be excluded.</p><p class="italic">The legislation also ensures that all distributions from trusts to registered charities and deductible gift recipients are also exempt, as well as distributions to other income tax-exempt entities like sporting clubs up to a reasonable cap.</p><p class="italic">There are also a range of ways that trusts may be able to reduce the impacts of these changes, such as making different decisions about the distribution of income or, for businesses operating through a trust, paying a wage to employed beneficiaries.</p><p class="italic">Importantly, the legislation also includes expanded options to limit or eliminate restructuring costs for small businesses and others using discretionary trusts.</p><p class="italic">These are sensible options that we have developed through close consultation with stakeholders.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 2 provides expanded rollover relief from 1 July 2027 to assist taxpayers that wish to restructure out of a discretionary trust into other arrangements, such as a company or a fixed trust.</p><p class="italic">And Schedule 3 provides an option for trusts to make an election for income tax purposes, and for as long as they choose to continue to make distributions to pre-nominated beneficiaries in line with an up front nomination, they will be exempt from the minimum tax.</p><p class="italic">That election will not require a restructure or restrict a trust's discretionary powers, and is not expected to result in state and territory stamp duties being payable.</p><p class="italic">Together, these reforms will improve the sustainability and integrity of the tax system and better align the tax treatment of income from work and income from assets, while providing appropriate transitional arrangements for existing structures.</p><p class="italic">Schedules 4 and 5 to the Bill contain the next tranche of legislation to implement the Government's reforms to negative gearing and CGT.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 4 clarifies the operation of the CGT reforms for a range of more complex and specific circumstances including for a range of trust structures.</p><p class="italic">And Schedule 5 legislates the definition of a new residential dwelling and exemptions from the limits on negative gearing for affordable and public housing and other purposes.</p><p class="italic">These reforms are about removing the distortions that have locked too many young Australians out of housing for too long.</p><p class="italic">They're about making our economy more productive by ensuring investment decisions are made for economic reasons, not tax reasons.</p><p class="italic">And they are about targeting the tax support for investment in housing to new builds and affordable housing&#x2014;so that these investments are supporting new supply.</p><p class="italic">Our Government is tackling the housing challenge from every responsible angle: boosting supply, rebalancing the tax system, and helping first home buyers into the market.</p><p class="italic">The final Schedule in the Bill provides transitional relief for excess superannuation contributions in the first year of Payday Super.</p><p class="italic">Since 1 July this year, the Government's landmark reforms to ensure super is paid at the same time as wages and salary have been in effect.</p><p class="italic">Payday super will strengthen the super system and help deliver a more secure retirement for more Australian workers.</p><p class="italic">The amendments in this Bill ensure individuals are not adversely impacted where the timing of employer contributions in the first year affect their concessional contributions caps.</p><p class="italic">Labor built the superannuation system, and we are always making it stronger.</p><p class="italic">All our efforts, including Payday Super and the amendments in this Bill, are about safeguarding and strengthening the super system.</p><p class="italic">Combined, the Government's tax reforms mean the personal income tax burden share on workers is expected to be 2 percentage points lower over ten years.</p><p class="italic">It will fall even further as these reforms run their course over the longer term.</p><p class="italic">The Government thanks the many stakeholders and community members who have contributed to the development of these reforms, including in response to the July consultation paper and draft legislation released in recent months.</p><p class="italic">Reform on this scale is complex and the feedback we received has been an important part of getting the implementation details right.</p><p class="italic">It is helping us build a better tax system for workers -</p><p class="italic">For businesses&#x2014;</p><p class="italic">And for future generations.</p><p class="italic">I commend the Bill to the Chamber.</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">INCOME TAX RATES AMENDMENT (MINIMUM TAX ON DISCRETIONARY TRUSTS) BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">This Bill amends the <i>Income Tax Rates Act 1986 </i>to ensure that the net income of discretionary trusts is subject to a minimum tax rate of 30 per cent for income years commencing on or after 1 July 2028.</p><p class="italic">It operates in conjunction with the core legislation in the Tax Reform No. 3 Bill, and for all the reasons I have just outlined, I commend the Bill to the Chamber.</p><p>Debate adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.184.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026, Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026, Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026; First Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7568" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7568">Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7544" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7544">Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7566" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7566">Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="28" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.184.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:41" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That these bills may proceed without formalities, may be taken together and be now read a first time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bills read a first time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.185.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026, Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026, Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7568" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7568">Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7544" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7544">Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7566" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7566">Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 4) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="1680" approximate_wordcount="3411" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.185.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That these bills be now read a second time.</p><p>I seek leave to have the second reading speeches incorporated in <i>Hansard</i>.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p class="italic"> <i>The speeches read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">DEFENCE LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (ACCELERATING CAPABILITY AND PROTECTING BASES) BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">On behalf of the Albanese Government, I am pleased to present the Defence Legislation Amendment (Accelerating Capability and Protecting Bases) Bill 2026.</p><p class="italic">Australia's strategic environment continues to deteriorate and is the most challenging since the Second World War.</p><p class="italic">In response the Albanese Government has implemented significant reforms that reorient Defence towards a strategy of denial through the National Defence Strategy.</p><p class="italic">Delivering the 2026 National Defence Strategy requires Defence to accelerate capability development, strengthen preparedness and protect our most critical assets and our people.</p><p class="italic">Australia's Defence Act, the legislative framework governing our Defence Forces, was enacted in 1903.</p><p class="italic">It was designed in a very different era for a very different strategic and operational environment.</p><p class="italic">While the Defence Act has been amended over time, developments in technology, capability, defence industry integration, and contemporary security threats mean that a more comprehensive and modern framework is required.</p><p class="italic">That is why the Albanese Government is introducing this Bill today, to respond to the very real and very immediate threats Australia faces now.</p><p class="italic">This Bill provides a modern statutory framework for protecting Defence bases and significant sites, our personnel on them, and defence capabilities and assets.</p><p class="italic">It also establishes a framework to support Defence capability development and preparedness, enabling the testing of advanced capabilities here in Australia.</p><p class="italic">These reforms are appropriate and proportional to the threats facing Defence and Australia, and contains comprehensive safeguards.</p><p class="italic">These reforms are critical to implement the National Defence Strategy and ensure progress on Pillars One and Two of AUKUS.</p><p class="italic">One of the most recent examples of contemporary security threats this Bill deals with is the use of drones over and around Defence bases.</p><p class="italic">We have seen an increase in the number of incursions into Defence bases by commercially available drones in the last several years.</p><p class="italic">Last year the Albanese Government acted to progress interim regulatory changes, within existing legislative authority, that sought to address a gap in Defence's ability to respond to these threats.</p><p class="italic">This Bill builds on that by providing an enduring and clear legislative authority to detect, identify, monitor, track and respond to drones and other uncrewed systems where necessary for Defence security purposes.</p><p class="italic">This will enable Defence to act before an unauthorised system compromises sensitive information, disrupts an activity or causes harm.</p><p class="italic">The powers are accompanied by appropriate limitations and safeguards, including training, authorisation, decision-making and oversight requirements.</p><p class="italic">The Bill requires oversight of the use of these powers by the Inspector-General of the ADF, to ensure that the new frameworks are used appropriately and accountably.</p><p class="italic">There are also important oversight functions for the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Defence.</p><p class="italic">SCHEDULE 1 &#x2014; CONDUCT ENGAGED FOR DEFENCE CAPABILITY ACTIVITIES</p><p class="italic">Schedule 1 contains the provisions relating to Defence capability development activities.</p><p class="italic">A central objective of the National Defence Strategy is to accelerate the development, acquisition and introduction of capabilities required for Australia's strategic circumstances.</p><p class="italic">To achieve this objective, Schedule 1 of this Bill establishes a new Defence capability framework to support capability development and preparedness activities.</p><p class="italic">Capability development is no longer confined to traditional Defence establishments or undertaken solely by Defence personnel.</p><p class="italic">They increasingly involve advanced technologies, integrated workforces, Australian industry and international partners, and may occur across multiple jurisdictions and in a wide range of settings.</p><p class="italic">The Bill responds to these changes by replacing fragmented and uncertain arrangements across States and Territories with a clear Commonwealth statutory framework, defined safeguards and strengthened oversight.</p><p class="italic">Defence's ability to develop and introduce new capabilities can be delayed or impeded by laws that were not designed with contemporary military activities and technologies in mind.</p><p class="italic">These constraints can be particularly significant where activities involve advanced technologies, Australian industry, foreign military personnel or multiple Australian jurisdictions.</p><p class="italic">For example, existing civilian regulatory requirements can affect the testing and evaluation of autonomous maritime, aerial and land systems, the development of electronic warfare and cyber capabilities, and the participation of industry and international partners in Defence training and capability activities.</p><p class="italic">In practice, these requirements&#x2014;designed for a civilian context&#x2014;mean that an activity can be delayed, modified or conducted in another jurisdiction, even where it is essential to the development of a priority Australian Defence capability.</p><p class="italic">The framework will operate through a ministerial declaration process which specifies activities that can be conducted.</p><p class="italic">A declaration will identify the conduct and participants it covers, impose appropriate conditions and specify which State or Territory laws, or which of a limited number of Commonwealth laws, will not apply to the specified conduct.</p><p class="italic">This will provide a single legislative mechanism for supporting capability activities, rather than requiring Defence, industry and international partners to rely on a complex patchwork of multiple exemptions and administrative arrangements.</p><p class="italic">Importantly, the framework is targeted and subject to clear limits.</p><p class="italic">Before making a declaration, the minister must be satisfied that the activity is necessary for capability development or preparedness, that its impacts are reasonable and proportionate, and that the proposed participants are appropriate.</p><p class="italic">It is important to reiterate that the framework cannot be used to authorise domestic policing functions, compulsory acquisition of land, the use of force against persons in Australia or other categories of conduct specifically excluded by the legislation.</p><p class="italic">The framework will not apply in operational contexts, and includes strong privacy protections, offences for non-compliance with conditions, and independent oversight.</p><p class="italic">The framework establishes a specialised electronic capability declaration framework for the development, testing and training of electronic capability activities.</p><p class="italic">The ADF is increasingly reliant on electromagnetic and cyber capabilities to carry out its functions&#x2014;an increasingly standard feature in major military platforms.</p><p class="italic">When integrated with more traditional systems, non-kinetic capabilities offer superiority in terms of scalability, proportionality and effectiveness.</p><p class="italic">It is critical that the ADF develop and test these technologies onshore to ensure Australia is more self-reliant.</p><p class="italic">The criteria for making an ordinary capability declaration continue to apply, but additional requirements and controls are imposed to ensure alignment with the guardrails for similar activities under the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 1 will reduce legal uncertainty and enable Defence to develop and introduce new capabilities at the speed required to meet Australia's strategic circumstances.</p><p class="italic">SCHEDULE 2 &#x2014; DEFENCE SECURITY ZONES</p><p class="italic">Schedule 2 establishes a contemporary and consolidated Defence security zone framework for protecting Defence personnel, activities, capabilities, assets and facilities.</p><p class="italic">This Bill replaces previous security arrangements across seven legislative frameworks with a single, integrated one.</p><p class="italic">Australia's existing Defence security arrangements have developed incrementally over many decades through a collection of schemes designed for different purposes and operational environments.</p><p class="italic">This has created complexity and inconsistency and has left some arrangements ill-suited to contemporary Defence activities and security threats.</p><p class="italic">Today's security environment has changed. Defence must be able to protect increasingly sensitive capabilities, complex military activities and visiting foreign military assets against a range of rapidly evolving state and non-state threats.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 2 responds to these challenges by establishing a consolidated Defence security zone framework that can be applied in a targeted way across a range of Defence activities and locations.</p><p class="italic">The new framework will provide for permanent, temporary, mobile and emergency Defence security zones.</p><p class="italic">This will enable security arrangements to be tailored to Defence facilities and activities, including major exercises, capability trials, visiting foreign military assets and sensitive AUKUS-related activities.</p><p class="italic">Defence also operates through a network of industry facilities, ports, airfields, training areas and mobile capabilities.</p><p class="italic">The Bill recognises this reality by allowing security protections to be applied where Defence activities occur, rather than only where Defence owns or occupies land.</p><p class="italic">The security zones enable a significant element of the reforms in Schedule 2 which respond to the growing threat posed by drones and other uncrewed systems.</p><p class="italic">These systems can conduct surveillance, collect intelligence, or carry out physical or cyber-attacks.</p><p class="italic">These risks are particularly acute around sensitive Defence capabilities.</p><p class="italic">The Bill provides a clear and enduring legislative authority to detect, identify, monitor, track and respond to unauthorised systems where necessary for Defence security purposes.</p><p class="italic">This will enable Defence to act before an unauthorised system compromises sensitive information, disrupts an activity or causes harm.</p><p class="italic">The powers are accompanied by stringent training, authorisation, decision-making and oversight requirements.</p><p class="italic">There are also appropriate safeguards to ensure Defence must work with other agencies including the Civil Aviation Safety Authority to ensure the safety of civilian aircraft.</p><p class="italic">The framework also recognises that sensitive Defence activities may occur at locations operated by Defence industry partners, and provides the flexibility to apply appropriate security protections where necessary.</p><p class="italic">The Bill sets out a range of powers available to law enforcement officers, which can be extended to appropriately trained and authorised Defence personnel where necessary.</p><p class="italic">These include access control, identity verification, search and seizure, removal and detention, security monitoring and movement within Defence security zones.</p><p class="italic">These powers are largely the same as those that existed across previous frameworks, but consolidation will ensure greater consistency across Defence sites, reduce complexity and provide a more consistent set of powers and safeguards, including more robust training and governance.</p><p class="italic">Importantly, these powers will be subject to statutory limitations, training and authorisation requirements, privacy protections, review mechanisms and independent oversight by the Inspector-General of the ADF.</p><p class="italic">In an environment of rapid technological change and increasingly sophisticated threats, these reforms will ensure Defence has fit-for-purpose and effective laws to safeguard the capabilities, people and infrastructure essential to Australia's national security.</p><p class="italic">SCHEDULE 3 &#x2014; OVERSIGHT BY PARLIAMENT AND INSPECTOR-GENERAL OF THE AUSTRALIAN DEFENCE FORCE.</p><p class="italic">Independent oversight, parliamentary scrutiny and accountability are central features of this Bill. The two new frameworks established by the legislation are accompanied by statutory safeguards designed to ensure powers and authorities are exercised lawfully, appropriately and consistently with their intended purpose.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 3 enables the Inspector-General of the ADF to provide independent oversight of activities conducted under Schedules 1 and 2.</p><p class="italic">The Inspector-General of the ADF will be able to examine whether activities under these frameworks are undertaken lawfully, appropriately and consistently with the purposes of the legislation.</p><p class="italic">The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Defence will also have an enhanced role in scrutinising key elements of the new frameworks.</p><p class="italic">This includes through an enhanced role for the Inspector-General of the ADF in briefing the Committee on capability declarations and associated activities.</p><p class="italic">These oversight arrangements are designed to provide Parliament and the Australian community with confidence that the frameworks established by this Bill are supported by robust accountability mechanisms.</p><p class="italic">The reforms recognise that effective national security legislation must be accompanied by effective transparency and oversight arrangements.</p><p class="italic">These oversight functions will complement, and do not replace, existing oversight, accountability and integrity arrangements.</p><p class="italic">The reforms do not alter the functions of existing statutory oversight bodies, including the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security and other independent oversight agencies where applicable.</p><p class="italic">The Bill also requires the Minister for Defence to cause an independent review into the operation of certain parts of the new framework five years from their commencement.</p><p class="italic">This will ensure the operation of the Bill can be considered, that it is fit for purpose and that the safeguards remain appropriate.</p><p class="italic">The independent review must be tabled in Parliament and it is the Government's intention that the review would then be referred to an appropriate parliamentary committee.</p><p class="italic">CONCLUSION</p><p class="italic">These reforms will provide a stronger legislative foundation for Defence to protect its people and critical assets, develop the capabilities Australia needs, and operate effectively in increasingly complex circumstances.</p><p class="italic">The Albanese Labor Government, through this Bill, is ensuring Defence is supported by the legal frameworks required to meet Australia's strategic needs into the future.</p><p class="italic">It will support the implementation of the National Defence Strategy and Pillars One and Two of AUKUS, while preserving clear limits, appropriate safeguards, independent oversight and accountability to the Parliament and the Australian community.</p><p class="italic">I commend the Bill.</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE (NATIONAL JOINT REPLACEMENT REGISTER LEVY) AMENDMENT BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">The National Joint Replacement Registry is administered by the Australian Orthopaedic Association.</p><p class="italic">The Registry collects information from all relevant hospitals in Australia to define, improve and maintain the quality of care of individuals receiving joint replacement surgery.</p><p class="italic">The Registry improves clinical effectiveness by tracking long-term outcomes, identifying which prostheses and surgical approaches perform best, and giving clinicians the evidence they need to make better choices for patients.</p><p class="italic">The Australian Orthopaedic Association is provided funding to operate the registry through a Commonwealth Grant Agreement, which is efficiently cost recovered through the imposition of a levy authorised by the <i>Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Act 2009 </i>on sponsors of joint replacement devices listed on the Prescribed List of Medical Devices and Human Tissue Products.</p><p class="italic">The purpose of the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026 is the remove the $5,000 levy cap per device per financial year.</p><p class="italic">By eliminating the cap, the amendment ensures the levy is allocated in proportion to the actual volume of devices supplied by medical device companies.</p><p class="italic">The existing levy cap has resulted in smaller and medium-sized medical device companies bearing a disproportionate share of the financial burden, while companies that supply large volumes of devices pay comparatively less.</p><p class="italic">Removing the cap will ensure the levy is allocated in proportion to the actual volume of devices supplied by medical device companies creating a fairer and more equitable distribution of the levy.</p><p class="italic">This is important because as demand for joint replacement grows with an ageing population and increasing rates of chronic disease and obesity, the Registry will become even more important to maintaining safe, effective and high-quality orthopaedic care.</p><p class="italic">The Government's continued support for the Registry reflects its commitment to evidence-based health care, patient safety, clinical quality and the responsible use of private health insurance contributions.</p><p class="italic">_____</p><p class="italic">TREASURY LAWS AMENDMENT (TAX REFORM NO. 4) BILL 2026</p><p class="italic">Today, the Albanese Labor Government is delivering on our commitment to boost innovation and investment through the tax system.</p><p class="italic">The reforms we are introducing today are part of our comprehensive plan to support businesses and grow our economy.</p><p class="italic">They are a key part of our ambitious tax reform package which is also making it easier for Australians to buy their first home, cutting income taxes for workers again and again, and better aligning the tax treatment of work and asset income.</p><p class="italic">A thriving private sector is the key driver of economic growth.</p><p class="italic">Our long-term growth agenda is built on that fact, and the reforms we are introducing today are as well.</p><p class="italic">These reforms give the private sector tools and tax concessions to help them succeed in an increasingly competitive world.</p><p class="italic">The Bill provides more certainty for investors and more incentives for innovation, building on the $3.8 billion in new tax relief and concessions for businesses and start-ups.</p><p class="italic">These reforms will mean our tax concessions are targeted at starting a new innovative business and investing in a new build, helping Australians to invest their money, grow their wealth, and boost growth.</p><p class="italic">Importantly, the Bill also provides more flexibility for businesses to meet tax obligations.</p><p class="italic">Cash flow is crucial for small businesses which is why we are providing more options to pay tax in a way that works for businesses.</p><p class="italic">And reforms to better target support for electric vehicle uptake will make existing tax breaks fairer and more sustainable.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 1 to the Bill implements the Innovative Business Capital Gains Tax concession.</p><p class="italic">The concession supports early investment in innovative businesses by providing eligible founders, employees and investors with access to a 50 per cent capital gains tax discount on equity investments.</p><p class="italic">This means early investors in innovative start-ups that begin with a low or zero cost base still receive a significant discount on a future capital gain.</p><p class="italic">This will support investment in innovative Australian start-ups, and the continued growth of Australia's start-up and venture capital system.</p><p class="italic">Critical technologies like artificial intelligence, quantum computing, robotics and clean energy will play a critical role in driving our nation's future economic growth, productivity and jobs.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 2 to the Bill simplifies and refines the Research and Development Tax Incentive to better target Government support for business R&amp;D in Australia and drive innovations and productivity gains.</p><p class="italic">This Schedule simplifies administration and better targets the incentive to genuine innovation, including by increasing core R&amp;D offset rates by up to 50 per cent.</p><p class="italic">It extends access to the refundable offset for young, growing firms for longer by increasing the turnover threshold from $20 million to $50 million, reduces the R&amp;D intensity threshold so that firms that invest more substantially in core R&amp;D can benefit from higher offset rates, and increases the maximum expenditure threshold.</p><p class="italic">In addition, the changes in this Schedule recognise the longer regulatory approval processes and product development timeframes of biotechnology and medical technology firms by providing access to the refundable offset for up to 15 years for eligible firms.</p><p class="italic">Older firms' eligibility for the higher offset rate is maintained through a non-refundable tax offset.</p><p class="italic">It also improves integrity requirements around small claims, with expenditure claims below $50,000 requiring a partnership with a Research Service Provider or Cooperative Research Centre to be eligible for the incentive.</p><p class="italic">This Schedule also introduces an instrument making power to allow a Treasury Minister, in consultation with the Industry Minister, to prescribe eligible R&amp;D activities as being integral to core R&amp;D.</p><p class="italic">This will future proof the incentive and allow Governments to modernise the definition of R&amp;D as markets, businesses and technologies evolve over time. Overall, these reforms are expected to lift investment in R&amp;D by young firms by $400 million per year. These reforms form part of the Government's response to the Ambitious Australia report.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 3 to the Bill expands the venture capital tax incentives to encourage more investment and support early stage and growth businesses.</p><p class="italic">These changes increase existing thresholds to reflect modern company valuations. This will allow venture capital investors to invest larger amounts over a longer period in start-ups that find it difficult to access traditional forms of finance.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 4 to the Bill allows taxpayers required to report and pay Pay-As-You-Go instalments on a quarterly basis to elect to pay on a monthly basis instead.</p><p class="italic">This will provide individuals and businesses with more flexibility to meet their tax obligations.</p><p class="italic">It is one of several initiatives we're rolling out that will ensure instalments better reflect real-time business conditions.</p><p class="italic">It also empowers the Commissioner of Taxation to require taxpayers with a demonstrated history of non-compliance to report and pay instalments monthly to strengthen the integrity of the tax system.</p><p class="italic">Schedule 5 to the Bill adjusts the electric car discount settings to ensure it remains fiscally sustainable, incentivises supply of more affordable options, and provides more targeted support for EV drivers.</p><p class="italic">This measure has been successful in boosting uptake of EVs while reducing transport emissions and contributing towards more fuel security.</p><p class="italic">The discount has helped take EVs from one in every 50 sales when we came to government to roughly one in every eight in 2025.</p><p class="italic">Now, we are ensuring these settings are sustainable for the future.</p><p class="italic">From 1 April 2029, a 25 per cent discount for electric cars up to the fuel-efficient threshold for luxury car tax will be applied to the 20 per cent fringe benefit tax statutory formula rate that applies to all other cars.</p><p class="italic">The full 100 per cent fringe benefit tax discount will continue to apply to electric cars valued up to $75,000 from 1 April 2027 to 31 March 2029.</p><p class="italic">All eligible electric cars will retain the fringe benefit tax treatment that was in place when the last relevant commitment commenced.</p><p class="italic">Full details of the measure are contained in the Explanatory Memorandum.</p><p class="italic">I want to acknowledge the many groups and individuals who have contributed to this Bill.</p><p class="italic">Like all big tax reform, implementing details relies on constructive feedback and expert insights, and I thank everyone who has helped us to get this right.</p><p class="italic">There has also been a lot of collaboration among Ministers and members of this place on these proposals as well, and I acknowledge their role too.</p><p class="italic">This is a Bill that recognises the hard work of Australian businesses and helps them to succeed.</p><p class="italic">It encourages entrepreneurship and economic growth.</p><p class="italic">The changes are sensible, but they will make a positive difference to the businesses and start-ups that employ Australian workers and make our economy stronger.</p><p class="italic">And that is why I commend this Bill to the Chamber.</p><p>Debate adjourned.</p><p>Ordered that the bills be listed on the <i>Notice Paper</i> as separate orders of the day.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.186.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026; First Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7553" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7553">Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="24" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.186.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill may proceed without formalities and be now read a first time.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bill read a first time.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.187.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7553" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7553">Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="1497" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.187.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" speakername="Tim Ayres" talktype="speech" time="17:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I table a revised explanatory memorandum relating to the bill and move:</p><p class="italic">That this bill be now read a second time.</p><p>I seek leave to have the second reading speech incorporated in <i>Hansard</i>.</p><p>Leave granted.</p><p class="italic"> <i>The speech read as follows&#x2014;</i></p><p class="italic">INTRODUCTION</p><p class="italic">Australia has one of the most comprehensive online safety frameworks in the world.</p><p class="italic">It protects Australian children from cyberbullying, and adults from cyber abuse.</p><p class="italic">It empowers the eSafety Commissioner to take down seriously harmful material, including image-based abuse.</p><p class="italic">It requires online services to report how they are keeping Australians safe.</p><p class="italic">And it has 17 industry-drafted codes and standards that were designed by big tech to protect Australians from illegal and restricted content.</p><p class="italic">This network of protections has helped many Australians.</p><p class="italic">But an independent statutory review found in a constantly evolving digital world, we are playing whack-a-mole.</p><p class="italic">That is why, today, the Albanese Government is introducing a Digital Duty of Care to Parliament.</p><p class="italic">Australia's Digital Duty of Care will set basic safety standards for the online services we use every day, just like we have in every other industry.</p><p class="italic">ILLEGAL AND RESTRICTED MATERIAL</p><p class="italic">The core of the Digital Duty of Care is to provide a safe online environment, where all Australians are protected from seriously harmful and illegal content.</p><p class="italic">It moves the safety net upstream to the people who design the product to stop the harm, before it ever reaches an Australian user.</p><p class="italic">It is not about controlling adults online&#x2014;it's about getting illegal and seriously harmful material offline, and giving adults choice.</p><p class="italic">Like when you buy a new appliance&#x2014;the government sets minimum safety standards, but ultimately what you choose to buy is up to you, as long as it's legal and safe.</p><p class="italic">The Digital Duty of Care also sets minimum standards for the features and tools tech companies use.</p><p class="italic">Online service providers will have to conduct annual risk assessments of the harms the features on their service could cause to Australians.</p><p class="italic">Features like algorithmic recommender systems, the ability to livestream incognito from your glasses, or the ability to artificially generate text and pictures.</p><p class="italic">Then they will need to put systems in place to prevent those risky features from causing harm to Australians.</p><p class="italic">Because the architecture matters. The business model matters. The incentives matter.</p><p class="italic">Platforms are not passive. They decide what is amplified, what captures us, which behaviours get rewarded.</p><p class="italic">They have been optimised for engagement and attachment, not for wellbeing.</p><p class="italic">Because the longer we stay, the more valuable we are.</p><p class="italic">And through My Feed, My Way, social media companies will have to provide user empowerment tools that give people over the age of 16 choice about what they see in their feed.</p><p class="italic">If someone wants their feed to be filled by friends and creators they follow&#x2014;the social media platforms must let them do that by default. You shouldn't be thrown into an algorithm filled with people you don't follow or subscribe to if you don't want to.</p><p class="italic">And if you're happy to keep getting personally recommended content in your primary feed, you should have choice about the specific kind of content you do and don't want to see.</p><p class="italic">Today, the Albanese Government has released the proposed rules for user empowerment tools.</p><p class="italic">They contain four principles that address some of the malicious compliance we've seen in other jurisdictions.</p><p class="italic">First&#x2014;we must be able to opt-in to the algorithm, with social media platforms required to send users a proactive notification giving them this choice.</p><p class="italic">Second&#x2014;the tools must be accessible, easy to use, prominently available, functional, clear and in simple language.</p><p class="italic">Third&#x2014;the choice must stick&#x2014;platforms can't revert back to their default every time they open the app.</p><p class="italic">Fourth&#x2014;choosing to opt out of the algorithm must not make your feed harder to navigate. The experience must be similar to those who have chosen to opt-in.</p><p class="italic">MATERIAL HARMFUL TO CHILDREN</p><p class="italic">I've heard from parents all over Australia who are so relieved that we have delayed access to social media until the age of 16.</p><p class="italic">But parents are understandably still worried about how they can protect their kids on other platforms, like online games and AI chatbots.</p><p class="italic">And that is a rational fear.</p><p class="italic">Just last week, we heard about a 14 year old girl from Western Australia who was approached by an adult on Roblox. He told her she was really good at the game and they started chatting. That chat moved to Discord and changed tone.</p><p class="italic">He asked for pictures, then blackmailed her. He told her to write his name in her blood, to self-harm, to send pornographic images. He asked her to live-stream her suicide.</p><p class="italic">Another is a 13 year old boy from Victoria who was lonely and struggling to make friends, and when his counsellor looked at his browser history, he had 50 different tabs of AI chatbots open so he could flick between them.</p><p class="italic">It was a way for him to feel connected&#x2014;after all, how can you feel lonely if you're connected with 50 different chats?</p><p class="italic">But some of the chatbots told him he was ugly and would never make friends. It egged him on towards self-loathing and self-harm, the report alleges.</p><p class="italic">Under Australia's Digital Duty of Care, under 18s must be protected from content and features that are harmful to young people.</p><p class="italic">Content that promotes or encourages eating disorders.</p><p class="italic">That glorifies crime or dangerous stunts.</p><p class="italic">Pornography or content that promotes hostile ideas about women and gender equality.</p><p class="italic">Content that causes serious distress, including abuse and bullying.</p><p class="italic">We know many kids don't tell parents they are seeing harmful content on social media often because they worry parents will "overreact" and deny access.</p><p class="italic">Sometimes they don't even recognise what is happening to them is harmful.</p><p class="italic">But it shouldn't be on the kid to stop or report the harm.</p><p class="italic">It should be on the companies that create the online environments, to make them safe, and to stop the harm before it occurs.</p><p class="italic">TRANSITIONAL ARRANGEMENTS</p><p class="italic">If the Digital Duty of Care passes through Parliament and Royal Assent, a 12-month transitional period will be in place before the Digital Duty of Care comes to effect.</p><p class="italic">This transitional period will provide time for the making of any necessary rules and regulatory guidance material to ensure industry is able to put in place measures to meet the new compliance requirements in time for the Digital Duty of Care to come into effect.</p><p class="italic">Online services that are currently complying with the Basic Online Safety Expectations and relevant codes and standards will be well placed to comply with their Digital Duty of Care obligations.</p><p class="italic">Noting that not all online services share the same level of risk and type of risks, the extent of a service's obligation, including the need to conduct full risk assessments, and the level of detail required will vary as determined by the eSafety Commissioner.</p><p class="italic">To be determined low risk, an online service provider will need to conduct a self-assessment process to certify that it does not do things such as:</p><ul/><ul/><ul/><ul/><p class="italic">Providers of low risk services will have minimal obligations under the Digital Duty of Care, including websites and applications run by small-businesses, services that predominantly or exclusively share exempt material, as well as information conduit services, like internet service providers.</p><p class="italic">Providers of low-risk services must continue to monitor any changes to their service or features and reassess the risk profile of their service when/if significant changes are made.</p><p class="italic">CONCLUSION</p><p class="italic">I would like to finish with a letter I received from an eight year old boy named Angus, who lives in Yeronga, in Queensland.</p><p class="italic">Angus wrote to me because he was worried about what Roblox was doing to friends, and what it might do to his little brother.</p><p class="italic">He said:</p><p class="italic">I have a friend who used to be a great friend who would play with me on playdates and we would have a great time. He got Roblox when he was about six years old, after he got Roblox he wasn't interested in playing with me anymore, all he wanted to do was play Roblox and it feels like he is addicted to it.</p><p class="italic">My friends say weird things that they have learnt from the game and I don't like it.</p><p class="italic">It isn't safe that it is an online game and strangers can play with you, and I worry about my friends being online with strangers who might be dangerous.</p><p class="italic">There are horror games on Roblox and it can be really scary for kids. When I have asked my friends to stop playing these types of games they don't listen.</p><p class="italic">I think that Roblox rots kids brains because it has terrible graphics, there is horror and shooting games and they learn very silly things.</p><p class="italic">If 8 year old Angus from Yeronga understands why we need to make the internet safer, then I believe 60 year old Angus from Cooma can too.</p><p class="italic">Online safety should not be a political issue.</p><p class="italic">All sides of Parliament need to work together to deliver a Digital Duty of Care.</p><p class="italic">There's no reason we can't work together to get this done.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="18" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.187.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" speakername="Deborah O'Neill" talktype="interjection" time="17:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In accordance with standing order 115(3), further consideration of this bill is now adjourned to 20 November 2026.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.188.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
COMMITTEES </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.188.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Economics References Committee; Reference </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="480" approximate_wordcount="976" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.188.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" speakername="Dean Smith" talktype="speech" time="17:44" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>This afternoon we will know whether or not the government's rhetoric about cost-of-living concerns is to be believed or whether it is to be totally rejected. In a short moment, we'll have an opportunity to see whether or not the government really is interested in understanding those cost-of-living pressures that are being faced by Australians.</p><p>In just recent weeks, we have had new evidence&#x2014;new data&#x2014;that speaks to the magnitude of the cost-of-living crisis in Australia. Those people who are living with cost-of-living pressures won't be surprised by the data. Perhaps, though, many members in the Labor Party and the Labor government will be surprised. Everyone knows that cost-of-living pressures now in Australia are the No. 1 concern to Australian voters, and not by a small margin but by a big margin. That's because the most recent data has revealed that, since May 2022, when Labor was elected to government, as of May 2026, there are an extra 520,000&#x2014;think about that: 520,000&#x2014;Australian households now experiencing high mortgage burden. An RBA statistic has identified the rate of increase of the high mortgage burden on Australian families&#x2014;and I'll come to that in a moment&#x2014;and data has revealed that that rate increase equals 520,000 Australian households.</p><p>In New South Wales, the percentage in the high mortgage burden being experienced by families in New South Wales has changed from 3.7 per cent in 20 May 22 to eight per cent in May 2026, a staggering 116 per cent increase. In my home state of Western Australia, the high mortgage burden has grown from 3.2 per cent to 7.7 per cent, a staggering 140 per cent. What does that represent in households? In New South Wales, that represents an extra 149,200 households experiencing high mortgage burden. In my home state of Western Australia, that represents an extra 52,000 households experiencing high mortgage burden. In South Australia, the percentage increase was 203 per cent. Remember, this is data from May 2022 to May 2026.</p><p>Excessive and wasteful government spending is fuelling inflation, inflation is driving up interest rates, and now rising interest rates are leaving Australians with the prospect of rising levels of unemployment. That's not politics; that's the law of economics. Excessive government spending is driving up inflation, forcing the RBA to increase interest rates, and the consequence of that is rising levels of unemployment.</p><p>For many Australian households, over the last four years, they have been able to shield themselves from cost-of-living increases because they've had the prospect of a job. In some states, like my home state of Western Australia, some people have probably felt comforted by the fact that they've had job options. All of that is about to change. The whole purpose of rising interest rates is to dampen the level of activity. The consequence of that is rising levels of unemployment.</p><p>All this from a government that, in May 2022, promised Australians that life would be easier under Labor. As we know, life has got considerably more difficult. And, more than that, in February of 2025, the Prime Minister had the audacity to say, 'If Australians vote Labor, they'll be better off in three years time, and that's important.' That's what he said. Well, we know that, over the period of this Labor government, life has gotten considerably more difficult for Australian families. We know that people are struggling with making ends meet. We know that charity and community groups are having to meet these cost-of-living pressures. They are at the frontline as working families and many middle Australian families now call on charities and community organisations to help them put meals on their plate and deal with their cost-of-living pressures.</p><p>In a few moments' time we'll have an opportunity to see whether or not the new Greens leader, Senator David Shoebridge, who had lots to say about cost-of-living pressures when he was first elected to the leadership, will put his vote with his rhetoric. And let's watch very, very closely to see what Labor senators do. Are they genuinely interested in understanding the real stories of Australians when it comes to hearing of their experiences in regard to cost-of-living pressures? A vote by Labor to reject a Senate inquiry into the cost of living is the loudest demonstration that Labor senators do not care about the day-to-day experiences of average Australian families. They do not care about the excessive levels of wasteful spending that are driving up inflationary pressures in the economy, forcing up food costs, forcing up building costs and forcing up rental costs. They do not care that the RBA is forced to act with just one lever, and that is raising interest rates. And they certainly do not care that rising levels of unemployment will have to accompany interest rate rises.</p><p>Already the Reserve Bank is saying that Australians should prepare themselves for rising levels of unemployment. The Commonwealth Bank has said this week that Australians should prepare themselves for rising unemployment. In particular, young Australians, who have probably not really had to experience the curse of high levels of youth unemployment, now need to prepare themselves, because inside those rising levels of unemployment will be much higher levels of youth unemployment. All this is from a government that said that things would be better under Labor. They have got considerably worse. All this is from a government, led by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, that said in February last year that things would get better in three years time. No-one thinks that things will get better in three years time under Labor.</p><p>Soon we'll know whether or not Labor really is interested in the concerns of working Australians. We'll soon know also whether or not the Australian Greens are as good as their word when Senator Shoebridge said that he was concerned about cost-of-living pressures and would make it a priority for himself.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="780" approximate_wordcount="661" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.189.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="17:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We are living in a cost-of-living crisis. Ninety-four per cent of Australians are concerned about rising grocery prices. Seventy-nine per cent of Australians say it is harder now to pay for food and groceries than it was just 12 months ago. While we are finding it harder to feed ourselves, this Labor government is feeding the cost-of-living crisis. Let's have a look at their promised cuts to backpackers. This federal Labor government wants to cut the rate of backpackers, which is going to have a massively adverse impact on food production in this country. This federal Labor government says that it wants to send us back to pre-COVID levels of backpackers.</p><p>Let's have a look right now at what happened during COVID. During COVID there was a massive cut to backpackers by reason of us not being able to move around the globe like we previously did, so, during COVID, there was plenty of food rotting on and in the ground. What was the impact of that on the cost of groceries and the cost of food? Prices skyrocketed, and that is what we will be looking at again with the cuts to backpackers promised by this federal Labor government. The cuts to backpackers will simply feed our cost-of-living crisis instead of helping us to feed ourselves in a cost-of-living crisis.</p><p>Let's also have a look at AI data centres. AI data centres are going to use copious amounts of our water. Mega AI data centres are stealing our water. What will happen as a result of this is that water will become scarcer, including during the climate crisis that we are suffering as a result of decisions made by this federal Labor government, and once our farmers struggle to have access to the water that they need to grow the food that we need, again, prices will go up. The cost-of-living crisis is fed by this Labor government supporting AI data centres stealing our water, making it harder for farmers to access the water that they need to provide the food that we need to eat.</p><p>The AI data centres will use more power. AI data centres stealing our power will give rise to increased energy prices&#x2014;in a cost-of-living crisis! To think that this federal Labor government is making decisions that are going to cause us to struggle even more than we already are to pay our electricity bills. And wait for this: it is 100 per cent certain that these mega AI data centres are going to cause mass unemployment at a time when we need more than ever to keep our jobs to try to survive in a cost-of-living crisis.</p><p>And these AI data centres are going to increase greenhouse gas emissions. Greenhouse gas emissions contribute to the cost-of-living crisis. Climate change causes fire. Climate change causes floods. The impact of climate change is increasing the cost of insurance that we pay to protect our homes. Supporting mega AI data centres is supporting the climate crisis and supporting, in turn, the cost-of-living crisis.</p><p>Let's look at our creatives in our communities. AI data centres will be stealing our creatives rights, will be stealing our copyright. The way in which creative people in our communities earn a dime is by the royalties they earn from the copyright that subsists in what they create. This federal Labor government, through supporting mega AI data centres at a time when there aren't even regulations in place to properly control them, is contributing to the cost-of-living crisis suffered by the creatives in our community.</p><p>Oh, well, guess what? The Tasmania branch of the Labor Party just came out in support of a moratorium on all AI data centres in Tasmania until such time as there are proper laws in place. Well, let this federal Labor government follow in the footsteps of its Tasmanian friends and put a moratorium on all AI data centres across this state and not contribute to the cost-of-living crisis.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="14" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.189.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" speakername="Sue Lines" talktype="interjection" time="17:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the motion moved by Senator Dean Smith be agreed to.</p><p/> </speech>
 <division divdate="2026-11-16" divnumber="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.190.1" nospeaker="true" time="18:02" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
  <divisioncount ayes="28" noes="32" pairs="6" tellerayes="0" tellernoes="0"/>
  <memberlist vote="aye">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100902" vote="aye">Alex Antic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100932" vote="aye">Ralph Babet</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100969" vote="aye">Sean Bell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" vote="aye">Leah Blyth</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100904" vote="aye">Andrew Bragg</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100971" vote="aye">Slade Brockman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100827" vote="aye">Matthew Canavan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" vote="aye">Richard Mansell Colbeck</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100962" vote="aye">Jessica Collins</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100973" vote="aye">Chris Gatenby</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100857" vote="aye">Pauline Lee Hanson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100921" vote="aye">Sarah Henderson</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100859" vote="aye">Jane Hume</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100947" vote="aye">Maria Kovacic</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100934" vote="aye">Kerrynne Liddle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100911" vote="aye">Susan McDonald</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100833" vote="aye">James McGrath</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" vote="aye">Andrew McLachlan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100935" vote="aye">Jacinta Nampijinpa Price</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100913" vote="aye">Matt O'Sullivan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100958" vote="aye">Fatima Payman</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100938" vote="aye">David Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100915" vote="aye">Malcolm Roberts</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" vote="aye">Anne Ruston</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" vote="aye">Paul Scarr</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100949" vote="aye">Dave Sharma</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100303" vote="aye">Dean Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100967" vote="aye">Tyron Whitten</member>
  </memberlist>
  <memberlist vote="no">
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100931" vote="no">Penny Allman-Payne</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100961" vote="no">Michelle Ananda-Rajah</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100903" vote="no">Tim Ayres</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" vote="no">Vanessa Bleyer</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100026" vote="no">Carol Louise Brown</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100853" vote="no">Anthony Chisholm</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" vote="no">Raff Ciccone</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100957" vote="no">Dorinda Cox</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100951" vote="no">Lisa Darmanin</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100960" vote="no">Josh Dolega</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100963" vote="no">Richard Dowling</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100883" vote="no">Mehreen Faruqi</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100950" vote="no">Varun Ghosh</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" vote="no">Nita Green</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" vote="no">Karen Grogan</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100256" vote="no">Sarah Hanson-Young</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100952" vote="no">Steph Hodgins-May</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100944" vote="no">Sue Lines</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" vote="no">Jenny McAllister</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100861" vote="no">Malarndirri McCarthy</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" vote="no">Nick McKim</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100312" vote="no">Deborah O'Neill</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100937" vote="no">Barbara Pocock</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100917" vote="no">Tony Sheldon</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" vote="no">David Shoebridge</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100918" vote="no">Marielle Smith</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100213" vote="no">Glenn Sterle</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100940" vote="no">Jana Stewart</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100972" vote="no">Tammy Tyrrell</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" vote="no">Charlotte Walker</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100864" vote="no">Murray Watt</member>
   <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100966" vote="no">Ellie Whiteaker</member>
  </memberlist>
  <pairs>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100933">Ross Cadell</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100178">Helen Beatrice Polley</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252">Michaelia Cash</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100241">Penny Ying Yen Wong</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100905">Claire Chandler</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100855">Don Farrell</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100851">Jonathon Duniam</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100920">Jess Walsh</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100291">Bridget McKenzie</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100907">Katy Gallagher</member>
   </pair>
   <pair>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100849">James Paterson</member>
    <member id="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100964">Corinne Mulholland</member>
   </pair>
  </pairs>
 </division>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.191.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
BILLS </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.191.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7516" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7516">Administrative and Judicial Review Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="12" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.191.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" speakername="Richard Mansell Colbeck" talktype="speech" time="18:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The committee is considering the government amendments on sheets IE114 and IE116.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="63" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.192.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="18:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>We have been delivered very late amendments on this legislation that include provisions proposed by the government&#x2014;perhaps with the agreement of the coalition&#x2014;to allow for members to become senior members without a full external recruitment process. Could I first ask the government, given they don't have any background in the explanatory memorandum or in the history of this, where these amendments came from?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="88" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.193.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="18:06" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I answered questions of your colleague in regard to this in this debate previously. These amendments, as I set out, are something the government is putting forward to streamline tribunal appointment processes. As you know, the government's been working incredibly hard to appoint members. This is one of the ways that the government has identified it can make that process smoother. It will allow the Attorney-General to respond more quickly to the changing operational needs of the tribunal while still maintaining merit based appointment processes at appropriate times.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="172" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.194.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="18:07" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>One of the key reasons the government gave for putting in the ART and replacing the AAT was to ensure that there was full merits review before there was any appointment. If you want to have external merits review, that should apply across the board. As I understand it, the proposal here is to allow for a quick and dirty rise in seniority from 'member' to 'senior member' after the member has been there for at least two years&#x2014;to avoid the external merits review, to avoid all that which the government said was essential to put integrity into the ART, and instead have this quick and dirty process whereby you can bump someone up from being a member to being a senior member without going through the external integrity processes. Minister, why has the government so rapidly moved from the position that positions, particularly important positions like 'senior member', require external vetting and integrity? Why have you moved so quickly from that? Is it because you've done a deal with the coalition?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="130" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.195.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="18:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>There's nothing quick about requiring someone to be a member for two years before this is able to be considered. Just to reiterate, because your characterisation is that this has not been made clear, those members would have already undergone a full merits review process before being appointed in the first place. This change essentially means that they won't go through two of those processes when they have already met those criteria. Of course, the Attorney-General must seek and consider advice from the tribunal on a number of matters, including the member's performance against things like the performance standards and code of conduct. All of those issues will be considered at the time of the appointment. But the member would have already undergone the full merits independent assessment panel consideration.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="779" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.196.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="18:10" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I can recall the government, Labor, getting up and attacking the coalition for, I think, more than 80 political appointments to the AAT and saying that there needs to be something other than just a politician&#x2014;in this case, the Attorney-General&#x2014;making appointments to the tribunal. I think that they were well-made arguments&#x2014;you shouldn't just have a politician bumping people up in seniority or appointing people to the tribunal, and, if you're going to have integrity in the ART, there needs to be an external vetting process which needs to have integrity and not just include the Attorney-General of the day. Of course, the coalition fought tooth-and-nail against that because the coalition wanted to have the political power in the Attorney-General just to appoint whoever the Attorney-General wanted. I understand their political point.</p><p>But, now, Labor is obviously drinking at the same well. When it comes to some of the most senior positions in the ART, putting people in as senior members, Labor's now junking the external review, junking that merits review, and saying that the Attorney can get some advice from the president, that they are not bound by it. You don't have to follow the president's advice; you can just get some advice from the president about the person's performance against performance standards, whether they've complied with the code of conduct or not&#x2014;they don't have to have complied; you just get advice about it&#x2014;and the person's leadership and management skills and whether or not they might be appropriate. You get the president's advice about it. The president might say, 'Actually, they haven't met the performance standard, they've breached the code of conduct, and I don't think they're right.' But, under this legislation, the Attorney can just bump them up anyhow&#x2014;no merits review, no external restraint; exactly what you were complaining that the coalition were doing, with their political appointments and giving all the power to the Attorney. You're replicating it here because you've got to deal with the coalition on this. It's a quid pro quo with the coalition on this. There is no doubt the coalition will come in and vote and back you in on this, because it's what they want. They want to have this power in the Attorney unfettered by any external reference or integrity process. This is what the coalition have wanted all along, and you're giving it to them.</p><p>Of course, it gets even worse, doesn't it? If you think about it, if you've got a member in the ART who is independently holding the government to account and making hard calls against the government time after time after time, you could see how that might agitate the government's Attorney-General. You could see how the Attorney-General may not like that. What you're doing here is saying to any member: 'If you want to become a senior member&#x2014;no external review for you. You better toe the line and do what the government wants. Don't annoy the government. Don't piss the Attorney-General off, because it's solely the Attorney-General who's going to be making a decision about whether you become a senior member or not.' You are eroding the independence of the ART, and you are just becoming what the coalition were before. The whole rationale for independence and independent review is being undermined because you've got this grubby deal with the coalition now.</p><p>It is no wonder you're trying to sneak it in at the last minute&#x2014;no wonder you didn't put this in the original bill&#x2014;because you know what the law council would have said about it. You know what the law societies and the bar associations and anyone watching would have said about it. They would have said you're undermining the independence of the ART. And so what do you do? You sneak it in. You wrap it up with a little amendment to the explanatory memorandum, and you sneak it in at midnight just before we're here to debate it, because you know you can't defend it. You can't defend your grubby deal with the coalition on this, to undermine the ART. It is extraordinary how quickly you have changed from being a government that said you wanted an independent tribunal, from saying how important external merit review was, from saying how important it was that just the Attorney doesn't have the call and can't just make political appointments. How quickly you've turned. You're now playing to the coalition's fiddle on this. Is this part of a deal with the coalition? Are these two amendments that have come in at the last minute a deal you've done with the coalition? You're both going to vote them up. Is that what's happened here, Minister?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="8" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.197.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="18:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge is misleading the chamber. He is&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.197.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" speakername="Richard Mansell Colbeck" talktype="interjection" time="18:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge, on a point of order?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.197.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="18:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I ask the minister to withdraw that.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="241" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.197.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="continuation" time="18:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>On what basis?</p><p>The TEMPORARY CHAIR: The minister has the call.</p><p>Senator Shoebridge, the chair is fully aware of the context of these provisions and the fact that a member who is then appointed as a senior member under these amendments would already have gone through a merits selection process in the normal way. Currently, general members who wish to be promoted to a senior member have to participate in a fully fresh merit-based assessment process even if they have already undergone that same merits based assessment process. The characterisations that Senator Shoebridge has just given fly in the face of the facts of the legislation and the amendment. Clearly, he is seeking to make political points to delay this legislation. I refer to my previous answers on the intent of the provision, and I make two points. Firstly, it is certainly not the government's intention to water down the integrity of the ART. That's exactly why we implemented it in the first place. This provision does not do that, no matter how many speeches Senator Shoebridge gives tonight about this. That will not be the case. The second point I'd make is, in reaching these conclusions, which are not based on fact, Senator Shoebridge has done exactly what he has protested against earlier in this debate. The tone is completely inappropriate, and we would draw the senator to the previous answers that I gave to his colleague earlier this evening.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="180" approximate_wordcount="551" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.198.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="18:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Let's be clear to anyone who's trying to follow along outside of this chamber about what the gift is that the government's proposing for their good little compliant members in the tribunal who don't rock the boat, who don't upset the government and who don't get the Attorney-General offside. If you're appointed as a general member of the ART, your salary is $251,000. Then you do two years under the new regime of the current Labor's attorney-general&#x2014;you do two good years not rocking the boat, being a good little general member, don't upset the government and sign off on whatever Home Affairs has put in front of you on migration; whatever you do, don't make the government unhappy&#x2014;and, after two good years as a general member, if you've got the nod of the Attorney-General and you haven't upset the government, then that attorney-general might be able to bounce you up to being a senior member on a $408,000 salary. There's a lot of self-interest there, isn't there? Don't rock the boat, agree with what the government does, and the Attorney might in his or her munificence, bounce your salary up from $250,000 to $408,000. And good news: under the new arrangements being put in by Labor, that won't have to go out to any inefficient independent panel. That's a political gift the Attorney can give to a member of the tribunal if they're good, they don't rock the boat, they support the government and they don't create too much fuss.</p><p>This is what the coalition have always wanted&#x2014;these powers in the Attorney-General. The coalition wanted unfettered political power to appoint whoever they wanted without going to external review, and they did, and they stacked the AAT with political appointments. Now Labor's doing it through the back door here, allowing the Attorney to bump up someone's salary from $250,000 to $408,000 in what's meant to be an independent tribunal, without having to go to any external review process. That's the reality of this&#x2014;undermining the integrity of the ART, the thing you said it was worthwhile to spend hundreds of millions of dollars reforming. Hundreds of millions of dollars were spent getting rid of the old AAT, getting the new ART in, doing all the organisational change and changing all the premises, apparently to create integrity, and then, the first chance you get, you cut a deal with the coalition to undermine it.</p><p>Is it any wonder you're trying to sneak it in at midnight like this, and is it any wonder you didn't want the law societies or the Law Council to have a look at this? It's a grubby political deal, and I'll tell you who will end up paying the cost: Australians across the board will end up paying the cost, not only through having to pay the salaries of whoever, politically, the Attorney wants to bump up the salary for but also through the undermining of the integrity of the ART. People will see these appointments for what they are: political appointments. This is what the coalition's wanted. They'll be grinning like a Cheshire cat. You're delivering their AAT through the back door for them. No wonder you're backing each other in with this.</p><p>Did the government seek the advice of the Law Council before putting these amendments through?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="120" approximate_wordcount="43" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.199.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="18:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I'll just point out that nothing that Senator Shoebridge said prior to the question that he asked is supported by any of the facts in front of the chamber. I've made that point before&#x2014;not to go over that again. None of it is&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.199.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="18:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>You said the salaries aren't correct?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="191" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.199.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="continuation" time="18:21" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Senator Shoebridge, you live in a post-truth world where you are able to make up anything you like about any of the institutions in our democracy in an effort to tear them down, and that is your prerogative. That's the world that the Greens political party now lives in. There are words for it. I won't use them in this chamber, but it doesn't really matter to you what the truth is. It's really just about the political points, and you get so convinced of your own reality that you make it true. You can't actually admit that you are drawing conclusions from facts that don't exist.</p><p>That being said, amendments like this, as they would be, are informed by operational experience. We've been going through a process of appointing members over the last two years. We have improved that system. We have only today appointed new senior members, and we will continue to do that to make sure that the ART is effective and operational and that it has the members at the FTE level that it requires. This is one of the things that will assist that in occurring.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="41" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.200.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="18:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I listened carefully to the minister's word salad there. The question was simple: did you seek the advice of the Law Council, the peak body representing the profession? Did you consult with them in any way before putting this amendment through?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="32" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.201.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="18:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I've answered the question. If the senator is going to use every single contribution to make personal insults towards me, that's fine, but I'm not going to keep reiterating all of the&#x2014;</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="6" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.201.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="18:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p><i>Hansard</i> will speak to the truth.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="100" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.201.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="continuation" time="18:23" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Well, interjections are pretty disorderly, but they come from that side of the chamber a lot down there, particularly when I'm speaking. I am not going to continue to reiterate the previous evidence that I've given. It's clear that Senator Shoebridge is in here tonight to make sure that we don't vote on this legislation, and that is his decision. But what we would like to do is ensure that the ART does have these streamlined processes to ensure that the administrative review system operates and provides the opportunity for people to get the judicial review that they are owed.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="420" approximate_wordcount="682" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.202.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="18:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The <i>Hansard</i> will speak to the truth or otherwise of those pretty outrageous assertions by the minister. Of course, whether the government want to answer a simple question with a simple answer is up to the government. I'm going to take from the minister's various iterations of an answer to the question that I put about the government consulting the Law Council, which you'd think would be a fairly straightforward answer for a minister to give in relation to a bill on the administrative and judicial review legislation, that the answer is, no, they didn't consult with the Law Council. And we know why. It is because no lawyer who had integrity, no organisation that had integrity and no organisation that wanted an independent ART would ever agree to this, for the reasons we've made clear.</p><p>I pointed out the salary increase. That comes from the schedule published by the Remuneration Tribunal. When we point out the figures on the schedule coming from the Remuneration Tribunal, we get the allegation from Labor that that's some kind of post-truth world. We read out the figures from the Remuneration Tribunal that show how they're going to be bumping up the salary, and we got this kind of Trumpian response from Labor. When we're talking evidence and we're putting the actual figures from the Remuneration Tribunal, we get a Trumpian response from Labor: 'There's nothing here you should believe.' This is the post-truth world that Labor lives in. They think that they can just fool the public with their messaging.</p><p>They had a second reading contribution on this that said that this legislation was all about improving people's rights and increasing integrity. Nothing could be further from the truth. When they get speaker after speaker doing what the minister is doing now or they get their drones coming forward with whatever speaking notes have been given to them by the Attorney-General and pretending that a bill that is taking away people's rights to written decisions, procedural fairness and an actual hearing is actually about improving people's rights or they stand up here and say black is white like this, is it any wonder people are losing faith in the Labor government and in government more generally? When we come and point out that the figures from the Remuneration Tribunal mean that the Attorney-General is going to be able to bump up someone's salary from 250 kay to 408 kay without going to an independent review process, which would undermine the integrity of the ART, we get this Trumpian kind of response from Labor that says that nothing we say is based in evidence. It's based on the schedule in the Remuneration Tribunal.</p><p>This kind of vacuous political messaging that's coming from the government&#x2014;that war is peace, that taking away rights is improving rights, that referencing actual schedules is somehow not relying on evidence&#x2014;is why people are losing faith. Every time Labor comes and does this, people know the truth. They can feel it. Their rights are being eroded. This government keeps doing this. They say, 'Watch my hand,' about one hand, and then they're taking away rights and taking away things from people with the other hand. That's why people are just so put off by the very project of government and by what this government is doing, exactly as we heard from the minister then.</p><p>This is an amendment the Greens will be opposing, and we'll be opposing it because it's bad. It's bad for the independence of the tribunal. It's bad for government. It's bad for people's rights when they come before the ART. It's bad for those members of the ART who will have to be looking over their shoulder with one eye to see what the government's going to say about their performance and see whether or not they might get a promotion from member to senior member. It's bad on all grounds. This Trumpian, post-truth stuff that's coming from you, Labor, does you absolutely no credit. You can't deal with the substance of the arguments. That's why you do it.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="22" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.202.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100880" speakername="Richard Mansell Colbeck" talktype="interjection" time="18:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that amendments (1) and (2) on sheet IE114 and amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116 be agreed to.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="21" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.202.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="18:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Can the question on the amendments on sheet IE114 be put separately to that on the amendments on sheet IE116, please?</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="108" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.202.4" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="interjection" time="18:24" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>To support Senator Shoebridge's request and to ensure that you and the chamber understand, we will be voting differently on those two amendments.</p><p>The TEMPORARY CHAIR: The question is that amendments (1) and (2) on sheet IE114 be agreed to.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>The TEMPORARY CHAIR: The question is that amendments (1) to (4) on sheet IE116 be agreed to. A division is required. It being past 6.30, the bill cannot proceed until votes can be taken. I shall report progress to the Senate.</p><p>Progress reported.</p><p>Further consideration of the bill in Committee of the Whole made an order of the day for the next day of sitting.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.203.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7527" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7527">Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="840" approximate_wordcount="1704" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.203.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100252" speakername="Michaelia Cash" talktype="speech" time="18:31" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise to speak on the Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026. There is no more fundamental responsibility of government than keeping Australians safe. Protecting Australians from terrorism is not optional. It is the first responsibility of government, and that is the standard against which the coalition judges this legislation.</p><p>The coalition will support this bill. We will also support the government's amendments implementing recommendations 5 and 6 of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security. But our support for these important national security powers should not be mistaken for an endorsement of the Albanese government's broader national security record, because, sadly, when it comes to national security, Australians deserve a government that acts before a crisis, not one that is constantly playing catch-up.</p><p>This bill is another example of the government leaving critical national security legislation until it is dangerously close to its expiry. The bill extends essential counterterrorism powers, including control orders, preventive detention orders and continuing detention orders, for another three years until December 2029. These are powers established and strengthened by former coalition governments. Court orders and preventive detention orders were introduced by the Howard government in 2005, continuing detention orders followed under the coalition in 2016, and extended supervision orders were introduced by the coalition in 2021. The coalition created these powers because we understood that protecting Australians requires strong laws, strong intelligence capabilities and a willingness to act. We will not allow them to lapse.</p><p>Labor has known for years that these powers are due to expire on 7 December 2026. Why? Because Labor itself legislated this sunset date in 2023. Yet it waited until August of this year to introduce the legislation reviewing them. The Independent National Security Legislation Monitor completed a major review of the postsentence order regime in March 2023. When did Labor finally table its response? It did so in August 2026, more than three years later, on the very day it introduced this particular piece of legislation. So Labor had the review, Labor knew the deadline, and yet, as is typical for this government, Labor delayed. That is, quite frankly, not good enough when Australia's national security is at stake.</p><p>Australia's national terrorism threat remains 'probable'. ASIO has warned that our security environment is becoming increasingly complex and that Australians are being radicalised at an alarming pace. We have witnessed the horrific consequences of terrorism in our own country. The terrorist attack at Bondi, which claimed 15 innocent lives at a Jewish Hanukkah celebration, was a devastating reminder of the threats confronting Australia. Terrorism is not some distant danger. It is a threat to Australians, our communities and the great Australian way of life, and it demands a serious response. That includes how we manage convicted terrorist offenders approaching the end of their prison sentences, how we supervise dangerous individuals in the community, and whether or not police and our intelligence agencies indeed have the powers necessary to protect Australians. That is why this legislation matters.</p><p>I want now to return to the report of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security. The committee's unanimous October '26 report made 10 recommendations and recommended that the bill be passed. The report recognised the importance of maintaining effective counterterrorism laws subject to appropriate safeguards and oversight. But the report also identified areas requiring improvement. One significant concern was the timing of applications for post-sentence orders. The committee found that applications were too often commenced shortly before offenders were due for release despite opportunities to actually commence the process earlier. That creates unnecessary difficulties for courts, legal representatives and corrective services, and, when we are dealing with serious terrorism risks, that is simply unacceptable. The committee recommended that applications for continuing detention orders and control orders ordinarily commence as soon as practicable within the 12 months before an offender's sentence or existing post-sentence order expires. Now, these are not merely administrative matters; they go directly to the effectiveness and the operation of Australia's national security laws.</p><p>The bill also makes important changes to how convicted terrorist offenders are managed following their release from prison. Currently, extended supervision orders and control orders can impose substantially similar restrictions on offenders living in the community, but they operate under separate legal frameworks. The bill removes this duplication by making control orders the principal mechanism for community supervision. Control orders generally operate for up to 12 months, with further orders available where the terrorism risk continues and statutory requirements are met. Importantly, continuing detention orders remain available for the highest-risk offenders who cannot be managed safely in the community, and where a Supreme Court declines to make a continuing detention order, it may still impose an extended supervision order where the legal requirements are satisfied.</p><p>The bill also ensures that the full 12-month control order period can commence upon an offender's release from custody. It improves arrangements for handling sensitive terrorism related material, it provides police with warrant powers to assess whether certain offenders approaching release should be subjected to control orders and it strengthens information sharing so courts can consider relevant findings of guilt, even where no conviction was recorded. The objective is straightforward: ensuring police and courts have the information and powers necessary to manage serious terrorism risks.</p><p>One of the most disturbing developments confronting Australia is the increased radicalisation of young people. The PJCIS report recorded that, since 2020, the AFP and its joint counterterrorism team partners had commenced investigations and operational activity involving 65 individuals aged 17 or younger. The youngest was, alarmingly, just 12 years old&#x2014;12 years old! That should concern every member of parliament and every member of the Australian community.</p><p>Young Australians are being exposed to violent extremist material through social media, gambling platforms and online communications, and radicalisation can occur at frightening speed. The bill responds by increasing the maximum duration of control orders for young people aged 14 to 17 from three months to 12 months. The PJCIS supported this change, recognising that disengagement and rehabilitation programs need sufficient time to operate. Courts will retain discretion to impose shorter orders, and the child's best interests will remain the primary consideration.</p><p>We cannot ignore the broader problem. A control order is at the back end of the problem. We should be doing everything that we can to prevent a 12-year-old from becoming radicalised in the first place. That requires effective intervention, intelligence cooperation and rehabilitation programs that actually work. The committee was clear that community safety must remain the primary objective. Protecting the Australian community must always come first.</p><p>The government is bringing forward amendments implementing recommendations 5 and 6 of the unanimous PJCIS report. Recommendation 5 concerns special advocates. These are lawyers appointed to protect a person's interests in national security proceedings where sensitive information cannot be disclosed to them. The amendment strengthens annual reporting on the number and availability of qualified special advocates. That will improve parliamentary scrutiny of whether the system has sufficient qualified lawyers to operate effectively. Recommendation 6 concerns the experts who assess the risk posed by terrorist offenders. These assessments inform critical decisions about whether offenders should remain detained or be subject to restrictions following release. The PJCIS found that the existing definition provided insufficient guidance about the required expertise. The amendment strengthens that definition, requiring experts to be appropriately qualified to assess both the risk of further terrorism offending and how that risk could be reduced. The coalition supports both amendments, and they are practical improvements arising directly from the PJCIS's recommendations.</p><p>The bill also expands Commonwealth criminal protections for United Nations personnel engaged in humanitarian assistance, emergency aid and peace building. These changes will enable Australia to ratify the operational protocol signed by the Howard government in 2006.</p><p>Although the coalition supports this legislation, serious questions remain about Labor's broader approach to national security. The handling of Australians linked to ISIS returning from Syria is but one example. In 2022, Labor deliberately repatriated four ISIS women and 13 children. Subsequently, the government adopted an approach under which members of the ISIS linked cohort could make their own arrangements to return to Australia. The coalition has consistently argued that the Commonwealth should exercise the strongest lawful control available over the timing and circumstances of returns by people linked to terrorism, and that was the principle behind our Criminal Code Amendment (Keeping Australia Safe) Bill 2026. Sadly&#x2014;in fact, shockingly&#x2014;the Labor government opposed it.</p><p>The recent release of convicted ISIS supporter Isaac El Matari has again highlighted difficult questions about managing serious terrorist offenders. Again, shockingly but not surprisingly, the Labor government did not seek a continuing detention order, citing the high legal threshold, and the AFP instead obtained an interim control order. This legislation preserves the continuing detention regime but does not lower that threshold. The existence of strong powers is one thing, but actually utilising those powers and ensuring those powers can be effectively used to protect Australians is another. These matters demand ongoing scrutiny.</p><p>The coalition supports this legislation because the national security powers it preserves are essential. We support the government's amendments implementing recommendations 5 and 6 of the PJCIS report, and we expect the government to act on the committee's broader recommendations, including better timing of applications, effective risk assessments and stronger oversight. Above all, this legislation must pass before the existing powers expire on 7 December this year. Australians cannot afford a gap in these critical national security powers. Labor knew the deadline, Labor had years to prepare and the parliament should never have been left considering legislation of this importance so close to the expiry dates.</p><p>The coalition's position is clear. We will support strong counterterrorism laws, we will support the police and intelligence agencies charged with keeping Australians safe and we will always insist that community safety remains the overriding objective. But the first responsibility of government is not to explain away threats. It is to protect Australians from them. The coalition created many of the powers before the Senate. We strengthened them as threats evolved, and we will continue to fight to ensure Australia's counterterrorism laws are strong enough to meet the threats we face. On the safety and security of Australians, the coalition will never compromise.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="900" approximate_wordcount="1265" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.204.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="speech" time="18:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 continues the race to erode fundamental rights and freedoms in this country that has been engaged in by the coalition and the Labor Party for many decades but, in particular, over the last 20 years or so.</p><p>Having made that point, I do want to say there are some aspects of this legislation that are positive. Of course the Australian Greens welcome stronger protections for United Nations and humanitarian workers. But I have to say protection has to mean something when it's inconvenient to advocate for it as well as when it is easy to advocate for it. For example, the silence has been deafening from this government while the United States has sanctioned the UN special rapporteur on the occupied Palestinian territories, Francesca Albanese. She's doing the job that the United Nations asked her to do. While we've heard some murmurings from this government, it is fair to say that they have not advocated for Ms Albanese with anything like the vigour that they should.</p><p>Australia, led by this Labor government, has made us all complicit in the genocide that is happening in Gaza at the moment. This government is in lockstep with the apartheid Israeli government, along with the United States and along with a small number of other countries around the world. We are continuing to allow the export from this country of weapons and weapons components that are being used in the genocide in Gaza. We continue to be complicit in that genocide.</p><p>The main parts of this bill that the Greens are concerned about are putting children on adult-length control orders. I'll come to some of the other parts later. But, before I even go to the details of why we are concerned about that, let's step right back in history to 2005, when elements of this regime were first introduced. They were sold to Australians back then as extraordinary and temporary powers. Australians were supposed to be reassured by the fact that there were sunset provisions in the legislation and that every three years the government would need to come back and ask parliament to extend them&#x2014;if that is in fact what the government wanted to do.</p><p>Surprise, surprise. Colour me shocked. Every government since then, Labor or coalition, has disappeared into the closed shop of the PJCIS, the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, and come back out in absolute zombie lockstep and asked parliament to extend these powers. What a surprise! Colour me shocked! In the last 20 years there have been literally many hundreds of new powers created in state, territory and Commonwealth parliaments to erode some of the fundamental rights and freedoms that our ancestors&#x2014;including, I'm sure, the ancestors of many people in this place, including mine&#x2014;fought and died to protect and enhance when they were under threat from fascists. And now we've rolled over so far that we are extending those draconian powers on a regular basis in this parliament. I tell you now, there'll be plenty of people who've fought, bled and died for this country who will be turning in their graves at the thought of what this parliament and state and territory parliaments continue to do.</p><p>The reason the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security is such an absolute stitch-up is it lubricates the wheels that grind away in eroding our rights and freedoms in Australia. That's why it's a joint party stitch-up&#x2014;the so-called parties of government. I've got news for the parties of government in this place: your combined vote is on a decline that is so steep and has been occurring for so long that this dream that you both have, that you simply hand government back and forth between the two of you over decades, is literally evaporating in front of your eyes right now. Gone are the days when that will simply be de rigueur in this country, when government will swap backwards and forwards between the majorities of the Labor Party and the coalition parties. Those days are coming to an end.</p><p>On average over the last 30 years, the combined vote of the major parties has gone down by nearly 1.5 per cent at every election. It happened last time, it happened the time before that and it happened the time before that. The reason it's collapsing is they are not here for the Australian people, and more and more Australian people are figuring that out. They're figuring out that the political duopoly is in fact two sides of the same coin; they are two sides of the same neoliberal economic coin, two sides of the same planet-cooking coin, two sides of the same corporatist coin and two sides of the same industrial security complex coin. That's what this bill is. This is just rolling over every time people like ASIO and other organisations in the security intelligence complex in this country ask for more powers; the major parties just roll over and give them to them. What they should be doing is asking themselves genuinely whether these powers are necessary. It seems to fall to the Australian Greens, and only the Australian Greens, to run the arguments around these powers and the fact that they should not be mindlessly and automatically rolled over every time the legislation demands it. We should have these debates, in terms of inquiries into legislation, in public, not behind the closed doors of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security.</p><p>Let everyone understand this: since 2005, when Australians were sold these powers as 'extraordinary' and 'temporary'&#x2014;this is the sixth time these so-called temporary powers have been rolled over. This time, they're going to be extended until December 2029. I confidently predict that, towards the end of 2029&#x2014;and it won't matter who's in government; it simply won't matter&#x2014;another bill will come before this parliament, and these extraordinary powers, these so-called temporary powers, will be extended again. There is nothing temporary about these extraordinarily draconian powers. These are permanent powers. I was in the Tasmanian parliament. I held the justice portfolio for the Tasmanian Greens. I well remember when the first tranche of state enabling legislation came through. It may have been 2005 or it may have been 2006, but I remember getting up and arguing in the Tasmanian parliament that, if we let these laws through, we'd never see the back of them. And you know what? I was proved right. We won't see the back of these, because the so-called parties of government will be back in this parliament in three years extending these horrifically draconian powers yet again.</p><p>So here we find ourselves extending control orders, putting children on adult-length control orders, making sure that police can bug people in prison to decide whether to chase an order against them, stripping people of the right to ask for an organisation to be delisted and keeping alive the secret detention powers that nobody appears to ever have used&#x2014;but how would we ever know? We live in a police state. We live in a surveillance state. We live in a state where the so-called parties of government have given away so many of the rights and the freedoms that ordinary people used to have in this country that we just don't know. You can disappear into the maw of the security-industrial complex in this country, and it would be a fair while until anyone ever found out about it, and sometimes, depending on the circumstances, when you get out you can't even tell your husband or your wife where you've been.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="7" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.204.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="interjection" time="18:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>'Why are you in the same clothes?'</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="372" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.204.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100847" speakername="Nick McKim" talktype="continuation" time="18:45" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Exactly. It is illegal for you to tell them that you've been held incommunicado for a period of time. Remember, this is the country where people seeking asylum would have their doors broken down in the small hours of the morning. Is this ringing any bells for you, folks? It's ringing some bells for me.</p><p>This is another step in the slow march to fascism that we are descending into in this country, and the thing about that is that it has to be called out, because we have got a huge concentration of wealth in the hands of a few. We have got the tech bros collectively scraping the entire artistic, creative and scientific output of humanity and corporatising it for profit. We have got data centres being built hand over fist to feed the parasitic plagiarism machine that is artificial intelligence. They are huge users of water and of energy that will be supplied to them through non-renewable means, because Labor is too gutless to stand up against these forces in our society and in our economy. These powers are going to make it harder for people to resist the slide into fascism, the destruction of nature and the literal rendering of this planet uninhabitable for humanity. That is what we are facing here, and it's hard not to come to the conclusion that we are actually being governed by tyrants in this country, because they are abrogating the No. 1 responsibility of government, which is to keep people safe. It's 2026 and the Labor Party is still publicly funding the burning of fossil fuels. That's how far away we are from genuine climate sustainability and genuine climate policies in this country.</p><p>I know my colleague Senator Shoebridge will go into more detail on this legislation, but, like every other so called national security bill that was sent to the closed shop of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, this is a stitch-up. It is a stitch-up between the Labor Party and the coalition parties, and it is a stitch-up to further erode the fundamental rights and freedoms of ordinary Australians&#x2014;those rights and freedoms that many people, including ancestors of mine, died to protect back in the day.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="1560" approximate_wordcount="3205" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.205.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100939" speakername="David Shoebridge" talktype="speech" time="19:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I want to thank Senator McKim for setting out what's at stake here in this legislation and why the Greens will be opposing it. This slippery slide that the Labor and the coalition seem keen on taking us into, no doubt with the help of their mates in One Nation now, is a kind of dystopian world where you can literally disappear into the security state, without anyone knowing, without legal protections and without clear or any judicial constraint. It's just extraordinary that we see this.</p><p>When it comes to the Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill, the Greens will be opposing this bill. But I want to point out: in the roadkill that features in most of this legislation, there are a couple of little bits of bouncy positivity. There are some aspects of the bill that are positive, and I'll go to those first. There are proposed stronger protections for UN and humanitarian workers, and that's good. But, of course, those don't really mean much when it's inconvenient to the government to provide those protections. So it's words on paper, but it doesn't seem to be backed in by any clear international commitment to protect UN and humanitarian workers.</p><p>A case in point would be the obscene number of humanitarian and UN workers that have been killed by the Israel Defense Forces in Gaza. Despite that, the Labor government is quite content with continuing to buy from Israel weapons being tested by the Israel Defense Forces on UN and humanitarian workers in Gaza. They seem quite comfortable with continuing to supply parts to the Israel Defense Forces so that they can bomb and kill UN and humanitarian workers. We see the words on paper here, but we see the actions of Labor, and we know what's stronger and more powerful in the world as it is. And it's their actions, not their words, as always.</p><p>And, of course, this government has said next to nothing about the United States sanctioning the UN Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories, Francesca Albanese. She's who most people who believe in human rights describe as 'the good Albanese'&#x2014;the one who actually stands up for rights and the one who actually cares about the rights of the people of Palestine not to be subject to the horrors of the Israel Defense Force, who does her job as the UN has asked her to do. Of course, where has been the government when it comes to this? It's complete silence on backing in the UN Special Rapporteur. And she's been sanctioned by the US simply for doing her job. You could say the same about the appalling sanctions the US has put against members of the International Criminal Court. Direct attacks from the US are trying to undermine some of these protections, and it's complete silence or, worse, complicity from the Labor government.</p><p>So we see the words in writing here, but we also&#x2014;and I think most Australians&#x2014;judge this government by their actions, not their words, because they are so, so far apart. Of course, when it comes to protecting aid workers, there's Australian aid worker, Zomi Frankcom, who was killed in Gaza in 2024 while delivering food with the World Central Kitchen. Zomi and her family deserve justice. Again, it needs more than just empty words from this government. Sending in a totally compromised individual to do a compromised investigation, where the Israeli authorities would not give access to critical evidence, and then pretending that that action by the government was in any way some kind of meaningful response to Zomi's murder was, again, more of the complicity and the pathetic inability of this government to actually take actions to match their words. This government should be speaking up when humanitarian workers are targeted, and then matching those words with action. This government continues to fail at that, on pretty much every test, every time they're tested. So it's good to see the legislation; it's good to see it in this bill. But, again, we feel this is another one of those moments: let's not watch what Labor says; let's watch what they do. And, each time, they disappoint.</p><p>We know why this happens, in relation to that particular conflict&#x2014;the genocide in Gaza. It's because the toxic hostage relationship that the Albanese Labor government, the coalition and One Nation have decided we should have with the United States means that you don't feel permitted to stand on principle. You don't feel permitted to actually make your actions match your words. Increasingly, the Australian public sees this betrayal of our core national interests&#x2014;your refusal to actually stand up and seek an independent path from the one you're permitted to run by the Trump administration or whoever is in Washington. We see it, and the Australian public sees it.</p><p>When it comes to the balance of this bill, what does it do? Every three years this government comes back and asks parliament to rubberstamp powers that were sold to Australians in 2005 as extraordinary&#x2014;totally out of character with our common law and traditional rights and liberties&#x2014;and temporary. We were told in 2005: 'Don't you worry. There's a sunset on them. They'll set after three years.' Then, of course, every three years, Labor and the coalition come together&#x2014;no doubt, this time, with the support of One Nation&#x2014;to say, 'The sun will never set.'</p><p>Not only do they say that the sun will never set; they make the powers more extreme. They take away more rights. They subject children, in this case, to even more draconian extrajudicial punishment. They continue to expand the concept of future crime&#x2014;of punishing you for crimes you haven't committed but the government thinks you might. Therefore, without going to a judge, they're just going to whack you in detention, whether you're an adult or a child. And that's what they're doing again today.</p><p>This bill puts children on adult-length control orders. It lets police bug people in prison to decide whether to chase an order against them. It strips people of the right to ask for an organisation to be delisted. It also keeps alive secret detention powers that nobody appears to have ever used but which are sitting there on the statute books for a government&#x2014;a nasty, pernicious government&#x2014;to use, whenever they choose, to literally pull people off the street, whenever they choose. This is fascist-ready law.</p><p>Of course the Greens oppose it. If the government insists on pushing through with this legislation, we will be moving amendments to protect children, at the least; to get some kind of guarantee for a fair hearing; to let these preventive detention powers&#x2014;which are so contrary to our concepts of the rule of law and of being judged by your actions&#x2014;finally lapse; and to make sure in those amendments, too, that our terrorism laws stop putting humanitarian workers at risk, when they're going about their business, in some of the hardest conditions on the planet, just trying to keep people alive.</p><p>So what are the effects of this bill? The first is that it extends control orders; preventive detention orders; post-sentence orders; terrorism stop, search and seize powers&#x2014;these fascist laws that are contrary to our concepts of basic liberty&#x2014;for another three years to 7 December 2029. This will be the sixth time that these so-called temporary, extraordinary laws have been rolled over and extended by this parliament. The Greens say: the sun should set on these laws. They are contrary to the concept of a free and democratic society, they are contrary to the concept of us being governed by the rule of law and not the rule of the executive, and they are contrary to basic concepts of freedom that should be underpinning us as a democratic society.</p><p>It also rewrites the post-sentence order scheme, so control orders will become the main tool for managing people after they finish their sentence&#x2014;expanding the role of control orders. It lifts the maximum control order for a child aged 14 to 17 from three months to 12 months, the same as an adult, ignoring the difference in development and ignoring the constraint that was meant to be put in there because we were meant to be treating children different to adults and not throwing draconian control orders on them for 12 months at a time. If you think they need extending, they should have constant judicial review before you do that to children. You want to get rid of those restraints and let the executive have control orders over children for up to 12 months without judicial review. We oppose that. Anyone who believes in basic liberties should oppose that.</p><p>This bill lets agencies get surveillance and interception warrants against people in custody to help decide whether they can get a control order against them. They don't have to have any evidence. They can start working up their case. There's not even a requirement for reasonable suspicion. These are going to be issued by ART members rather than judges. This links to other legislation this government is doing undermining the independence of the ART. You want a compliant ART that can issue these kinds of orders for you without having to trouble a judge. Get one of your favourite senior members who the Attorney has bumped up and given a 150K pay rise to to give you one of these orders!</p><p>It removes the right of an individual or an organisation to apply to have an organisation delisted, making delisting declarations non-disallowable as well, taking away parliamentary oversight of this and, again, giving more power to the executive to list an organisation and then to prevent the parliament from having any oversight of it. This is what fascist governments do. They pile up powers in the executive, they take away powers from the judiciary, they take away basic rights, they take away parliamentary oversight and they give the power to control and list organisations to the executive. It lets findings of guilt with no conviction recorded be used to control order and post-sentence proceedings. That is totally contrary to our concept of rule of law or being judged on your actions by an independent judiciary and not on some political test put forward by the Attorney-General. That's what this legislation does.</p><p>When a weaker version of these powers was first introduced in 2005, there was enormous controversy because they are so contrary to our basic concepts of rule of law. The sunset clauses were put in there, and, again, as I said, if this goes through, it'll be the sixth time.</p><p>The government has ignored the parliament's own independent monitor in this. The INSLM, the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor&#x2014;highly credentialed, highly regarded&#x2014;reported on the post-sentence order scheme in March 2023. It gave the government the report in March 2023, and what did the government do? They buried it. They sat on it for three years. Having sat on it for three years, you then only tabled it as part of the response to this legislation on 12 August this year, the same day you introduced the bill. This bill ignores all of the recommendations from the INSLM. The review by the INSLM compared parts of this scheme to <i>Alice in </i><i>Wonderland</i> or a Philip Dick fiction novel. It recommended abolishing continuing detention orders altogether and writing rehabilitation and reintegration into the objects of the law. This government buries the report for three years then brings legislation in at the same time as they give public release of the INSLM's report, and they ignore everything they said. The INSLM was right about how deeply dystopian this scheme is.</p><p>Future crime not judged by a judge, being judged not on your actions but on the political views of the government of the day about what you might do in the future, potentially going to jail, being under control, being held in your house, being limited in what you could do because the government thinks you might have some kind of future crime&#x2014;the INSLM called it out for what it was: <i>Alice in </i><i>Wonderland</i> stuff. You bury the report for three years and you fail to implement any of it. This is another one of these stitch-ups between Labor and the coalition. You mention national security, and we're all meant to just roll over and say whatever you want&#x2014;'Whichever rights you can take away, take them; whichever liberties you want to take away, you can take them'&#x2014;because you mention the word 'terrorism' and the parliament just gets cowed. Well, enough of that. Some of these rights are fundamental to us. Some of these rights are fundamental to any free society. The Greens oppose this <i>Alice in Wonderland</i> dystopian legislation you're bringing through, like we do each time you bring it&#x2014;surveillance creep stitch-up, taking away the rights.</p><p>In the short time that's available to me, I'm going to move the second reading amendment that's been circulated:</p><p class="italic">At the end of the motion, add "but the Senate:</p><p class="italic">(a) notes that:</p><p class="italic">(i) Australian humanitarian organisations operate in some of the world's most challenging environments, including contexts where de facto authorities or armed groups may be listed under Australian counter-terrorism or sanctions regimes, and, that in these settings, humanitarian organisations must negotiate access, move funds, procure goods and services, and work with local partners to deliver food, healthcare, shelter, protection and other forms of assistance,</p><p class="italic">(ii) Australia has obligations under international humanitarian law to facilitate impartial humanitarian relief for civilian populations affected by armed conflict, and that humanitarian exemptions support compliance with those obligations,</p><p class="italic">(iii) humanitarian assistance is provided on the basis of humanity, neutrality, impartiality and independence and is not intended to support the objectives of any party to a conflict,</p><p class="italic">(iv) current Australian laws create uncertainty and potential exposure to criminal or civil liability for Australian humanitarian organisations, their board members and other office-bearers, and Government decision-makers approving humanitarian funding, and that leads financial institutions and donors to de-risk,</p><p class="italic">(v) Australian humanitarian organisations have long advocated for a standing humanitarian exemption, the absence of which from Australia's counter-terrorism financing and sanctions frameworks remains an urgent gap in Australian law,</p><p class="italic">(vi) Australians have consistently shown remarkable generosity in responding to humanitarian crises through their support of Australian humanitarian organisations and expect their donations can be used to deliver life-saving assistance to vulnerable people wherever needs arise,</p><p class="italic">(vii) under the current <i>Criminal Code Act 1995 </i>('Criminal Code'), humanitarian organisations may be required to choose between delivering life-saving assistance in some of the world's most complex crises and exposing themselves to potential criminal liability; as a result, civilians affected by conflict, disaster and displacement may experience delayed, reduced or foregone access to essential assistance, including children, older people and people with disabilities,</p><p class="italic">(viii) legal uncertainty contributes to risk-averse practices by financial institutions, donors and other funders, increasing barriers to the transfer of funds and the delivery of humanitarian assistance,</p><p class="italic">(ix) a humanitarian exemption would bring Australia into line with the United States of America, United Kingdom, European Union, and Canada, which have all adopted humanitarian exemptions, and would implement United Nations Security Council (UNSC) Resolution 2664, which Australia is required to implement, but has not yet legislated,</p><p class="italic">(x) inconsistent exemption standards across Australia's counter-terrorism and sanctions regimes create confusion and compliance uncertainty,</p><p class="italic">(xi) the Declaration for the Protection of Humanitarian Personnel, as led by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, commits endorsing States to work with States to ensure that humanitarian activities carried out by humanitarian organisations are not criminalised where those activities are consistent with international law, and that measures are taken to prevent harassment, arbitrary arrest and detention and reprisals against humanitarian personnel for carrying out their mission,</p><p class="italic">(xii) recommendation 5 of the Joint Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade report, <i>Australia's Thematic Sanctions Framework: A Legislated Review of the Operation of the Autonomous Sanctions Amendment (Magnitsky-style and Other Thematic Sanctions) Act 2021</i> (March 2025), called for a standing exemption from all sanctions measures for legitimate humanitarian assistance, consistent with the approach taken in UNSC Resolution 2664, and found that sanctions permits are not an effective or efficient substitute for such an exemption,</p><p class="italic">(xiii) the reform sought by the humanitarian sector is a clearly defined exemption for qualifying humanitarian actors and activities that enables humanitarian assistance while leaving the underlying prohibitions on terrorism financing and material support in place for all other conduct,</p><p class="italic">(xiv) Australian non-government organisations (NGOs) with Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) accreditation undergo a rigorous assessment of governance, financial management, risk management and program quality, and are subject to ongoing oversight,</p><p class="italic">(xv) these existing mechanisms provide Parliament and the Australian public with confidence that Australian humanitarian organisations are professional, accountable and well placed to manage risk in complex operating environments,</p><p class="italic">(xvi) these safeguards demonstrate that a humanitarian exemption can be implemented in a way that facilitates life-saving assistance while maintaining strong protections against terrorism financing and other forms of wrongdoing, as comparable exemptions overseas already do, for example, by requiring reasonable efforts to minimise any benefit to terrorist groups,</p><p class="italic">(xvii) the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security, in relation to this Bill, recommended that the Australian Government conduct engagement with relevant humanitarian organisations to consider further reform for a broader humanitarian exemption across the Criminal Code and other relevant federal legislation and that any humanitarian exemption reform to the Criminal Code should be informed by the national intelligence community to ensure that changes protect genuine humanitarian personnel whilst avoiding providing legal protection to terrorists or other criminals; and</p><p class="italic">(b) calls on the Government to introduce legislation for a humanitarian exemption in the Criminal Code, including an offence specific carve-out or defence to sections 102.6, 102.7 and 103.1 and 103.2, with the same subject-based and activity-based test applied consistently across sections 102.6 to 102.8, to reduce barriers to effective, principled humanitarian assistance in line with proposed sanctions reform by 1 October 2027, that:</p><p class="italic">(i) is both subject-based and activity-based, and applies to humanitarian activities carried out by eligible humanitarian actors in accordance with international humanitarian principles and at a minimum in line with UNSC Resolution 2664, including DFAT-accredited Australian NGOs,</p><p class="italic">(ii) extends to the financial institutions, donors and local partners that fund and enable humanitarian assistance, and to the provision, processing or payment of funds and the provision of goods and services necessary for the timely delivery of humanitarian assistance, including necessary and incidental costs such as administrative fees and taxes,</p><p class="italic">(iii) is coordinated across both counter-terrorism and sanctions measures to ensure clarity and reduce uncertainty for Australian humanitarian organisations, and</p><p class="italic">(iv) is accompanied by clear Government guidance, communicated to the banking sector and AUSTRAC, to address financial de-risking".</p><p>I really want to thank the humanitarian and aid sector for bringing this through, because this second reading amendment calls upon the parliament to amend these laws so that aid workers, when they're going into some of the most dangerous parts of the world, where there's conflict, where some of the control is done by listed organisations, are allowed to continue to do their work without being subject to criminal offences. It's essential if we're going to live up to the promise, and I commend that second reading amendment to the chair.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="420" approximate_wordcount="778" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.206.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100908" speakername="Nita Green" talktype="speech" time="19:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank parliamentary colleagues for their contributions to the debate on this bill. The Australian government's first priority is the safety of all Australians and protecting the values we hold dear. As the Director-General of Security recently affirmed, the temperature and trajectory of Australia's security environment is concerning. Our laws must remain agile in response. The Counter-Terrorism Legislation Amendment Bill 2026 is a proportionate and effective response to the challenging and evolving terrorism threat environment that we face. It makes targeted reforms to the key counterterrorism powers to ensure they remain available, effective and proportionate. These changes are informed by the advice of law enforcement on their operational experience in responding to the current threat environment.</p><p>The bill extends the sunset date for key counterterrorism police powers and orders frameworks, which remain important tools for our law enforcement agencies in the current complex threat environment. It makes amendments to streamline and rationalise the control order and post-sentence order frameworks by embedding control orders as the primary Commonwealth mechanism to impose conditions on serious terrorist offenders in the community. These amendments reduce duplication between these frameworks and establish a single primary mechanism to manage terrorism risks in the community. It enhances the control order framework in its application to young people to ensure that law enforcement have a full spectrum of effective and proportionate measures to address the growth in youth radicalisation. It improves information-sharing powers, making sure that decision-makers in the control order and post-sentence order frameworks have a complete picture of the terrorism risks that a person poses. It also makes technical amendments to strengthen the framework for listing terrorist organisations, and it amends division 71 of the Criminal Code to give effect to the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Safety of United Nations and Associated Personnel. This reinforces Australia's commitment to protecting those who undertake critical humanitarian peacebuilding and development work.</p><p>I want to acknowledge the work of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security for its scrutiny of this legislation, with particular thanks to the chair, Senator Ciccone, and deputy chair, Andrew Wallace MP. The government is carefully considering the recommendations made by the committee; however, it has introduced amendments to the bill to address two key recommendations which relate to these legislative powers. The bill will amend the definition of 'relevant expert' in the post-sentence order framework to mean any person with expertise in and who is qualified to express opinions as to the risk and means of a risk of a terrorist offender committing a serious part 5.3 or 5.3A offence. This would ensure that the definition more closely reflects the role to be performed by a relevant expert in post-sentence order matters. The bill also makes amendments to the National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004 to strengthen annual reporting requirements. The amendment will require additional information concerning special advocates appointed in the post-sentence order and control order proceedings involving court-only evidence to be reported on. This will improve transparency and support oversight of the availability of appropriately qualified special advocates across Australia.</p><p>Separately, the bill will also extend the sunset date of section 122.4 of the Criminal Code until 29 June 2027. Section 122.4 makes it an offence for a Commonwealth officer or a person engaged to perform work for a Commonwealth entity to communicate information in breach of a duty arising elsewhere under the Commonwealth. It is important that section 122.4 continues to provide this protection until parliament has considered the broader secrecy reforms currently before the Senate that would support the repeal of section 122.4.</p><p>In relation to the second reading amendment moved by the Greens, we will have more to say on this during the committee stage if we get that opportunity. The bill does deal with the response around the protocol around humanitarian workers, although I do indicate that the government won't be supporting the second reading amendment as circulated.</p><p>In conclusion, it is crucial that Australia's counterterrorism legislation remains effective, proportionate and responsive to the contemporary threat environment that Australians face. The targeted amendments in this bill will maintain critical counterterrorism powers and ensure that Australia's counterterrorism laws remain effective, proportionate and responsive to evolving threats. The bill is an important part of the government's continuing and holistic efforts to protect Australians from the threat of terrorism. We must stand in unity against the threat of terrorism, and I look forward to support for this bill from across the parliament.</p><p>While I'm on my feet, I table an addendum to the explanatory memorandum relating to the bill. It responds to the matters raised by the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="0" approximate_wordcount="42" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.206.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100916" speakername="Paul Scarr" talktype="interjection" time="19:15" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>The question is that the second reading amendment moved by Senator Shoebridge in the terms circulated in the chamber be agreed to. A division is required. Given the time is after 6:30 pm, that division will be deferred. The debate is adjourned.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.207.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill 2026, Therapeutic Goods (Charges) Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7509" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7509">Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7508" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7508">Therapeutic Goods (Charges) Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="540" approximate_wordcount="1331" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.207.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" speakername="Anne Ruston" talktype="speech" time="19:22" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise to speak on the Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill 2026 and the related Therapeutic Goods (Charges) Amendment Bill 2026. Let me say at the outset the coalition will not be opposing these bills, but I want to be very clear about what these bills do and what they don't do. The Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill 2026 is about knowing sooner that a medicine is about to run out. It is not a bill about making sure that that medicine doesn't run out.</p><p>Under this bill, a company that decides to stop supplying a reportable medicine in Australia must tell the regulator at least 12 months ahead or as soon as it practically can. If that plan changes, it must say so. The secretary will be able to ask the supplier of any approved medicine&#x2014;not just a reportable one&#x2014;whether it's available, running short or on its way out altogether. The Medicines Watch List, the list of medicines whose loss would hurt patients most, will be kept current as the documents it relies on change.</p><p>The bill also lets near-identical biological medicines from the same company share one entry on the register, rather than a new listing for every pack size. The charges bill sets the fees for those groups. There will be less duplication and less red tape, and that's sensible. It puts beyond doubt the power of authorised officers to enter and inspect clinical trial sites so the people who volunteer for those trials can trust that they're being given in a safe environment. None of that is controversial.</p><p>Since this bill passed the other place in August, the Community Affairs Legislation Committee has examined it and reported. The nurses and midwives called it a positive first step and said more work was needed. The physicians told the committee that the bill on its own is unlikely to deliver a comprehensive solution. They support the bill and so do we, but none of them believes it solves the problem, because there is a problem.</p><p>Australia import about 90 per cent of the medicines that we rely on, and we account for barely two per cent of the global market. When a factory overseas stumbles or a shipping route closes, we are a long way down the queue. We saw that again this year. When conflict broke out in the Middle East in March, medicines bound for Australia had to be rerouted. Throughout 2025, more than 400 medicines were listed as in shortage on any given day. That has not improved. Just weeks ago, the number was around 420. Forty of them were considered critical.</p><p>And they keep coming back. An analysis of the TGA's own data published just last week found that more than half of those critical shortages had happened before and thirteen of those medicines had been critically short more than once. Take Bicillin, a long-acting penicillin used to treat syphilis and to protect people living with rheumatic heart disease. It has been in short supply since April last year, our emergency supplies ran out in September and relief is not expected until next March. For Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, where rheumatic heart disease is still far too common, that is not an inconvenience; it is plainly dangerous.</p><p>Think about what that means at the pharmacy counter. It means an older Australian who has taken the same tablet for years being told it simply isn't available, and far too often the GP is the last to find out. When nearly 1,500 GPs were polled earlier last year, almost three in four said they usually first heard about a shortage from their patients. The patients told the doctor. That is a backwards way of going about it. So, yes, earlier warning certainly helps, but a warning is not a solution. You cannot fill a prescription with a notice.</p><p>We know prevention can work because we've seen it. It was the coalition that made medicine shortages reporting mandatory from January 2019 and it was the coalition that legislated the minimum stockholding requirements so companies must hold months of stock of key PBS medicines here in Australia. Earlier this year, the department's own review found those requirements had reduced both the number and the severity of shortages.</p><p>That is what it looks like when you stop a shortage before it starts. Contrast that with the government's handling of IV fluids&#x2014;the saline drips that every operating theatre and emergency department depends on. By the government's own admission, it knew a shortage was coming from the middle of May 2023. By the middle of 2024, hospitals were told that they had to ration. At the time, I asked a simple question: what does a future made in Australia actually mean if the government can't even guarantee a supply of saline solution? The answer came in March 2025&#x2014;a $20 million investment matched by industry to expand local production&#x2014;and we welcomed it. We welcomed the fact that the acute shortage was to be resolved. The minister told Australians we would no longer be hostage to overseas supply, but the full extra capacity is not due until 2027. That's around four years from the first warning that a fix was needed.</p><p>That brings me to our two amendments. The coalition will move two amendments. The first is the second reading amendment circulated in my name. When it was moved in the other place, the government voted it down. We will move it again here because the problem has not gone away. It asks the Senate to recognise how dependent we are on imports, how stubborn the number of shortages has been and that substitution approvals have more than doubled since 2018. It notes that this bill does not deal with the underlying cause. It calls on the government to do what it has so far avoided doing&#x2014;to develop a comprehensive medicine shortage policy to build our sovereign capability so more essential medicines are made here at home in Australia and to set targets to bring the number of shortages down.</p><p>The second amendment, which I'll move in the committee stage, puts that work into law. It requires the minister to commission regular independent reviews of Australia's medicines security. The first must begin within six months of this law taking effect and be finished within a year&#x2014;and, after that, there must be a fresh review at least every five years. When the same medicines run short again and again, that is not bad luck; it is a pattern. A pattern can be found and a pattern can be fixed. Each review must look at the questions that these bills leave unanswered&#x2014;how much we rely on medicines and ingredients made overseas, which critical medicines have no safe substitute, whether we are holding enough stock and whether we could make more of it here, and what shortages mean for hospitals, for aged care, for general practice, for Aboriginal community controlled health services and for patients in rural, regional and remote Australia. It must hear from people who live with this every day&#x2014;doctors, nurses, pharmacists, patients, wholesalers, manufacturers and state and territory governments. The report must be tabled in this parliament, and the government must table its response to every recommendation within six months. It will not stop every shortage&#x2014;nothing can&#x2014;but it means the hard questions get asked and answered out in the open before the next crisis rather than after it. If no-one measures it, no-one is accountable for it.</p><p>The coalition will not stand in the way of these bills. They will help Australians see the next shortage coming. But our job in this place is to make sure it never arrives at all. An early warning is welcome, but a warning is not a solution. I commend our amendments to the Senate and I urge the government and the crossbench to support them, because patients and the people who care for them deserve nothing less.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="360" approximate_wordcount="803" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.208.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100965" speakername="Charlotte Walker" talktype="speech" time="19:31" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Most Australians probably don't spend much time thinking about medicines supply chains&#x2014;and why should they? By all economic norms of globalisation, these aren't concerns that should live rent free in our minds. But, as we've seen in the past 12 months, when global supply chains get disrupted the knock-on effects spread to far-reaching places. For most Aussies, when they go to the pharmacy with a prescription they should expect it to be filled. They expect that the medicine their doctor has prescribed will be available and affordable, and that they will get it on the day. These are normal and reasonable expectations in a developed country like Australia.</p><p>But we know that, for a growing number of Australians, this isn't the reality anymore. We've seen shortages of ADHD medication, hormone replacement therapies, contraceptive pills, diabetes medication and even IV fluids. These are medications used by thousands of Australians every day that they rely on to manage chronic conditions, to maintain their health and, in many cases, to stay alive. When these medications suddenly become unavailable, the consequences can be devastating. For someone managing ADHD, it can mean weeks of struggling to concentrate at work or university. For a woman going through menopause, it might mean being unable to access hormone replacement therapy that has finally made her symptoms manageable. For someone with a serious chronic illness, it could mean having to change treatment that has taken years to get right. For healthcare workers, it means spending valuable time trying to find alternatives, contacting suppliers, rewriting prescriptions and reassuring understandably frustrated patients. None of this is good enough, and that's why the Albanese Labor government is taking further action to strengthen Australia's medicines supply chain.</p><p>The Therapeutic Goods (Charges) Amendment Bill 2026 and the Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill 2026 are about making our medicines system more responsive, more transparent and better equipped to deal with shortages before they become full-blown crises. While Australia can't control every disruption to global medicines supply chains, we can absolutely improve how we prepare for them and respond when things go wrong. We as a country are particularly vulnerable to these kinds of disruptions. We're a relatively small market, geographically isolated and heavily dependent on medicines manufactured overseas. A manufacturing problem on the other side of the world, a shipping disruption or an unexpected surge in demand can quickly become a problem for Australian patients. These problems aren't always predictable, but we can make sure that, when a pharmaceutical company knows that a medicine is going to become unavailable, the people responsible for managing that shortage find out as early as possible. This is one of the central purposes of this legislation. Currently, pharmaceutical sponsors are required to notify the TGA when they decide to permanently discontinue a medicine, but the supporting requirements differ depending on whether discontinuation is considered critical. For critical medications, 12 months notice is needed, but for other medication only six months is deemed necessary. This bill simplifies this system and means that sponsors will be required to give 12 months notice of planned discontinuation for all reportable medicines. This six-month difference can be huge. Time flies quickly when you're scrambling to identify alternative suppliers, arrange new stock, advise healthcare professionals and make sure patients aren't left without treatment. Giving the TGA more warning means giving our health system more time to act.</p><p>The Albanese Labor government are proud of their long tradition of building, supporting and maintaining the healthcare system in Australia, and this legislation is a continuation of that investment into our health services. That has always been at the heart of Labor's approach to health care. Access is about more than affordability. There is little comfort in having a prescription subsidised through the PBS if the medicine is not available when you need it, and that's why these reforms matter. They are part of the practical work of maintaining and strengthening our healthcare system, ensuring Australians can have confidence that, when they need treatment, the system is better equipped to deliver it. The Albanese Labor government understands that protecting Medicare means looking after the entire healthcare system. It means making medicines more affordable through the PBS, strengthening bulk-billing, investing in the health workforce and ensuring Australians can access care closer to home. It also means making sure our health system has the information and tools it needs to respond to medicines shortages before patients feel the impact. No government can prevent every supply disruption, but we can make sure Australia's health system is better prepared, better informed and focused on protecting patients. Ultimately, these reforms reflect a principle that has guided Labor governments for generations: that Australians deserve a healthcare system that they can trust, and that access to essential treatment should never be taken for granted.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="311" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.209.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="19:37" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Many improvements have been made to arrangements to deal with medicines shortages and discontinuance reporting since the introduction of these arrangements in 2019, but supply disruptions do continue to impact the health and wellbeing of people in Australia and the health practitioners and systems that support them. The bill before the chamber, the Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill, strengthens key aspects of the mandatory medicines shortage and discontinuation reporting scheme under the Therapeutic Goods Act, principally by requiring sponsors to notify the secretary of any decision to permanently discontinue the supply of reportable medicines in Australia at least 12 months in advance; requiring sponsors who give such notice to update the secretary if there is a change in that approach, including if the supply is no longer proposed to be discontinued or if the discontinuation is to occur at a different time to that notified; and enabling the secretary to require all sponsors of approved medicines to provide information about the availability and any shortage or discontinuation of their products in Australia.</p><p>These amendments are consistent with this government's unwavering commitment to public health, and will mitigate the public health risks associated with medicines shortages and discontinuations, by supporting a strong and effective mandatory reporting scheme under the Therapeutic Goods Act. Together with the associated amendments in the Therapeutic Goods (Charges) Amendment Bill 2026, the bill will implement measures to reduce costs and regulatory burden for sponsors who have multiple biologicals in the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods. These amendments are consistent with this government's commitment to reducing regulatory burden. The other minor amendments in the bill will support the consistent and effective operation of the Therapeutic Goods Act and the therapeutic goods regulatory framework. I thank members for their contribution to the debate on these bills.</p><p>Question agreed to.</p><p>Bills read a second time.</p><p class="italic"> <i>(Quorum formed)</i></p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.210.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill 2026, Therapeutic Goods (Charges) Amendment Bill 2026; In Committee </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7509" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7509">Therapeutic Goods Amendment (Medicines Shortages and Other Measures) Bill 2026</bill>
  <bill id="r7508" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7508">Therapeutic Goods (Charges) Amendment Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="600" approximate_wordcount="1802" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.210.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" speakername="Anne Ruston" talktype="speech" time="19:42" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I move the amendment on sheet 4024 circulated in my name:</p><p class="italic">(1) Schedule 1, page 6 (after line 22), after item 7, insert:</p><p class="italic">7A At the end of Chapter 3</p><p class="italic">Add:</p><p class="italic">Part 3-4 &#x2014; National medicines security reviews</p><p class="italic">41AA National medicines security reviews</p><p class="italic"> <i>Requirement to conduct reviews</i></p><p class="italic">(1) The Minister must cause independent reviews of Australia's medicines security arrangements to be undertaken.</p><p class="italic"> <i>Matters review must consider</i></p><p class="italic">(2) Without limiting subsection (1), a review must consider Australia's capacity to maintain the supply of critical medicines during shortages, discontinuations, market withdrawals, public health emergencies and supply chain disruptions, including considering the following:</p><p class="italic">(a) Australia's reliance on imported medicines, active pharmaceutical ingredients and overseas manufacturing;</p><p class="italic">(b) the availability of medicines identified as critical to public health, including medicines included in a determination made under subsection 30EJ(1) (Medicines Watch List);</p><p class="italic">(c) the availability of medicines with limited or no clinically appropriate substitutes;</p><p class="italic">(d) stockholding, procurement and distribution arrangements for critical medicines;</p><p class="italic">(e) opportunities to strengthen domestic manufacturing capability and supply chain resilience;</p><p class="italic">(f) the impacts of shortages and discontinuations on hospitals, aged care services, primary care providers, Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations, regional and remote communities, and vulnerable patient groups;</p><p class="italic">(g) mechanisms for improving transparency, monitoring and early warning of supply risks.</p><p class="italic"> <i>Consultation requirement</i></p><p class="italic">(3) The persons conducting a review must consult with the following:</p><p class="italic">(a) health practitioners;</p><p class="italic">(b) patient organisations;</p><p class="italic">(c) medicines sponsors and manufacturers;</p><p class="italic">(d) pharmacists;</p><p class="italic">(e) wholesalers;</p><p class="italic">(f) state and territory governments;</p><p class="italic">(g) any other persons, entities or bodies considered appropriate.</p><p class="italic"> <i>Frequency of reviews</i></p><p class="italic">(4) The first review must:</p><p class="italic">(a) commence within the period of 6 months beginning on the day this section commences; and</p><p class="italic">(b) be completed within 12 months after the commencement of the review.</p><p class="italic">(5) Each subsequent review must be completed within 5 years after the completion of the previous review.</p><p class="italic">(6) For the purposes of subsections (4) and (5), a review is completed on the day after the day the report of the review is given to the Minister.</p><p class="italic"> <i>Report of review</i></p><p class="italic">(7) The persons who conduct a review must give the Minister a written report of the review.</p><p class="italic">(8) The Minister must table a copy of the report in each House of the Parliament within 15 sitting days of that House after the Minister receives the report.</p><p class="italic"> <i>Government response to recommendations</i></p><p class="italic">(9) If the report sets out one or more recommendations to the Commonwealth Government:</p><p class="italic">(a) the Minister must cause a statement setting out the Commonwealth Government's response to each of the recommendations to be prepared; and</p><p class="italic">(b) within 6 months of tabling the report of the review in a House of the Parliament, the Minister must table a copy of the statement in each House of the Parliament.</p><p>As I pointed out in my second reading contribution, we do this because we are particularly concerned that, whilst it seeks to give early warning to medicine shortages, this bill really does not provide the strict transparency and accountability that we think are necessary given the seriousness of the impact of medicine shortages to Australians. So what we're seeking do to by moving this amendment is to insert into the legislation, not into the rules or anything that comes later but actually into the legislation, a requirement for the minister to undertake an independent review of Australia's medicine security arrangements.</p><p>We have seen too many examples where medicine security is compromised. Because even though medicine shortages have been flagged, we know that we are a small nation at the very end of a supply chain and often the last ones to get supplied whenever there is any critical shortages that occur, so we need to make sure that we actually have a handle on what the security of medicines into this country really looks like. It is simply not good enough to pretend everything is fine when we know that it is not. Such a review would need to consider Australia's capacity to maintain supply of critical medicines during shortages, discontinuations, market withdrawals, public health emergencies and supply chain disruptions, because we know those sorts of things are happening to our nation all the time and we need to be better prepared when they occur.</p><p>We need to consider a whole heap of different issues when we consider our medicines supply chain. First of all is Australia's reliance on imported medicines, active pharmaceutical ingredients and overseas manufacturing. We know in Australia that we rely on overseas manufacture and supply for over 90 per cent of the medicines that Australians rely on, so we need to understand what that looks like and where the risks are. We also need to consider the availability of medicines identified as critical to public health, including medicines included in determinations under the Medicines Watch List, because we know a number of medicines in this nation are in short supply. We also know that there are medicines in this nation that are the difference between life and death for Australians. We need to understand in this process where those particular critical points are so that we are in a position to act more quickly than the government has acted to date.</p><p>We also need to take into account the availability of medicines with limited or no clinically appropriate substitute. Whilst many medicines are able to be substituted to varying degrees by a number of different medicines, there are medicines and even critical medicines in this nation with no real substitute. We need to identify where they are, and we also need to be very much alert to what is happening to them and the likelihood of any shortages occurring in those particular types of medicines. We also need to be aware of stockholding, procurement and distribution arrangements for those critical medicines. It's simply not good enough to know that we have a medicine; we need to understand how that medicine is actually getting to the people that need it.</p><p>We also need to understand opportunities to strengthen domestic manufacturing capabilities and supply-chain resilience. It's all well and good to talk up made in Australia, but, unless you can actually deliver on that, they are just words. And we hear way too often words that never eventuate into real outcomes for Australians from those opposite. So we need to understand: When you talk about strengthening domestic manufacturing, how are you going to go about that? What are the medicines that you are going to prioritise in terms of that sovereign domestic capability? And how are we actually going to go about it in terms of the timing? We also need to understand supply-chain resilience, as I said. We are a big island with a tiny population, at the end of most pharmaceutical manufacturing supply chains. We are a long way away from where most of our drugs are manufactured. We are additionally vulnerable to supply-chain challenges simply because of where we physically sit in the world and our physical size in terms of our population. We need to understand that.</p><p>We also need to understand the impacts of shortages and discontinuations on hospitals, aged-care services, primary care providers and Aboriginal community controlled health organisations. For so many of these people, missing a medication can have catastrophic results. We also need to understand that a supply chain is not just coming into the nation; it's the supply chain which distributes those particular drugs around the country, and there is reliance on these various very large holders of drugs for access to those drugs, particularly in hospitals, aged care and our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. We know that, in many of these more remote communities, the patients are much more vulnerable, and their reliance on these medications is much, much more acute.</p><p>We also need to understand what the mechanisms will be to improve transparency, to improve monitoring and for early warning of supply risks. We have seen time and time again under this government that they were well aware that a shortage was coming down the pipeline and did nothing about it. No particular example can be more obvious than that the government knew for 12 months that saline solution manufacture in this nation was insufficient to meet demand. They knew that there was a supply-chain shrinkage or shortage coming down the pipeline. They did nothing about it. And we still know that we will be entirely reliant for some years to come, while the Australian manufacturer of saline solution is ramped up. You simply cannot admire a problem. By making this a requirement in legislation, what we want to do is make sure that the government can no longer admire a problem or hide a problem. If there is a problem, I think Australians deserve to know that, and if there is a problem, there is much more pressure on the government to resolve it if they know that people know about that problem. That is the reason we are asking this chamber to consider the amendment that we are putting forward on sheet 4024.</p><p>We believe that the first review should commence within six months of the passage of this bill, and that review needs to take into account all of those things that I have just outlined. We expect that that review should be finished within 12 months of its commencement. We don't need these things dragging on forever and ever. It is a really important review and it deserves to have priority. We then need to have subsequent reviews thereafter. Simply doing one review, ticking that box and pushing it away is not good enough. We need to have light shone on medicine shortages in this nation.</p><p>Whilst this may seem like a small change, it is an incredibly important addition to actually addressing the underlying causes of Australia's medicine shortage, rather than just having faster notification of the problem. Faster notification serves a purpose, but it doesn't solve the problem. If we as a country are going to take Future Made in Australia and medicine security seriously, we need a holistic approach to this particular issue. We need to examine our current capabilities, our gaps and the opportunities to address them in the future. This is a wonderful opportunity for us as a parliament to require the government to make sure that something as important as access, supply and distribution of medicines to the Australian public is absolutely at its best and that, when problems occur, we can have confidence that the government is actually going to tell us the truth about it. But, most importantly, we need this review to be independent of government to ensure a truly transparent and frank assessment.</p><p>I commend these amendments to the chamber and I urge all senators to support the amendments because of their importance to the lives and livelihoods of Australians.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="60" approximate_wordcount="114" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.211.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100845" speakername="Jenny McAllister" talktype="speech" time="19:52" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I will just indicate briefly that the government doesn't support the amendment proposed by Senator Ruston. We recognise and acknowledge the importance of medicine shortages and the importance of effective responses. We also note that medicine shortages are complex and that there are many different stakeholders and interests involved. There simply isn't enough time to consider Senator Ruston's proposal, including speaking to the stakeholders who would be affected by such a proposal. But I do note that the department is presently exploring options to strengthen Australia's health product supply resilience, and the TGA is also establishing a medicine shortages communication framework working group with stakeholders as a subgroup under the medicine shortages stakeholder forum.</p> </speech>
 <speech approximate_duration="420" approximate_wordcount="911" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.212.1" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100306" speakername="Anne Ruston" talktype="speech" time="19:53" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I thank the minister for her response to the amendments, but I have to say it is incredibly disappointing that we're here in absolutely good faith and in the interests of making sure that we have got transparency about something that is as important to Australia as our medicine supply and the ongoing shortages that seem to be constantly repeating themselves. We're not talking about medicine shortages that just happen every now and again; we're talking about more than 420 medications being in short supply in this country right now, as we stand here today.</p><p>What we want to do is provide a transparent mechanism in legislation so that we can always be ahead of the game when these shortages are coming down the pipeline. When the minister stands up and says that the government is not going to support this amendment, she is, in effect, saying that the government doesn't want to support transparency and accountability in relation to the supply of medicines to this country. This government doesn't want transparency and accountability when it comes to their actions and their handling of the supply of medicines to this country. Don't forget, we're not talking about aspirin here. In many instances, we're talking about medicines that will save people's lives. If people do not get access to these medicines, some people will die. All we want is transparency and accountability around the process that the government has put in place to make sure that we understand as early as possible that those shortages are likely to occur and to make sure that the consequences and impact of those shortages across the entire Australian health and care network are known to all Australians.</p><p>To possibly say that the reason that you can't do this is that it's too onerous for stakeholders&#x2014;if there is one thing that Australian medical and aged-care stakeholders have told me in the 4&#xBD; years that I have been in the role of the shadow minister for health and aged care, it is that the government never consults them. The government tells them what the legislative change or the reform piece is going to be, and then it goes and talks to them later, but it takes no notice of anything that they say. So to suggest that the sector would be resistant to doing reviews or that for them to have their views sought and be consulted with would in any way prevent the government from going ahead with this, I think, is completely and utterly farcical. The one thing that I've always believed is that the best policies are made when, at the time when you develop the policy, you have in the room the people who are going to be impacted by it. That means making sure that you hear the voices of the clinicians, the pharmacists and the aged-care providers&#x2014;the very people who are administering the medications to Australians. We need to hear what the implications of any changes are for them. We need to listen to the patients as well.</p><p>New analysis of 11 years of TGA data by the ABC just this weekend showed that, as of last month, 40 medicines were in critical shortage in this country. More than half of them had been short before. Thirteen had been in critical shortage more than once. These are really important statistics. These aren't one-off events; they are a pattern, and the government has watched that pattern repeat itself time and time again. So we're saying to the government: you've failed in your duty to make sure that you solve the problems of medicine shortages. So what we're saying to you is that we want transparency and accountability. We want you to tell this parliament, on a legislated and regular basis, what is actually going on.</p><p>I note the human cost. Bicillin, which is a long-lasting, long acting penicillin, has been in shortage since April 2025, and it's not expected to be back until March 2027. This deals with rheumatic heart disease, which is most prevalent in our Indigenous communities, some of Australia's most vulnerable. This is the sixth recorded shortage of this medicine. How many warnings of a medicine shortage does the minister need before he's prepared to act? There are other examples. Creon, which Australians with cystic fibrosis rely on to digest food, has been short for more than a year. The country's only Q fever vaccine was due to run out within days of that analysis, and that matters enormously to our farmers, shearers and abattoir workers. Other affected medications include a heart imaging agent, a blood pressure injection for late pregnancy, a morning-after pill and a scabies treatment. Australians will remember shortages of EpiPens, ADHD medications, IV fluids and Ozempic.</p><p>Experts say our medicine supply chains lack resilience. As I said, we import over 90 per cent of our medicines and we make up just two per cent of the global market. When supply tightens, we're at the end of the queue. In response, the TGA conceded that the government cannot compel companies to supply medicines. It also admitted its own list of long-running shortages is not comprehensive. The ABC actually found shortages missing from the TGA's own archive data, so the government doesn't fully know the scale of the problem, yet it says it lacks the power to fix it. Agree to this amendment, and you will have the transparency to be able to do it.</p><p>Progress reported.</p> </speech>
 <major-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.213.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
ADJOURNMENT </major-heading>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.213.2" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Australian Parliament </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="695" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.213.3" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100928" speakername="Karen Grogan" talktype="speech" time="20:00" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Last week I had the opportunity to run a series of community catch-ups across Port Augusta and Whyalla. Being able to hear directly from the people in those regions is so critical to us to be able to represent our communities in this place. Conversations like the ones I had last weekend are critical to inform how policies are developed and how we understand the implications and the realities of what plays out on the ground, and contribute significantly to ensuring that our regional communities are front and centre when we make decisions in this place. Those conversations can be pretty robust. People don't turn out to talk to you just because they agree with you, and that's great. That's what we want. We want to hear different views, different perspectives and understand how people are experiencing changes in policy and different initiatives but also understand the things that are critical to them, their families and their community. The very simple fact of people sharing their perspective is critical to a healthy democracy. That's what we need to be pushing so hard for these days.</p><p>People spoke to me about a range of issues. I had some people turn up to talk about the Whyalla Steelworks and the closure of the blast furnace, and some of those people who came are people who've come to talk to me over a number of years. That level of engagement, that understanding of how a particular issue has played out over years for various people in the community is really important to be able to then feed that back directly to the minister so the minister can understand what's happening on the ground from real people who are living in these communities. It's a really, really important part of what we do. Other people raised their experiences with the NDIS, the tax office, Centrelink&#x2014;all of those Commonwealth issues that we can help people with&#x2014;and being able to be there on the ground and help them navigate through them is really important. Not every conversation in that environment is easy. Some people are upset, and some people are challenged by what they're facing and trying to understand how to navigate it, but every single person who came out to talk to me was respectful. Yes, we had robust conversations, and I thoroughly enjoyed them, but every last person was really respectful.</p><p>One person who came out didn't have an issue at all. When I asked them, 'What is it that you're really passionate about or that you want to talk about?' they said: 'I was just really grateful to get a letter in my mailbox saying that you were going to be here and inviting me out and then a follow-up text message to say you were going to be in the park. I felt that I should come out and say hello and show my support for the fact that you're engaging in the community.' It makes us better representatives&#x2014;it makes us better people in this chamber and in this building&#x2014;if we are hearing directly from people on the ground, understanding their lived experience and understanding the things that they're passionate about. Our democracy is so much stronger when people speak up and so much stronger when, in this chamber and in the other place, we are listening to the community, we're hearing what they say and we're making sure that their voices are represented in this place. In my case, it's so much more important that we ensure that people in regional communities and in rural and remote areas, particularly South Australia in my case, are really heard and have that opportunity to talk to us and to bring up the things that are important to them. We must ensure we protect our democracy across this country and protect that very precious piece of our democracy that says that, in Australia, our elected representatives are in the supermarket or are walking down the street or in the local park, and that people can talk to them respectfully. We must ensure that we can bring people's voices to this place to make sure we build a better future.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.214.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Afghanistan, Omari, Mr Sami </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="553" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.214.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100970" speakername="Andrew McLachlan" talktype="speech" time="20:05" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>Earlier this year, on 15 August, we marked the fifth anniversary of the Taliban taking control of Kabul and the fall of the republic. From that moment, the people of Afghanistan have continued to endure great repression at the hands of the Taliban. As senators know, Australia welcomed many Afghan families to Australia, especially those that had worked with the Australian defence forces. South Australia now enjoys a vibrant Afghan community which makes an amazing contribution to the life of my state.</p><p>On 19 August we celebrated Afghan Independence Day, which I attended at the invitation of Mr Sami Omari, a very active member of the Afghan community. It was a beautiful evening, with much celebration of Afghan culture and with many speeches from community leaders. All emphasised the tragedy that was unfolding in their homeland, especially the Taliban's violation of human rights and the systematic efforts to erase women and girls from public life. The message was clear: Afghan women must have the opportunity for education and advancement. I wish to honour Mr Sami Omari. He is highly accomplished, Afghan born and a policy consultant in international relations and diplomacy. He has served as a prosecutor and legal adviser in Afghanistan, has worked as a cultural and security affairs instructor with the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and the ADF, and has extensive experience working alongside NATO.</p><p>I especially wish to bring to the attention of honourable senators the speech he delivered at the National Press Club in September this year, titled 'Five years of silence: the Taliban win nobody talks about'. His view is that Afghanistan has almost entirely disappeared from the national conversation and, in turn, public consciousness. As the world looks away and focuses on other matters, this should be considered in reality a second defeat. Silence itself is the Taliban's greatest victory. The suppression of media reporting in the country has been extreme. Voices of freedom in the country have been silenced while the interest of the world has waned. He advocates for maintaining principled engagement, keeping dialogue where necessary and humanitarian access, but without treating the regime as legitimate.</p><p>Sami strongly articulated that Australia has unfinished business and an unfinished obligation to Afghanistan and its people, with Afghans still in the country facing persecution for assisting Australian operations. As a nation, we are morally obligated to continue to support the thousands of Afghans who work alongside Australian troops, including bringing them to this country where they seek a visa. We must heed the important calls of Sami and his community, for they are right; we owe it to the Afghanistan people, we owe it to the 41 Australian soldiers who died on operations and we owe it because of the sacrifices made by more than 39,000 ADF and civilian personnel who conducted and supported operations in Afghanistan for over 20 years.</p><p>Finally, my message to those that seek to stoke fear and anxiety in our community by attacking the many cultures that make up our nation is: look at Sami, his family and his community. You'll only see proud Australians. It's leaders like Sami who remind us all to recommit ourselves to multiculturalism and to a culturally tolerant society, lest we become no better than those that seek to oppress others in countries such as Afghanistan.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.215.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Denman, Ms Enid </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="240" approximate_wordcount="485" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.215.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100974" speakername="Vanessa Bleyer" talktype="speech" time="20:09" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>I rise to acknowledge Enid Denman. Enid died yesterday. She was 93 years of age, and, from 2004, she lived as a long-term resident at the Beauty Point caravan park. Sadly, in the last handful of years she suffered great injustices perpetrated against her by the then operator of the Beauty Point caravan park through the then manager, Joshua Manticas. She tried to sell her cabin at the park, to fund living in a care facility where she could receive all of the services and support that she needed. The park denied her right to do so. Her garden was destroyed&#x2014;a hedge that she had been tending to over an extended period of time&#x2014;despite that the park should not have done so. Her rubbish was refused to be taken away from her home, from her site at the caravan park, despite that the park should have continued to do so. Her boom-gate access to her site was denied, thereby depriving her of access to the services that she needed, despite that the boom-gate access should not have been denied to her. She had mobility problems and was not able to make her way to the other side of the boom gate to be taken out for the day. She could not get to the other side of the boom gate to receive the food that she needed to be delivered to her to eat.</p><p>But what she did about all of this was to stand up for her rights and to stand up for the rights of other long-term residents at the Beauty Point caravan park. She was an upstanding member of the community and an upstanding human being. It was my great privilege to have acted for her as a lawyer, acting on her behalf in the anti-discrimination commission, to stand up for her rights to get the access to all of the services she was entitled to and deserved.</p><p>As a result of her strength, as a result of her standing up for herself and the Beauty Point caravan park community, laws have finally been put in place, through the Tasmanian parliament, not only to protect the rights of all long-term residents at the Beauty Point caravan park, but also to protect all of the rights of all long-term residents at caravan parks across Tasmania. Enid, I commend you for the significant role that you played in achieving that great outcome.</p><p>I acknowledge Enid's son,Bruce Bennett, who also worked tirelessly to assist Enid in protecting and enforcing her rights. I acknowledge Enid's friends and family, who will now be mourning her death.</p><p>But let us take this opportunity to remember her strength and her tenacity. Let us take this opportunity to remember how, with such great strength, she stood up for all of those in her community. Enid, you made a profound and lasting difference to so many people's lives. Thank you, Enid.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.216.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Victoria: Horse Racing </minor-heading>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="751" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.216.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100900" speakername="Raff Ciccone" talktype="speech" time="20:13" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In August, I rose in this place as the Spring Racing Carnival was about to begin, and I spoke about the important contribution that racing makes to my home state of Victoria. Today I can report that the carnival didn't just meet expectations; it exceeded them. For the first time since 2018, the Melbourne Cup Carnival at Flemington attracted more than 307,000 people across four days, including more than 97,000 people on cup day&#x2014;the biggest crowd in a decade. More than 30,000 came through the gates on Caulfield Cup day&#x2014;also its biggest crowd in a decade. Away from the track, more than 3.3 million Australians watched the Melbourne Cup, with streaming audiences up by almost 25 per cent.</p><p>On the track, Ciaron Maher achieved an unprecedented Melbourne Cup trifecta, training the first three horses across the line&#x2014;magnificent! Equally significant is the changing face of the crowds. Sixty per cent of general-admission ticket holders at Flemington were aged 35 and under, up 53 per cent. At Caulfield, female attendances grew by almost 17 per cent, and attendance among those aged 24 and under grew by nearly 38 per cent. Women are changing the sport from the saddle too. Last year, Jamie Melham became the first woman to win both the Caulfield Cup and the Melbourne Cup, a decade after Michelle Payne's historic victory. In many states, women now make up the majority of new apprentices. A sport that once barred women from riding professionally now sees them winning at the highest level, and good on them.</p><p>Behind every race are thousands of Australians who work hard to keep this industry moving. Nearly 100,000 Victorians take part in racing, close to 80 per cent of them in regional communities. Few stories capture the resilience of racing better than Swan Hill jockey Harry Coffey. Harry has lived with cystic fibrosis since birth. He broke his collarbone in a fall on derby day, had surgery on the Sunday, and guess what? Two days later he rode Shockletz to sixth in the Melbourne Cup. Unbelievable. That says something about racing people. They rise before dawn, they work in all weathers and they dedicate their lives to the horses in their care, and they do bloody love them a lot.</p><p>Of course, not everyone in this place sees it the same way. Some here would happily shut the gates for good. They are quick to chase a headline but slow to meet the strappers, the trainers and the stablehands who treat these horses like family. Since 2017, Racing Victoria has invested more than $44 million in welfare programs, including support for retired horses. From 20 November, National Thoroughbred Week will open the gates at stud farms, stables and aftercare centres so all Australians can see that for themselves. On 27 November, Thoroughbred Breeders Australia will showcase its fast-tracked traineeship helping young people build a future in the industry. In August, I hoped that this carnival would deliver a photo finish for all the right reasons, and on so many measures it did. But this sport does ask a great deal of those who ride.</p><p>Sadly, last week the racing community lost Izzy Neale, a beautiful 22-year-old apprentice jockey who died after a fall in the Cotton Cup in New South Wales. Izzy rode 88 winners and had a bright career ahead of her. Her family had shared that she rode horses before she could walk and that her love of horses grew into a love of racing. Even in their grief, they shared that through organ donation Izzy will give others the chance of life. What an incredible woman. Her passing is a heartbreaking reminder of the risks that jockeys accept every time they go onto the track. Every one of them deserves our respect and our commitment to making this sport as safe as it can be, particularly for the fans who turn up every single week and all the communities, the regional communities, that are heavily reliant and dependent on racing&#x2014;all those workers, hospitality workers, cleaners, security guards, bus drivers, truckies and taxidrivers, the full lot.</p><p>For people on the other side here to criticise this industry, I say shame on you. Shame on you for demonising the very people that are the lifeblood of many communities around our great country and our state of Victoria. But I do want to extend my deepest sympathies to Izzy's family, her friends and the racing community. I know tomorrow they'll be mourning this wonderful person. Vale, Izzy.</p> </speech>
 <minor-heading id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.217.1" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026 </minor-heading>
 <bills>
  <bill id="r7553" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id:legislation/billhome/r7553">Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026</bill>
 </bills>
 <speech approximate_duration="300" approximate_wordcount="739" id="uk.org.publicwhip/lords/2026-11-16.217.2" speakerid="uk.org.publicwhip/lord/100956" speakername="Leah Blyth" talktype="speech" time="20:18" url="http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;adv=yes;orderBy=_fragment_number,doc_date-rev;page=0;query=Dataset%3Ahansards,hansards80%20Date%3A16%2F11%2F2026;rec=0;resCount=Default">
<p>In September this year, I spoke in this place about my opposition to Labor's proposed digital duty of care legislation. It is their failed misinformation and disinformation bill all over again. We all want to keep kids safe online, and we want to keep them as safe as we possibly can, but we've got to consider what freedoms we are trading under the illusion of safety. As I said then, I did not enter this chamber to hand governments more power over what free people may lawfully say, read or see. I entered to defend these hard-fought freedoms. Free speech is not a problem to be managed. It is a freedom that we must value and we must protect.</p><p>The digital duty of care bill has the potential to censor and stifle legitimate public debate and lawful speech, and I have significant concerns that this will prevent what we can see and say online about issues like women's sex based rights. Where the minister can decide what constitutes harm and serious harm in relation to online content, I am under no illusion that what this government will censor and ban is any opposition to the ideology they are pushing, like that men can be women. Australian law no longer recognises the biological reality of sex and instead relies on self-identification, which means that legally men who say they are women are offered all the protections of biological women under the law. As confirmed by the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, it means men now have protections for potential pregnancy and breastfeeding, which is downright absurd. Biological males who identify as female and who induce lactation are protected under antidiscrimination legislation designed for breastfeeding women. This is nothing more than state sanctioned perversion. These infants are force-fed a secretion that may or may not be harmful. There is little medical evidence that points to the nutritional value of the secretion or the possible harms.</p><p>When Labor's agenda is to have you believe anything, including things that you know are not true, it seems like we are living in George Orwell's <i>Nineteen Eighty-Four</i>. Men can be women, the Prime Minister didn't fall off the stage, you'll save $275 off your electricity bill and you'll only need a Medicare card to see a doctor&#x2014;all of these things are known not to be true and are not founded in reality or fact. Advocating for the biological reality and simple fact that men cannot be women is possibly to be deemed hostile by the eSafety Commissioner and breach Labor's digital duty of care legislation. Under proposed section 27 of the bill, online services seeking to comply with their obligations must ensure that online risks are being mitigated, which in this case would mean they would simply remove or never post content. Self-censorship to avoid multimillion-dollar penalties will become commonplace. So, if you can no longer advocate for biological reality and scientific fact, does that mean that anything that Labor doesn't support will also be censored? On things like net zero and divisive proposals like the Voice to Parliament, anything at all that is critical of the government has potential to be banned.</p><p>These concerns have been raised by the Rule of Law Institute of Australia, and they summarised their evidence in the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee last week. It was also outlined by Mr Merritt from the institute that an online service provider has a greater interest in preserving shareholder funds than in preserving freedom of speech, so it has a very strong incentive to suppress and remove material to avoid the potential of a very large fine. These views do not stand in isolation. At Women's Forum Australia, Rachael Wong and Stephanie Bastiaan have consistently raised concerns with how the eSafety Commissioner is treating speech that raises concerns about gender ideology. But the most striking revelation has come from the Office of the eSafety Commissioner, who have indicated that the wording contained in the digital duty of care bill is too vague.</p><p>I want to thank everyone who has reached out to me to voice their concerns about Labor's digital duty of care legislation, as well as those who have reached out and called out the protections for men who are now protected to breastfeed. It makes it impossible to hold governments to account and for Australians to express their freedom under bills like the digital duty of care bill.</p><p>Senate adjourned at 20:23</p> </speech>
</debates>
